My guest today is Jialu Streeter, Director of Partnerships at Stanford Institute for economic policy research. Her 2022 documentary "Homelessness in California" offers a variety of insights on the causes of homelessness. And it has reached almost half a million views.
Why is California's homeless approach financially unsustainable? And is it true that California can only manage the homeless crisis instead of ending it?
California has the highest percentage of unsheltered homeless, 70%, the highest in the whole country.
We are exasperating the problem in a sense, like we're not doing anything about it.
The people in San Francisco are saying we had enough, we're feeling not safe walking in our
own neighborhood, our children are worried about stepping on needles, and children are exposed to
open-air drug scenes every day on their way to school. That's not normal.
We're spending a lot of money on this, and it's questionable where the money goes.
If a homeless is ready to receive treatment, the question is, are we ready? And right now,
we are not ready. The system is failing them. My guest today is Jalu Streeter, Director of
Partnerships at Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research. Her 2022 documentary, Homelessness
in California, offers a variety of insights on the causes of homelessness, and it has reached
almost half a million views. You know, we just have one program and another program
built upon each other. People don't think about the end game. Why is California's homeless approach
financially unsustainable? And is it true that California can only manage the homeless crisis
instead of ending it? Let's find out in today's episode. I'm Siamak Khorrami. Welcome to California Insider.
Thank you for having me. We want to talk to you about homelessness. You've done a lot of,
you've done a documentary, and you've studied this. A problem we have in California is that
we're spending a lot of money and efforts on homelessness, but at the same time,
the number of homeless people is going up. Can you tell us what's going on?
Yeah, absolutely. So I think we're not spending our money wisely. There are a lot of disjointed
programs out there, but at the end of the day, we don't have enough shelters, we don't have enough
treatment, we don't have enough housing, and on top of that, we also don't have enough accountability.
And how did we end up here? Can you explain to us? Yeah, so in terms of the lack of shelters,
you can really look at the data. Between 2004 and today, the unsheltered population
really exploded in California. So why did that happen suddenly? So let's take San Francisco,
for example. San Francisco in 2004, Gavin Newsom at the time, he was the San Francisco mayor,
and he adopted a 10-year plan, which called for elimination of emergency shelters. So at the time,
his plan was, let's build a lot of housing, let's build a lot of permanent supportive housing,
so people don't have to go to shelters, and we can get rid of all the emergency shelters.
So between 2004 and 2014, that all 10 years, if you look at the data, the shelter capacity
froze. So we didn't build any more shelters? No new shelters were built, and all the
attention and all the financial resources were poured into building housing, building permanent
supportive housing. And for 10 years, how many did they build? They built 2,699 units in San
Francisco. But what they didn't consider is the homeless population kept increasing, right? And
then so they didn't build enough permanent supportive housing to house the increasing
population who are homeless, and then they stopped building shelters. So now, where do the homeless
go? They go on the street, okay? So if you look at the unsheltered homeless in San Francisco,
between 2004 and today, it doubled, the unsheltered homeless. What's the number of
population in San Francisco right now? The homeless population is about 8,000,
and that's based on the 2020 data. I haven't looked at the 2022 data yet. Some people have
told us that the shelters are not full, and people are not using them. Have you seen that?
No, I would say no. So if you look at the data, how many shelters do we have in California?
If you add beds in emergency shelters, safe havens, and transitional housing, if you add
beds all together, okay, you have about 50,000 beds, okay? So it's actually 47,000 beds. But
you have 160,000 homeless. So it's one bed for every three homeless. So most of the time,
you actually have a shortage of housing. Most of the time, you have a shortage of shelters.
And so in Santa Clara County, for example, that's where I'm from, you have one bed for
every five homeless. In Alameda County, where Oakland and Berkeley are, that's one to four,
one bed for every four homeless. So if you just look at the data, there's a huge shortage of
shelters. And I don't know upon what evidence people say the shelters are empty. I do hear,
however, on the other hand, I do hear some people say shelters are crowded, and shelters are not
safe, and there were drug dealing and drug using in shelters. That's a different situation. I think
those are things we can improve for shelters. But just say shelters are empty, I don't see
evidence for that. How does California compare to the rest of the states? To the rest of the
country? Yeah. So if you look at, there are definitely several differences between California
and other states in terms of homelessness. For one, California has the highest unsheltered population
among the whole homeless population. So you'll see them more in the street.
Yes. So California has the highest percentage of unsheltered homeless, 70%, the highest in the
whole country. And secondly, compared to many other states, California has a very high percent
of male homeless and a very high percent of homeless population who are not with a family.
So that's about 85% of California's homeless population are not with a family. They're
individual adults. Is there a reason for this? I don't know. I think more research should look
into why we have more male adult individuals who are homeless. I actually have asked some professors
on my documentary about this. And then they said, first of all, they don't know that they were
making a speculation. Probably it's easier to access drugs in San Francisco. That's more attractive
to some individuals who are addicted to drugs. And if they want to continue to use drugs and
being homeless, that's a little easier for them to be. That's where it's a little easier for them.
So how much of this homeless issue we have is connected to drug addiction? What percentage of
it? Yeah. So that's a really good question. The question is what percentage of the homeless
population in California have mental illness and with drug addiction, right? So actually,
there were two camps to answer that question. One camp, mainly some academics in California,
some government folks, they would say it's a small percent. They would cite government data.
So the government data says the following. About 25% of all homeless in California have
mental illness, severe mental illness. And 30% of all homeless individuals in California
have severe drug addiction. So that's the government data. And on the other camp,
in the other camp, people say, no, no, no, like the prevalence of those problems is extremely high
in unsheltered homeless population. So which camp is right, right? And I tend to cite with
the latter group because I think the former group, they cite the government data. They're not
technically incorrect, but it's a little bit misleading because you have to look at how the
data are collected. They're based on self-reports. So suppose I walk up to you.
So I have to go, so the homeless person needs to say, I have a mental illness or I have a drug.
Exactly. So I walk up to you, I say, hey, do you have a mental illness?
I have to admit, yes, I do. And most people that do have a mental illness,
they probably don't want to say they have. Yeah, they may feel ashamed to acknowledge,
or some of them may just not know they have a medical condition, but that's not it. Say you
acknowledge you have a mental illness, you're homeless. And then I will ask a follow-up
question and say, is this mental illness severe? Has this lasted a long time? And if you say no,
even if you had said yes to the first question, if you say no to the second question,
you will not be counted in that 25% because the 25% is for severe mental illness.
So you have to be kind of a psychologist of yourself and diagnose yourself with
how severe your situation is. Yeah, exactly. And then the data is collected like that.
But do the people that believe that we're in that camp, do they know how the data is collected?
I believe they do. But unfortunately, when those data are cited loosely in news media or on
newspapers, people conveniently drop the word severe. Then now it becomes 25% of the homeless
individuals have mental illness. There's a huge difference between whether you have the word
severe and not having it because the survey was designed to highlight the severe part.
So that's misleading. And also even suppose we say, okay, that data are 100% accurate. 25% of
all homeless have severe mental illness. So even if that's correct, look at what's the prevalence
of severe mental illness among the general population, 5%. So right there, you have a
five-time difference. And you mentioned the shelters versus somewhere in San Francisco,
they decided to go from shelters to housing. Why do you think that happened and what's the
impact has been? They haven't built any shelters. So this housing first model where you invest in
housing, what's been the impact of that? Yeah. I think so what happened is when you pour all
resources into building permanent supportive housing, you are actually overlooking or
neglecting other options such as non-congregate shelters or safe havens or other options. So
there's like an opportunity cost of building permanent supportive housing. So you know this,
we all know based on the LA city controller's report, it costs like 600,000 to build one
permanent supportive housing. One studio, right? Yeah. I mean, I think it depends. They have
different sizes, studio, one-bedroom, two-bedroom, but mostly just one apartment unit costs between
500 to $700,000 per unit. So you can house one person or two people or maybe one family.
So what is the opportunity cost of doing that? Well, if you are living for the same amount of
money, you could have saved so many more. You could have moved so many more unsheltered
homeless under a roof at least to keep them warm at night, to keep them from the harm
and the harshness of unsheltered life outside. So I think that's the opportunity cost
that people oftentimes are not thinking about. So how much is the cost of a shelter? Yeah. So
there are different options. So the Bay Area Council Economic Institute, they released a
report last year. They compare that. You can look this up online. They compare different costs of
shelters. So going from the cheapest, cabin community is 10,000 per bed. Okay. And then
congregate shelters, 40,000 per bed. So to build it one time and then there's an ongoing cost,
exactly. And then you have something called non-congregate shelters, which are really nice,
actually. They cost between $100,000 to $150,000 per unit. And then those are, I think, the future
of the shelter system because very different from the congregate shelters. The congregate
shelter is like you have a space and you have many beds. It's kind of overcrowded. But
non-congregate shelters, it's a little more expensive, but you have your own room. And
sometimes you even have a shower inside. Sometimes no, but you share bathrooms, you share
kitchen on site. And then they also provide you with support. Like, you know, if you need a job
training or... It's like a campus thing. Exactly. Yeah. So I actually visited this place called
Life Moves in Mountain View. They are a non-profit organization that operate shelter systems in the
Bay Area. They have one site in Mountain View and that's the one that I visited. I talked with
their director, Brian Greenberg. He has a PhD in, I think, psychology. He's like a great person.
Like, you know, the site is well-organized, super clean. I used their bathroom. It's cleaner than
a bathroom you can see in the playground. And the people there are content. And then, you know,
they actually, during the day, many of them go to work. So they have a key to their room so,
you know, they have safety. And then they have a place to store their stuff. So I feel that's
the future. It's much cheaper than permanent supportive housing. So you're mentioning
shelters. For each apartment unit that we're building, how many shelter beds would we get?
Yeah. So depending on what kind of shelter you're talking about. So we know permanent supportive
housing costs about $600,000, right? But if you're looking at a non-congregate shelter,
which you have a key to your own room, you have privacy, that's $100,000. So right there,
it's a six-time difference. So you can put six people under a roof versus putting one.
Yeah. And you have privacy. This is not congregate shelter. Congregate shelter will be even cheaper.
Now, do you think the policies are going to shift?
I think there are some shifts happening right now, especially during the pandemic. As you can see,
project room key, project home key. So those are projects that convert the unused motels
into shelters, into non-congregate shelters. So I think that's sort of like the beginning of
people realizing permanent supportive housings is too expensive, and we need some other ways
to house people. However, there is still people at the camp who believe permanent supportive
housing is the only way. And you cannot do anything unless you put a person in a permanent
apartment. So you still have very, very strong belief in that. And that camp is going to resist.
Some people have told us that there's special interest in this homeless space, and they've
turned it into a business. And some, maybe just they operate in it, and this is what it is. They
build housing, and this is like another project for them. And it's sad to see that some people
are making a living in the process of potentially helping the homeless, but they're really taking
a lot of effort to build this housing while we could do other things with this money. What are
your thoughts on that? Yeah, I think it's, so I've talked with a lot of non-profit leaders
in this space, and I think for most of them, I cannot speak for every one of them, but I think
for most of them, their heart is in the right place, that they do sincerely want to help the
homeless. And I do think for a lot of them, they spend their whole life, decades of their career
in this industry, trying to build housing for low-income families, for homeless individuals.
So for them, I feel if I were in their position, I feel very strongly about my career. I feel very
strongly about what I do, that I contribute to relieving people's pain, and perhaps I don't
want to see that going, right? I don't want to see the industry being replaced by some other way.
Yeah, so I don't know whether it's a special interest, perhaps there is, but I don't know.
But maybe getting stuck in the way you know how to do, and not thinking outside of the box.
Yeah, yeah. Definitely, I do feel, you know, if you have done something one way,
so for 40 years, it's very difficult for you to see, hey, maybe there are some cost-effective
ways out there. Now, you got into this about a year and a half ago, right? Last year, yeah.
And what did you think before of what's going on with the homeless, and what do you think now?
Yeah, so I started working on this because we realized homelessness is getting worse
in California, in the Bay Area, in San Francisco, you know, where I go to very often.
Before I started this project, I was like, I don't really know, like, perhaps homeless people,
why are they homeless? They don't have housing, right? They're poor, maybe they have some problems
that we need to help them. That's basically my presumption that they're poor, and that they don't
have a place to go. But now I, after this project where, in which I interviewed 33 stakeholders,
including policymakers, nonprofit leaders, academics, and homeless individuals themselves,
some of them are at war and are addicted to drugs. So now I start to gain a more diverse,
more complete perspective, that I realize people fall into homelessness for all sorts of reasons.
Some of them for economic reasons, and some others for non-economic reasons,
such as mental illness, drug addiction, or childhood trauma. So it's really misleading
to use one word, homeless, to describe all of them, because the word homeless is saying
they lack a home. And then naturally, the solution would be to provide a home.
But that's like a one-size-fits-all solution, right? And I feel like that's like you,
to group all the homeless people together and just call them homeless,
it's like you ignore the differences between patients with brain tumor, heart disease,
lung cancer, and group them all together. Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, that's one thing I learned from
doing this project. Another thing that I learned is people really disagree
on this subject. I didn't know. There's so many different opinions,
you know, and it's very politically sensitive. So people are not collaborating, or they're not
listening to each other. It's kind of like you have your way, or somebody else has their way.
Yeah, they don't agree. I would say they don't agree on many things. For one, they don't agree
what is a basic human right. Okay, so one side say shelter is a basic human right. You need to
keep human beings in a safe, clean shelter overnight. On the other hand, you have people
say shelter is not housing. You cannot do anything unless you keep them in a permanent housing. But
it's impossible financially, you know, how expensive it is. You build two houses for every
20 people that you can put in a shelter. Exactly, right. So right away, you have this people,
two groups coming at each other. Another thing that's like really, people really disagree with
each other is whether and to what extent the homelessness problem is related to mental illness
and drug addiction. People really disagree on that. Okay, they can start a street fight just
over that topic. So we already talked about it just now. Like some people say it's,
some people say, it's a minority, you know, look at 25%, 30%. That's a minority. It's not all.
And then they also claim the mental illness and drug addiction, they're the consequence,
not the cause of homelessness. You become homeless first, then you get, then you adopt those habits,
perhaps. I believe that we cannot make a blanket statement. Now, having studied all of this,
you know, in the last year, you've been to it, and looking at California with all the innovation
and potential that we have, this is a very innovative, high tech state. What are your
thoughts on what you see compared to what you know about the tech side of things and your...
Yeah, yeah, I think it's really sad. For one thing, it's very sad that we don't have good data.
Right? So for one thing, just now I told you how we, how we collect data on mental illness and
drug addiction, right? It's because we don't have good data linkage. So what is a data linkage?
If we, if this homeless person is on the street, I look him up, or her, look her up in the system,
I can right away make connection between his or her status right now with their previous records
in the public health records, their criminal justice record, or maybe even their education
records, so that we can, we know whether, for example, in terms of mental illness, whether the
person has mental illness before or after homeless, right? And whether this person is from San Francisco
or from California, or maybe from another state, or maybe they have family members who they can
reunite with, and then they can, you know, help them get back on their feet. But right now, we
don't have that kind of data linkage. And I mean, there are some in LA, they have one project that
was sort of linking data from different sources. But by and large, we don't have good data linkage.
And I think, you know, as you just mentioned, we're in the epicenter of high tech, you know,
why don't we have good data? I don't know. And what about the leaders you interviewed? You had
talked to different people in different camps. What do you think it will take for these people
to work together, or at least talk to each other and try to reconcile what they think is right?
Yeah, I think a lot of times there are different interests that political leaders, they have to
take into account, right? So they need to, they have constituencies who may not want them to
build new housing in the neighborhood, because that's going to jack up the density of a neighborhood,
and that's going to reduce the housing price of that neighborhood. So that's, you know,
right away, you have one group. And then you have groups that's like homelessness advocates who say,
hey, let's build more housing, let's build more shelters. So right away, you have political
leaders were like, I don't know, you know, I don't, I don't want to upset either groups. So
I think they're sort of like in this stalemate, just instead of doing anything, they just do
nothing, or sometimes just throw money at the problems. And then we see how much money has
been spent. And so far, I think the situation in general is getting worse. And also, I think the
political leaders, in general, they're not asking for accountability, which is really sad in places
like San Francisco and LA, you know, you have increasing crime, you know, you have open,
open air drug markets. And I think those things really need good leadership to correct.
So what kind of accountability would they need to have?
Yeah, for one thing, you know, I don't want to criminalize drug users, I think for drug users,
they really need to receive treatment. Okay, so that's one thing we can do. And but on the other
hand, I think drug dealers are different, especially the repeat offenders, right? So,
you know, right now, you read that San Francisco has a new DA, and her priority is to ask
accountability upon those who have repeat offend, how do you say this, who are repeat offenders.
So, you know, people who have been arrested for dealing drugs, but then released on the same day,
why do we release them? You know, but then they just go back on the streets and then do a drug
again, and we arrest them and release again. I think that's a poor use of taxpayers money.
And also, it's not good for public safety. So we are exasperating the problem, in a sense,
like we're not doing anything about it. Yes. Yeah. I think right now, San Francisco has this
recall, had this recall election. They recalled their former district attorney, Tessa Boudin,
and now have a new DA. I think that's a way the people in San Francisco are saying, we had enough.
We're feeling not safe walking in our own neighborhood. Our children are worried about
stepping on needles. And children are exposed to open air drug scenes every day on their way
to school. That's not normal. But I think it's very sad that normal citizens like myself
are told that is normal. It's okay to have homeless on the street. It's okay to have
encampments. They are just normal human beings. Why can't we just let them sleep on the street?
What's the big deal? Right? So when you're asked that question, what's the big deal? I don't know.
Maybe it is normal, right? Then you sort of start to normalize all this craziness.
So you think this average, so the camps that are in different size of this homeless situation,
the average residents of big cities in California, they're kind of outside of this camp,
and they are essentially the victims of... They are.
Aside the homeless people, they're also the victims of this.
Yes. Yeah. If you look at data, there have been surveys collected upon
San Francisco and LA residents. There was one collected, I think it was either this year or
last year, asking normal residents in San Francisco and LA, how do you feel the crime
have changed? And then 70% of them said crime has increased. So that's just... They're honest.
They are not politicians. They don't have any interest in this industry, but they care about
the safety. They care about the health of their children, of their family. And so I think they're
telling the truth that they feel crime has increased. So is this fixable? Can we have a
solution for this based on your interviews? Yeah. I think there are a lot of things that
we can do. There are a lot of low-hanging fruit, I would say. For one, as I already said,
we need more shelters right away. And we need to make them good shelters.
Some people say, oh, there are drug dealers inside the shelters. Get rid of them.
To me, that's a low-hanging fruit, right? Some people say, oh, shelters don't allow pets. Get
rid of the rules. Get rid of unreasonable rules. Set up shelters, have good shelters that people
are willing to go, and have more treatments. So I don't know whether you know, but for homeless
individuals who have mental illness or drug addiction, it's very, very difficult for them
to access treatment. So in Santa Clara County, for example, we have millions and millions of people.
How many detox beds do we have? So if you want to get rid of your addiction, it's...
Yeah, we have 10 detox beds for men, 10 detox beds for women. I mean, I'm talking about if you
are on Medi-Cal, okay? If you have a private insurance, sure, you can... But the chances of
you having a private insurance, being homeless is very... No, yeah. Most of the homeless are on
Medi-Cal, which is Medicaid for California. So they're on Medi-Cal, and then they have those
10 detox beds for men, 10 detox beds for women, and then some residential treatment for them.
So it's very, very limited, and there is no... So I would really ask for treatment on demand.
If a homeless is ready to receive treatment, the question is, are we ready? And right now,
we are not ready. The system is failing them. Which is very hard for somebody that's addicted
to drugs to come out and say, I'm ready to quit. And then if you make them wait, they might go
back. They might change, because there are so many triggers when they go back to their encampments.
Other people are using, their neighbors are using. It's very tempting for them to just go back.
So the next day, they may not be ready. When you say, I have a bed available for you,
they may not be there for you anymore. Did you find out why we don't have enough beds
for that? Because we were spending a lot of money on this, and it's questionable where the money
goes. Yeah. But it's sad to hear that we don't have the beds for these people when they are
actually making an effort to change, to get out of that. Right. I don't exactly know why we have
so few places, so little treatment available. But I do know, based on my reading of a report
issued by California State Auditor, which is a government agency. So they released a report
last year. They did an audit of homeless services in California. And then they found there were,
I think it was like 41 programs, nine government agencies across California using
$13 billion over two years. And then so they, you can read their report, and then they said
California has a disjointed approach to deal with homelessness. And then there are a lot of
duplication, a lot of silliness, like you are doing your program, I'm doing my program,
I'm not talking to you, the programs are not coordinated. And they might be wasting a lot
of resources in the process. Right. So yeah, so on the surface, we're spending a lot of money,
but it's a good question where the money has gone to. Because it doesn't really reach the people
that need it. Exactly. Right. Yeah. So you've talked to about 33 people, experts in this space,
right? Is there anybody working to end this? Yeah, I don't think so. I think in California,
just like it's nobody's job to end homelessness. So a lot of people's job is to manage homelessness
services, homelessness programs. So, you know, we just have one program and another program,
you know, built upon each other. And a lot of people don't think about the end game.
And I interviewed Roseanne Hegarty, the CEO of Community Solutions, and she told me,
we need to have approach that's like, how we ended smallpox. You don't just manage smallpox,
right? You don't just just sort of like provide services to manage smallpox. You want to be ahead
of the game and end smallpox. And in this case, we want to be ahead of the curve and end homelessness.
And that should be the end game. Do you have any other thoughts for our audience?
I feel like homelessness is getting worse in California and people are really now getting
to a point like, you know, enough is enough and we need to turn this around. So I feel we need
to get out of ideologies. We need to get out of, you know, this is how we've done business for 20
years and that's how we're going to do it for the next 20 years. We need to look at out-of-the-box
solutions. If something works, let's do it. Let's try it. Let's take all the low-hanging fruit.
Let's build good shelters. Let's provide treatment on demand. Let's have common sense and build,
you know, a good data system so we can link all sorts of data and use our eyes and use data,
use evidence to really figure out how to end homelessness. Jialu Streeter, Director of
Partnerships at CPIR at Stanford. It was great to have you on California Insider. Thank you so much
for having me. Thank you for watching. Please click the icon on the left to subscribe to our channel.
We bring you the most pressing issues California is facing with straightforward and in-depth
interviews. See you in the next video.