MONTICELLO- A 32-year-old Neversink man has been convicted of second-degree assault following a violent attack on a 75-year-old woman in September 2025, Sullivan County District Attorney Brian Conaty announced Friday.
Steven Schmitz was found guilty following a bench trial before Sullivan County Supreme Court Judge Stephen Schick.
According to prosecutors, the assault occurred around 1 p.m. on September 3, 2025, on Jan Drive in the Town of Neversink. Schmitz allegedly ran out of his mobile home and attacked the elderly woman, punching her in the face and chest and knocking her to the ground. While she was down, he continued the assault, kicking her multiple times in the torso and legs. The woman’s partner intervened and helped stop the attack.
The victim sought medical attention the following morning. Photographs documented bruising to her chest, back and left leg, along with a shoulder injury. Prosecutors said she continues to experience physical limitations and is unable to perform some everyday activities she could manage before the assault.
In announcing the conviction, Conaty highlighted the victim’s personal history and contributions to the community, describing her as a devoted mother and grandmother, a cancer survivor and a woman who emigrated from Ireland alone before raising three children as a single mother and building a successful business.
He also praised her commitment to helping others, including children with disabilities and those in underserved communities.
Conaty condemned the attack and said his office would seek the harshest penalty allowed under the law, emphasizing the importance of respecting and protecting older members of the community.
Schmitz is scheduled to be sentenced on February 11, 2027, and faces a maximum sentence of seven years in state prison, followed by five years of post-release supervision.



Comments