Investment manager Brent Johnson caused a stir in 2018 when he published his dollar milkshake theory.
He predicted the world would face a major currency crisis but said the U.S. dollar would be the last domino to fall. This was like heresy to those who were predicting the death of the dollar due to rampant money printing and global “de-dollarization.”
But today, four years later, Johnson’s theory seems to be playing out as the U.S. dollar strengthens rapidly against all major currencies.
So with a global currency crisis possibly unfolding, what does it mean for the dollar’s status as the world’s reserve currency?
In this interview with NTD’s Paul Greaney, Johnson explains how important reserve currency status is—not just for the standard of living in America, but also for U.S. power and influence globally.
“The U.S. is using the dollar as a weapon. Putin is using energy as a weapon. So we’ve got economic war, and we’ve got, literally, kinetic war going on … anybody who really understands what a global reserve currency is, it’s not an economic thing. It’s a power thing. And nobody ever gives up power. The king very, very rarely abdicates the throne.”
I happen to think it'll get pretty serious.
They're ultimately going to have to decide,
do we save the currency,
or do we save the bond market and the banking system?
It's true today in Japan, in the UK, in Europe,
in Turkey, and many other places around the world.
This does not mean things are good in the United States.
I just think it means that they are better
in the United States than they are overseas.
Historically, have these types of crises
resulted in political change globally?
Yes.
Sides are being chosen.
Rather than the world coming together,
the world's kind of moving apart.
You know, the dollar, if used correctly,
is probably the biggest weapon we have,
perhaps even greater than a nuclear bomb.
Good evening.
Welcome to NTD's Fresh Look America.
I'm Paul Grady.
The dollar milkshake theory
made Brent Johnson famous in 2018.
He predicted a global currency crisis,
but said that the U.S. dollar,
before it faced its own crisis,
would rise significantly against other world currencies.
It wasn't a popular opinion at the time,
but it looks like that is exactly what is happening.
Since 2018, the dollar is up 15% on the British pound,
15% on the euro,
and 27% on the Japanese yen.
Johnson says that the demand for dollars globally is huge.
It is the world's reserve currency.
People need it for international trade.
And also, many outside the U.S. have taken out dollar loans,
and the interest payments alone on that debt is huge.
This is one reason why the U.S. government
has been able to print so much new money recently
without the dollar weakening versus other currencies.
For background on the dollar milkshake theory,
you can watch our previous interview with Johnson
that was at last year's New Orleans Investment Conference.
But today, we'll focus on what a currency crisis
would mean for America's position
as the world's most powerful country.
So Brent Johnson, thank you.
It's great to speak with you.
Thanks for having me back.
Good to talk to you.
So Brent, you're predicting a global currency crisis.
How serious will it get?
And how will it affect regular Americans?
Well, yeah, how bad will it get?
That's a very good question.
I happen to think it'll get pretty serious.
That doesn't mean it's going to happen tomorrow.
I actually think something as big as a currency crisis
will typically take longer to fully play out than many others.
And part of the reason I think that is
once you get a currency in trouble
or government bonds in trouble,
you typically get reactions from monetary authorities,
governments, central banks to try to quell the problem.
And so I think they will probably do whatever they can
to kind of kick us down the road.
But I think we've kind of gotten to the point
where they can no longer kick it too far.
And so I do think that we will have a serious crisis.
Are you expecting something akin to the financial crisis?
Can you make some comparison there?
Yeah, I think it's more akin to the currency crisis that we had,
the Asian currency crisis in the late 90s
or the number of currency crises that Argentina's gone through.
What's happening, I think there's a lot of people,
perhaps in the US, who understand that the US
has borrowed too much money.
We run a budget deficit, we run a trade deficit.
You know, we borrowed a lot of money at very low interest rates.
We're never going to be able to pay it back.
They're going to have to inflate the debt away.
All of these arguments for how the US has been too profligate
and at some point we're going to have to pay the price.
And I do think that there's truth in those arguments.
But what I think a lot of people miss
is that while that may someday be true for the United States,
it's true today in Japan, in the UK, in Europe,
in Turkey, many other places around the world.
So while it may be true for the US someday,
it's already true for others today.
And as a result, that's why you've seen the dollar rising
so aggressively versus these other currencies.
And so, you know, the governments and the monetary authorities
of these other countries, whether it's the UK,
whether it's Japan, whether it's Sri Lanka,
they're ultimately going to have to decide,
do we save the currency or do we save the bond market
and the banking system?
History shows that governments try to protect both,
but they ultimately have to choose one
and they choose to save the bond market and the banking system.
And as a result, the currency falls a lot.
And when the currency falls,
that's when you get the currency crisis.
So can you take some of these areas
that we're seeing crises in at the moment
and perhaps what we could expect to see in the United States
if things play out in a similar way?
Well, I think what you have to remember,
well, if I can give you an example,
both Japan and Europe and the UK,
they have borrowed a lot of money over the last 10 years,
whether it's for bailouts, stimulus programs,
however you want to define that.
A lot of that was done at either very low interest rates
or negative interest rates.
Now with inflationary pressures
as a result of the COVID policies and the shutdowns
and, you know, deglobalization and the lack of supply,
we're getting inflationary pressures,
which the world has not had to deal with
on a great scale for a very long time.
That, those inflationary pressures
makes it harder to use the tools
that were used in the global financial crisis
to combat a global slowdown.
So now we have a global slowdown and inflationary pressures.
If they were to use the same policies
they used coming out of the global financial crisis,
it would exacerbate the inflationary pressures
as opposed to fight them.
So you were saying these central banks in the past
and up until now have used inflationary measures
to combat crises, similar crises,
but now we're seeing across the world,
you know, record high inflation.
You're saying it's not as easy.
Is it impossible for them to use these?
They risk, if I'm not mistaken,
on one hand exacerbating the inflation
or on the other hand, you know, financial crisis.
That's right.
And if they do use these policies
to combat the deflationary pressures
and do exacerbate the inflationary pressures,
then they're going to have a social crisis on their hand
because the citizens are not just going to sit there
and accept record high inflation
and a decreasing standard of living.
If you look back,
I don't want to sound too overly dramatic,
but if you look back at every revolution in history,
it happened when people were out of work
and they were hungry and they were cold.
Well, right now we've got high inflation.
Their jobs are not as secure and, you know,
food prices are rising, you know,
and energy prices are rising.
So they're cold.
They have the potential to be very cold this winter.
They have the potential to be hungry
and they have the potential to be very upset.
And so I think, you know, history shows
that governments typically use financial repression
to get out of an over-indebted situation.
What that means is they let inflation run hot
and inflate the debt away.
It works really, really well on a spreadsheet.
You know, you hold rates low,
you let inflation go high,
you let inflation run at 5% or 6% for 10 years,
and you've just inflated away 50% of the debt.
Works fantastic on a spreadsheet.
The problem is when you do that in the real world,
that's when people walk out into the street with pitchforks, right?
And politically, it's not easy for politicians
and governments and central bankers
to just let inflation run wild.
It's much more difficult to do it in the real world
than it is on the spreadsheet.
So you're saying that these policies have been,
you know, government deficits,
rampant government spending has been happening for a long time.
You're saying that governments have had ways
to get around this through various techniques,
financial techniques, but this time it's different.
So on one hand, they can keep printing money,
let inflation run hot and risk people on the streets.
You know, to me as somebody sitting here,
but imagining a leader, okay, let's fix that problem.
Let's not let inflation run hot.
Let's not have people on the streets.
But what are they trying to protect exactly?
Well, they're trying to protect the status quo.
They're trying to protect their jobs
and they're trying to protect the economy from collapsing
or from a currency collapse.
It kind of depends on which country we're talking about.
But, you know, Powell, Jay Powell,
the head of the Federal Reserve,
has been extremely criticized to an extreme level
for letting inflation run too hot, right?
And so now he's kind of, for lack of a better word, he's mad.
He's mad.
He's upset that inflation got so high.
And so now he's trying his best to bring inflation down.
He's trying to bring inflation down by crushing demand.
And I think he will be more successful in that
than people think he will be.
If he wants to crush inflation, he can do it,
but he'll have to crush the economy to do so.
He literally said at the last meeting,
you know, we need to have a recession
that's going to bring pain.
It may mean people having to lose their jobs
and it may mean people having to get paid less.
Now, that's not a very popular thing to say,
but he said, I believe that that is a lesser evil
than letting inflation continue to run away to the upside.
So here's the point.
Neither solution is good.
You know, the central bankers and these monetary authorities
have backed themselves into a corner
and there's really no good solution out.
And again, it goes to my point,
you either save the bond market or you save the currency.
And I think we're going to see a progression of dominoes
where countries get put in this position
of having to save the currency or save the bond market.
I think they will initially try to save both.
They will ultimately have to choose
to save the bond market and the banking system,
which means the currencies will fall.
And then I think we get into a progression of the dominoes.
Ultimately, it will hit the United States,
but I think that's a further, much further down the road.
And I think it happens all over the world
before it happens here.
And again, this does not mean things are good
in the United States.
I just think it means that they are better
in the United States than they are overseas.
So why do you think authorities will choose
to save the bond market over the currency
and allow this currency crisis to happen?
What leads you to think this?
Well, because history tells me that's what happens.
You know, from a government perspective,
you would much rather inflate away the debt
than to have a collapse.
You know, I think the interesting thing that,
you know, if you talk to anybody in Germany,
they have somebody in their family
who lived through the Weimar inflation.
And so the biggest fear that they have
is the money losing value.
If you talk to any American,
they have somebody in their family
who lived through the Great Depression.
In the Great Depression, money had incredible value
because there were no jobs, there was no money.
So the little money there was had great value.
And so, you know, in America,
we have always fought against deflation.
In Europe or in Germany,
they for a hundred years have fought against inflation.
And it both lead to ruin, both are horrible,
but they're just different sides of the same coin.
Historically, have these types of crises resulted
in significant monetary change
or even political change globally?
Yes, in a short answer, yes.
Not necessarily.
There's typically some kind of a change.
It doesn't necessarily mean there's a regime change,
although it certainly could lead to regime change.
If you think about it, it depends on how bad it gets.
But once a currency loses value,
it basically means there's no more trust in the government.
Trust is lost.
It's hard for a government or a regime to last
if there's no longer trust in it.
And for them to survive a situation
where there's no longer trust in it,
the only way they survive is through force.
And again, I don't necessarily want to predict
these dire outcomes,
but I would expect as currencies lose value around the world,
you're going to see social pushback
and you're going to see revolutions,
for lack of a better word, right?
And some of these will be successful
and some of them won't.
But I think on a bigger stage,
there's been this kind of popular meme
over the last couple of years
that the US and the West
has painted themselves into this corner.
China and Russia are these long-term strategic geniuses
who have done everything right
and they're playing chess while we're paying checkers.
And I think that's kind of the wrong analogy.
Number one, I don't think that they're playing chess
and we're playing checkers.
I don't think that they're that much smarter
and better prepared than the West is.
But I think the game I would more equate this to,
this is the great game.
This is the game of thrones.
You know, this isn't chess and checkers.
This is for all the marbles.
The US is the global hegemon
and has been for a long time.
They want to keep that spot more than anything else.
And more than anything else,
Russia and China want to ascend to that spot
and they're sick and tired of the US telling them what to do
and they're not going to play the game anymore.
And so all of this is kind of coming to a head
at the same time that we're having these financial challenges.
And in fact, it's all related, right?
You know, the US is using the dollar as a weapon.
Putin is using, you know, energy as a weapon.
So we've got economic war
and we've got literally, you know,
kinetic war going on on the borders of Europe.
So, and, you know, many people think that the US
is bound to lose the global reserve currency status
and they will even make the argument
that for economic reasons,
it makes economic sense for the US
to give up the global reserve currency
because while it's a great advantage,
it's also a great burden.
Well, I think that's true
if you look at it through an economic lens.
But anybody who really understands
what a global reserve currency is,
it's not an economic thing.
It's a power thing.
And nobody ever gives up power.
The king very, very rarely abdicates the throne.
I'm not saying it can't happen,
but very rarely does it happen.
And while I don't know everything,
I'm pretty sure the US is not just going to hand over
the global reserve currency
and the global, being the global leader.
And so anybody who wants to ascend to that place
is going to have to knock them off.
And I don't think that they will take that lightly.
So, you know,
Can you explain what the US has to lose
in this potential global crisis?
Well, we have a lot to lose.
We have a, you know,
we have a very high standard of living
in the United States, right?
There's certainly, you know,
sectors of the population who do not have it great.
You know, inequality is rising,
but by and large,
the US has a very high standard of living.
Despite the problems we have,
people from all over the world
still want to come to the United States.
People flowing into the United States
actually helps the United States
because it helps increase demand for businesses,
for products, for services.
It helps growth, right?
It helps economic growth.
If what plays out
leads to the US losing that status
as the safe place in the world
or the global hegemon
or having the world reserve currency,
then potentially people stop
wanting to come to the US
and they want to go somewhere else.
So then we would lose that
not only flow of capital that comes with it,
but we would lose that flow of demographic growth.
And, you know,
once you're at the top,
there's really only one way to go
and it's down, right?
So it doesn't mean that we have to become,
you know, a third world country,
but, you know,
nobody ever wants to take a step back.
You know, everybody always wants to take a step forward.
And once you get used to a certain level of living,
it's very hard to go back to a lower level,
even if that lower level is still pretty good.
And so, you know,
we can see social unrest here in the US.
I mean, we're already seeing it.
We've seen it a lot over the last couple of years.
I just think that, you know,
I don't like sounding like a negative person.
I know when I talk about these things,
it sounds very gloomy.
I think ultimately we'll get through this.
You know, the sun will still rise.
And in many ways,
this great turnover or this great crisis is going to prove,
it's going to present a number of great opportunities as well.
And I think for people who understand the dynamics
that are happening and why they're happening,
I think there's going to be opportunities
to make money over the next couple of years.
And, you know,
while I think about things kind of on a moral level
and a personal level,
that's not my day job.
My day job is to put my moral compass aside.
It's to put, you know,
what I would like to see happen aside.
And my job is to figure out what's going to happen
and place capital in a way
that will make money when that happens.
And, you know,
while that will not necessarily be a fun two or three years,
I think it's going to be a two or three years
that's presented with many dangers,
but many opportunities as well.
I want to ask you about those opportunities
in one minute, Brett,
but I want to ask you,
I think a lot of people are following the Fed now,
even people who may never have heard about
or cared about the Federal Reserve,
you know, pre-COVID,
are following the Fed's meetings,
what they're doing.
And perhaps you can give us some perspective.
How are the Fed's decisions today
impacted by this great power struggle,
global power struggle that you're talking about?
Well, I think there's a couple of ways.
Number one, I think
the Fed is tasked with the domestic economy.
The Fed is not tasked with the global economy.
But as the global hegemon,
and for those who are not familiar,
I apologize for anybody not familiar with this lingo,
hegemon is just,
it's a word that describes kind of the global leader.
You know, the dollar,
if used correctly,
is probably the biggest weapon we have,
perhaps even a greater weapon
than a nuclear bomb.
Because it's, in many ways,
it's silent and it's misunderstood.
I think a lot of people understand
when you drop a nuclear bomb on something,
it's going to blow it up.
That's not too hard to understand.
But not everybody understands
the intricacies of the global economy
and what a stronger dollar kind of does to other,
it's almost like a stealth weapon, right?
And so what I believe has happened is,
you know, I mentioned earlier,
we're in this Triffin's dilemma.
I think the Fed knows we're in Triffin's dilemma.
And I think that they know that
if they raise rates,
while they're raising rates,
they are raising rates on the U.S. domestic economy,
but they're essentially raising rates on the whole world.
And I think that they know
that we can handle higher rates better
than many other parts of the world.
And because in the last couple of years,
we've kind of led to this bifurcation of globalization.
We've got East versus West.
We've got Russia versus the United States.
We've got China versus the United States.
We've got Russia versus Europe.
Sides are being chosen.
Rather than the world coming together,
the world's kind of moving apart.
And I think each side is trying to shore up their team,
for lack of a better way of saying it.
And I think anybody that's on the margins,
you know, both Russia and China and the U.S. and West,
they're in Europe,
they're reaching out to these people
that are on the margins and say,
hey, come to our side or hey, come to our side.
And I think if you're trying to get somebody to your side
who doesn't think they need to be on your side,
if you put them in a position where now they need to,
it's more likely to get them to agree with you.
So if a country is fine,
but then all of a sudden the dollar starts going higher
and their funding costs are going higher and it's harder
and they started having some,
you know, economic and social problems at home.
Now maybe they need help.
Now the U.S. can go to them and say,
hey, we're willing to help you out.
But in exchange for our help,
you're going to have to give us help
versus Russia versus China
on this U.N. Security Council vote
on this new trade agreement,
whatever it is.
In other words, help, but help with strings.
And, you know, I think that's kind of what's going on now.
And I've talked to a lot of people
who completely disagree with me.
They say that the Fed has nothing to do with that.
Well, that may be true,
but the Treasury is involved.
Many people don't know this,
but the Treasury Department actually sets dollar policy
and the Treasury wants a stronger dollar.
And so if the Treasury wants the stronger dollar,
the Fed has some leeway to help them out or not.
But, you know, if the Treasury in general
says we want a stronger dollar,
that means that they don't want the Fed
doing huge amounts of QE and not raising rates, right?
So I think that the dollar has without question
been used as a weapon this year,
whether it's the sanctions being put on,
you know, Russia and some of its allies
by removing them from the SWIFT system
and the dollar payment system
and the confiscation of assets.
But then also I think raising rates
and generally putting people in economic stagnation
or economic struggles, you know,
it allows the U.S. to kind of wield that sword
that may not be obvious to most.
So you're saying that, okay, as the Fed raises rates,
the dollar becomes stronger.
These other currencies become weaker,
but these other countries,
they need U.S. dollars to finance their debt,
to do trade, to do all sorts of things
because the U.S. dollar is the reserve currency.
So then the U.S. can go to them and say,
hey, we can sort you out with some dollars,
you know, we can make it easier for you.
But you have to sign on to the security pact.
You have to cut off Russia X, Y, Z.
Is this what you're saying?
That's what I'm saying, yes.
And I know a lot of people disagree with that,
but, you know, if it was me, that's what I would do.
So I don't put it past them.
Or if I actually say, I wouldn't prefer to do that.
If I were tasked with a job that required to do it,
that's how I would do it.
There you go.
It is a democratic system, Brent.
Maybe someday.
Last question.
You can take off your moral hat
and we can speak a little bit about money.
How are you planning to perhaps protect your wealth
or, you know, increase your wealth
pre-crisis and during the crisis?
Well, I think as a very general statement,
I favor investments in the United States
and kind of North America versus the rest of the world
until I see that we're kind of either most of the way
or all the way through this crisis.
I can't see a situation where the U.S.
goes into an economic downturn
and the rest of the world takes off and has global growth.
I just, I don't think that's possible.
I think it's possible where we see the whole world
go up together, in which case I'm fine being in the U.S.
I can see a case where the whole world goes down together,
in which case I'm no worse off being in the U.S.
than being anywhere else.
I can see a situation where the U.S. does okay
and the rest of the world does very poorly,
in which case I'm better off being in the U.S.
Or it's possible that the U.S. does very poorly
and the rest of the world does great.
But that last option I think is such a low probability,
I'm willing to overlook it and not allocate assets there.
And so in the other three possibilities,
I might as well be in the U.S.
It provides the deepest markets, more liquidity,
I believe less risk and in many ways more opportunity
because I think as we get into a crisis,
global capital will seek out the U.S. as a safe haven
and push U.S. asset prices higher
relative to the rest of the world.
And I also, I've always said,
I think everybody should own gold.
It doesn't mean I think it's gonna pay off right away,
but I think if you own gold,
if you can get through the crisis with gold
in your portfolio, you will at least have an asset
that you can start to rebuild with
because gold can't be inflated away.
It can't collapse.
It's durable.
It's been around for 5,000.
So for all the reasons that people understand gold,
I think it's important to have it in the portfolio
just so you always have an asset
once you get through the crisis.
Brent Johnson, we really appreciate it.
Thank you, Brent.
Till next time.
Thanks for having me.