(Picture: Pexel)

(Continue P.1)

How The New York Times misleads its readers on communist China, including the regime’s persecution of Falun Gong.

Engagement Doctrine

The United States was slow to respond to the CCP’s escalating aggression, and The New York Times proved less than helpful.

“They know that they have to be intellectually honest at some level, but what they cannot do is ever connect the dots to talk about strategic trendlines,” James Fanell, a former naval intelligence officer and China expert who co-authored with Thayer the recent book “Embracing Communist China: America’s Greatest Strategic Failure,” told The Epoch Times.

The CCP intentionally kept its ultimate goals vague, presenting it as a “peaceful rise” of a “responsible” power. But the trajectory of the development wasn’t difficult to chart, the authors said.

Rather than a quest for emancipation, the Party’s goal of surpassing the United States economically and militarily reflects a pursuit of domination, they said.

The CCP’s talk about a “peaceful rise” and a “multipolar” world, where the United States, China, and other nations would share responsibility for maintaining order, amounts to little more than “smoke and chaff,” Fanell said.

“They know there’s only going to be one top dog,” he said. “They want to be the top power in the world. They’ve said that in many, many ways.”

Upstaging the United States as the leading world power would give the CCP the ability to dictate political and trade rules globally, the authors said. Pax Americana, for all its faults, has allowed for a measure of universal values, press freedom, religious freedom, and economic freedom. Pax Sinica under the CCP promises no such generosity, they warned.

“We know what it’s going to look like,” Fanell said. “We see it every day in China. Total control. Social credit system. State control of every facet of your life. That’s what it is.”

There’s no disabusing the CCP of its hegemonic ambitions, Thayer said.

“Xi Jinping could die tomorrow. He could die this afternoon, and the individual who replaces him is not going to go back to the happy time,” he said.

“The individual who replaces him is going to maintain the same policies, the same aggression, because the individual, at the end of the day, is far less important than the ideology of communism and the fact that their power has grown. And that ideology wedded to power explains their increasingly aggressive behavior internationally.”

Especially since the COVID-19 pandemic, there has been significant bipartisan agreement in the United States that the CCP’s ambitions need to be met head on—a strategy Thayer and Fanell endorsed.

The New York Times, however, has discouraged treating the CCP as an enemy. Instead, it has argued for continued engagement.

Last year, its editorial board penned an op-ed titled “Who Benefits From Confrontation With China?” It stated that “Americans’ interests are best served by emphasizing competition with China while minimizing confrontation” and that “glib invocations of the Cold War are misguided.”

The engagement policy, which hollowed America’s manufacturing base and helped to turn China into a daunting military adversary, “has yielded less than its proponents hoped and prophesied,” the board wrote. It argued, however, that a relationship with China “continues to deliver substantial economic benefits to the residents of both countries and to the rest of the world.”

Thayer called such a framing “appalling.”

He said the engagement doctrine has allowed the regime to pull through moments of crisis and has blocked efforts to bring about its collapse.

“What the engagers did was prevent us from getting rid of this odious regime,” he said.

The New York Times published a section called “China Rules” in its Nov. 25, 2018, edition. The section included giant Chinese characters on a red background and a glowing report on the Chinese Communist Party, while simultaneously criticizing the United States. Samira Bouaou/The Epoch Times

Interests and Nostalgia

The New York Times’ adherence to the engagement doctrine might trace back to several sources.

Thayer blamed the paper for “ideological obtuseness where they refuse to see the nature of communist regimes as they are.”

“They have no trouble at all when it comes to condemning odious regimes. It’s only communist odious regimes where they have an ideological blindness,” he said.

Fannell pointed out that The New York Times has a vested interest in avoiding confrontation with China because it wants to maintain access to its market.

“I think it’s that obvious,” he said.

After prolonged devotion to the engagement doctrine, it’s also difficult for its proponents to admit they were wrong, he said.

“They just seem to be so obsessed with looking for anything to support their thesis.”

There’s also a sense of longing among some for China under Jiang’s rule—a time when The New York Times was allowed to do business in China and even criticize the regime to some degree, as long as it aped the Party line, particularly on Falun Gong.

“The nostalgia was poignant” last year at the Council on Foreign Relations lunch meeting on China in New York, commented Farah Stockman, of the New York Times Editorial Board, in an op-ed titled “Farewell to the U.S.–China Golden Age.”

“We were privileged to live in China during a remarkably free and open period of time, to learn the language, make friends, find spouses, and some for a while could even own property,” said Ian Johnson, who won a Pulitzer in 2001 for an incisive series on the Falun Gong persecution for The Wall Street Journal.

Stockman tacitly admitted the supposed “brain trust for the country’s foreign policy establishment” was blindsided by developments in China, which “was turning into something they hadn’t expected” and caused them to lose “visibility, access and insight.”

But the supposed golden age of China’s openness was always an illusion, multiple experts said.

Jiang’s apparent invitation to capitalists, lauded on the pages of The New York Times, turned out to be a sleight of hand, according to Desmond Shum, a former Chinese tycoon.

“I concluded that the Party’s honeymoon with entrepreneurs ... was a little more than a Leninist tactic, born in the Bolshevik Revolution, to divide the enemy in order to annihilate it,” he wrote in his memoir “Red Roulette.”

“Alliances with businessmen were temporary as part of the Party’s goal of total societal control. Once we were no longer needed ... we, too, would become the enemy.”

According to Fanell, the “golden age” rhetoric traces back to the CCP’s own propaganda, which lacked “a sense of reality.” The regime’s atrocities have never let up, and neither has its direction changed.

“It’s not a surprise that the aperture was very wide and that the regime, the CCP, invited in and rewarded amply individuals who were interacting, because the regime wanted, if you will, to profit from them, to use them, to use their skills, to use their abilities, to use their connections so that a positive image of the [People’s Republic of China] was projected and ... knowledge transfer could occur,” Thayer said.

“It’s not at all a surprise that as they were needed less, the openness or the aperture closed. The friendliness, the reciprocity, the bonhomie relationship which they might have had is reduced.”

Doubling Down

Instead of confronting reality, it appears The New York Times has been trying to recreate the illusion of “warm relations” it previously benefited from.

Upon Jiang’s death in 2022, the paper delivered a eulogy describing him as a “garrulous” and “disarming” politician who “presided over a decade of meteoric economic growth.”

In an unusual move, the paper’s executive editor, Kahn, personally contributed to the article—the only time he had done so since taking the top job at the paper earlier that year.

The nearly 3,000-word obituary represented an exercise in “willful ignorance,” whitewashing the communist dictator’s legacy of gore and deception, according to Thayer.

The article left out key aspects of Jiang’s story that “would allow him to be seen as the thug that he was,” he said.

Upon Jiang's death in 2022, New York Times executive editor Joseph Kahn personally contributed to a syrupy obituary. Screenshot via The Epoch Times, New York Times, Minghui

Jiang’s responsibility for the persecution of Falun Gong was euphemized in the piece as mere “intolerance of dissent” and palmed off with a single sentence:

“After members of the Falun Gong spiritual sect surrounded the Communist Party headquarters in protest in April 1999, he pressed for mass detentions, which set the pattern for later rounds of repression and for an increasingly powerful security state.”

The dusting off of the “sect” label was significant, in the FDIC’s view. More than two decades ago, it implored the paper to drop it, not just because of the term’s pejorative implications, but also for technical inaccuracy. Falun Gong didn’t come up as an offshoot of another religion, but instead traced its origins to a practice transmitted along a private lineage, a similar trajectory to many practices that were popularized starting in the 1970s under the “qigong” moniker.

In addition, the paper’s description of the 1999 protest at the top CCP leadership compound was inaccurate. If it had inquired with participants in the protest, it would have learned that they were seeking the government appeals office, and it was the police that led the crowd to the streets surrounding Zhongnanhai.

Yet somehow, this was par for the course at The New York Times, which has, since 2019, openly targeted the Falun Gong diaspora in the United States with a series of hit pieces that unearthed some of the worst excesses of its prior reporting, according to FDIC.

“Terms like ‘secretive’ or ‘dangerous’ repeat multiple times. ... Falun Gong beliefs are described as ‘extreme,’” the FDIC report reads.

CCP’s persecution of Falun Gong is usually glossed over in the articles as mere “accusations” or “claims tinged with hysteria,” it said.

The millions thrown in prisons and labor camps in China over the past quarter of a century suddenly became “tens of thousands ... in the early years of the crackdown.”

Mirroring CCP propaganda, the articles equated businesses started by Falun Gong followers, such as The Epoch Times, with Falun Gong itself, even after Epoch Times representatives explained that the company cannot and does not represent the practice.

The distinction would have been easy to grasp for The New York Times. The Sulzberger family that leads it is Jewish, but that doesn’t mean the paper speaks for the religion of Judaism.

Despite all the paper’s efforts aligned with CCP interests, however, the CCP has shown little appreciation for The New York Times.

In February 2020, The Wall Street Journal ran an op-ed by Walter Russell Mead headlined “China Is the Real Sick Man of Asia.” It panned China for mishandling the COVID-19 epidemic and questioned Beijing’s power and stability.

The CCP protested the headline as “racist” and responded by kicking out three of the paper’s China correspondents.

The next month, the Trump administration capped U.S.-based personnel for Chinese state media, de facto expelling 60.

The CCP then expelled most of the correspondents of The Wall Street Journal, The Washington Post, and The New York Times.

In late 2021, the Biden administration relaxed restrictions on Chinese media in the United States in exchange for the CCP giving The New York Times and others their visas back. But the CCP has been slow to do so. The paper seemed to have only two correspondents in China as of May 3.

There are indications, however, that The New York Times is doubling down. On Aug. 16, it ran a hit piece on Shen Yun Performing Arts, a massively popular classical Chinese dance company started by Falun Gong practitioners in the United States.

Shen Yun has been a prime target of the CCP, facing various forms of interference and sabotage. Its performances, under the tag line “China before communism,” seek to portray authentic Chinese culture. Some of its dance pieces also depict the persecution of Falun Gong.

It’s not clear whether the push against Shen Yun will win the paper more favorable treatment by the CCP.

“This is the nature of a communist regime. As they’ve grown in power, they’re going to start becoming a lot colder, they’re going to become a lot more repressive and treat foreigners, even individuals who used to be old friends of China, in a very different way,” Thayer said.

Facing economic headwinds caused by mistreatment of foreign businesses as well as the devastating impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, Xi’s regime is once again trying to court foreign investment.

But The New York Times is already a willing partner in that effort, giving Xi little incentive to allow the paper a longer leash, Fanell and Thayer agreed.

“Xi Jinping doesn’t give a rat about The New York Times. He knows where they’re coming from,” Fanell said.

“He doesn’t even have to pay them off.”

(End)

By Petr Svab

August 16, 2024 Updated: September 01, 2024

https://www.theepochtimes.com/us/behind-the-new-york-times-china-coverage-decades-of-distortion-5653964?ea_src=author_manual&ea_med=related_stories