Why U.S. stocks are off to the worst start since 1995*

Financial Action Task
1 follower
Feb 21, 2026
U.S. stocks are having their worst start since 1995, the same year Pixar’s original Toy Story was released. Yahoo Finance Host Julie Hyman, Yahoo Finance Reporter Jake Conley, and Citi Wealth Chief Investment Officer Kate Moore break down what investors need to know.
U.S. stocks are seeing their worst start to the year since 1995.
That's versus global markets.
It's not just that the U.S. is down slightly.
It's that the rest of the world is up sharply.
For the rest of the world to continue to outperform the U.S.,
they're going to have to have some fundamental follow through.
And frankly, that's not what we're getting quite yet.
U.S. stocks are seeing their worst start to the year since 1995.
That's versus global markets.
And it's according to data from Goldman Sachs.
We have the Goldman Sachs data, but we also have our own eyes.
And we have seen, if you look at various indices around the world
and the global performance, ex-U.S., it has been better.
It's not just that the U.S. is down slightly.
It's that the rest of the world is up sharply.
Looking at since the beginning of the year,
the U.S. is flat to down a little bit,
while the rest of the world is up roughly 8%.
Put that out over a year, the U.S. is up 11%.
The rest of the world is up roughly 30%.
And this is on a few things.
It's on valuation, it's on concentration,
and it's on a little bit of geopolitics.
Starting with the valuations,
you saw a note out from Apollos, Torst and Sloc a couple of days ago.
U.S. stocks are just getting more expensive.
They're now trading at a price-to-earnings premium
of roughly 40% over the rest of the world.
Those stocks are just getting more expensive to hold
while performance is lagging.
The U.S. is also, as you know, Julie, highly overweight in tech.
Investors are looking for some diversification right now.
The rest of the world's equities can offer that,
where the U.S. market is so heavily weighted
toward these names that are going to be dependent
on how the AI trade rolls out.
Finally, we've just got this geopolitical risk premium
on the U.S. that kind of won't go away,
whether that's Greenland, whether it's Venezuela,
whether it's the Trump administration's tariff regime.
All of these factors combined,
you're now seeing one of the biggest performance gaps
between the U.S. and the rest of the world
we've seen in a long time.
Of course, everything is relative.
So in other words, you're coming off of strong performance
for the U.S. pretty consistently, right?
Versus in some areas,
not everywhere in the rest of the world,
you have them coming from a lower point, right?
So there is potentially more upside,
at least according to investors,
for maybe someplace like Europe, for example.
A bigger growth story there as some of those stocks,
some of those regions have lagged over the last few years.
The U.S. has been taking up.
Now you see investors starting to look
at the international case a little more closely.
I've been talking with family offices, with hedge funds,
with other big investors for the past few years.
And even though there's no large-scale capital shift yet,
it is something that's starting to be
on the minds of those investors.
And they're starting to say,
should I be considering moving
some of my asset allocation abroad?
There's one country that keeps coming up over and over again
as a place that investors like.
It is Japan.
And there is just now an announcement
between the U.S. and Japan
for Japan to begin investing in the U.S.
$36 billion is the first tranche.
It's an area that you are very familiar with
in the energy industry, which is interesting.
$36 billion, and that's out of a $550 billion
trade agreement.
As you point out, this first tranche
is going toward oil and gas and toward critical minerals.
The majority of that money is going
toward a very large-scale natural gas plant in Ohio,
roughly nine gigawatts of energy projected.
And that's as Ohio is becoming a data center hub.
So you see the play there for AI.
For Japan, this is also a bit of a realignment,
moving capital into the U.S.
and de-risking off China,
off some of its other strategic dependencies,
getting in on the U.S. critical mineral play
that the Trump administration is talking up,
getting in on the oil and gas play there.
Japan imports most, the dominant share of its energy.
And so those external agreements are really important.
The U.S. tariff regime on Japan is also playing a role here
in getting this deal across the board.
One of Japan's driving industries is the auto industry.
Think Lexus, think Toyota, think Nissan, right?
Part of the tariff regime
that the U.S. has agreed on under this deal
is that the levies on automobiles will come down.
That's gonna be a crucial over
for the Japanese economy to pull.
And again, they import so much energy,
so these kind of agreements
are gonna be really important for them.
Here's the challenge.
When you look at the performance in 2025,
the vast majority of outperformance for non-U.S. markets
came from multiple expansion,
came from valuations closing the gap with the U.S.
The problem is the fundamentals
for those markets don't match the U.S.
You don't have the balance sheets, the cash flow,
the earnings, the margins,
and what we think is the growth opportunity
that you get from both tech and communications,
the largest market cap weights within the U.S. market.
So okay, so last year you had a bit of a catch-up.
And for example, in Europe in 2025,
about 90% of the return could be explained
by this multiple expansion instead of by earnings.
We think at this point in the cycle,
it's incredibly important that returns
are driven by earnings
and not driven just by valuations.
For the rest of the world to continue to outperform the U.S.
on a total return basis,
they're gonna have to have some fundamental follow-through.
And frankly, that's not what we're getting quite yet.
So we've just come this big chunk
through fourth quarter earnings.
We have a good sense of what's happening
outside of the U.S. as well,
although we know that reporting
bleeds out a little bit further.
And it's really important to note
that the U.S. earnings growth
is meaningfully outpacing everywhere else in the world.
So while, yes, the U.S. looks like it's lagging,
kind of flattish,
the majority of the returns, once again,
from outside of the U.S.
are coming from multiple expansion.
And currency adjustment also played a role last year.
We're gonna be watching that very closely.
So we've already seen that rally.
Our earnings gonna back it up.
I mean, but there must be some pockets of strength,
some of the same trends
that are fueling what's going on here, right?
Data center expansion, power.
You know, Europe certainly has
some strong industrial companies
that are servicing the power industry, for example.
So there's are, you know, places.
You're saying just like it's not as broad
as maybe the multiple expansion would indicate.
Even before this multiple expansion,
when you quality adjusted U.S. and European markets,
and also sector adjusted,
you actually didn't get that massive valuation discount
that is the narrative.
Everyone says, oh, Europe is cheap to the U.S.
Well, when you look at the companies
in the semiconductor space, in the industrial space,
things that we have significant secular growth,
they were actually trading at multiples
commensurate with their U.S. peers, right?
It wasn't this massive discount.
So high quality stuff was well-owned,
and lower quality things, particularly the banks,
which have been the largest driver for Europe,
you know, were trading at a discount.
And frankly, they should,
because they don't have the same,
you know, kind of structural environment as the U.S.
This is what I would also say.
There were places where earnings growth
has been phenomenal, say outside of Europe,
that also have put up great numbers
on a total return basis.
And some of that is in emerging Asia.
That's another place that we've had an overweight
in our portfolios.
You know, particularly looking at Korea and Taiwan,
some of these numbers are, you know, off the charts.
It is a very single story, single narrative
kind of driver to that performance.
But we think it can continue,
and we're continuing to hold that significant overweight
in our equity portfolio.
