What is it true kindness

In Athens of 5 th BC, poet Sophocles  wrote the tragedy “Antigone”. The 5 th BC was a transitional time for the city of Athens. Athenians of 5th BC had a growing sovereignty over other Greek cities and this sovereignty  brought prosperity and a new governance called “democracy”. But this new era also brought complacency in Athenian’s hearts. Satisfied with their economic and political achievement, Athenians turned a blind eye to the divine and believed that they are equal to Gods and that they have the right to act like Gods. Sophocles foresaw this tendency of Athenians disbelieving the divine and wrote the tragedy “Antigone”. 

The story of Antigone

In Antigone, the heroine called Antigone is a princess of Thebes. Her two brothers promised to rule Thebes in turns. When the first brother did not give his turn to the youngest, the last proclaimed a war against his brother and both brothers were killed during the war. Their uncle Creon became king of Thebes and gave an order no man in Thebes to bury the body of the brother who proclaimed war against Thebes. Antigone buried her brother even though she knew that she would be discovered  and punished. Creon indeed as a punishment buried Antigone alive in an underground tube.

Antigone claims that she will bury her brother because the custom of the burial of dead was passed down to Greeks by their Gods. Antigone states that no man is allowed to violate the divine custom and go against the divine’s will she is not responsible to her King but to Gods and if her King violates the divine laws, then she will continue to follow divine laws.

“Though you are mortal you violate the laws of the gods, unwritten and unshaken; for not today and yesterday, but eternally these laws exist, and no one knows since when they appeared: and I could never be frighten at anyone's will and not meet  god’s justice, transgressing Gods;

She even states that she will do that perfectly aware that she may lose her life for doing so.

So for me the pain of this death is nothing , but if it were and I tolerated my brother  to remain unburied, that would be pain to me;

Amon who is the son of Kreon and he is about to marry Antigone tries to persuade Kreon not to kill Antigone. Amon express the idea that citizens in Thebes they all believe Antigone is doing the right thing.

But I can secretly hear how much this daughter is mourned in the city, who, although less than all women deserved it, so dishonorably dies for such a brilliant and honest deed: for her brother, who lay slain in battle unburied in this way;

εικόνα.png

Antigone and Polynices by Lytras Nikephoros, 1865 via National Gallery, Athens

Creon is not convinced. He insists on his decision. Then Tiresias, who was believed to have the gift of precognition foretells calamity for Creon for his bad deed. According to ancient Greeks, Tiresias was believed to be the representative of Gods on earth. Creon disprepects Tiresias and thinks that Tiresias is trying to persuade him to bury the brother of Antigone because he is  paid to do so:

 “I don’t believe you. For all the farce of fortune tellers ( meaning Teiresias is a fortune teller )  are  money-hunger”

Tiresias answers to Creon:

“Learn, therefore, that you shall not see many of the sun's swift ways yet…for you have  lawlessly shut up a living soul in a tomb; and another dead man away from the gods of the underworld you keep, without burial and without the lawful honours, while you have no right, neither you nor the gods in Heaven, but by force you have forced the Gods of the Underworld..  For all this, the vengeful sternophages of Hades and the gods, the Furies, have set you up in a pen, so that you may fall into the calamities yourself”;

Calamity indeed stroke in Creon’s house. Amon his son commits suicide for Antigone, Creon’s wife commits suicide for her son Amon and Antigone is already dead in the tube.

εικόνα.png

Being stubborn and  believing your way is the only way you commit the sin of arrogance according to ancient greek thought so it is a matter of time Gods will give the retribution you deserve . For ancient Greeks, the goal of the Gods for sending calamity to people is to punish their arrogance and to restore modesty and trust to the divine again. Ancient Greeks believed that Gods bring calamity to people to remind them that however great they think they are, they are not Gods, and they should pay true homage to Gods for Gods are always in control of the fate of mortals.

Contemporary Antigone

During Covid pandemic, Elena’s father died from a car accident. At the same time, Elena, her mother and her 2 years old daughter caught a Covid.

εικόνα.png

Elena called her aunt to announce her father’s death. Aunt Silia said that she knows Elena has Covid, so aunt Silia suggested that Elena should’t attend her father’s funeral. She even threatened her that she will call the prosecutor to arrest her for not following the orders of the state. According to state orders, a person with Covid symptoms should stay 8 days at home and should not come to contact with anyone.

Elena became furious and said that attending her father’s funereal is a responsibility to her dead father . Attending a dead man’s funeral is a traditional custom appointed by  ancestors. If aunt Silia dares she can go ahead and call the prosecutor. “You can call the prosecutor, the police, whoever. I will attend my father’s funeral”.

Seeing her determined, aunt Silia did not dare to oppose Elena.

At her father’s funeral Elena was late. She paused for a moment before entering the church. She asked herself if she is not considerate to others by having Covid and still wanting to attend her father’s funeral. Her desire to accompany her father to his last day on this earth she thought it was stronger than her concerns  and she entered the church anyway. She did not dare to go close to her brother and sister as she knew that they were very afraid of the Covid. But her sister Alia stood up. And asked her to sit next to her to watch the ceremony.

What are the similarities to ancient and modern world?

Creon caused many disasters to himself because he could not accept the fact that Antigone was right in her own way. He showed no room for tolerance or acceptance to Antigone’s angle of seeing things.  Antigone wished to respect traditional customs and she barely held any egoistical motive for burying her brother. She wanted to do the right thing that is to pay homage to the gods. And therefore pay homage to her brother as indicated by the Gods.

Elena likewise did not wish to attend her father’s funeral out of sentimentality. She wanted to honor her father and pay homage to what is the traditional way of honoring the dead. Both women’s decision came as a trust in the divine.

Antigone and Elena were merely protesters against the political order. They did not wish to deny the laws of their country. They only wished to preserve the traditional custom of honoring the dead. For them, the rituals of the dead was not a formality they could casually dismiss.  Because they truly believed in the divine, they would never accept not following these rituals.

Creon could not compromise, even though his son and the priest and common opinion urged him to do so.  Aunt Silia on the other hand compromised, so further complication of the situation was averted.

In Antigone, Antigone’s sister Ismene is afraid to bury her brother and when Antigone asks her to go together to bury him, Ismene  refused. But when her sister Antigone does get arrested, Ismene stepped forward and asks Creon to accompany her sister to death. Even though Ismene at first she seems to be afraid for her life, that she will be punished if she gets caught,  at the critical time of her sister being arrested she is willing to give her life for her sister.  Alia likewise she feared for her life, that she will catch the covid pandemic, still this fear did not hold her back when her sister entered the church. She went ahead to comfort her and she sat next to her for both of them to attend the funeral.

Epilogue

Although some people do not have a very strong believe in customs like burying the dead and attending funeral procedures (Ismene, Alia), still they are good people because they are willing to sacrifice their own concerns fears and personal gain to be supportive to another human being. Antigone and Alia though they appeared stubborn and unyielding in their decision to go against political orders, they did that because they paid homage to Gods and this is an act of a kind heart respecting the divine. Amon, public opinion, Aunt Silia although they believe that political orders should be respected, they understand another being’s way of thinking and are willing to compromise two different views (political and divine laws)  so that peace within society be restored. And give room and space for different opinions. Creon, as Plato states for all human beings he is not evil, he is just ignorant. He doesn’t see that believing his law are the only way, he hurts another human being (Antigone), he violates divine laws (burial of dead) and he pushes his son and his wife commit suicide because of his strict policy. To be a good person and to do good deeds, you have to put yourself in someone else’s shoes. You have to accept different thinking and different needs than your own egoistical point of view. Being kind is being receptive to another human being.

εικόνα.png

These people who care about others without any egoistical motive, are truly kind persons and will do selfless good deeds in trouble times (burying the dead, conforting sister at her sorrow, accepting other people's views).