Ranking Member Pat Toomey Opening Statement at Housing Hearing - March 31, 2022

U.S. Senate Banking Committee GOP
29 followers
16 Video Views·Mar 31, 2022
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and welcome to all of our witnesses.
I think we've had at least six hearings on housing this Congress, including two just
on private equity's minor role in housing.
But there's been one topic, however, that's been a conspicuous omission.
We've not had a single hearing on the government's role in driving up housing costs.
In the last 16 months, this administration with the cooperation of Democrats in Congress
have dropped hundreds of billions of dollars in helicopter money to stimulate an already
strong economy.
Eighty billion dollars went to rental assistance, that's 80 billion dollars above all the ordinary
spending in this space, went to rental assistance, vouchers, and other housing subsidies.
It comes to hundreds of billions of dollars per year.
And despite record demand, the Fed continued to artificially hold down mortgage rates at
near record lows.
So just as this administration has given us the highest inflation in 40 years, it's also
given us these astonishing increases in housing costs.
House prices skyrocketed almost 17 percent in the last year, 17 percent, while rents
jumped about 12 percent.
Now some of my colleagues seem to be willfully blind to government's role in driving this
inflation.
The problem is actually bigger than that.
Across these six housing hearings that we've had, this committee has spent most of its
time seemingly grasping for justifications to spend even more taxpayer money and expand
government's role further.
Setting aside the question of whether the federal government should have a role in the
housing market, we should at least ask ourselves, do we really need to spend even more taxpayer
money on housing?
I think a more skeptical framework should guide us in these hearings.
Whether in housing or otherwise, we ought to ask ourselves, what exactly is the market
failure that we're trying to correct?
And we should ask whether taxpayers' already generous safety net is somehow still inadequate.
And in answering these questions, we should bear in mind the risk that the government's
solution will be worse than the problem.
The risk of government failure is particularly acute when it comes to housing.
The number and cost of housing subsidies that are already existing boggles the mind.
There is the mortgage interest deduction, capital gains exclusion on home sales, tax
deduction on property taxes, VHA, VA, USDA, mortgage insurance, and GINI mortgage-backed
securities guarantees, down payment assistance.
There's the low-income housing tax credit program.
Then there's also this overlapping array of HUD programs, including project-based rental
assistance, tenant-based rental assistance, public housing, Section 202 housing for the
elderly, Section 811 housing for persons with disabilities, Section 521 rural rental housing,
CDBG, home block grants, homelessness assistance, and then we have the GSEs, which subsidize
more than half of all single-family mortgage debt, and I've probably left out a few.
But look, after 50 years, 50 years, and many hundreds of billions, maybe well over a trillion
dollars in subsidies, there's been no meaningful change in home ownership rates.
In 1970, the home ownership rate in America was 64 percent.
Today, it's 65 percent.
Black ownership levels are similar today to when the Fair Housing Act was passed in 1968.
These government policies spent an enormous amount of money, but they mostly just made
housing more expensive.
The inference is inescapable.
When it comes to housing, government has often been the problem, not the solution.
Today, we're likely to hear that the government should further subsidize senior citizens'
ability to age in place.
Now, to the extent that seniors want to stay in their homes, certainly they're right, and
very understandably, that's a very strong preference for a lot of seniors, completely
understandable.
But we shouldn't lose sight of the fact that it often makes perfect sense for seniors to
decide to maybe move out of a three- or four-bedroom, two-story house where they raise their children.
Many seniors downsize to apartments, to mother-in-law suites, or to smaller homes.
And in many cases, the seniors had already built up significant home equity, and so by
selling their house, they have new and sometimes very significant resources relative to all
of their other resources that they can use for any purpose they see fit.
My point is that downsizing can be a good thing for the senior, but also beyond that,
because when a senior chooses to downsize, a new home comes on the market.
Maybe the buyer will be a young couple looking to start a family.
And this turnover helps to match a scarce resource to its highest and best use.
So we should just be careful about any government interventions that might offset this natural
set of reasonable choices that are available to people.
To reduce inflation and make housing more affordable, we ought to pursue reforms that
will leverage the power of free enterprise, increase housing supply, and make markets
more competitive.
In January, the chairman reiterated the housing finance reform principles that he released
in 2019.
His principles overlap considerably with the reform principles that I've released.
I hope to be able to work with the chairman to develop a bipartisan consensus on this
critical issue.
Meanwhile, I hope the administration will finally engage on housing reform.
Treasury has still not met its obligation to deliver a reform plan to Congress, and
it's now six months overdue.
So instead of seeking out any excuse or pretext to regulate more and spend more, the administration
should look to opportunities for bipartisan legislation like housing finance reform that
relies on free enterprise, not government, to make housing more affordable for more Americans,
including seniors.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
