Is the Soviet WW2 film “Come and See” accurate

AtoZ Heritage
50 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 11, 2022
Is the film "Come and See" historically accurate? Let's find out!
When talking about the 1985 Soviet film, Come and See, most videos on YouTube talk about
the director, or the production of the film, the techniques used, and its reception by
audiences. But this video isn't really about any of that. Today we're going to assess
the historical accuracy of the events depicted in the film, and look at some of the moral
questions raised too with regards to the Second World War. So, spoiler alert, if you haven't
seen the film, go watch it first because we're going to be focusing on what happened
towards the end of it. But as a brief synopsis.
The film follows the story of a boy called Fleora who joins the Soviet partisans fighting
in Belorussia in 1943. He's young and innocent at the start of the film, and it's a lost
youth or lost innocence kind of story where he befriends a weird girl he falls in love
with, but then the Germans come along and wipe out their partisan camp, and Fleora's
village, in an anti-partisan operation. They join up with some surviving partisans and
villagers, but the Germans come back, lock another village in a barn, and burn it to
the ground. And this part is true. The Germans did wipe out close to 700 Belorussian villages,
which the film correctly states at the end. The SS also did lock peasants in barns, shot
at them, and burned the barns down. So this is all a true representation of what happened.
There are some inaccuracies though. The director himself said that the film is based off the
events of the Katyn village massacre. Not the more famous Katyn massacre where the Soviets
killed the Polish army officers in 1939, but the village massacre which happened in 1943.
Well, we know which German units conducted the 1943 Katyn village massacre. They were
the SS-Sonderkommando Der Levanger, or SS Special Unit Der Levanger, which was a battalion
at the time, and Schutzmannschaft Battalion 118.
And while it was the favourite tactic of Oskar der Levanger to get drunk, do despicable things
to the local population, lock them in barns and burn them down, the problem is that the
captured Germans at the end of the film directly state that they were not part of these units.
The captured SS soldiers say that they're from the 15th Einsatzkommando.
Well, there wasn't a 15th Einsatzkommando at Katyn, so this is inaccurate. Why they
didn't just say they were from the Schutzmannschaft Battalion 118 or the Der Levanger Battalion
isn't clear, but I suspect the reason why is because they wanted to have the leader
of the German unit get captured so that they could then have the Germans explain their
actions. This would allow them to pose the moral questions that they did at the end of
the film. And obviously, Oskar der Levanger and Erich Koerner, commander of Schutzmannschaft
Battalion 118, weren't captured and killed in Belarus. So I think they just chose a random
unit number and said that it was the Einsatzkommando, because members of the audience might have
heard about the Einsatzkommando and would be able to follow the events. However, they
accidentally chose a real Einsatzkommando. Online sources say Einsatzkommando 15 went
to Croatia, which isn't Belarus.
Now you might say, ok, but we know that it was the Der Levanger Battalion and the Schutzmannschaft
Battalion 118 that conducted the Katyn village massacre, so apart from this slip-up, it's
all good, right? Well no, even if the guy had said that they were from one of these
two units, the film is still inaccurate. Why? Well, the men in the film are wearing the
wrong uniforms.
The SS shown in the film have the SS logo on their collars, rather than the two crossed
rifles that the der Levanger unit used as their logo. It's hard to tell, but this
guy in this photo of SS prisoners in 1945 is a member of the der Levanger unit, and
has the two crossed rifles logo. The guys around him are other SS members, and they
have the standard SS lightning bolts on their collars.
Another photo of the der Levanger Brigade fighting at Warsaw shows the men with the
two crossed rifles too. So this confirms that the SS depicted in the film aren't from
the der Levanger unit. Which means they must have been from the Schutzmannschaft Battalion
118. Except they're not from that battalion either, because here's a photo of the leaders
of that battalion, and you can see very clearly that they didn't have the SS logos on their
collars. Why? Because they were an auxiliary police unit manned by Ukrainian nationalists,
not members of the SS.
So, since they are SS, the only unit they could be from is the der Levanger Battalion.
But if so, they're not dressed accurately. And the der Levanger Battalion isn't Einsatzkommando
15. Then the German says that the guy standing next to him is his leader, who gave them their
orders. Well, if this was Einsatzkommando 15, then this would be a representation of
SS-Hapsturmführer Willi Wolter. But Wolter was in Croatia, and fought there until September
1944. So it couldn't have been him, or der Levanger, or Koerner, since the SS captives
are killed in the film, which they weren't in real life. In other words, the film isn't
accurate when it comes to the German units involved, or their commanders.
There are other things to consider too, and in this case I'm not calling these inaccuracies
as such, just things to take note of and bear in mind. In 1943, the Germans were under orders
not to kill middle-aged men. The Reich needed slave labourers, and the abled-bodied men
were sent to Germany to work.
In the film, a few men, about five, are shown being spared from the burnings, but it would
have been more than this. Also, if this had been the der Levanger unit, then the young
women would have been taken away first to be used, and then brought back to be killed
with the rest. One girl, the girl who Fleora befriends earlier on, is shown having this
happen to her, but that's it. So the representation is there, but if we were to be more true to
life, it would have been on a larger scale.
The Germans were desperately short of fuel in 1943. Yet, in the film, the Germans burn
a barn, not with torches, but with tons of petrol bombs and flamethrowers, which seems
a bit excessive. They definitely used gasoline to burn their victims, but I'm a little
sceptical that they would use the copious amounts of fuel they did in the film just
to burn one barn and a couple of buildings. Yes, the director of the film apparently lived
through a village burning, and is reported to have said that there were flames everywhere,
and it was raining flames. So it could have been like this, but because the Germans didn't
have much fuel to spare, I think this excessive amount is artistic license.
In the same vein, the Germans are shown to have plenty of trucks and gasoline, which
often wasn't the case. They did have trucks, but most of the Germans used horses. In fact,
the SS der Levanger unit was often working in cooperation with the SS cavalry brigades.
And the reason for that was because there wasn't enough trucks or petrol to go around.
So this may give the false impression that the Germans were swimming in petrol, which
they certainly were not.
The most intriguing part of the film, for me though, is right at the end. And the film's
directors did this on purpose to get us thinking. The partisans capture some of the SS soldiers
and Russian or Ukrainian collaborators from the unit that burned the village. Obviously,
this is all artistic license, since in real life, the German commanders of the units involved
weren't captured like this, but it does allow the film to pose several good questions
to the audience, so we can let it slide.
Should you just kill these criminals outright? Do you spare any of them? Were the Russian
or Ukrainian collaborators forced to do what they did, like they try and claim in the film?
No one believes them in the film, of course, and in real life, the Ukrainians in the Schutzmannschaft
Battalion were volunteers, but that's not explained. However, not all Ukrainians fighting
for the Germans were volunteers, so that's something to bear in mind. One of the villagers
screams, I lost my children in that burning hell. So does he have the right to murder
them in return? Is vigilante justice lawful? If so, why do our modern law systems forbid
it? Are these criminals not entitled to a trial? If not, why bother having trials at
all? Why not just kill every suspected criminal, guilty or not? And if you kill these criminals,
are you not stooping down to their level?
To me, this is where the film really shines. The exact same questions were being asked
at the end of the Second World War. Some just wanted to shoot all the Nazis, but the Allies
tried to take the moral high ground and have a war-crimes trial. That then resulted in
many denialists, Nazis, and others branding these trials as a sham, led by a kangaroo
court, and so on. The Allies and Soviets also did bad things in the Second World War, yet
there were no trials for them, and thus it was seen as a victor's justice. So, maybe
the Allies shouldn't have bothered taking the moral high ground and just whine the Nazis
all up?
And that's where these questions that the film asks really come in. It's not just
a fictional, philosophical conundrum to get you thinking, it's actually based in hard
reality, and it has some very serious implications.
At the end of the film, Fleora finds a picture of Hitler on the ground. He shoots at it over
and over in a rage, and this is the only time Fleora actually fires his rifle. As he does
this, the film shows pictures of Hitler, and with every bullet, the footage of the war
is reversed, turning back time, and all the events of the war, and then the National Socialist
rise to power, the Weimar Republic, the First World War, etc. Hitler gets younger, until
it's just a picture of baby Hitler in his mother's arms. And that's when Fleora
stops firing. He doesn't shoot baby Hitler. Even though he's been through so much, he
can't kill a child. The message of the film, therefore, is that despite everything,
you cannot completely lose your humanity.
Or, perhaps, this is a way of saying that you cannot stop things from happening. One
of the SS explains that he wanted to kill all the children because, with the children,
it starts all over again, meaning that the conflict never ends because the children grow
up and then start the next war. So he thought that killing all the children would stop the
cycle, and that's why he also says that not every race has a right to exist. But Fleora
cannot kill baby Hitler, which could be interpreted in a few ways, but to me, this suggests that
he cannot stop the war from happening, and probably means that he has lost his innocence,
just like baby Hitler did.
The film poses other questions. The German commander claims he's an old and sick man
who didn't do any harm to anyone, which brings up the whole, I was just following
orders debate, and the, I just gave the orders, I didn't actually kill anyone myself, excuse.
In other words, no one wants to take responsibility for their actions. These were genuine excuses
made by the Germans at the end of the war to get themselves off the hook. And you still
get people trying to defend the Germans to this day with the exact same excuses.
The commander also says, but this is wartime, and it's nobody's fault. Well, all's
fair in love and war, right? So do our morals just go out the window when it's wartime?
Can we all just become mass murderers because we're fighting someone else? Again, these
are questions the film asks, and they're right there in line with what the Allies had
to deal with during and at the end of the war.
Now the fanatical German doesn't accept the excuses, and calls his commander a swine
and a dog, and more names, including atypical German. And the film depicts the difference
between a normal German, who was supposedly just following orders, versus one of the SS
fanatics. This was actually a real defence used by many Germans in the aftermath of the
war. Many German generals, for example, tried to claim that they weren't members of the
SS, and thus didn't commit war crimes. Any that they did happen to commit were all Madman
Hitler's fault, and they were just following orders. Of course, the normal Germans did
commit crimes alongside the SS, and the myth of the clean Wehrmacht has since been debunked
although many still believe the lie. But the film does well to bring up this issue. However,
it also slips up a little. For one member of the SS to call another member of the SS
a typical German is silly, especially since it was the commander who was there and made
the village massacre happen. It's clear from the historical sources that the commanders
of the units involved in massacres like this were as fanatical as anyone else. So the film
brings up the issue, but in a very awkward way that doesn't make much sense. It would
have been better if they'd captured an SS commander, and a regular German army commander,
and then had this sequence play out. But then that would have been inaccurate, since no
regular German army unit took part in the Katyn village massacre, and so it would have
led to more inaccuracies. In other words, they tried to shoehorn the
just-following-orders excuse into the film, but it comes off clumsily and doesn't make
sense the more you think about it. Also, the fanatical German is called a Fascist by another
German. Which is also inaccurate because they weren't Fascists, they were Nazis or National
Socialists. The Soviets and the Communists, and many other people to this day, get this
wrong. But there's actually a major difference between a Fascist and a National Socialist.
And a German soldier in the Second World War wouldn't have called his fanatical comrade
a Fascist for this reason, so this is a slip-up. The Russian or Ukrainian collaborators try
to say that they're not guilty, that they should just be let go, and that they should
just kill the Germans. One says, they made us do it. Nonetheless, they're all killed,
and in the comments of my Operation Keelhaul videos, or in the ones on the Ukrainians,
I got a lot of Russian viewers arguing that Nazi collaborators should all be killed, even
those who didn't collaborate, or didn't fight in the war, or those that were women
and children. Well, this film is asking the question, but is this really the case? Were
they forced into fighting for the Germans? Now, we know that the Schutzmannschaft Battalion
118 were Ukrainian Nationalist volunteers, so there's no excuse for those guys. But
you have to remember that the Germans were murdering, pillaging, and stealing all the
food and women from the Ukrainians, the Belarusians, and more, forcing many to choose between collaboration
or starvation. So some were genuinely forced into helping the Germans, or working with
them to some extent. Should they all be shot as well?
And again, these are genuine questions that played out in the Second World War, which
is something the film does well to bring up. For the most part, the Soviet authorities
had little mercy for collaborators, even those who had been sent to the slave labour camps
of the Reich. But were they right? Let me know in the comments below.
The fanatical German says,
"...you've got no right to be. Not every race has a right to exist. Inferior races
spread the contagion of Communism."
This is all an accurate depiction of how the SS thought. But there was more to it than
just that. I've been over this in my other videos, so I'd recommend that you check
out my video on Hitler's Socialism if you want to get a better understanding of the
ideology behind the SS and what they were trying to do in the Soviet Union. And overall,
despite the odd clumsy mistake here or there, Come and See is a faithful representation
of events that took place in the war. Not 100% accurate, it's not a documentary, but
I'd still recommend watching it if you haven't already. So thanks for watching, bye for now.
