SpaceX recently announced their plans to send a Dragon 2 on a voyage to Mars as early as 2018. In this episode we chat about their plans and what it means for the future of Mars colonization.
In Space News: * Sentinel 1B Launch via Soyuz * Mikhailo Lomonosov via Soyuz 2.1a * IRNSS 1G Launch via PSLV * Atlas V anomaly discovered * NASA seeks to boost Mars communications network * SpaceX receives GPS3 launch contract * Hubble discovers a moon orbiting dwarf planet Makemake
TMRO Live is a crowd funded show. If you like this episode consider contributing to help us to continue to improve. Head over to http://www.patreon.com/tmro for information, goals and reward levels. Don't forget to check out our SpacePod campaign as well over at http://www.patreon.com/spacepod
Coming up, new launch pad.
Atlas 5 anomaly discovered.
There's a new moon out there.
And our main topic is hashtag red dragon.
Stay tuned.
Tomorrow begins right now.
And welcome to Tomorrow, season 9, episode 15,
for Saturday, April 30, 2016.
My name is Benjamin Higginbotham.
Before we get started, let's give a huge shout out
to all of the patrons of Tomorrow,
who have helped to make this specific segment of this episode
happen.
These are the people who have contributed $10 or more
to this episode.
We are a crowdfunded show.
Every single dollar helps, and there are different reward
levels along the way.
To find out more information on how
you can help crowdfund the shows of Tomorrow,
head on over to patreon.com slash T-M-R-O.
Now I am joined by Jared of the head, space of the mic,
and my beautiful, lovely, wonderful, and talented
Carrie Ann Higginbotham.
And we're going to go ahead and get
started with some space news.
First up, we've got some launch coverage.
We've got a Soyuz launching the Sentinel-1B.
Decollage, liftoff, base cutoff.
I always think the Ariane space launches are just beautiful.
There's something about just all of it that makes it the-
They look like a 1950s sci-fi film.
Is that what?
Is that it?
Yeah.
I mean, it just looks gorgeous.
It's super, super old school, looks almost fake.
But it's not, and it happened Monday, April 25th,
at 21.02 Coordinated Universal Time.
As I mentioned, that was a Sentinel-1B.
It's an identical spacecraft that was launched in 2014.
Those two will actually fly in tandem about 180 degrees
apart from each other.
They can see in day or night, and they're
going to be observing all types of weather radar.
They can spot icebergs and oil spills, volcanoes,
just natural phenomena that happens on the Earth.
It's the fourth satellite that's part of Europe's Copernicus
Earth Observation Network, which also sounds like something
out of a sci-fi film.
Project Copernicus.
Not sand, just sand.
Oh my gosh, Copernicus has taken on a life of its own.
Actually, Copernicus is kind of awesome.
It's one of the most ambitious space-based Earth observing
networks ever built. They're building a fleet of satellites
to monitor the planet over several decades.
So it's not just like one satellite
that's going to look at general things.
I mean, it's a whole slew of different stuff
that's going to look at the entire Earth
and look at climate change.
So no matter what the US does, Europe's got us covered,
because they're going to be looking
at all the different climate stuff
and looking at the science behind all of that.
All right, next up, we have another Soyuz.
The rocket is neat, and the payload is neat,
but what's unique is where it launched from.
Take a look.
And liftoff.
That happened Thursday, April 28, at 02.01.
Coordinated Universal Time.
They really like that flame trench.
Coordinated Universal Time.
The reason that's unique is, as you may have noticed,
that is not the Baikonur Cosmodrome.
That's actually the Volshtechny Cosmodrome,
which began construction in 2011.
And it was Putin's kind of pet project,
and it was very, very delayed and marred
with corruption and huge tons of problems.
So this marks the very, very, isn't that an awesome shot?
It's gorgeous.
Again, it looks totally not real.
It is.
It's totally real.
No, I know.
I just, it's.
Looking right up the business end of the Soyuz rocket
right there.
That's hot.
Now, this is in Russian territory,
as opposed to the Baikonur Cosmodrome, which is not.
Although, Russia still maintains a lease
on the Baikonur Cosmodrome until at least the year 2050.
Now, right now, they're not actually
done with their new Cosmodrome.
They just kind of launched and said, yes, it's operational,
but there's still a lot more work that needs to be done.
They will eventually allow heavy lift Angara rocket
launches from this pad.
And they're going to upgrade it for human space flight
capability, which is pretty cool.
Now, talking about the actual payload
that was on that particular rocket,
they have the Mikhail Lomonoshev, hopefully
I said that right, which is the largest of the three satellites
that were launched.
It's going to study high energy cosmic rays and gamma ray
bursts, which are really powerful elements out
in the universe.
It's also going to investigate Earth, attempting
to pinpoint the origin of a mysterious brilliant flash that
occurs in our upper atmosphere called
transient luminous events.
Isn't that an awesome name?
I-L-I-N.
It feels like that should be my Twitter screen name,
transient luminous event.
We've also got the AIST, A-I-S-T,
however you pronounce that, 2-D.
It's a smaller spacecraft.
It's going to demonstrate maneuverability.
And it has a high resolution hyperspectral scan
of the Earth.
And then we've also got a CubeSat named SAMSAT-218, which
is basically for education.
They're also going to be demonstrating
how you can move and deal with CubeSats out in space.
So there you go.
The Soyuz at their all new Cosmodrome.
One thing I don't think I mentioned
is it is a new Cosmodrome.
It is awesome.
Unfortunately, right now they've got like one launch
per year on its manifest.
So I guess it's the Russian equivalent to the Space Launch
System where there's not a whole lot going on with it right now.
But there is an incredible future
that can be set up there.
All right, moving on.
We also have an Atlas V. No, no, I'm sorry, a PSLV launch.
And that launched Thursday, April 28.
I can't hear myself in my own ear.
Can you guys hear me?
OK, cool.
Thursday, April 28 at 0720 Coordinated Universal Time.
This is the most powerful polar satellite launch vehicle
in the PSLV XL configuration.
This is the seventh and final spacecraft
for India's regional navigational network.
Basically, it's like GPS, but only for India.
So they don't have to rely on the US or Russian GPS
constellations.
Their constellation was IRNSS Ernest,
which has been renamed to NAVIC or NAVIC.
I'm not sure if it's a short A or long A.
Probably NAVIC.
Sounds cooler, much easier to pronounce that way.
So that completes their constellations.
That is the final satellite in their constellation.
It's a total of seven satellites.
Off you go.
Good job, guys.
All right, let's hand this over to Mike,
talking about an Atlas V.
If I may, before I get into the Atlas V,
two things I wanted to mention about this IRNSS
launch with the PSLV is, for one,
we're starting to see a lot better footage coming out
of the Indian launch sites, which is great.
It's great to have HD footage from there.
And two, this occurred on the same day
as that Soyuz launch from Vastachny,
just a few hours later.
So I thought that was really cool.
But in any case, talking about the Atlas V,
the engineers for United Launch Alliance
have discovered the cause of why the Atlas V had an anomaly
when it launched the last Cygnus cargo mission back in March.
And with that, the engine booster
shut off a few seconds before it was originally planned.
And the reason for that was because of a valve
inside of the RD-180 engine.
We have a picture of the RD-180 engine during construction.
But the main thing that is the problem with this
is that the valves that manages the blend of the RP-1 kerosene
fuel and the liquid oxygen flowing into the main engine
caused a reduction in fuel flow during the launch.
And this is called the mixture ratio control valve, which
we also have a picture of in one of the basic schematics
that Pratt & Whitney and Aerojet Rocketdyne have out.
And with this, in the kind of bottom right corner
there is where this mixture ratio control valve is.
And according to the United Launch Alliance officials,
they said they did not see anything unusual with it
until late in the flight of the first stage.
And that's where they had the problems,
and the booster engine shut off early.
And they still have a lot of inspections
to complete as they try to determine
why this mixture ratio control valve performed unexpectedly.
And they're checking out all of their current inventory
of RD-180 engines to ensure that their following flights are
successful.
And until they have enough confidence
with the next engine in its flight manifest, which
will be launching the MUOS 5 satellite into orbit,
no official launch date will be announced
as the Atlas 5 launches are pushed back
until they are ready to proceed.
But at least now that they know what the cause of the failure
was, even though they don't know why it happens,
at least they can start working on a solution
and look at that on all the other RD-180 engines
they're going to use.
So very good news, and hopefully they're
able to figure out a fix for that
and make sure that they can do the testing on the next launch.
And interestingly, they've actually
set the next Atlas 5 vertical so that they
can inspect that valve in a different position
and do lots of different things while they're
mounting the solid rocket boosters
and eventually the payload.
So very interesting, and hopefully they
get a good fix for that very soon.
Awesome.
Well, now it's vertical.
Jared, vertical.
Jared, talk to us about Mars communication.
Yeah, so obviously communication,
a very important thing to do with your spacecraft
that you're going to have there.
And NASA's actually officially announced a solicitation.
Easy for you to say.
Yes, very easy, of ideas for a Mars orbiter
planned for a mission in the 2020s
as both a scientific platform and a telecommunications relay.
And NASA is preparing to up the bandwidth of its assets
around Mars in preparation for eventual human missions
in the 2030s.
Originally, landers on Mars used communication systems
directly with the Earth.
Now, this requires them to move at a lower
speed for data transfer, not really all that great.
And right now, NASA uses Mars Odyssey, Mars Reconnaissance
Orbiter, and MAVEN to handle data for the Mars Exploration
Rover Opportunity and Mars Science Laboratory Rover
Curiosity.
Now, MAVEN has the fastest data transfer rate
at about two megabits per second from Mars.
So that's actually pretty darn fast.
That's actually, when you consider,
it's what, seven light years away from us?
Not light years.
Light years.
Not light.
Light minutes.
It's seven light minutes away from us.
That sounds better.
Just keep going, Jared.
Yeah, sure thing.
And this right here that we have on the screen
is actually a early engineering diagram
that JPL has put up with it.
Because the Mars 2022 platform is
planned to include things like solar electric propulsion,
which will allow for a more massive spacecraft,
improved solar panels to power that solar electric propulsion,
an improved high gain antenna system,
and also a laser optical communications package
for high data transfer rates.
We're talking 25 megabytes per second, roughly,
from Mars, which is an order of magnitude better.
Wait, megabytes or megabits?
Megabytes.
Well, that's pretty good.
Yeah, it's really good stuff.
Yeah.
And it's going to, of course, have an improved science
package on board as well.
Because if you've got something in orbit around Mars,
you might as well just stick some scientific payload on it
as well.
Now, the reason they're very concerned about this
is that Mars Odyssey is 15 years old at Mars.
So they kind of want to get something in there
so that MAVEN doesn't have to be the backup
for telecommunications on Mars.
Because if you have MAVEN be the backup,
that means you have to dedicate most, or not most,
but some of your time away from science to communications.
And they want to use MAVEN for as much science as they can,
instead of having to use it to relay data back and forth.
Now, this kind of comes on the heels of a canceled mission
that they actually developed back in the early 2000s
called Mars Telecommunications Orbiter, which
would have basically been a dedicated data relay
system at Mars.
But it was canceled in 2005.
So we're finally getting that telecommunications system
and that internet in the solar system ready to go for Mars.
It's going to be important as we start putting humans on Mars.
Very, very important.
How old is Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter?
Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter is going to be 10 years old.
Ooh.
So 10 years in operation.
I'm flies.
Yeah, no joke.
All right, Space Mike, talk to me about GPS.
Gippus.
So with GPS-3, which is the next constellation of satellites
that the United States Air Force is going to put up,
they have awarded a launch contract
to SpaceX for the competition that they
won to launch the next GPS-3 satellite.
And this is actually specifically
the GPS-2 satellite, which we have a mock-up here of.
And with this, this launch contract
is worth $82.7 million US and covers
the costs of the launch vehicle production, mission
integration, launch operations, and spaceflight certification.
And this doesn't come as much of a surprise
since United Launch Alliance declined
to bid on this particular launch contract.
But what is surprising is that when,
according to the United States Air Force officials,
SpaceX was not the only company that
bid on this particular contract.
Although who the other company was is unclear,
but it definitely was not United Launch Alliance.
So that's very interesting.
And the Air Force will hold at least nine more similar launch
contract competitions for the GPS-3 fleet.
And with the multiple engine contracts that
are currently in development, some unexpected players
may be entering into the evolved expendable launch vehicle launch
competitions very soon.
And meanwhile, United Launch Alliance still has the Delta IV,
and the ban has been lifted for now on United Launch Alliance
being able to use the RD-180 engines for national security payloads.
So it'll be really interesting to see who launches
the rest of the GPS-3 fleet.
All right.
I want to know who the other bidder was.
Maybe was it the space program on tomorrow?
I hope so.
Spot it.
This is just my suspicion, but I think
it might have been Orbital ATK.
But it could have been something else.
There's other contracts in there.
And maybe it was even Blue Origin,
although they don't have their orbital vehicle flying yet.
They haven't even done a test flight of that yet.
They're still doing just work on the engines, the BE-4 engine.
But very interested to know who that could have been.
It makes me wonder if it was even an international company that
is able to market things here in the United States.
And they didn't release any details of who it was
or why their bid was rejected.
But that'd be really interesting to find out.
And if anyone does have any links to that procurement process,
I'd be really interested to find out.
It's both interesting and boring at the exact same time.
Yeah.
All right, Jared, talk to me about a make-make-toid.
A make-make-toid?
Yes.
Is that what we're calling it now?
That's what we're doing.
If it's a Plutoid, it's going to be a make-make-toid.
No, it's make-make.
Yeah, it is make-make-toid, first of all.
No, I like make-make.
Yeah, that's OK, white people.
Anyways, NASA's Hubble Space Telescope
has found a moon in orbit around dwarf planet Makemake
after a detailed study.
Now, they were using the Wide Field Camera 3 on Hubble,
and scientists were able to see the moon, which, as you can see,
wasn't hard to find it.
There's a big arrow with text next to it out of space.
Just kidding about that.
But that is it right there.
It is 1,300 times fainter than Makemake itself.
And the moon has been designated.
Here's a great name for it.
You got me with that one, Jared.
I'm still laughing at that.
Here's a good one.
It was designated S-2015-136427,
but they're nicknaming it MK2.
Now, it's approximately 100.
This is why we can't let astronomers
name anything anymore.
They don't.
They number it, obviously.
Obviously.
Excuse you, Ben.
It's about 160 kilometers in diameter
compared to Makemake being, oh, I put 870 miles.
Oh my gosh, quick metric math.
Well, a lot bigger.
And it orbits once every 12 days and is about 21,000 kilometers
above Makemake's surface.
Now, much like Pluto's moon, Charon,
MK2 is significantly darker than Makemake.
And also studying MK2's orbit will
allow for very accurate measurements of Makemake,
such as its mass, and also further confirms ideas
that scientists had that most dwarf planets likely
have moons around them.
Now, we can actually figure out where MK2 came from just
by looking at the shape of its orbit.
If it's a circular orbit, that would
imply that it was from a collision.
If it's a very elliptical orbit, that
would imply that it was a captured body.
So keep your eyes tuned on that one.
That's going to be very interesting results
once we start getting an even more focused study on that.
All right, we're going to take a quick break.
And when we come back, we're going
to be talking about our path forward to Mars, hashtag
red dragon.
Stay tuned.
We'll be right back.
I do love our Spacepod correspondents.
Minnie Stoge said, make Makemake great again.
Makemake great again.
Oh, goodness.
Hashtag.
All right, now before we get started with our main topic,
I do want to give a huge shout out
to all of the patrons of Tomorrow who
have helped to make this specific segment
for this episode happen.
These are people who have contributed $10 or more
to this specific episode.
We've also got our Tomorrow producers.
These are people who have contributed $5
to this specific episode.
They're going to get access to After Dark
as soon as we post it online, as well
as access to the Google Hangouts that we do once in a while.
So thank you everyone for helping to make this show go
week after week.
For more information on how you can help crowdfund
the shows of Tomorrow, head on over to patreon.com slash T-M-R-O.
And now I do want to comment on last week's topic, hashtag.
You can see what's in preview.
Hashtag impossible drive.
I wasn't here.
And so.
You go back and watch these shows?
I do go back and go watch these shows.
You guys said this.
This is great.
The best part is that you guys have comments,
and you're going to have comments.
Please leave us comments, and then Ben will
answer all of them next week.
You absolutely should do that.
I want to see Ben sweating bullets
about hardcore theoretical physics,
because that's what this is.
Who doesn't?
And then I cut Mike off.
So that's not.
First off, thanks guys.
You're welcome.
That's not how this works, though.
I don't ever claim to have all of the answers.
What I do is I try to find.
Well, OK, I do claim to have all the answers.
But what I actually try to do is find the people
who do have these answers.
So after I heard that, and after I saw that show, I was like,
all right, we obviously need more information on the EM
drive.
That was a little painful.
So I reached out to our resident rocket scientist, Vax Hedrub,
and he had this to say.
OK, guys, so I'm actually posting here
a video to you guys on the Impossible Drive show
that you did last week.
There are at least five do-it-yourselfers
who are currently building units in order
to try and replicate reported results from Roger
Scheuer, who was the original inventor in England,
and a professor whose name is Yang in China.
They've reported numbers as high as 4 tenths of a newton.
That's 400 millinewtons per kilowatt.
That's a lot of thrust.
For reference, the attitude control thrusters
that we generally would put on satellites are 5 newtons.
So this would be approximately 1 tenth of that, 0.4 newtons,
to the kilowatt.
On the NASA Space Flight Forum, one of the things
that they also did was they created a wiki.
The emdrive.wiki is the website.
And on there, you'll find some really good authoritative
information on the theories of how this thing works
and reported results with lots of really good
what they would know as figures of merit.
So this is real amount of power put in,
very precise measurements of the devices that have been built,
the frequencies that they used, what kind of microwave
generators, whether they were using magnetrons
or whether they were using dedicated microwave amplifiers.
So there's a lot of really good stuff out there.
I actually have a fairly exhaustive post for this
on my WordPress blog spot.
That's vaxheadroom.wordpress.com.
And it's called RF Drive to the Stars.
So you can see there not only links
to a lot of different things, but also that
includes some of the visualizations that I've done.
So some of those are really pretty cool.
And hopefully, you can use that as a jumping off point
for more information.
Thanks.
All right, so that's step one.
Here's where you can get more information.
But then we're actually going to take this to the next level.
Next week, we're going to have Dave Disler on.
He's a NASA Space Flight Forum moderator
for the emdrive section.
He's a builder of two generations of emdrive devices.
And he's also a retired RF and microwave systems engineer.
So we're going to be bringing him
on the show of Dave Disler next week for season nine, episode
16.
Yeah, that's right.
And so hopefully, you guys can tune into that episode.
And we're going to rehash this topic one more time.
Because I do think that the hashtag impossible drive,
if it works, and if all the science does end up working
out, could be a very big deal.
And I want to make sure that we get that information correct.
So there you go.
All right, our main topic this week
is hashtag red dragon.
That's just for you, as opposed to hashtag.
Hashtag red dragon.
SpaceX made some announcements nonchalantly.
I think it was on Twitter.
Is that correct?
Yeah.
I believe so, yeah.
So what did they say?
So the announcement was on Wednesday
that they are planning to launch one
of their uncrewed Dragon capsules
to Mars in the 2018 launch window.
And that would be really cool.
They've been working on lots of different phases of this
that are coming together for this plan, one
of which is the whole Dragonfly program,
testing out the Super Dracos, which
would allow the Dragon capsule to have propulsive landings.
A lot of that has been able to do propulsive landings here
on Earth.
But the whole announcement is that this could potentially
land on any body in the solar system.
They could land on the moon, land on Mars.
And this is a really interesting program.
They're already going to be doing free-flying uncrewed
Dragon capsules under the name of Dragon Lab.
And so this is kind of marrying both of those programs
into something really exciting that
would have a lot of impacts.
Not only would they be the first commercial company
to land a spacecraft on Mars if they successfully do it,
but they would also be able to work with NASA
to be able to hopefully supply some more additional science.
And NASA is going to be working with SpaceX
to help give them a lot of their information
and their experience of landing on Mars over the decades.
And this is a really cool thing.
And I'm very excited for it.
And hopefully it works.
But at the same time, I'm also hoping
that it doesn't get rushed.
And that if they do this, that the mission
would be successful.
So if they don't make it in the 2018 launch window,
hopefully in the 2020 launch window.
But if they can do it in 2018, that would just be amazing.
Well, wait.
What's wrong with the?
So hang on.
If this is a test mission to figure stuff out,
how do you define success?
Successfully having a soft landing on the surface of Mars
and being able to communicate and return data back,
at least telemetry back, from that spacecraft.
So I'm going to push back.
As long as you capture data of sorts,
even if you don't have a soft landing
and you have a high energy event on landing,
as long as you get data back and you understand what happened,
then that would be, in my world, considered a success.
Because you've got data to move forward.
Because these are precursor missions, right?
I mean, how are we viewing these missions?
What are they?
What are they for?
I'm kind of viewing this mission as SpaceX doubling down
on the idea that they are going to be
the ones who are going to attempt to lead
human colonization on Mars.
Because that is what Elon has always stated,
that his goal is to have a city on Mars.
And this feels like he's really trying to get that going
and that this mission is going to be that first step
to see what Dragon version 2 needs to actually do
to land on Mars.
Because they said that it's been designed to land on Mars.
But of course, there's a difference between designing
something to land on Mars and then actually
having it land on Mars.
So I'm not sure what they're even
thinking about in terms of testing.
Because you really can't fly like a dragon in,
you can't do it from orbit around Earth
and back down in order to get the data for what you need.
Because that's not correct.
It's too much atmosphere.
And I was wondering about some interesting things,
too, which is that obviously you don't want
to rush something like this.
So I don't think they're going to make the 2018 window.
Because let's face it, Dragon version 2 hasn't flown yet.
And Falcon Heavy hasn't flown yet either.
And we're literally talking like 18 months from now,
going out and flying to untested, unflown.
Well, that's where the window begins.
I mean, that's not when the window ends, right?
Let's be fair.
OK, so 19 months instead of 18.
I'm also wondering, too, about the windows.
Because the 2020 window requires more energy
to actually get to Mars than the 2018 window.
Because the 2018 window, you can move at either 7.7
to 11.11 kilometers per second of total energy expenditure.
While the 2020 window is 13.2 to 18.4 kilometers per second.
So there's a very big difference in the amount of energy
you're going to need for that.
And that can lead to a difference
in what you're actually going to be able to carry on your Dragon.
How much fuel you can carry, how much payload you can carry,
your entry angle, the speed.
All those things are going to have to be factored in.
And it's a very ambitious test flight.
And I'm very interested to see what
is actually going to happen.
So Zyggr has two interesting comments back to back.
One is, make the mistakes and learning moments
on the test flights.
That's what they're for.
Yes.
Mistakes, right?
I mean, learning moments, right?
You don't know what you don't know.
So that's why you have these flights.
And the second one is, don't wait for perfect.
You'll never move forward.
So two just general good concepts.
Yeah, but it's expensive.
It's an expensive whoops in order to do this.
I mean, and there's also suggestion
that you launch two within the very short window as well.
And that's, you know, if one fails
and the other one's on the way, there's
a very likely chance that the problem with the first one
will also be a problem with the second one.
So yeah, it's a really tough kind of thing.
And now that it's been publicly announced,
it's kind of like you've got to commit to it.
I got a question from the chat room
from two different people basically
asking the same thing.
Zed Weasel and Green Jim 2, or I, or E,
said, will it have the Mars ascent vehicle Earth return
vehicle for sample return?
In other words, they fly Red Dragon down.
Are they going to have a vehicle that
can come back to Earth for a sample of Martian stuff?
I don't believe that for this first test mission they would.
They probably would do that for follow-on missions.
And the whole point of doing this is to, first of all,
see if you can land.
And if you can, then you can start
sending down cargo and supplies or even rovers
with the Dragon capsule to be able to start setting up
the infrastructure for when humans finally do land there
and, of course, to set up colonization.
And there's a couple of reasons why I think they could do this.
I mean, the Falcon Heavy is scheduled to debut this year.
It's hopefully going to be launching this year.
And with the Dragonfly program, I'm
not sure exactly how far they are with their progression.
But they started, at least the first test flight,
as far back in November of last year.
So they might be quite far along with a lot
of these different projects.
And we're going to see the first crewed flight, hopefully,
in 2017.
Not crewed flight, excuse me, the first demo flight
of the Dragon V2 in an uncrewed version in low Earth orbit.
So there's a lot of different factors
and a lot of different milestones
that might make this possible.
And something else that might make it so that they
could launch in either window is the introduction
of the Raptor engine for their upper stage, which
would be using methane instead of kerosene.
And with that, they would be able to get a huge performance
boost out of their upper stage engine.
And that might be able to allow for as much extra performance
as they need to be able to have a successful rendezvous
and orbit into Mars and then descent and hopefully
successfully landing on the surface.
Yeah, so there's a really good question in the chat room
here from Jason519, which is that,
could we do a test of an in-situ hydrogen fuel generator
on board of Red Dragon?
And I would imagine that that would be a very high priority
scientific payload that you would want to have there.
I know on JPL's Mars 2020 rover, they're
actually going to have a oxygen gas generator there
to see if they can take the atmosphere from Mars, which
is mostly carbon dioxide, and generate breathable oxygen
gas from that.
So I would love to see that as a payload.
And according to what SpaceX says,
it's somewhere on the order of about one ton
of scientific payload that they could land
on the surface of Mars, which that's a lot.
And of course, that's not including
the weight of the actual Dragon capsule itself.
But one ton is about 50 kilograms more
than what Curiosity weighs.
So that's a lot of scientific payload.
A lot of stuff.
I mean, Curiosity, it weighs nearly 900 kilograms.
But really, only about 100 kilograms of that
is actual scientific payload.
So this could be potentially a very nice mission
to have in terms of science return
in what we may want to do.
ER3061 asks, how long do you think
this has been in planning work before the announcement?
This has been in the plans for a long time.
I mean, I've heard about this idea at least five to seven
years ago.
This has been a plan for quite a long time
and something that they've been announcing for quite a while.
But this is the first official, like, OK,
we're actually going to do this Red Dragon thing in 2018.
That's why this is a big news item right now.
Yeah.
Back in 2011, NASA's Ames Research Center up
in the Bay Area here in California
actually worked with SpaceX sort of to formulate
an idea of what would be needed to actually use a dragon
for, like, a Red Dragon mission.
And then there were actual bids put in by Ames in 2013 and 2015
for the 13th round of NASA's Discovery missions
in order to actually fly a Red Dragon.
But they were not picked up, unfortunately.
But it sounds like SpaceX has said, well,
we're going to do it anyhow.
So I guess that's a good result from that.
And Valerian, I guess, says the main problem they will face
will be supersonic retro propulsion, correct?
Yes.
So describe what supersonic retro propulsion is.
OK, basically, supersonic retro propulsion, you are coming in
hot.
You are like, woo!
You are coming in super fast.
And you've got to fire the brakes.
But you've got to fire the brakes
at the last possible second so you don't use all of your fuel.
That's essentially what it is.
Like, what we do with the rovers that we landed,
such as the case of Curiosity, first you
brake using the aerodynamic forces and a heat shield
in order to allow you to come in.
Then you deploy a supersonic parachute out
that slows you down to about 200 miles an hour.
And then in Curiosity's case, they detached it,
had it attached to that Sky Crane, which was basically
rocket engines that we've already used and proven
used on Mars in previous missions,
slowed it down to a couple inches per second,
deployed it on a cable system, and then dropped it down,
cut it, and flew it off.
That was crazy, by the way.
Yeah, it was.
Well, it was crazy.
But it was also the smartest engineering decision
that they could have made as well.
In the case of SpaceX, I have no idea
what they would actually do.
Because from what I understand, there have been studies done.
And the entry speeds of a Dragon after aerodynamic braking
is literally right on the edge of what SuperDracos can handle.
So that's one of those things that I'm
wondering if they're going to have to modify the Dragon
capsule to make it lighter.
So that way you can actually get more thrust to weight out
of it and therefore be able to use the SuperDracos to land.
And it's kind of like what I said at the beginning.
It's easy to design it.
And then there's the whole problem
is that when you have that problem coming up,
oh boy, you've got to figure out how to fix it and quick.
All right.
Any final comments from you guys?
I mean, what's making this a big deal?
Why are we excited about this?
We've gone to Mars before.
Why is this any different?
Because this will be the first commercial company to do it
that has very ambitious plans, serious plans,
to start sending humans there to stay there and colonize there
and, in the future, terraform Mars into another Earth.
I mean, this is us getting off the planet
to ensure humanity's survival.
It's our backup plan.
This is plan B. And SpaceX is doing it.
That's just, that's awesome.
That's incredible.
That's, to me, anyway.
All right.
I'd love to know what you guys think.
Leave your comments on YouTube, Facebook, Twitter,
wherever you want.
Hashtag RedDragon.
Why do you think this is a big deal?
Or do you not think this is a big deal?
And how do you think they're going
to actually execute on this?
It's an interesting topic.
On that note, we're going to take a quick break.
And when we come back, comments from our last week's show.
So stay tuned.
We'll be right back.
I should have said a galaxy of media at the end
instead of a world of media.
All right.
Before we get into comments from last week's show,
a huge shout out to all of the patrons of Tomorrow
who have helped to make this specific segment
of this episode happen.
These are the people who have contributed $10 or more.
Then we've also got our producers who have contributed
$5 or more to this specific episode.
And then we've also got two other reward levels.
The next reward level is the Patreon Plus.
This is $2.50 or more to this particular episode
of this show.
And you get, in addition to everything else,
you get the After Dark episode.
And you get the, what am I trying to say,
the Google Hangout.
And we've also got one more level.
We've got our patrons.
These are the people who contributed as little as one
penny up to $2.49.
That's right, as little as one US penny
gets your name in the show week after week.
So we'd like to thank everyone who
contributed to the shows of Tomorrow.
Head on over to patreon.com slash T-M-R-O for more
information on how you can help crowdfund our shows.
I'm doing my best to make sure that the ads don't.
Ads just annoy me at this point.
I don't know about you guys.
But they're just in the way.
They pop up.
They're just annoying.
And we get so little revenue from the ads
that I'm just trying to turn them off.
And we are able to do that because of patrons
that make that happen.
Because we get enough revenue from the Patreon campaign
to actually run the show week after week
and run our space pod.
So I'm doing, if you see ads somewhere,
let me know because I don't want you guys to see ads.
Whether you pay or don't pay, just hashtag no ads.
All right.
Sounds good.
All right.
Thank you, by the way, patrons.
Yes, thank you very much.
Absolutely.
Thank you.
Yeah.
Couldn't do this without you.
All right.
Let's go ahead and get started with some comments
from last week's show.
Yeah, so you guys are really hitting YouTube really hard.
There were a couple comments like here and there.
But YouTube was just like, poof.
How were they like?
Poof.
There you go.
All right, good.
Now you've got all of us.
Poof.
Oh, goodness.
All right.
It's all good.
It's OK.
Because we translated weird on the TV.
That's what happened.
Probably a little bit.
So this first comment comes from Mark Smed off of YouTube.
Says, launch an EM drive into space
and test it on a free flying set just to see if it works.
It's funny.
It's kind of what we're talking about
with the hashtag RedDragon, just kind of see what works,
gather some data.
There's nothing better than real life actually doing it.
On paper, it's nice and all.
But actually doing it, learn, figure out
what it's really like.
Having said that, just like we were talking with RedDragon,
there's a cost involved to that.
If it's on its own launch, it's going
to be $60-plus million to run that test.
So open your checkbook.
I say stick it in a CubeSat.
Is it small enough to stick into a CubeSat?
I'm not sure.
But it did not look like those are small enough.
Let's figure out how to do that.
Or even remotely close to small enough to stick it.
From what I could tell, they're sizable.
I mean, stick it outside the CubeSat.
All right.
Attach it to multiple CubeSats.
Yes.
So I mean, it just comes down to money and resources, right?
So you have to have one, and then you
have to have the measurement to make sure that you're not
measuring thrust that was already given to you
by the rocket or something else.
You have to be able to measure something.
And then you actually have to be able to build, pay for it,
and launch it.
And that's not inexpensive, at least not today.
Hopefully someday it will be.
You'll be like, ah, just launch it.
Just put it on a plane and go.
Send it up.
Just send it up.
Get it out of my sights.
Bah!
But that's not today.
That's not today.
All right, next up, Capcom.
Next one comes from Gideon Nimblesick.
Gideon.
I did this to myself this time.
Says, nerd question.
Nerd question!
Nerd!
Nerd, give me your lunch money.
Nerd.
Jared mentioned rocket engines with an ISP, which is,
what's ISP?
Specific impulse.
Perfect.
Of 470 to 480 seconds, which ones would that be?
I just realized ISP is specific impulse.
And you look at that and you go, well,
obviously something that starts with an I is specific impulse.
Yeah.
Anyhow, yeah.
Internet service provider.
First off, let's start with what is specific impulse
and why is it important?
Specific impulse is essentially the efficiency of your engine.
That's very important because the higher the specific impulse
you have, the more efficient your engine is,
the better you can actually get a payload up
and all those other fun things that come with it.
So that's why things that have very low specific impulses,
like methane and RP1 mixing with liquid oxygen,
don't have as high a specific impulse as something
like, say, liquid hydrogen and liquid oxygen mixing together.
And that's basically like you get one pound of thrust
for 400 and some odd second.
What is that, 480 seconds?
Sort of energy content and all that other fun chemistry
stuff over a specific amount of time.
So yeah, for this amount of thing,
you get this much stuff on time, right?
Or you can go the other direction.
Essentially.
So that's what it is.
And then the question is, which engines
would have an ISP, a specific impulse of 470 to 480 seconds?
I made a mistake.
Because I was thinking in my head, space shuttle main
engine, because that is essentially
the most efficient liquid-fueled engine anyone has ever flown.
I think it's awesome.
452 seconds of impulse, so I was incorrect.
But there are NERVA engines that were tested back
in the 60s and 70s.
NERDA?
NERVA, which just lets you know, before you
scream acronym alert, it stands for Nuclear Engine
for Rocket Vehicle Application.
Wait, wait, wait, wait.
So these were the engines that were tested in like the 60s.
Yeah, 60s and 70s.
And then they were like, yeah, these are banned.
Basically.
OK, cool.
Yeah.
So what was the ISP on those?
They were actually about 800 to 900 seconds of impulse.
Wow.
Pretty good.
Too bad they're banned and would radiate everything around them.
Yeah, well, you know.
Those basically, those weren't like a traditional rocket
engine, right?
They just basically created an explosion
and then you rode the wave of the explosion?
No, these were like traditional rocket engines.
Then I'm thinking of a different one.
It's just that the different fuels you could use
and the mixtures were more efficient with that.
You essentially used the nuclear power
to heat up your fuel and combust it and other things like that.
Space Kid at 88 says, yeah, they were shaking themselves apart.
Yes, they were very good engines.
So good that they literally fell apart.
All right.
So there you go.
Next up, Capcom.
This one comes from Aurora7207.
10 launches, 10 days is not so unbelievable.
Missiles are always ready to fly.
Jet fighters are on constant standby.
Commercial airlines run almost constantly.
We are just talking about a space ferry, something
that can run consistently.
Rockets are 100-year-old technology already.
So Aurora7207, we agree, but we got there
in a completely different way.
We disagree completely on how we get there.
But fundamentally, with your comment,
I do agree that we will get to 10 launches in 10 days.
But the idea that, ah, it's 100-year-old technology,
we got this stuff down.
Look, a chemical rocket engine essentially
has a jet engine or two inside of it to drive the fuel.
So consider that the engine itself
requires a jet engine in it to drive the things to make it go.
That's how powerful these rocket engines are.
They run on the edge of what the materials they
are surrounded by can tolerate.
The margins are razor thin.
A jet engine does not have these thin, thin margins.
They are tested.
I mean, jet engines are amazing.
Yes.
They're awesome.
But they're nowhere near as impressive as a rocket engine.
So yeah, it's 100-year-old technology,
and it's still scary hard to do.
It's extremely difficult stuff.
Maybe it will get simpler in the future,
but that day is not today.
Yeah, so when a jet engine fails,
it's not as energetic as when a rocket engine fails.
That is a high-energy event when a rocket engine.
Well, because, again, you've got the jet engine
inside the other thing that's way more powerful, right?
So you've got a dual failure of your jet engine.
And by the way, when a jet engine fails,
there's some energy there.
Oh, yeah, it's spectacular.
That's a spectacular thing.
It's amazing.
It's beautiful in slow motion.
So I do believe that we will get there,
but it will have to be through new materials, new science,
new methods of propulsion, like the EM drive.
Well, I don't know if the EM drive is ever
going to get you out of atmosphere or out of 1G.
But yeah.
Yeah, I mean, like plasma and ion engines,
you don't even want to use them in a vacuum.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
You could only use them in a vacuum.
But the general idea is the same.
So there you go.
Like Masten Space Systems, he's proven over and over
that he can, not full big things,
but hopefully that scales up fairly linearly to bigger
objects.
Absolutely.
Blue Origin is starting to get faster.
Same thing with SpaceX.
And this whole comment's related to Carrie-Anne's story
about the XS-1, which potentially would be,
you know, I've been imagining it as around the same size
as the Air Force's X-37B, you know,
a small kind of vehicle that would
have a small satellite launcher either on the top of it
in like a shuttle-type stack.
So that's not too much of a scale-up
for Masten Space Systems.
And he's already proven that he can fly his rockets
multiple times a day.
So I agree that that might not be so far off
and that they might actually be able to do it.
All right, awesome.
One last.
One last comment, I believe.
This one just-
I was going to close the show, and I
realized we've got one more.
No, this one just totally made me laugh in every single way.
Again, talking about the impossible drive.
Mr. Dempsis says, space magic, gonna space magic.
I think that's in reference to something you said.
You're like, it's magic.
Yeah, because we all agree.
If you throw it in the lake, it'll float.
That was your exact quote.
Yeah, because we all agreed at the end of the episode
last week that it's basically magic.
But next week's episode, we will learn that it's not magic.
Or what kind of magic it is.
Yes.
Black magic.
Is it air?
Is it fire?
This show is made by black magic.
Yes, I'm aware of that.
There's a lot of black magic that goes into this show.
Ha ha!
Zinga!
Whoa, hey.
Check is in the mail.
Yeah.
I'm sorry, say it again, space Mike?
Cosmic magic.
Ah, nice.
Cosma magic.
Cosmagic.
All right, that is our show.
I'd like to thank everyone so much for watching.
Once again, next week, we're going
to be talking about the M possible drive.
Ha ha, hashtag EM possible.
Ha ha!
See what you said.
Zoom!
See what you did there.
Yeah.
Did it all by myself.
I didn't have help from anyone else on that one.
Dave Disler is going to be on talking about explaining
that in better detail, why it's a big deal,
how real it actually could be or maybe isn't.
All those questions that you guys had,
we're going to hopefully be able to answer next week.
So we look forward to doing that.
Stay tuned.
After Dark is up next.