In the ninth century, the Vikings transformed the history of Ireland and Britain. Among their most powerful leaders was Ímar , a mysterious Viking sea king who ruled alongside Olaf the White, established his power in Dublin, waged war against Irish kingdoms and helped forge a Norse dynasty that would influence the British Isles for generations.
But was Ímar actually Ivar the Boneless, the legendary son of Ragnar Lothbrok and one of the most famous commanders associated with the Great Heathen Army?
In this historical documentary, we explore Ímar's extraordinary career, from his campaigns in Ireland and the rise of Viking Dublin to the conquest of Anglo-Saxon England, the siege of Dumbarton Rock in 870, and his mysterious death in 873, when the Irish annals described him as “King of the Norsemen of all Ireland and Britain.”
Drawing upon medieval chronicles, Irish annals, Anglo-Saxon accounts and Norse legends, we investigate the evidence connecting Ímar to Ivar the Boneless, separate historical fact from later mythology, and uncover the origins of the powerful Uí Ímair dynasty, whose descendants would rule across Ireland, Northumbria and the Irish Sea.
Was Ímar one of the greatest Viking rulers of the ninth century, and was he truly the legendary Ivar the Boneless?
The sea was the great road of the Viking world, and in the ninth century few men understood how
to use it more ruthlessly than Aemar. His ships moved between Ireland and Britain,
at a time when kingdoms were divided, alliances were fragile, and a powerful warlord could turn
a fleet of longships into something far greater than a raiding force. Aemar emerged from that
violent world, not simply as another Viking commander, but as a ruler whose name became
tied to some of the most important Norse campaigns of the age. From the stronghold of Dublin,
Norse power reached deep into Ireland and across the Irish Sea in Britain. Armies fought for cities,
tribute, land, and control of trade routes, while kings and warlords struggled to hold their ground
against a new kind of threat. These were no longer brief attacks carried out by men
who intended to disappear over the horizon with silver and slaves. The Norse were beginning to
stay, to build bases, to form dynasties, and to compete directly with the rulers of the kingdoms
they had once raided. At the centre of this struggle stood Aemar, a man whose origins
remain uncertain, but whose power was impossible for contemporary chroniclers to ignore.
When he died in the year 873, the Irish annals remember him with an extraordinary title,
describing him as the King of the Norsemen of all Ireland and Britain. It was a remarkable
way to remember any Viking leader, and it tells us something about the scale of his authority,
reputation, and influence he had built during his lifetime.
Yet Aemar is also one of the great mysteries of the Viking Age. Some historians have connected
him with Ivar the Boneless, the famous leader associated with the Great Heathen Army,
while others have treated that identification more cautiously. What is certain is that Aemar
belonged to a powerful Norse dynasty that would shape the politics of Ireland and Britain for
generations, and that his career unfolded during one of the most dramatic periods of conquest and
upheaval in early medieval history. This is the story of a sea king who rose from the world of
longships and war bands to become one of the most formidable Norse rulers of the 9th century.
It is a story of Dublin, conquest, dynastic ambition, shifting alliances, and brutal warfare
across the Irish Sea. Above all, it is the story of Aemar, remembered by the annalists
as the King of the Norsemen. The earliest source and contemporary reference of Aemar
comes in the Irish Annals under the year 857. The Annals of Ulster record that Aemar and Amlieb,
the ruler traditionally identified with Olaf the White, inflicted a defeat upon Catil the Fair,
and his Norse-Irish followers in Munster. It is a remarkably short entry, but it immediately reveals
several important things. Aemar was already operating alongside Olaf as a commander capable
of leading an army far from Dublin. Munster lay deep in the south of Ireland, meaning that this
was not a minor clash around the Viking settlements of the east coast. Aemar and Olaf possessed enough
military reach to intervene in warfare across the island. Their enemy is equally interesting.
Catil the Fair led men described as Gal-Godil, usually rendered as Norse-Irish or Norse-Gaels.
The term suggests warriors whose identities crossed the increasingly blurred boundary between
Scandinavian and Gaelic society. Some may have been Scandinavians who had settled among the Irish,
others may have been Gaels who had entered Viking warbands, and the group as a whole appears to
have operated independently enough to become an enemy of Aemar and Olaf. The battle therefore
warns us against imagining the Viking presence in Ireland as a single united invasion. Scandinavian
leaders fought other Scandinavian leaders. Norse-Gaelic groups could ally themselves with
Irish kings against rival Vikings. Irish rulers could employ Viking forces and then fight the
groups later. The struggle taking place in 9th century Ireland was not simply Irish against
Norse. It was a shifting political landscape in which ethnicity, loyalty, and military necessity
constantly overlapped. The fact that Aemar appears beside Olaf in this campaign also tells us
something about his rank. Olaf had already been recognised as one of the dominant Scandinavian
figures in Ireland. Four years earlier, the Annals of Ulster had recorded his arrival and stated that
the foreigners of Ireland submitted to him and that he took tribute from the Irish. By the year 857,
Aemar was commanding beside him rather than appearing as an obscure subordinate.
A later source, the Fragmentary Annals of Ireland, attempts to push Aemar's arrival further back.
According to this account, Olaf came to Ireland carrying demands for tribute on behalf of his
father and after Olaf's departure, his younger brother Aemar followed to collect the same
payments. This would place Aemar in Ireland before his first secure contemporary appearance in the
year 857. The fragmentary annals are valuable, but they must be handled differently from the
Annals of Ulster. The surviving compilation is considerably later and contains narrative
material that does not always have the same chronological reliability as the contemporary
annals. Some passages may preserve genuinely old traditions or material from lost sources,
while others have clearly been expanded into stories. What the passage does suggest is that
Aemar and Olaf may have belonged to a dynasty already attempting to impose authority upon the
Scandinavian communities of Ireland. The language of tribute is important. These were not simply
captains looking for monasteries to raid, the claim was political. Someone was asserting the
right to extract wealth from both Scandinavian settlers and Irish rulers. The following year
gives us another glimpse of Aemar, this time in the Chronicon Scotorum. In the year 858,
it records that Serbul and Aemar defeated Senel Fiachach and their Norse-Irish allies Nearatir.
Serbul was the king of Osrage, one of the most formidable Irish rulers of the period.
Aemar was therefore not operating outside the Irish political system, he was participating
within it, fighting alongside an Irish king against other Irish Norse-Gaelic enemies.
The detail is essential to understand the development of Viking power in Ireland.
Military success increasingly depended upon alliances with Irish dynasties. A Viking ruler
who understood the feuds of the Irish kingdoms could use them to his advantage, supplying ships
and warriors to one king while weakening another. Irish rulers in return could use Scandinavian
forces against their domestic rivals. Aemar was becoming part of that system extraordinarily
quickly. In the year 859, the Annals of Ulster place him at the head of another major expedition.
Maid was not the same territory, it lay at the political heart of Ireland and was associated
with the kingship of Tara. At the time, the dominant ruler was Mael Sechnail, one of the
powerful kings of 9th century Ireland. The expedition therefore represented a major
intervention in Irish politics. Again, the composition of the attacking force is revealing.
Olaf and Aemar were originally Scandinavian rulers, but Serbo was an Irish king. They were
campaigning together against another Irish power. This conveys that Dublin's power was not confined
to its walls or harbour. The military system developing around the settlement was capable
of sending substantial armies inland. Horses could be acquired locally, Irish allies could
provide intelligence and supplies, and rivers and roads could be used to penetrate territories that
earlier coastal raiders would have struggled to reach. The Viking presence was becoming territorial.
Four years earlier, in the year 863, the Annals of Ulster provide one of the most important
descriptions of Aemar's political status. During an attack upon the lands of Flan Mac Connach,
the Analysts name Olaf, Aemar and Usyl together and call them the free kings of the foreigners.
The Scandinavian regime in Ireland appears to have accompanied several members of the same ruling
group simultaneously. Modern historians often call these men kings of Dublin because Dublin was
the principal centre from which their power operated, but the contemporary language is
broader. They were kings of the foreigners. That may suggest authority over people rather than
simply a defined territorial kingdom. Their kingship could have extended over Scandinavian
and mixed communities scattered through Ireland, united through dynastic loyalty,
military power, tribute, and control of the major Viking bases. The raid itself is also
interesting. The Annals say that the foreigners searched ancient burial caves and monumental
sites. The implication is not merely that they were burning farms, they were searching deliberately
for stored wealth. Ireland's ancient burial monuments had long been associated with kingship,
legend, and the distant past. Some still contained precious objects, while others
may have been believed to conceal treasure. The Scandinavian army was systematically
exploiting the landscape, opening places that previous generations had either respected,
feared, or simply never thought to disturb. The presence of Lorcan, the King of Might,
beside them once again demonstrates how complicated the political situation had become.
A ruler whose territory lay within Ireland's central kingdom was cooperating with foreign kings
while they devastated the lands of another Irish ruler. For Aemar, such alliances were useful
because they provided access to local political rivalries that no foreign army could fully
understand on its own. Then the record becomes less clear. From the year 864 and onwards,
Aemar becomes almost invisible in the contemporary Irish record for several years.
That silence has become one of the central problems in the study of his career. Before
turning to it, however, the fragmentary annals preserve a dramatic account of events
within the ruling dynasty itself. Under the year 867, they describe a conflict involving Olaf,
Aemar, and their brother Ossil, with whom the annals of Ulster call Ossile. The fragmentary
annals explicitly state that the three brothers were the sons of a king. Ossile is portrayed as
the youngest, but perhaps the greatest warrior among them, surpassing both Irishmen and Norsemen
in different forms of combat. The story then claims that his brothers came to hate him,
and that Olaf and Aemar discussed killing him. The annals of Ulster confirmed that Ossile was
indeed killed by his own kinsmen, although they do not provide the elaborate story found in the
account. That distinction is important. Something violent almost certainly happened
within the ruling dynasty. Ossile died at the hands of his relatives. Whether Aemar personally
participated in planning his death is much harder to establish. The later narrative may preserve
authentic dynastic memory. It may also have been shaped into a moral story about jealousy,
rivalry, and betrayal. We cannot know, but if there is truth behind it, the episode reveals
the instability that often accompanied shared kingship. Three ambitious rulers could cooperate
against outsiders, while simultaneously competing among themselves for wealth,
warriors, and authority. Dynastic politics among Viking rulers could be every bit as
dangerous as warfare against their enemies. After this point, contemporary Irish sources
cease naming Aemar until the year 870. This gap is particularly significant, because it overlaps
almost exactly with one of the greatest Scandinavian offences ever launched against
Anglo-Saxon England. In the year 866, what the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle calls the Great
Army entered East Anglia. The following year, it moved north and captured York. The Northumbrian
kings Osbert and Aella were killed in the fighting, and the survivors made peace with the invaders.
In the year 868, the army moved into Mercia and occupied Nottingham. In the year 870,
it invaded East Anglia, defeated King Edmund, and conquered his kingdom.
Later English traditions associate a Viking leader named Hingwar or Ivar with the death of Edmund.
This is where the famous identification becomes possible. Was Aemar of Ireland the same man
remembered in English and later Scandinavian tradition as Ivar the Boneless? There are strong
reasons for considering it. The names are linguistically compatible. Aemar disappears
from Irish records precisely while Ivar becomes prominent in Britain. The Irish Aemar reappears
when the English Ivar disappears from the English historical narrative, if they were the same person.
The implications are enormous. Aemar would not merely have been one of the founders of
Norse Dublin. He would also have been among the commanders involved in the destruction of the
old Northumbrian kingdom, the capture of York, and the campaigns that transformed Anglo-Saxon
England. His absence from Ireland would then be explained not by weakness or exile,
but by expansion. While other rulers maintained Scandinavian power around Dublin,
Aemar may have been campaigning hundreds of miles away, at the head of one of the most feared
armies in Western Europe. Whatever he was doing during these missing years,
he returned unmistakably to the Irish analystic record in the year 870 and when he reappeared,
he did so during one of the greatest military achievements of his career. The Annals of Ulster
record that Olaf and Aemar, explicitly described as two kings of the Norsemen, besieged Dumbarton
Rock, the great fortress of the Britons of Strathclyde. The siege lasted four months.
Eventually, the fortress was destroyed and plundered. Dumbarton Rock was no ordinary
stronghold. Rising above the River Clyde, it had served for centuries as the principal fortress
of the Kingdom of Outclut. Its position gave its rulers access to the Clyde and control over an
important region of Western Britain. To attack it required far more than any sort of rapid raid,
traditionally associated with Viking warfare. Aemar and Olaf were prepared to remain before
the fortress for four months. That fact alone demonstrates the sophistication their armies
had developed. A force capable of sustaining a siege for an entire season required food,
organization, ships, manpower, and the ability to prevent defenders from receiving relief.
This was not a band of raiders landing briefly from the sea. It was an army conducting sustained
strategic warfare. The fragmentary annals provide further detail. According to their version,
the besiegers eventually reduced the inhabitants through hunger and thirst after the water supply
inside the fortress failed. Only then was the stronghold overwhelmed, its wealth taken,
and a large number of its people carried away captive. The story may contain later embellishment,
particularly the dramatic explanation of the failing water supply, but the basic picture agrees
with the Annals of Ulster. Dumbarton endured a prolonged siege and then fell. For the Kingdom
of Strathclyde, it was a catastrophe. For Aemar, it was a demonstration that his power now operated
on both sides of the Irish Sea. The following annal entry makes the
scale of the victory even clearer. In the year 871, Olaf and Aemar returned to Dublin from
Scotland with 200 ships. The Annals of Ulster state that they brought with them a great multitude
of captives consisting of Angles, Britons, and Picts. Dublin was receiving not merely a victorious
army, but the human and material proceeds of a major conquest. The captives are particularly
revealing. Britons would naturally have been taken in Strathclyde, but the reference to
Angles and Picts suggests that the expedition ranged across a much wider area or that the
prisoners from several campaigns were gathered during the return. Those captives had economic
value. Slavery was deeply embedded in the Viking economy. Dublin became an important centre in
networks that carried enslaved people through the Irish Sea into the wider known world.
Some captives would have been retained as labourers or household dependents.
Others would have been exchanged, ransomed, or sold. Soon afterward, according to the
fragmentary annals, Olaf left Ireland to assist his father, whom the sources call Goughraid,
in a war among the Norse. The writer even says that the reasons for the conflict were known,
but were omitted because they did not concern Ireland. If this tradition is accurate,
the consequence was extremely important. Eymar was left as the dominant surviving ruler of Dublin.
His younger brother was dead. Olaf had departed. For perhaps the first time,
Eymar may have stood without an equal beside him. The next passage in the fragmentary annals
is one of the strangest and most tantalising notices associated with him. It gives Eymar
a genealogy, calling him the son of Goughraid, son of Ragnell, son of Goughraid Cunnung,
son of Goughraid. It then says that Eymar and the son of Olaf plundered from west to east,
from south to north. The geographical language is probably rhetorical rather than literal.
Medieval writers often use phrases such as from east to west, or from north to south,
to communicate comprehensiveness. It does not necessarily mean that Eymar personally marched
through every part of Ireland, but the meaning is still striking. The writer remembered Eymar as a
ruler whose forces were campaigning across an enormous area. This fits remarkably well with
the image created by the contemporary annals. He had already fought in Munster, campaigned in
Mide, besieged Strathclyde, and returned with captives from several peoples of Britain.
Few Viking leaders of the period can be demonstrated to have operated across such
a wide geographical range. The genealogy attached to the entry is much more difficult.
Later writers clearly wanted to place Eymar within a prestigious Scandinavian royal ancestry.
Modern historians have therefore treated the genealogical sequence cautiously.
This matters because genealogies were political documents. To claim descent from ancient kings
was to legitimise present rule. Eymar's descendants would have been one of the most
important dynasties in the Viking world, the Uyghur, the descendants of Eymar. Later generations
had every reason to construct an impressive ancestry for the founder of their house.
But even if that exact genealogy cannot be trusted, its existence tells us something about
Eymar's later reputation. He had become a dynastic ancestor worth remembering. Then, in the year 873,
the contemporary analytic record reaches its conclusion. The Annals of Ulster record the
death of Eymar. The notice is only a few words long, but it might be the most important sentence
ever written about him. The Annals call him the King of the Norsemen of all Ireland and Britain.
That is an extraordinary title. Medieval analysts did not normally waste space on meaningless
decoration. Titles were used to identify political status, and the geographical scope
attached to Eymar's kingship is remarkable. The phrase should not necessarily be interpreted
as saying that Eymar literally ruled every Viking in Ireland, England, Scotland and Wales,
in the manner of a later territorial monarch. But the title demonstrates that Eymar's
contemporaries remembered his authority as extending across the Irish sea world.
Chronicon Scotorum preserves a similar death notice, calling him the King of the Norsemen
of all Ireland, although without the additional reference to Britain found in the Annals of Ulster.
The difference between these two versions is valuable. It reminds us that analytic texts
were copied, abbreviated, and transmitted independently. A title preserved in one
tradition might be shortened in another. Neither source should automatically be treated as a
perfect transcript of some original document. Nevertheless, both agree on one essential point.
Eymar died as a king, not merely as a fleet commander. The Fragmentary Annals contain
another death notice around the same period, concerning a king of Loughlin named Goffred,
traditionally interpreted as Eymar's father. The Annals say that this king died of a sudden
and terrible illness. The identification, however, is difficult, and some historians have argued that
later scribal intervention may have confused the entry and that it could have originally referred
to Eymar himself. This uncertainty illustrates one of the fundamental problems in reconstructing
Eymar's life. The closer we remain to the Contemporary Annals, the clearer the outline
becomes. Eymar appears as a military commander in the year 857. He allies with major Irish kings,
he campaigns in Mide. By the year 863, he is explicitly called one of the Kings of the
Foreigners. He disappears during precisely the period in which the Great Heathen Army is
transforming Anglo-Saxon England. He reappears as a king commanding the four-month siege of
Dumbarton. He returns to Dublin with an immense fleet, and captives drawn from several peoples
of Britain, and in the year 873, he dies with a title associating his authority with the Norse
world of both Ireland and Britain. The further we move into later narrative sources, the richer
the story becomes, but also the less certain. Later Scandinavian tradition gives us Eyvar
the Boneless, the son of the legendary Ragnar Lothbrok, one of the most famous Viking figures
ever remembered. The temptation to join these traditions together is enormous, and perhaps they
should be joined. If Eymar and Eyvar the Boneless were indeed the same man, then the fragments
suddenly form an outline of an astonishing career, stretching from Dublin to York, East Anglia and
Strathclyde. But even without making that identification, the contemporary evidence
alone embellishes Eymar as one of the most powerful Scandinavian rulers of the 9th century.
There is another clue to the scale of his achievement, and it appears only after his
death. His name became a dynasty. Within a generation, the Irish Annals begin naming
rulers as sons and grandsons of Eymar. The Annals repeatedly identified them through the descent of
Eymar, because his name had become the defining mark of the dynasty. This was the beginning of
For generations after Eymar's death, his descendants would fight for Dublin, York,
and the kingdoms surrounding the Irish Sea. Some would rule in Ireland, others would become kings
in Northumbria, their fleets would appear in Scotland, England, and the islands between them.
That later history gives additional meaning to the title attached to Eymar in the year 873.
The analyst who called him King of the Norsemen of Ireland and Britain,
was not describing a man whose achievements disappeared after his death. Eymar had created,
or at least consolidated a dynasty capable of surviving him. His greatest legacy was therefore
not a single victory, not even the fall of Dumbarton. It was the creation of a political
house whose rulers would dominate the Viking world of the Irish Sea long after its founder
had disappeared. And this is where the question of Eyvar the Boneless becomes impossible to avoid,
because while Irish scribes were recording Eymar fighting from Munster to Strathclyde,
English writers were recording another Scandinavian leader, whose name was effectively
the same, whose career occupied the very years missing from Eymar's Irish record,
and whose army was tearing apart the kingdoms of Anglo-Saxon England. Whether those two histories
belonged to one man is one of the great unresolved questions of the Viking Age,
and to understand why so many historians have connected them, we have to follow the
For several years after the year 863, Eymar almost disappears from the Irish record.
The silence is striking because it comes precisely the moment when Scandinavian warfare in Britain
entered a completely new phase. Until this point, Viking attacks on the Anglo-Saxon kingdoms
had often followed the familiar pattern seen elsewhere in Western Europe. Fleets arrived,
settlements and monasteries were attacked, portable wealth was seized, and the raiders
eventually returned to their ships. But in the middle of the 860s, something much larger appeared
in the year 866. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle records the arrival of what it calls the Great
Heathen Army in East Anglia. Instead of immediately ravaging the kingdom,
the newcomers took winter quarters there and made peace with the East Anglians and obtained horses.
That simple detail is important. Mounted warriors could move far more rapidly through the interior
than men dependent entirely on ships, and the acquisition of horses transformed the army from
a coastal raiding force into something capable of campaigning across entire kingdoms. It is here
that the possible connection with Eymar becomes impossible to ignore. A 10th century Latin
chronicler named Æthelwyrd, working from material related to the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle,
associated the arrival of the Great Fleet with a Viking ruler whom he called Yngwær or Yngvar,
a name corresponding to the Scandinavian Ivar. A Norse ruler called Ivar operating in England
could therefore quite naturally appear as Eymar in an Irish text. That linguistic correspondence
does not by itself prove that these two men were identical, more than one Scandinavian could
obviously possess the same name. But when it is combined with the timing, the possibility becomes
much more interesting. Eymar is highly visible in Ireland during the late 850s and early 860s,
then his name fades from the Irish annals at approximately the same time that a Scandinavian
ruler bearing the corresponding name becomes associated with the great army in England.
Later, when the English Ivar disappears from the historical narrative, Eymar suddenly reappears in
the Irish sources, campaigning in Britain before returning to Dublin. The fit is not perfect and
there are some serious problems that must be considered, but it is close enough that historians
have repeatedly asked whether these apparently separate careers were actually fragments of the
life of one extraordinary man. The first great target of the army was Northumbria. In the year
867, the army moved north and entered York, one of the most important cities in Britain.
Northumbria was already divided by a civil conflict. King Osbert had been driven from the
throne and replaced by Ayla, whom the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle describes as having no hereditary claim
to the kingship. Faced with the Scandinavian occupation of York however, the two rivals
temporarily reconciled and gathered their forces against the common enemy. Their army attacked York
and appears initially to have broken into the city, but what followed was disastrous. The
Northumbrians suffered enormous losses and both Osbert and Ayla were killed. The survivors made
peace with the Viking army. In a single campaign, the invaders had exploited an existing political
fracture, destroyed two rival kings and occupied the principal city of the kingdom. York was not
merely another wealthy settlement to be plundered and abandoned, its Roman walls, strategic position
and connection to the North Sea made it an ideal centre from which Scandinavian power could be
exercised over Northern England. The importance of the victory becomes even clearer in the years
that followed, because Northumbria did not simply return to its previous political order,
Scandinavian rulers and Scandinavian backed kings would dominate much of the region and York itself
would eventually become one of the great Viking kingdoms of Britain. Later Scandinavian literature
transformed the fall of Northumbria into one of the most famous revenge stories of the Viking Age.
In the saga tradition, Ayla had captured and killed the legendary Ragnar Lothbrok by casting
him into a pit of snakes. Ragnar's sons then assembled an enormous army to avenge their father
and among them the most cunning was Ivar the Boneless. The sons defeated Ayla, captured him
and subjected him to a terrible execution, commonly connected in later literature with the so-called
Blood Eagle. It is a magnificent story, but it belongs to a very different category of evidence
from the 9th century chronicle. The contemporary English source notes that Osbert and Ayla were
killed fighting the Viking army at York, and it does not say that Ayla had previously killed Ragnar,
that the invasion was organised as a family revenge expedition, or that Ayla died beneath
a ritualised Blood Eagle. Those elements emerge from traditions preserved much later. This does
not automatically make every component fictional. Oral traditions could preserve genuine memories
for generations, and later Scandinavian writers may have inherited fragments of real dynastic
history. The following year, the army turned south into Mercia in the year 868. It occupied
Nottingham and established itself behind the town's defences. King Buchred of Mercia appealed
for assistance to Æthelred of Wessex and his younger brother Alfred, the future Alfred the
Great. The West Saxons marched north and joined the Mercians before Nottingham, but the campaign
produced no decisive battle. The Scandinavians remained protected behind their fortifications,
the Anglo-Saxon forces proved unable or unwilling to force them out, and the Mercians eventually
made peace. Asser, writing his Life of Alfred in the year 893, describes the same situation.
The army occupied Nottingham, the West Saxon brothers came to aid Buchred, and when the
heathens refused battle behind the fortress, and the attackers could not break the defences,
a settlement was reached. This episode reveals another important feature of the Great Army.
Its leaders did not need to win every encounter on the battlefield. They understood how to seize
fortified positions, negotiate from strength, and force local rulers to purchase peace when
neither side wanted to risk a costly assault. The objective was not necessarily the extermination of
every enemy army. Tribute, supplies, horses, political submission, and secure winter quarters
could all be victories. A commander who survived year after year in such warfare required more than
personal courage, he needed patience, logistical skill, and the ability to judge when the battle
was worthwhile, and when negotiation offered more. If Eymar was indeed one of the army's
principal leaders, then these campaigns help explain the political sophistication
visible later in his Irish career. In the year 869, the army returned to York
and remained there for another year, consolidating its position before launching its next major
campaign. Then in the year 870, the army rode across Mercia into East Anglia and established
its winter quarters at Bedford. King Edmund of East Anglia fought against them and was killed,
after which the Scandinavians took control of the kingdom and devastated the religious
communities they encountered. In its earliest form, the chronicle is frustratingly brief.
Edmund appears, fights, dies, and his kingdom falls. More than a century later, however,
Edmund's death had become the centre of a powerful saintly tradition. In around the year 985,
the Frankish scholar Abbo of Fleury composed the Passio Sancti Edmundi while in England.
According to the tradition, later transmitted by Elfric, Abbo claimed to have received the
story through Archbishop Dunstan, who in turn had heard it from an elderly man, said to have
been Edmund's own sword-bearer. In Abbo's narrative, the invading leaders are Eyvar and
Abba. Eyvar sends demands to Edmund, requiring him to submit, share his treasure, and rule
beneath Viking authority. Edmund refuses to abandon his faith or accept the humiliation
imposed upon him. He is captured, beaten, tied to a tree, and shot with arrows before finally being
beheaded. His severed head is later recovered miraculously, guarded by a wolf. This is the
version that transformed Edmund from a defeated 9th century king into one of medieval England's
greatest royal martyrs. Yet Abbo was writing more than a hundred years after the conquest of East
Anglia. There is another intriguing clue in the English tradition. In the account of the fighting
in Devon in the year 878, years after Eyvar's death in the Irish Annals, the Anglo-Saxon
chronicle describes a Scandinavian commander as the brother of Eyvar and Halfdan. The important
point is not the identity of the commander himself, which has generated its own debates,
but the way Eyvar's name functions. He was clearly remembered as a figure important enough
that other Viking leaders could be identified by a relationship to him. The English tradition
therefore knew Eyvar not merely as an anonymous warrior, but as a member of a prominent ruling
family associated with the leaders of the great army. This fits broadly with what the Irish
materials tells us about Eymar, that he too belonged to a royal dynasty, was associated with
Olaf, and eventually became the ancestor through whom later rulers defined themselves. In Ireland,
they became the Uyghur Mare, the descendants of Eymar. In the English and Scandinavian traditions,
Eyvar likewise appears surrounded by an elite family of Viking commanders.
The details of the genealogies are different, and sometimes contradictory, but both traditions
preserve the image of a ruler whose importance was dynastic as well as personal. For the purpose
of Eymar's story, perhaps the most revealing fact is that we do not actually need the legendary
identification to recognise the scale of the man. Strip away Ragnar, the Snake Pit, the Blood Eagle,
the mysterious nickname, and the historical Eymar remains extraordinary. The Irish record
already shows a ruler commanding armies throughout Ireland, working with powerful Irish kings,
sharing kingship with Olaf, crossing the sea to Britain, destroying one of the strongest
fortresses of Strathclyde, and eventually being remembered as a king of the Norsemen of Ireland
and Britain. If he was also the Eyvar who helped break Northumbria and conquer East Anglia,
then his career becomes one of the most remarkable of the entire Viking Age. If he was not,
then the two exceptionally powerful Scandinavian rulers with corresponding names
were operating in the same interconnected Irish sea and British world at exactly the same time.
But the story did not end in York or East Anglia. By the year 870, the Irish annals place Eymar once
again beside Olaf, far to the northwest, before the great fortress of Dumbarton Rock.
Another mystery eludes historians. Where exactly was Loughlin, the kingdom from which Olaf and
Eymar were said to have come? Older historians often identified Loughlin simply with Norway,
and later medieval Irish writers certainly used the term in that way. But for the 9th century,
the picture is much less straightforward. Some historians argue that the earliest Irish
references to Loughlin did not describe Norway itself, but rather the Scandinavian kingdoms
established in northern and western Scotland, including the Hebrides, the Northern Isles,
and parts of the Scottish mainland. This matters because the fragmentary annals say that Olaf
eventually left Ireland and went to Loughlin to help his father Goffred, who was being attacked
by other Norsemen. Could this Goffred actually have been Ragnar Lothbrok? There is no strong
contemporary evidence for that identification. The Irish material names Eymar's father as Goffred,
while the much later Scandinavian saga tradition makes Ivar the Boneless a son of Ragnar.
The names are not equivalent, and no early source bridges the gap by saying that Goffred was another
name for Ragnar. The safer conclusion is that Eymar and Olaf probably belonged to a Scandinavian
ruling dynasty connected with the western Viking world, whose power base may initially have lain
in Scotland and the islands rather than in Norway. The later saga tradition that turned Ivar into a
son of Ragnar Lothbrok may preserve some distant memory of an important royal ancestry, but it
cannot be securely reconciled with the Goffred genealogy preserved in Irish sources. Another
major source for the later legend of Ivar is the Gesta Danorum, or the Deeds of the Danes,
written by Saxo Grammaticus in the late twelfth and early thirteenth centuries.
Saxo was attempting to construct a grand history of Denmark from its legendary beginnings down to
his own age, combining earlier written material, oral tradition, heroic poetry and stories that
had already been reshaped by generations of retelling. His account of Ragnar Lothbrok and
his sons therefore cannot be treated as straightforward as ninth century history,
yet some of the details surrounding Ivar are intriguing because they occasionally seem to
from much earlier Irish and English sources. Saxo calls him Ivar and places him among the
sons of Ragnar. Unlike later Icelandic saga tradition however, Saxo does not call him
the Boneless and his family tree is noticeably different. Ragnar's wives and sons are rearranged,
some familiar figures appear with altered relationships, and others appear nowhere else.
This alone shows that Saxo was not preserving a single fixed biography, he was drawing together
several traditions into one dynastic narrative. Even so, the Ivar he describes has a very
distinctive character. He is presented as intelligent, restrained, and politically
trustworthy, rather than simply as the most savage warrior in the family. At one point,
when his brother Abba becomes involved in a rebellion against Ragnar, Ivar avoids the
conflict and voluntarily withdraws rather than turning against his father. Ragnar rewards this
loyalty and later entrusts Ivar with authority over his kingdom while he is away. Saxo therefore
remembers Ivar not merely as a fighter, but as someone capable of governing territory and
exercising royal responsibility. That is one of the first places where the legendary figure begins
to resemble the historical Aemar. The Irish annals do not describe Aemar's personality,
but they do show that he was much more than a raiding captain. Saxo also associates Ragnar
and his sons heavily with the Western Viking world. Ragnar campaigns in Britain, Scotland,
the Pictish territories, the islands and Ireland and Saxo even places Ivar and the other sons in
Ireland when news reaches them of Ragnar's death. This is particularly intriguing because Ireland is
precisely where the historical Aemar is securely attested. Saxo then gives Ivar one of the most
famous episodes associated with him. Rather than immediately attempting to conquer everything by
force, Ivar supposedly approaches Aela with apparent humility and asks for only as much
lands that can be covered by a horse hide, when the request is granted. Ivar cuts the hide into
extremely thin strips and uses them to enclose a much larger area than Aela expected. The story is
a variation of an ancient folktale, but what matters is Ivar's characterisation. Saxo presents
him as a conqueror who wins through cunning, negotiation and legal trickery before resorting
to open force. Again, that legendary personality is at least compatible with the historical Aemar.
The Irish annals show Aemar repeatedly operating through alliances rather than simple destruction.
He fought beside Irish kings, joined coalitions involving rival Irish dynasties, shared kingship
with his brothers and participated in warfare that depended upon understanding complicated
local politics. The historical evidence never tells us whether he personally used deception
or elaborate political tricks, but it does reveal a ruler capable of surviving in a world where
diplomacy, tribute, alliance and warfare were inseparable. Saxo's cunning Ivar could therefore
preserve some distant memory of a ruler famous for not merely strength, but for political
intelligence. After Agnar's death, Saxo's Ivar becomes deeply involved in England. The later story
gives him authority there for roughly two years, before he returns to Denmark, leaving his brother
Agnar to oversee affairs in Britain. Saxo's claim that Ivar ruled England should not be taken
literally, England was not yet a unified kingdom and no Viking ruler controlled the entire island,
but beneath the exaggeration may lie a genuine memory of a Scandinavian ruler named Ivar,
exercising significant authority in Britain before moving elsewhere. That possibility fits
strikingly well with Ivar's death title, which remembers him as the King of Norsemen of Ireland
and all Britannia. Saxo's Ivar is likewise remembered as a ruler whose authority stretched
beyond Denmark and into Britain. His connection with Ireland is also significant. The historical
Ivar is securely recorded campaigning in Britain with Olaf in the year 870, and the following year
they returned to Dublin with a huge fleet and captives. Saxo places Ivar and his family across
the same regions, Ireland, Scotland, the Pictish territories and England. Rather than preserving
exact history, Saxo may have inherited traditions in which the deeds of several 9th century Viking
rulers had been absorbed into the legendary family of Ragnar Lothbrok. That would explain
many of the contradictions. Historical figures could become brothers, victories could be reassigned,
political influence could become kingship over entire countries, and real wars could be transformed
into revenge stories. Ivar's greatest legacy was the dynasty that survived him. His descendants
became known as the Ullamere, meaning the descendants of Ivar, and for generations they
dominated Viking politics around the Irish Sea. Members of the dynasty ruled Dublin and York,
held power in Northumbria, and extended their influence across parts of Scotland,
the Hebrides, and the Isle of Man. Their fleets repeatedly crossed between Ireland and Britain.
The dynasty's strength came from its ability to operate across several kingdoms at once.
A ruler driven from Dublin might still find support in Britain, while control of York or
Northumbria could strengthen claims elsewhere. The mobility made the Ullamere extraordinarily
resilient, and allowed them to recover from defeats that might have destroyed a more local ruling
house. Their influence also touched regions farther south and east, including areas connected to the
Viking territories of East Anglia, although the strongest and clearest centres of the Ullamere
remained in Dublin and York. For more than a century after Ivar's death, his name remained
a source of legitimacy. Most Viking leaders vanished with their war bands, Ivar left behind
a dynasty. There is one final tradition surrounding Ivar that captures how enormous his reputation
became after his death. In later Scandinavian saga literature, Ivar the Boneless was said to
have ordered that he be buried in a place where enemies invading England would be forced to pass.
As long as his body remained there, the story claimed, anyone who attacked the country would
meet disaster. The tale belongs to the world of legend rather than contemporary history,
but its meaning is interesting. Ivar was no longer remembered simply as a conqueror,
even his grave had become a supernatural guardian of the land he had once helped invade.
The saga then carries the story for almost two centuries, to William the Conqueror. According
to one tale, when William came to England, he sought out Ivar's burial mound, broke it open,
and discovered the body inside had not decayed. William ordered the corpse be burned on a great
pyre, destroying the protection supposedly created by Ivar's burial. Only after this,
the story says, was William able to proceed with his invasion and conquer England.
There is no evidence that William ever opened the grave of Ivar the Boneless,
and the episode appears in Scandinavian literature written centuries after 1066,
but as a legend, it says something remarkable about the memory of Ivar. Later generations
imagined that even William the Conqueror could not take England until the power of a dead Viking king
had first been broken. Irish analysts remembered him as the King of the Norsemen of Ireland and
Britain. Scandinavian storytellers eventually imagined that his corpse possessed the power
to stop conquerors. The analysts gave Ivar only a handful of lines, history gave his dynasty more
than a century, and the great heathen magic of his burial mound struck fear into even the greatest
of conquerors.