‘Hong Kong Was Not a Colony?’ Scholar Criticizes CCP for Distorting History

Indo-Pacific Conflict Zone
34 followers
29 Video Views·Aug 30, 2022
Hong Kong media, Pai Daily, recently revealed academic textbooks submitted for review by the Hong Kong Education Bureau state that “Hong Kong was not a former colony.”
Why is the Chinese Communist Party pushing the false narrative that Hong Kong was never a colony,
even though it was under British rule from 1841 to 1997, with a brief stint
under Japanese occupation during World War II? Stick around and let's find out.
Hong Kong media Pi Daily recently revealed academic textbooks submitted for review by
the Hong Kong Education Bureau state that Hong Kong was not a former colony.
This is a patently false statement, says Hong Kong historian Hans-Jung Wing-Yu.
He explains that communist regimes and altering history go hand in hand. Altering textbook content
is a necessary step to maintain continued suppression of the Hong Kong independence
movement. Its aim is to erase Hong Kong from ever having been a British colony,
irrespective of the actual history. Why does this matter?
In 1960, the United Nations passed Resolution 1514. It states that any colony secured through
armed conflict has a right to self-determination or the right to seek independence, according to
the intention of the resolution to end colonialism. This UN resolution means Hong Kong is eligible
to seek independence if it so desires. It wasn't until the Sino-British negotiations
in the 1980s that British handed over Hong Kong sovereignty to China while retaining
governance over the colony. Jung explains, quote, the CCP is now claiming the communist
regime never relinquished Hong Kong sovereignty, unquote. The historian lays out five key points.
Point number one, during the wave of decolonization after World War II,
the UN listed colonies eligible for the path to independence under UN Resolution 1514.
Hong Kong and Macau were originally included in that list of colonies.
The second point, on October 25th, 1971, the United Nations General Assembly voted to admit
the People's Republic of China, that's mainland communist China, and expel the Republic of China,
that's Taiwan. The United States, the most significant opponent of the resolution,
had argued for the communist PRC to be admitted separately from the Republic of China.
Point number three, the CCP fabricated the technicality, Hong Kong is not a colony,
to distort facts. The idea is to have the public believe the lie that Hong Kong and
Macau were not technically ordinary colonies. Point number four, by removing Hong Kong and
Macau from the UN non-self-governing territories list, it doesn't erase the past that Hong Kong
was in fact a colony. It does change the course of history, however, by silencing Hong Kong's
future independence movement. The last point, by altering textbook content and inserting the
false narrative that Hong Kong was not a colony, and then additionally implementing a prohibition
against any discussion on the topic, means that the public is conditioned over time to adopt a
new false history as historical fact. The British handed Hong Kong over to CCP China in 1997,
a year later the Hong Kong was not a British colony narrative was born.
CCP textbook guidelines required the word colony be replaced with the word Hong Kong,
per November 1998 documents submitted to the Legislative Council by the Law Drafting Division
of Hong Kong's Department of Justice. Historian Hans-Jung Win-Yu remembers this change as he was
part of the machinery that carried out the new guidelines. He witnessed it as a manager of the
Assessment Development Department of the Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority.
Not until the 2010s, when the issue of Hong Kong independence emerged, were the 1998 textbook
guidelines actually enforced. He also says that in 2018 the Bureau's textbook review team barred
phrases such as China taking back Hong Kong and China insists on taking back Hong Kong sovereignty.
These were flagged as inappropriate wording requiring revision. Jung warns that the situation
intensified following the overnight ratification of the national security law June 2021,
absent any form of democratic Hong Kong legislative oversight. This is when the Bureau's textbook
review team made a most bizarre ruling deeming the statement Hong Kong is located in the south
of China as inaccurate. Quote, how can one dispute the fact that Hong Kong is located in the south of
China? It turns out they did not disclose the reason behind this bizarre ruling to the public
because the reason was so absurd. Believe it or not the textbook review team sincerely believed
that by putting Hong Kong and China together in one sentence Hong Kongers might believe that they
share equal status with mainland China. And that's why the revision Hong Kong is located in the south
of China was deemed inaccurate requiring publishers to revise the statement. Unquote. He recalls that
he had argued with the Bureau over similar semantics reviewing examination papers many
times during his tenure. Soon thereafter he was fired from his position by the authorities.
Jung explains that Hong Kong is a strong legal foundation as a colony under British law
which the CCP cannot alter. Britain's charter of the colony of Hong passed in 1843 after the
founding of Hong Kong laid the legal foundation for Hong Kong as a colony. In fact the official
name of Hong Kong was the colony of Hong Kong throughout the period of British governance
referred equally throughout British academia. It doesn't help the CCP that Sun Yat-sen the father
of the pre-CCP nation of the Republic of China that lived from 1912 to 1949 is on record referring
to Hong Kong as a colony. Sun said that his revolutionary ideas came from Hong Kong from
the colony of Hong Kong in a public speech at the University of Hong Kong in 1923. Hong Kong had been
a British colony following the opium wars going through three iterations of British colonial rule
since the mid-1800s. Then in 1898 China leased Hong Kong to the British for 99 years. It's only
since 1998 that Hong Kong's colonial status became a sore spot for the CCP. Pre-1997 British handover
CCP China never denied Hong Kong's obvious status as a British colony. Hong Kong served as a
Hong Kong expert Liao explains,
For historians watching the manipulation of Hong Kong's colonial past
it's baffling to observe how CCP China wants it both ways. The CCP needs to continue to have a
quote-unquote gray area economy of international Hong Kong. What's different now is that the CCP
wants to essentially operate Hong Kong as its own colony complete with global business access
while implementing its machinery of totalitarian control. This is possible as long as Hong Kong
is unable to seek independence and is held hostage by China. Going back to Sun Yat-sen,
the father of modern China, before it became communist it was Sun Yat-sen that mentioned
the abolition of the unequal treaties in the declaration of the first national congress of
the Chinese Kuomintang in 1924. Following World War II decolonization trends the newly formed
CCP China continued with Hong Kong as a British colony though all other Japanese and European
occupied Asian territories were returned. This is notably due to Hong Kong's international
business connections benefiting the CCP. The CCP now alleges that Hong Kong's fall into British
hands was due to three so-called unequal treaties. Yeung clarifies the quote-unquote unequal treaties
concept. He says, quote, let's be clear the quote-unquote unequal treaties appeared 80 years
after Hong Kong became a British colony. The precedent was set in the 1960s by the Vienna
Convention on the Law of Treaties. It stipulates that a treaty facilitated by the threat or use of
force needed to be renegotiated via peaceful negotiations. If negotiations failed the treaty
remained in force. Unquote. Yeung believes that the CCP and the Education Bureau's refusal to
recognize treaties is violating the rule of law. He says, quote, an unequal treaty is only a moral
or subjective concept not a legal concept. A treaty is a treaty. Unquote. Yeung believes
students challenging the fake history will result in educational discourse immediately collapsing.
Evidence that both the CCP and the Education Bureau are lying. Yeung says that it's a pity
the education under the CCP rule is dishonest. Integrity and the principle of truth in education
have been completely lost. Any educator would agree that it's hard to stomach. He says, quote,
it's invariably what happens under CCP rule. Unquote. What surprised Yeung was the brazen
deployment of outright lies fabricated by CCP authorities to write fake history directly as he
says. Turning the concocted narrative that Hong Kong is not a British colony into reality. It's an
equivalent feat to saying that 2 plus 2 is 4. He laments that Hong Kong's ideology is now lining
up with the CCP's only 25 years after the CCP takeover of Hong Kong. In Hong Kong Yeung says
education has fallen. He says, quote, students only learn lies no truth and there's no insight
no critical thinking. Hong Kongers are required to comply with regulations. Unquote. When asked
how to remedy the CCP contamination of Hong Kong's learning institutions, he says, quote, they must
be awakened and seek other knowledge. Find good books to read. Parents should do their own research
and share it with their children. Unquote.
