There is photographic, video and contemporary reports of Adolf Hitler being elected into the Socialist Bavarian People's State and the Communist Bavarian Soviet Republic. While historians have acknowledged that this happened, they're reluctant to come to any conclusions regarding it (since it will fundamentally undermine their own narratives). In this video, we're going to dive into the evidence and the debate surrounding this topic. Was Hitler a Communist in 1919? Let's find out.
This video isn't sponsored. My income comes purely from my Patreons and SubscribeStars, and from YouTube ad revenue. So, if you'd like to support this channel and make these videos possible, please consider becoming a Patreon or SubscribeStar. All supporters who pledge $1 or more will have their names listed in the videos. For $5 or more you can ask questions which I will answer in future Q&A videos (note: I'm behind with the Q&A's right now, and have a lot of research to do to catch up, so there will be a delay in answering questions). There are higher tiers too with additional perks, so check out the links below for more details.
Thank you to my current supporters! You're AWESOME!
- - - - -
📽️ RELATED VIDEO LINKS 📽️
Hitler's Socialism | Destroying the Denialist Counter Arguments BEST book I've EVER read on Hitler and National Socialism Marx's Anti-Semitism DEFINED | The Difference between Fascism and National Socialism it REALLY Began - BankWars: Weimar Hyperinflation Episode 1 Theory 101 - - - -
ABOUT TIK 📝
History isn’t as boring as some people think, and my goal is to get people talking about it. I also want to dispel the myths and distortions that ruin our perception of the past by asking a simple question - “But is this really the case?”. I have a 2:1 Degree in History and a passion for early 20th Century conflicts (mainly WW2). I’m therefore approaching this like I would an academic essay. Lots of sources, quotes, references and so on. Only the truth will do.
This video is discussing events or concepts that are academic, educational and historical in nature. This video is for informational purposes and was created so we may better understand the past and learn from the mistakes others have made.Credit: TIKhistory
This is a picture of the funeral procession for Jewish Socialist-Revolutionary Kurt Eisner,
who had been a member of Karl Marx's party, the Social Democratic Party of Germany, the SPD.
And yes, that is Hitler. There's also video footage of this event where Hitler is visible,
although I can't show it here for copyright reasons, and there's contemporary evidence
explaining why Hitler was elected into Kurt Eisner's Bavarian People's State,
and then, after Eisner's Socialist Republic collapsed, he was elected again into a Bavarian
Soviet Republic which was Communist. And why, despite being a raging anti-Semite not long after,
Hitler was attending the funeral of a Jewish Socialist-Revolutionary who was the leader of
that Bavarian Socialist Republic. Also, one of Hitler's chauffeurs, Julius Schreck,
founder of the SS, and seen here with Adolf, fought in the Bavarian Red Army. And Freikorps
Epp fought against this Soviet Republic with members including Ernst Röhm, Hans Frank,
Rudolf Hesse, and both of the Strassers, who were supposedly the left-wing element of the
Nazi Party but were fighting against the Communists in 1919, whereas Hitler and his
chauffeur were fighting for them. There's a lot to unpack here, so let's get on with it.
Let's start with the facts. On the 7th of November 1918, before the Social Democrats
seized power all over Germany, Kurt Eisner, a Jewish revolutionary, quit Karl Marx's Social
Democratic Party because he thought it wasn't revolutionary enough, and conducted a putsch
in Munich. As leader of the Bavarian Independent Social Democrats, he founded a far-left Bavarian
Socialist Republic, also known as the People's State of Bavaria. Eisner wanted independence from
the Weimar Republic, and attempted to reform the capitalist system into a socialist one,
although he promised that they would not do what Lenin had done in Russia.
Well, a soldier called Adolf Hitler was elected into the soldier's Soviet Council and became
the deputy battalion representative. He was elected by his fellow soldiers, who also
overwhelmingly voted for the Social Democrats in January 1919, meaning that they thought
that Hitler best represented their socialist views. But this Bavarian Socialist regime
was unpopular in the countryside, and lost support after the election of January 1919.
I mean, it's no wonder, since just like every other socialist regime, they failed
to maintain food supplies, or provide jobs, or keep the transportation system functioning.
Workers began to heckle Eisner and shout him down at meetings. In cabinet, Eisner was angrily
told by one of its members,
"...you are an anarchist! You are no statesman! You are a fool! We are being ruined by bad
management!"
So, an aristocratic student and former officer, Graf Anton von Arkowalli, assassinated Kurt
Eisner on the 21st of February 1919, ironically as Eisner was on his way to resign. There
is film footage and a still photograph showing him, Hitler, marching in the funeral procession
of the Bavarian independent leader, Kurt Eisner, wearing a black mourning armband,
and another red one in support of the socialist government. Here again is the still photo,
and I can't show the footage of Eisner's funeral because I don't want my video to
get copyright striked by YouTube, but I have seen it, you can find it if you're determined,
and Hitler is in it.
Hoffman's photograph is grainy, but both he and his son have confirmed that the photo
depicts Hitler. In fact, an arrow had been affixed to the photo's negative that points
directly to Hitler, added by Hoffman, his son, or his grandson. In the early 1980's,
Hoffman's son publicly confirmed that the man in the photo was indeed Hitler. While
Hitler could easily have joined, for instance, the Thule Society, which had inspired Eisner's
assassination, and which was full of future National Socialist leaders such as Alfred
Rosenberg, Rudolf Hess, or Hans Frank, Hitler chose publicly to show his support for Eisner.
Sepp Dietricht, later a general in the Waffen-SS and head of Hitler's SS-Liebstandarte,
was elected chairman of a soldiers' council in November 1918. So yes, Hitler and Dietricht
were elected into a revolutionary socialist government in 1919, and Hitler took part in
the funeral procession of Kurt Eisner, who was Jewish, which is why he may not have wanted
to admit that later in Mein Kampf.
"...towards the end of November 1918, I returned to Munich. I went to the depot of
my regiment, which was now in the hands of the soldiers' councils. As the whole administration
was quite repulsive to me, I decided to leave it as soon as I possibly could."
He said he left Munich, and then…
"...the situation there could not last as it was. It tended irresistibly to a further
extension of the revolution. Eisner's death served only to hasten this development, and
finally led to the dictatorship of the councils, or, to put it more correctly, to a Jewish
hegemony, which turned out to be transitory, but which was the original aim of those who
had contrived the revolution."
Hitler claims he was having doubts whether he could shape events at this time, and then
says…
"...a few days after the liberation of Munich, I was ordered to appear before the Inquiry
Commission, which had been set up in the 2nd Infantry Regiment for the purpose of watching
revolutionary activities. This was my first incursion to the more or less political field."
Almost all of this is a lie. He had been involved with the Bavarian Socialists, and was a political
representative in their Soviet. So, he was already in politics before March 1919. And
rather than leaving Munich and not getting involved in the supposed Jewish Revolution,
Hitler took part in it. The Communists had referred to Kurt Eisner's Bavarian People
State as a pseudo-Councils Republic, Schein-Retter-Republic, probably because it didn't bow to Moscow
like they did. Well, after Kurt Eisner's death, the Communists held their own revolution
and created what they called a real Councils Republic-Retter-Republic. Yes, real Socialism.
Today, Bavaria has finally elected the dictatorship of the proletariat. This real Socialist dictatorship
under the command of Max Levine attempted to create a Soviet-style system in Bavaria
with links to Moscow. Hitler was elected again into this government as a representative for
his battalion, so Hitler became a member of the Communist-Soviet government that had links
to Moscow. And yes, this was real Communism, or Socialism, or whatever you want to call
it.
On 14th of April 1919, the day after the Communist-Retter-Republic, Soviet Republic, had been proclaimed,
the Munich Soldiers' Councils approved fresh elections of all barracks representatives
to ensure that the Munich garrison stood loyally behind the new regime. In the elections the
following day, Hitler was chosen as deputy battalion representative. Not only then did
Hitler do nothing to assist in the crushing of Munich's Red Republic, he was an elected
representative of his battalion during the whole period of its existence. Hitler not
only supported Germany's Communist regime during this brief time period, but also bestowed
his blessings to a government that had pledged allegiance to Lenin's Soviet Russia in Moscow.
Worse, having described this Communist-Republic as a Jewish hegemony, Hitler effectively admitted
that he had supported, and was a part of, a government that was once in Jewish hegemony
at this time. So it's no wonder he wanted to distance himself from this.
Well, the revolutionary Socialist government in Berlin, headed by Friedrich Ebert, leader
of Karl Marx's Social Democratic Party, wasn't happy that Bavarian Bolshevik Communists
had declared independence from the rest of Germany, so he sent in his own revolutionary
forces to put them down. The government troops and the Freikorps, both of which were fighting
for the revolutionary Berlin government, have since been deemed to be counter-revolutionaries,
because they fought against the Spartacists and other Communists. However, this is a blatant
misinterpretation of history. The Bolsheviks in Russia weren't counter-revolutionaries
just because they fought against the Mensheviks. Stalin wasn't a counter-revolutionary because
he fought against Trotsky. The Soviets and Chinese Communists weren't counter-revolutionaries
because they got embroiled in border wars with each other. And similarly, the Freikorps
weren't counter-revolutionary because they fought for a revolutionary Socialist government
headed by the same party Karl Marx had been a part of, against another lot of revolutionaries.
Yet somehow, historians have fallen under the sway of Marxist propaganda and continue
to spout this myth that the Freikorps were counter-revolutionary and far-right, whatever
that means.
And if the argument were true that the vision of all Freikorps, and of all its members,
stood completely opposed to democracy, it was instead of Fascist ethos that they espoused
and practiced, we are left with no answers as to why DDP members such as Friedlin Solodur,
and even some Jewish veterans, had fought in the Freikorps. Even the Freikorps Oberland
– sections of which were later to form the nucleus of the SA – included not only Heinrich
Himmler and Arthur Rodel, who, as we shall see, was to become a concentration camp commander,
but also several Jewish members. Even Himmler's politicalization towards Fascism
– Nazism – was only to take place in 1922. There was, thus, no direct line from servicing
the Freikorps to a politicalization towards radical right-wing Fascism – Nazism.
There's a difference between Fascism and Nazism which many historians refuse to recognize,
which is why I'm correcting the quote.
Anyway, the revolutionary Freikorps and revolutionary government troops destroyed
the revolutionary Bavarian Soviet Republic in little over two weeks. The Freikorps were
defending the revolution against a second revolution, and so weren't counter-revolutionary
at all. Their destruction of the Bavarian Communists was made easier by the fact that
this second Soviet regime was equally as unpopular as the first. Why? Because the Communists
decided not to help the poor at all in their time of need, despite claiming in their ideology
that that was what they existed for. As food shortages heightened, especially of milk,
the people demanded that the Soviets feed them, and their response was, what does it
matter? Most of it goes to the children of the bourgeoisie anyway. We are not interested
in keeping them alive. No harm if they die. They'd only grow into enemies of the proletariat.
A lot of the Bavarian Socialist leaders were Jewish, adding to the idea that the Marxists
were a bunch of Jews. But one soldier in the Bavarian Red Army who wasn't Jewish was
Julius Schreck, who would later go on to be Hitler's chauffeur until he died of natural
causes in 1936. Schreck would, in March 1925, found the Schutzstaffel, or SS for short.
So the guy who founded the Nazi SS, and later became Hitler's chauffeur, was a Communist
in 1919, and fought for the Red Army.
Hermann Esser, one of Hitler's earliest supporters, who became the first propaganda
chief of the NSDAP, had been for a while a journalist on a social-democratic newspaper.
Gottfried Feder, whose views on intra-slavery so gripped Hitler's imagination in summer
1919, had sent a statement of his position to the Socialist government headed by Kurt
Eisner the previous November. Just to point out, Gottfried Feder was one of the founders
of the German Workers' Party that would later become the National Socialist German
Workers' Party, or NSDAP, the Nazi Party.
It's also interesting that many socialists will say that the Nazi Party did attract socialists
to its ranks in the early days, but it was all a trick, and Hitler had them bumped off,
proving that he wasn't a socialist. They talk about Ernst Röhm getting assassinated
in the Night of the Long Knives, and also that Hitler killed Gregor Strasser and exiled
his brother Otto Strasser, all of whom supposedly represented the left-wing socialist element
of the National Socialist Party. There's a million counter-arguments against this,
but on the topic of this video, it's interesting that neither Ernst Röhm nor the Strassers
participated in the Communist Bavarian Socialist Republic. You'd think that they, as the
left-wing socialist element, would support the Communists. But not only did they not,
they actually fought against it.
Both Strassers and Ernst Röhm were members of Freikorps Epp, along with Hans Frank and
Rudolf Hess. Hans Frank would be the guy who took charge of Poland and oversaw the extermination
camps. Rudolf Hess would obviously go on to be the Deputy Führer, second only to Hitler,
until he decided to fly to Scotland because he really liked I.M. Breuer. And Epp would
later be appointed by Hitler to Reichsgovernor of Bavaria in 1933. So all of these supposedly
left-wing elements of the Nazi Party fought in the supposed far-right counter-revolutionary
movement against the Communists in Bavaria, which Schreck and Hitler were in.
So who was the left-wing element of the Party again? More likely, two revolutionary left-wing
entities were vying for power against each other, and all of these future members of
the National Socialist Party were caught up fighting for what they perceived to be real
Socialism. But obviously, Hitler later wanted to downplay his role in the Socialist and
Communist Soviets of Bavaria, and the reason was because he had to do his best, later,
to separate his National Socialist ideology from Marxist Socialist ideology, since there
were so many similarities between the two. In fact, it's my opinion that that was the
reason Mein Kampf was written, to make a distinction between his Socialism versus their Socialism.
That's why there are passages in Mein Kampf where he's defending himself from the accusation
that they were one and the same.
The racial Weltanschauung, the Nazi worldview, is fundamentally distinguished from the Marxist
by reason of the fact that the former recognizes the significance of race, and therefore also
personal worth, and has made these the pillars of its structure. These are the most important
factors of its Weltanschauung worldview.
"...if the National Socialist movement should fail to understand the fundamental importance
of this essential principle, if it should merely varnish the external appearance of
the present state and adopt the majority principle, it would really do nothing more than compete
with Marxism on its own ground. For that reason, it would not have the right to call
itself a Weltanschauung worldview. If the social program of the movement consisted in
eliminating personality and putting the multitude in its place, then National Socialism would
be corrupted with the poison of Marxism, just like our national bourgeois parties are."
Translation. The only difference between National Socialism and Marxism is that National Socialism
believes in racial classes rather than economic classes, and that if the Nazis forget this,
and if they stood by the principle of mob rule, then they would be Marxists. And yes,
I'm paraphrasing slightly and bringing in other elements he wrote elsewhere in Mein
Kampf, but that's exactly what he wrote. Now, he wouldn't have written this if others
weren't accusing him of being a Marxist by another name. So he was writing this to
not only defend himself, but also distinguish his Socialism against their Socialism.
When Hitler says in Mein Kampf that he wasn't part of the Social Democratic Party, and doesn't
mention his involvement in the Bavarian Soviets, and doesn't mention his attendance at Kurt
Eisner's funeral, we know why. Because he was trying to distance himself, as well as
his National Socialism, from the Marxists. And the Marxists are equally happy to accept
this because they want to distance themselves from National Socialism.
Because they're all very similar Socialist movements.
But don't worry Communists, because historians are eager to come to your rescue. In his book
Hitler's First War, historian Thomas Weber explains that Hitler didn't like Munich,
and only returned to it because his regiment was to be demobilized there. Plus, the fact
that he had no friends, or family, or a job, or a life, yep, definitely sounds like a Communist,
meant that he ended up staying in Munich because that's where his social network was.
Or, he was a Socialist. But no, because Weber refuses to accept this. If he really was a
Socialist after the war, how do we make sense of his anti-Socialist expressions during the
war, for which contemporary sources exist at least for 1915? How do we make sense of
his closeness to, and adoration of, officers among the regimental staff who clearly were
not Socialists?
So to answer the second part, let me ask the same question from the opposite side. If he
really was a far-right counter-revolutionary who hated Jews at this time, how come he was
friendly with his fellow soldiers in the regiment, some of whom were Jews, and most of whom were
Socialists, who then went on to elect him twice into the Soviets? Clearly, it doesn't
matter which side of the spectrum he's on, because he'll have to have put up with people
in his regiment that don't align with his views. And just because he had to rub shoulders
with people with differing viewpoints doesn't mean he wasn't a Socialist, or a Nazi, or
whatever, right? So this second question is neither here nor there.
And unfortunately, Weber doesn't provide any examples of the anti-Socialist expressions
that Hitler supposedly said, so I'm curious to know if they were actually anti-Socialist,
or whether they were typical of the disputes raging at the time within the Socialist camp,
since the Social Democratic Party split into various factions as a result of the ideological
flaws inherent within Marxist Socialism, something I discussed in-depth in the Weimar series.
In a similar vein, a lot of people will give me a quote of Hitler saying he doesn't like
Marxists or Marxism, and say, see, he hated Socialists, so he couldn't have been one.
But no, he's criticising Marxism, not Socialism itself. Marxist Socialism is but one variant
of a whole spectrum of Socialist movements. The argument I'm making is that Hitler was
a Socialist, but not a Marxist Socialist. He hated Marxists because he didn't think
they were real Socialists, just like Marxists think that everything is not real Socialism.
So when Weber says Hitler made anti-Socialist comments, is that another case of Hitler criticising
certain Socialist individuals, or factions of Socialists, or is it a case of him hating
on Socialism itself? Because I suspect that, if he did make such statements, that he didn't
But more importantly, this argument falls flat because we know that Hitler was elected
twice into the Bavarian Soviet Republics. So even on the off-chance that he was genuinely
anti-Socialist in 1915, which I doubt, but let's just assume that for a moment, then
it makes even less sense why he would suddenly spout Socialist ideology and get elected into
the Bavarian Soviets. Surely his fellow soldiers would know he was anti-Socialist. So more
likely he wasn't anti-Socialist in 1915, even if he disputed some of the Socialist
policies or whatever it was that he said. Also, we know he attended the funeral of Kurt
Eisner, who was Jewish. So the same logic could apply to this. If he was an anti-Semite
later, how come he wasn't an anti-Semite earlier? Well, perhaps it's because he changed
his mind. Maybe he wasn't an anti-Semite in early 1919, but became one later that year.
In fact, that's what the evidence suggests. And similarly, if he was anti-Socialist in
1915, then maybe he was pro-Socialist by 1919. He changed his mind about the Jews, so maybe
he could change his mind about Socialism too. And interestingly, Weber himself says
exactly this elsewhere in his own book.
However, his widely-articulated ideas had not yet, in 1916, made the transformation
from merely bitterly extolling the stupidity of a military enemy in the House of Habsburgs
towards expressing National Socialist ideas as found in Mein Kampf. In short, Hitler might
have acquired most of his subsequent rhetorical style by this point. He might also have harboured
fantasies about a political career. His political ideas, as expressed to others, were, it seems,
still limited to an expression of some pan-German ideas, and to venting of frustration about
the battlefield adversaries of the List Regiment. Hitler clearly changed his mind regarding
the Jews in 1919, and it seems that he also changed his mind about Marxism, which he then
decided was a Jewish plot.
Contrary to the accepted Marxist interpretation, Hitler was not an opponent of Marxism and
did not want to destroy it because he was inimical to Labour, but because he was caught
up in the insane idea that Marxism was an instrument of the Jews for the achievement
of world domination, and above all because he rejected internationalism, pacifism, and
the negation of the personality principle by Marxism. Perhaps he only perceived that
the Social Democrats and Communists were part of a so-called Jewish conspiracy as
a result of the growing belief throughout Germany in mid-to-late 1919 that this was
what was happening. Thus, following the crowd, he turned away from those so-called Jewish
variants of Socialism, and then joined a Socialist movement that was based on German nationalism
and race. That could be a better explanation than saying, as Weber does, that Hitler just
wasn't sure which way to turn in early 1919, and was confused. Because yes, it's madman
Hitler time.
Err, no, I'm not accepting that excuse. Another book, Death by Democracy by Hett,
also tries to excuse Hitler's Socialism.
How do we square this with Hitler's later record? It is possible that at this early
point he could accommodate himself to any government with a collectivist ideology, of
the right or left. More likely, it was simple opportunism. Private Hitler did not want
to return to his pre-war life of poverty and isolation. The army had become his home as
well as his employer, and if staying in it meant serving a radical Socialist government,
so be it.
Right, he hated Marxists with a passion, but was willing to join them in 1919 because he
didn't want to leave the army, even though he could have joined the Freikorps, or some
other Nationalist organisation, or just not gone into politics and have just stayed in
his regiment. But no, he was such an opportunist that he decided not to look for other opportunities.
Well, the alternative to this argument is much simpler. He was a Socialist, and remained
so throughout his life. That would actually be the best conclusion here. But of course,
we're not allowed to consider that option.
Hitler's shift from revolutionary Socialism to the anti-Semitic far-right is important
to, oh yes, that's right, he can't be on the left because Hitler hated the Jews,
and we know that no Socialist ever hated the Jews. Nope, none whatsoever. Except Karl Marx
did, so did Stalin, and so did Lenin as well actually, and most of the members of the Labour
Party. Are we just going to ignore the fact that anti-Semitism is a left-wing position?
Are we going to ignore the fact that Hitler was a revolutionary, and that National Socialism
conducted a failed revolution in 1923, and a successful one in 1933? Also, Hitler implemented
far more Socialist policies than the Social Democrats ever did. Are we just going to ignore
all that because we don't want anyone to realise that anti-Semitism is fundamental
to Socialist ideology?
Christ drove the Jewish money-changers out of the Temple, and that the money-changers
of our age enlisted on the side of tyranny happen again to be Jews is perhaps no more
than a historic coincidence.
As Samuels writes,
"...racial intolerance against Jews plays little part in the question of whether Hitler's
own beliefs were more right-wing or left-wing, since historically the Socialist movement
from day one has been hostile to the Jews and their capital merchant culture."
Unsurprisingly, Ian Kershaw gives a very similar view to Hett in his biography of Hitler.
After providing evidence that Hitler was elected into the Soviet Council's Republic, Kershaw
writes,
"...how to interpret this evidence is, nevertheless, not altogether clear, because, having swallowed
the blue pill, he can't accept what the facts are telling him."
Instead of admitting that Nationalism and anti-Semitism are actually left-wing ideas,
Kershaw dismisses this and says,
"...ideological muddle-headedness, political confusion and opportunism combine frequently
to produce fickle and shifting allegiances."
No, the only muddle-headedness here is the historians who can't fathom why glorious
Socialism and Communism might not be what they dream it is. Also, while we're on the
subject, the reason why you can't define Fascism, Kershaw, is because you're denying
what's at the beating heart of it, Socialism. That's why Kershaw also doesn't like the
idea of Hitler being a Socialist who formed his own racist nationalist version of Socialism.
If, as seems almost certain, Hitler felt compelled to lean outwardly towards the majority Social
Democrats during the revolutionary months, it was not prompted by conviction, but by
sheer opportunism aimed at avoiding, for as long as possible, demobilization from the
army.
I see. So the reason Hitler got into power in 1933, and implemented more Socialist policies
than anyone else before him in the history of Germany, including both the Socialists
and the Communists, was because he was trying not to be demobilized. Really. Is that the
conclusion we're really coming to, Kershaw?
Kershaw then speculates, with no evidence at all, that Hitler was against the Left at
this time, which is why the soldiers voted for him, contradicting what he stated earlier
in his book about them being in favour of the Socialist government. In other words,
we have a Marxist historian floundering to explain away the reality that Hitler was a
Communist in 1919. Hitler was probably known to those around him, at least towards the
end of April, which is after he was elected the first time, for the counter-revolutionary
he really was, whose actual sympathies were indistinguishable from those of the White
troops preparing to storm the city. Again, no evidence here, just speculation. Also,
he was elected into the Socialist government before April, February in fact, so this is
more clutching at straws. Also, if Hitler was a counter-revolutionary, why wasn't
he fighting with the supposed counter-revolutionary troops, the Freikorps? Why instead was he
elected into the revolutionary government? Why did he never join the forces of counter-revolution,
and instead mounted his own revolution in 1933, with a failed one in 1923? Again, speculation
and a dismissal of the evidence because the facts don't fit into Kershaw's blue-pilled
worldview.
Historian Richard Evans, a historian who has his roots in the Marxist tradition, gives
a detailed history of the Bavarian Soviet Republics, yet doesn't even mention that
Hitler was elected into them in 1919. He takes Hitler's view, clearly incorrect, that his
first interest in politics came as he joined the German Workers' Party in September 1919.
I can't imagine why a historian who has his roots in the Marxist tradition would do
this, but what's really interesting is that Evans says this.
"...while conventional right-wing politicians delivered lectures or spoke in a style that
was oratund and pompous, flat and dull or rough and brutish, Hitler followed the model
of social-democratic orators such as Eisner or the left-wing agitators from whom he later
claimed to have learned in Vienna."
Well, isn't that strange? Yes, he might have listened to these socialists in Vienna,
but also, he might have listened to them during his stint as a socialist and communist in
early 1919. I mean, Hitler attended Kurt Eisner's funeral, so maybe he heard him speak during
his time in the Bavarian People's State. Did Kurt Eisner ever go to Vienna before the
war? If not, then the only opportunity Hitler would have had to hear him speak would have
been during late 1918 and early 1919, just when he was elected into the Soviets. So why
aren't we allowed to put two and two together here? Why must we excuse and ignore the growing
convergence of evidence?
What these historians are forgetting is that during this time, various social-democratic
groups were trying to bring the ideas of Socialism and Nationalism together. At the same time,
deviant socialist movements were deemed right-wing extremists and similar by so-called Orthodox
Marxists. In fact, this practice still goes on, with Noam Chomsky calling Lenin and the
Bolsheviks right-wing in a speech given in 1989. And we have an Orwell quote where non-Moscow
socialists were being called Trotsky fascists during the Spanish Civil War. So this is a
common occurrence with socialist factions.
One wonders, given this, why Hitler would be regarded as more of a right-wing socialist
or revolutionary conservative than a left-wing socialist. Hitler proposed calling his socialism
a type of National Social Democracy. And finally, as Ian Kershaw himself admits, Hitler only
started hating on the Bolsheviks and the Jews in the summer of 1919, after the fall of the
Bavarian Soviet Republics.
So, the evidence points clearly to the fact that Hitler was a Communist in early 1919.
Both the Marxist-influenced historians and the National Socialist ones will, of course,
try to excuse their way out of this for ideological and financial reasons. But by doing so, they're
just highlighting the fact that they carry a deep ideological agenda to push the idea
that there is a separation from so-called Real Socialism and the other variants of Socialism
that they do not like.
Well, good for them, but not on my watch. If you want to learn about all the socialism
Hitler implemented during his time in power, check out my 5 hour video on Hitler's Socialism.
And to learn more about the political and economic situation in the early Weimar years,
including the key split between the various socialist factions, check out my Weimar Hyperinflation
series. Thanks for watching, bye for now.