Speed running getting banned on Xiaohongshu

China Insider with David Zhang
2.3K followers
232 Video Views·Jan 16, 2025
⭐️ Support me and my work ⭐️
https://Davidzhang.net
Donate to support me: https://donorbox.org/china-insider-with-david-zhang
My social media:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/chinainsiderwithdavidzhang/
X or Twitter: https://twitter.com/DavidZhang360
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/people/China-insider-with-David-Zhang/100088454928778/
==========================
My sponsors:
🫐 Blueberry Creative 🫐
👉 Use this link for 15% off on all products code "David"
https://lanmeiyoupin.shop/en
⭐️ Free shipping over 70 USD (US Only)
==========================
Subscribe for the latest:
- Daily News and Analysis on China's political landscape.
- Exposing Communism in China
- Expertise in the geopolitics of US-China
Here is me speedrunning to get banned on rednote or xiaohongshu, the ccp tiktok refugee app,
and after 13 hours, I finished the challenge.
I wasn't alone though, other notable mentions include Mao Lebron, and we of course got the
tank.
And here is how it was done.
It's called rednote or xiaohongshu, which means the little red handbook in Chinese.
This app where everybody apparently from tiktok is fleeing to, calling themselves the tiktok
refugees.
And let me see, because you never know, this could open up a possibility of, cause right
now this app right, it doesn't have an American version, it's just a Chinese mainland version
that Americans are using.
So what that means is, right now is a crucial moment, the Chinese people on there and the
American people are able to connect with each other and discuss things.
Which gives me an idea, what if I post some of my short videos on there, and perhaps that
can help the Chinese people see what exactly is going on in China.
It could be a good chance for us to spread our CIA propaganda on there as well.
We're going to post three videos and we're going to see if, well, they work out.
So we're going to write China's tofu, write construction of China, we're going to do something
Chinese as well.
Is it not letting me type in Chinese?
Yeah, okay, so we got politics in Chinese, we got zhongguozhengzhi, which means Chinese
politics.
Let's see if that works.
Okay, we'll do four for now.
Same thing, we're going to do this time, we're going to do a more recent video.
So this one I just did two days ago, which is about a person that had gone missing in
Myanmar, in Burma.
So it's a pretty crazy story, but it's about Chinese passport failing again, so we're just
going to call that the title as well.
So you know, it's the same thing we're doing for what we did on YouTube, but, okay, so
this one we're going to do Chinese hashtag zhongguofuzhao, which means Chinese passport
in Chinese.
We're going to do the name of the person, which is Wang Xing, okay, so three of them,
and we're going to publish again.
As you can see, I got my little profile set up, I just put a random name on there.
I think here, okay.
So right now, what they're going through is, they're actually being, I don't know if you
can see in the blue part, so they're being, how would you describe it, they're being reviewed,
in a sense, I believe, either by machine or by a person to basically look into whether
or not this content is fit for publishing.
Okay, so because I read some reviews on the App Store, and it says that they got banned
for questioning somebody, some journalists who were arrested, so we'll see if this one
gets approved.
Perfect, so one of them has already been published, and the two other are still under review,
so we're just going to wait a little bit, and we'll be back once things are settled.
My initial thought was, since that they welcomed American users, or at least tried to pretend
like it was a welcome, why not try to see how long the censorship will take me to post
sensitive photos and videos before I'm banned?
Now the logic behind this is that the CCP is very afraid of outside information coming
into China, hence why they built a censorship firewall in the first place.
So naturally, an app that currently allows Americans to register is bound to face this
problem.
So, we saw screenshots like this already.
Why do you get both weekend days off, and no overtime?
Or how much does a construction worker in America make?
Unionized workers make 1200 a week, and that's converted to about 9000 yuan a week.
So that amount of money is insane for a Chinese person.
And so if you keep having these cultural exchanges happen between an American and a Chinese,
it's bound to be really bad for the Chinese government.
And then I realized that, I guess these are not critical enough for the CCP, I had to
jack up the intensity.
So I posted the photo of the tank man.
Surprisingly, it actually went through the censor apparatus.
I also did various searches for sensitive terms.
So of course, you'll see a bunch of these, which is just Uyghurs, like the pretty girls
and guys.
Obviously, you're not gonna see anything about the concentration camps.
So let's say I go to this one about Uyghur girls, right?
Let's post something like, the real Uyghurs are in concentration camps being silenced
and persecuted.
So I'm gonna send this.
Okay, pretty offensive to them, right?
Now what about another sensitive one, Falun Gong, let's see.
You cannot find anything here if you search Falun Gong.
What about in Chinese?
Of course, one video, and I don't know what this one is about.
So you know how there's a Chinese copypasta?
So there's like a list of things that if you write, you'll get banned immediately.
We're gonna see.
What about June 4th?
So if I search June 4th, you will actually see exactly nothing about June 4th, 1989,
of course.
What about Liu Si?
So if I search June 4th and Tiananmen, I get nothing.
So I'm just gonna comment this on some stuff.
Okay, so I'm just gonna go into random videos, and I'm just gonna comment, okay?
Let's see this one, I don't know who this is, but I'm just commenting June 4th, Tiananmen
Square in Chinese.
And then for this one, I'm gonna do an English, June 4th, 1989.
And let's say on a video about this beef noodle shop, I'm just gonna say Taiwan is not a part
of China.
Okay, Taiwan is not a part of China.
And Pedro Pascal is on here for some reason, let me say, Pedro, please don't bow to the
CCP.
Okay?
All right, so we're gonna end it here.
I will check back in a day or so to see what happens.
I then commented on various posts about things like Taiwan is not a part of China, CCP sucks,
free Taiwan, free Tibet, Tiananmen Square, the Uyghur concentration camps.
I did this in both English and Chinese, and it didn't work.
I was not banned.
Next, I tested Falun Gong photos, which is a very sensitive topic in China.
It's censored all across China.
Because since the persecution against Falun Gong in 1999, the group's existence has been
deemed the utmost importance to be scrubbed from Chinese internet, fearing, of course,
the Chinese people would find out the reasons about the persecution.
So I attempted three photos, and all three attempts failed.
The auto-review process, well, honestly, there's no surprise here, considering the CCP literally
cannot stand information about Falun Gong being told to the Chinese people.
And Red Note informed me that these are all illegal content.
Well, what's illegal about a parade and a bunch of banners?
Xiaohongshu is actually the most censored app in China with the heaviest amount of control.
In fact, the creation of this apparatus might have influenced other apps as well.
Here's a post about a green jade vase with a caption
that would be sensitive and it was banned off of Red Note.
I'll give you a few seconds to think about this.
So as it turns out, because the man mentioned that this is a thin bottled vase,
and in Chinese the homonym to Xi Jinping's name, Xi Jinping, was the same as Xi, which means
skinny, jing, which means bottleneck, and ping, which means the vase, that homonym got him banned.
This is the level of censorship on Red Note.
And so that's why when people say, oh, Xiaohongshu or Red Note
is a place, a sanctuary from political content.
No, sir or ma'am, it's not because of that.
It's because they literally censored all of those political content.
Now, with the influx of the English speakers, they're urgently hiring English censors to control,
of course, all of the incoming anti-CCP messages me and others have been putting out.
Now, at this point, I still wasn't banned yet.
So I had to post one more Tiananmen Square related photo.
And this one, of course, also features soldiers aiming their guns at students.
And still, I wasn't banned.
So I was getting anxious at this point.
I was kind of self-doubting.
Am I not worthy of the title of an anti-CCP rebel?
What if I'm not good enough?
And all these doubts made me want to go to the extreme.
I had to pull out my trump card.
And mission was success.
13 hours after registering my account,
I had successfully completed the challenge running to get banned on Red Note.
However, I now invite all other speedrunners and viewers alike
to try this challenge for yourself and try to refresh the record.
I know some people have already beaten mine.
They've been banned pretty fast.
What I've noticed is that the experience of speedrunning varies depending on the account
and actually depends on which spy or censor person is working on the clock.
Christine Liu, for example, on X posted first an artist take on the tank photo.
She was fine.
And then she posted another photo which contained the Tibetan flag.
She says here is her favorite bag.
And then her third photo, the movie Top Gun Mavericks jacket, which had a Taiwan flag on it.
And she wasn't initially banned because of that.
But later she received a permaban after her third post.
Another account from Canada is also banned after posting just a few pictures about Winnie the Pooh.
What I've also noticed is that to get suspended from which is temporary,
you just need to post comments that are sensitive, right?
But if you want to get banned, you actually need to post content,
images or videos that are really, really politically sensitive.
Now, this isn't to say that the whole experience is like this.
Some people have already posted on Reddit and other sites about how they just got banned for
essentially posting nonpolitical things or seemingly nonpolitically sensitive content.
So much for this migration, right?
People already find out that, well, the censorship is real here.
So here's my criticism of this whole TikTok migration refugee thing.
In this video, the woman complains about the U.S. censoring their freedom of speech.
Everyone on this app has been so, so kind,
unlike our government who wants to take away our freedom of speech.
So I will gladly stay here.
So the irony is that a comment in her post says,
quote, friendly reminder on Chinese social media platforms,
please do not mention sensitive topics like politics, religion and drugs.
Please adhere to the one China policy and reject pornography, gambling and drugs.
It's OK, because sooner or later,
these people would realize that they cannot even post about anything like the LGBTQ movement,
elections, women's rights without getting a review and possibly denied from even posting.
And more likely the case is what these people who went to Red Note seeking a place
away from politics will soon find themselves actually banned because of things they commented
or they did, which, of course, they think had nothing to do with politics.
So they migrated to an actual platform run by the CCP that censors their free speech,
harvest their data and probably will recognize all of that in their public opinion warfare.
Because, of course, the CCP controls everything.
This is not their American version of the app.
This is the actual app that's used in China.
Why?
Because that's how the CCP works.
Their standard of censorship is on the next level.
You might think what you said wasn't political.
That's your thinking.
Not theirs.
So good luck living the experience of actual censorship.
Maybe afterwards you will find it that it was enjoyable for a day or two
to get back at the US government.
But afterwards, hey, the CCP actually censors things because, you know,
they are a dictatorship, a totalitarian government.
And of course, they won't let this last long either.
Clubhouse, remember, there was another social media app once that allowed Chinese users to
interact with a room full of other Chinese people, with Uyghurs, Tibetans,
people who, you know, lived outside of China, Hong Kongers.
And then the second day it was banned in China because they are afraid that information is
going to get exchanged and that people in China are going to listen to those outside of China
and actually destabilize the government, just like Chinese EVs, phones and everything else.
It might look cool for a short period of time, but after prolonged use,
you'll find that they have nothing in the core values or in the core system that makes them good.
But in fact, they're just these short term hypes.
And with the combination of censorship, the denial of freedom,
you're going to eventually find that it's not all rainbows and sunshines.
So what's really the outcome?
Well, I personally think that the CCP will likely ban US users from the Chinese app
or that they're going to make a new version, which is like TikTok to Douyin
that will be launched in US app stores, which, of course, will be banned just like TikTok did
because, you know, the bill actually says any of the foreign adversary controlled apps.
So there's no way that they're going to allow a floodgate of information outside of China
to be exchanged with the people inside China, Americans and Chinese people.
That's a color revolution in the making in their eyes.
So they're probably just going to censor everything.
All right, that's it today for the episode of me speed running to get banned on Red Note,
the new TikTok refugee app.
If you enjoy the content, leave a like, comment,
put your thoughts and subscribe to our channel until next time.
Bye bye.
