Ranking Member Pat Toomey Questions at SEC Oversight Hearing - September 15, 2022

U.S. Senate Banking Committee GOP
29 followers
16 Video Views·Sep 15, 2022
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Gensler, in your written statement, you acknowledged,
as you have in the past, that there are some tokens that are not securities.
And I know your view that whether or not a digital asset is a security is a facts
and circumstances analysis. I know your view that the SEC has very broad authority.
But you've also made it clear in the past that Bitcoin is not a security.
Now, some SEC staff have also previously said that Ethereum is not a security.
The SEC's Dow report characterizes Ethereum as decentralized.
So here's my question briefly and without getting deep into the weeds on this.
And I acknowledge your belief that most tokens have a large degree of central control.
But generally speaking, is it fair to say that a significant factor for you and whether or not
a digital asset is a security is whether it is centrally controlled or decentralized?
Well, I look to the Supreme Court that's often written about this
probably close to a dozen times in 50 years. And it's whether the investing public is anticipating
profits. And that includes anticipating profits from appreciation as well as from, as you've
mentioned, rights based upon a common enterprise, but the efforts of that common enterprise.
Right. So I guess another way to put my question, which you haven't answered,
is, is it possible to have a common enterprise if it's something is decentralized? How can I have a
common enterprise? I mean, it doesn't centralize, isn't centralization necessary to constitute a
common enterprise? You could have some things that are quite open, but still have if the public is
anticipating a profit based upon that common enterprise. So I'm being careful with my words
here to be accurate as best I can. The common enterprise, are you relying on a group of
individuals? And look, these are not laundromat tokens. There is a group of people that are
actually... You're not answering my question, though. So let me try it this way. What is it
about Bitcoin that causes you to conclude it is not a security? Well, one is there's no group of
individuals in the middle. Right. It's decentralized. There's no group of individuals in the middle
that are basically... And you're not... In essence, the investing public is not betting on somebody
in the middle or six people in the middle. So you're choosing not to use the term
decentralized, but that's what you're describing. It is the decentralized nature of Bitcoin, I think,
is really what you're getting at. Here's my point. And I'm going to run out of time here. But
there are a lot of projects, as you know, that... I mean, decentralization and centralization
occurs on a continuum, really, I think. And you've acknowledged that there are tokens, plural,
that are not securities. I think it's because of this centralization that you come to this
conclusion. And my point is, it is not reasonable to fail to provide clarity, to provide the
definition of exactly where on this continuum you have a sufficient common enterprise that it
qualifies as a security and where you don't. You've said Bitcoin doesn't. Some of your colleagues
have said Ethereum doesn't. But a reasonable developer who wants to comply with this
doesn't know where that line is drawn. So I think where we might have a difference is
there are many factors. And so it's not one spectrum of centralization versus decentralization
with the Supreme Court. And I try to stick to... They're the Supreme Court. And there'll be
debates about other laws. I try to stick to what they say, a common enterprise. I think about a
group of individuals in the middle. That developer is in the middle and the investing public's
betting on them, counting on them, even if the token might be on a thousand computers.
That's not what the Supreme Court's looking at. It's not about the token being on a thousand
computers. It's just like a group of developers in the middle. But if there is nobody controlling
it in the middle, that's what we call decentralized. And that does happen.
As you know, of course, the Howey test requires all four of the tests to be met in order for
something to be defined as a security. Let me move on to another related issue, which is,
as I said in my opening statement, I don't think that the SEC has provided a crypto-specific
roadmap to the registration of crypto intermediaries. One example of the problem that arises
is the SEC's customer protection rule was written in 1972 and doesn't address how a broker-dealer
should hold a customer's blockchain private keys, for instance. Now, I know the SEC claims to have
provided relief, but the relief has very onerous contingencies. It's time-limited. And my
understanding is few, if any, broker-dealers have been able to comply. So I know you've said many
times you want to have the industry, the intermediaries come in and have a conversation
with the SEC about this. But wouldn't it be better if the SEC came out and laid out
how you would apply the rules and regulations to these novel devices?
So we're in conversations with a number of these intermediaries across the exchange,
the lending, the broker-dealer, the custody space. As I've said a year ago in the lending space,
people should make no mistake. And I think it sounds like, Senator, you and I might even agree
that the lending platforms are under the securities laws. But in the exchange space,
in the broker-dealer space, I accept that people have not come in and used what was
put in place under Chair Clayton, that broker-dealer custody rule that you mentioned.
And so I've said to staff, let's use everything in our regulatory toolkit,
whether it's exemptive orders and others, to help facilitate and get this industry,
people will not have trust in this space unless it comes into investor protection.
I'm out of time, Mr. Chairman. So I would just say my concern is that the approach
you're taking with these one-off discussions, if it did even result in an opportunity to comply,
it'd be this idiosyncratic exemptive order negotiated with a single company. And that's
not a good way to pass rules. It ought to be through the APA and a very public process.
If the chair would forgive me, I think we've been very clear through 70 or 80 actions,
starting with that Dow order, the Munchie order, and many others,
and they were full votes of the commission, not just staff.
Secondly, I just look at other times in history, the SEC and the asset-backed securities market
took 10 or 11 years where they did these, as you would say, exemptive orders or relief to
individual issuers and did a roll at the end of that 10 or 11 years based upon all that experience.
So we actually believe it's worthwhile to talk to the industry,
talk to the market participants and get them registered.
