TOWN OF CHESTER – Allegations that Chester Comptroller Neil Meyer has been shredding paperwork and entering the town’s confidential file room while under investigation raise serious concerns about the integrity of the probe, according to a former FBI agent.
Mid-Hudson News reported earlier this week that an employee brought concerns to Supervisor Brandon Holdridge and the Town Board, alleging that Meyer had spent considerable time discarding paperwork and repeatedly entering the town’s confidential file room. Holdridge declined to comment on the allegations this week and Meyer did not return a message seeking comment.
“In his defense, we don’t know what he allegedly shredded,” said David Shapiro, MPA, director of the Inspection and Oversight Program at John Jay College of Criminal Justice in New York City. “However, the timing is inappropriate, suggesting the destruction of evidence related to the accusations of potential unlawful activities surrounding him.”
Shapiro, a frequent contributor to Mid-Hudson News, said the reported activity would be a concern for anyone conducting an independent public corruption investigation. Meyer was placed on paid administrative leave this week, pending the conclusion of the probe.
Shapiro also questioned why additional safeguards had not been implemented more quickly, including restricting Meyer’s access to sensitive areas and securing a Chester-issued laptop that he allegedly retained for approximately a week after the investigation began.
“The precautions normally required to protect and further an independent investigation seem to have been imposed without adequate promptness,” Shapiro said. “As is said: justice delayed may be justice denied.”
Chester Councilman Giuseppe Cassara again this week called for the Orange County District Attorney’s Office to investigate Meyer. Shapiro said the New York State Comptroller’s Office would likely be the more appropriate agency to handle the matter.
Chester’s investigation followed scrutiny of Meyer’s role in the Town of Wallkill. Republican officials have questioned why he allegedly had access to Town Hall and municipal computer systems despite not being a town employee.



Comments