Will Checking Your Partner’s Phone Ruin Your Relationship?

Happily SINGLE
3 followers
If a healthy person doesn't trust someone, they don't say,
give me access to everything, give me all of your logins.
They say, I'm having real issues here,
going into this relationship because I don't trust you.
What is our special question of the day
that we're going to answer?
Well, Christina sent something in which I...
Where did she send that, Audrey?
She sent it at podcast at matthewhelsey.com.
And this is our segment called Q&Audrey.
Everyone, if you could pitch in and let us know what you think
we should call this little segment where Audrey reads a question from the audience.
The front runner right now is Q&Audrey.
Yes, let's see if we can come up with different options.
It's not bad, though, Q&Audrey.
Christina wrote in and said,
Hi, I really like this guy and we've dated off and on for about a year,
but I wasn't ready for a relationship at first
since I had just got out of a three-year relationship
and wanted some time to myself.
I'm now ready to date this guy and he has some trust issues with me
and what we've been through previously.
For example, my ex calling and liking my pictures on Instagram.
He wanted to look through my phone recently and I said no.
He said in order to trust me,
he would need my login info for my Instagram and Gmail
in order to trust me again.
I feel like this is an invasion of privacy and a control tactic.
Am I in the wrong or is he?
This is giving me doubts on if I really want to be in a relationship with him now.
Thanks for your help.
So did she, they dated three years ago and she decided not to or?
No, she had just got out of a three-year relationship,
so she doesn't say when they dated,
but presumably she came out of this relationship,
was dating him for a bit,
but wasn't ready to commit to him and to commit to a relationship.
She's now had some time to herself, come back towards him,
they've come back into each other's lives and he is saying to her,
I have trust issues, I don't trust you,
because while we were dating last time,
your ex was calling you and he was liking your pictures on Instagram.
So I would like to log in to your Instagram and your Gmail
in order to build up the trust again.
I have a lot of thoughts on this, but I'd love your thoughts.
I mean, look, my top-line thoughts are that
you should address the issues from the time.
So what was it, if you took your moral compass and said,
what have I done that I believe was either wrong or hurtful,
it's worth exploring that and then addressing those things.
For example, if she feels like I am a little in the wrong
because I kind of led him on and I didn't actually tell him
that I wasn't ready for a relationship
and I kind of let him get more and more invested
all the while I was still talking to my ex
and having some kind of flirtations there
and ultimately I ended up hurting the new guy
because I wasn't ready for anything
and I didn't really let him know that early on,
then that's the conversation you address.
You say, you sort of come clean on that stuff
and you say, look, here's the reality.
I came out of a relationship and I wasn't ready for something,
but I acted poorly with you.
I was selfish in the way that I approached our situation
because rather than admitting upfront I wasn't ready for more,
I let things progress to a level that then hurt you.
I wasn't in love with my ex or, you know,
I wasn't trying to be back with my ex,
but I also wasn't in a place where I was able to fully commit to somebody
and I'm sorry that at the time I wasn't more honest with you about that.
Think about how important what I'm about to say must be
for me to interrupt my own video.
Well, here's why it's important.
It's going to change your love life and it's free.
If you want to know why someone may have faded out,
why they may have disappeared,
why all of a sudden it felt like the momentum was lost with this person,
go to whyhesgone.com
where I talk about the main reasons someone disappears.
Go check it out, whyhesgone.com
and now let's go back to the video.
That being said, I've had time to think about what I want.
I really find myself now in a place where I can give to a relationship
and you're the person I'd like to give that a try with
because I really like you and I did in the beginning,
which is why I wanted to get to know you in the first place,
albeit at a time when I wasn't ready.
However, if we're going to start from a place of trust,
that has to cut both ways
and you trusting me has to also come
with me being able to trust that you respect healthy boundaries
and that you respect my privacy
and you asking for the login to my social media
and to my whatever it was, emails or phone or whatever,
it's not acceptable to me.
I wouldn't want to have that kind of relationship with anybody
and I certainly wouldn't ask the same of you.
If I was going into a relationship with you
where I felt there were trust issues,
I wouldn't be asking for the logins.
I'd be asking myself,
do I really trust who this person is as a human?
Do I trust their character and do I see them,
do I see it being worth giving them a shot?
I wouldn't say, I wouldn't make it conditional
on whether I had the logins to their devices
and I ask the same of you.
Now, I'm telling you the truth about the past.
I've come clean about where I was at the time
and I'm also being honest with you about where I am now.
If that's not enough for you, that's a real shame
because I think we could be great
and I think that we could have something really special
but I also understand that this is a line for me
that's being crossed and I don't want to start on the footing
of me feeling like my privacy has been invaded.
Yeah, I couldn't agree more.
I also think ultimately,
if you choose to get back together with someone,
that's not to say if somebody has hurt you in the past,
you're going to have to work through certain things
but if you choose to get back with someone,
you should choose to trust them again
and trusting them doesn't mean having access
to their email, their social media.
It means you trust them in spite of the fact
that you have no proof that they're not doing anything.
That's what trust is.
It's if I have to check your phone every time
in order to trust you, then I don't trust you
and if you choose to get back with someone,
you have to come at it from a place where you are going,
I trust you enough to see whether or not
this is going to go somewhere
and whether or not you're going to be good for me
and I think if you can't do that,
that means that the relationship, the trust is broken,
it's too far gone, which can happen
and that's a real shame
but it's also, it's the part where you're saying
which it is a shame
but that does happen sometimes for people
but you have to be self-aware enough
to know that if the security you need
is to be able to constantly check people's emails
and social media and messages in order to feel safe,
then there's something wrong with the relationship.
Well, and there's something I would argue,
there's something you have to really look at in yourself
because if a healthy person doesn't trust someone,
they don't say, give me access to everything,
give me all of your logins.
They say, I'm having real issues here,
going into this relationship because I don't trust you
and maybe that's partly my fault
because I'm overthinking things
or I'm letting my demons get carried away
but until I can address those for myself,
then going further isn't going to work for me.
You don't respond to it by saying, give me your logins.
Yeah, or let's work together to,
you know, let's invest in trying to make me trust you
because I recognize that this could be my thing
but it's also, you know, being instigated
by something you've done.
So let's work together to get to a place
where we, you know, we have that trust
and we rebuild together as a team
but in a healthy way rather than
from a foundation of checking.
Yeah, what I would say to her is,
make sure you feel you have had
a really open, clear conversation with him
about the areas where you feel you fell short
and what you wish you had done differently
and say it plainly and directly
because that's what gives credibility
to your words today.
What you don't want, it's easy
when someone doesn't trust you
to get into a very,
this pattern of what becomes really noisy communication
of, I didn't even do this
and you're making a thing out of this
and it wasn't even a thing and this and that.
And you know, like there's a kind of like,
or an over justification is the opposite of that
where it's like, I'm so sorry
and I didn't mean to do this.
I didn't mean to do that.
Instead, there has to be a point at which you say,
this is what happened.
This is why it happened that way.
And there isn't anything more
that I can say about that factually
because that's it.
That's what it, that's the situation.
Allowing him to dictate the paradigm
of chopping it up a thousand different ways,
which by the way, asking for your logins
is just another version of that
is I want to just look in your stuff
to just chop it up even more ways.
Well, that's you buying into their paradigm.
That's you allowing them to dictate
the rhythm of the communication.
What I want Christina to have
is the closure that she communicated clearly
and openly and directly
and then said, that's all there is to say.
And I'm ready to move on.
And if you're not, that's okay.
But I can't, unless you want to,
unless you want to just work together
to build trust going forward.
There's no more I can say about that
because I've explained to you everything.
But I would argue she's allowed to revisit it.
Sorry, he would be allowed to revisit it with her
if he feels insecure in moments
or triggered in moments.
I think it's not so much about going,
you know, here's all I have to say about it.
Now let's move on.
It's about not indulging
the worst sides of him and his jealousy
because ultimately if you indulge that side of him,
Yes, yes, I agree with that.
I agree with that.
But there's a tone and a manner of communication
that someone who is trying to
find more than there is
or trying to, you know,
if they're coming from their demons
and if they're coming from their own trauma
and their fears,
then they will try to stoke the fires
of that conversation to create more.
And you have to kind of be the water
that's constantly putting that out.
Not by shutting things down and saying,
I'm never talking about this again.
But if someone's getting an agitated tone
and saying, but what about this?
And when you did that and when, you know,
it's like back then I was in this situation.
I was feeling this and I'm not proud of that.
I'm not proud of being unclear.
I'm not proud of not being straight
about my intentions or whatever.
But that's the whole story.
And if there's healing to be done amongst,
between us, that's okay.
I'm all for that.
But there isn't any more story to tell.
That's the part where you have to be,
you don't let someone drag you
into slicing and dicing the situation
in more ways than the situation actually deserves.
Because then you are,
you're allowing their trauma,
you're allowing their demons
to set the tone for the conversation.
You can communicate with them and help them heal.
But what you can't do is get dragged
into matching their tone
and their manner of communication.
Yeah, I would say, Christina,
listen back to what Matt said in his,
in your answer.
Like you could transcribe that
and it's just perfectly written.
But also Matt's tone was just right too
as far as being the water on that flame.
And don't, yeah, don't go,
don't be invited to the demon dinner.
Have your own, have your own,
set the table yourself
and let that be the narrative.
Wait, before YouTube sends you down the rabbit hole
of watching raccoon videos
or videos of large crocodiles
on Florida golf courses,
I have something that will help your love life
more than these things.
And it's at whyhesgone.com.
If you want to know why someone faded out,
why they were giving you attention
and all of a sudden they stopped,
this guide shows you.
Go to whyhesgone.com
and then enjoy your baby bear videos.
