Why the Midterms Might Have Killed the Electoral College

PWE News
9 followers
15 Video Views·Nov 16, 2026
The midterms made it so the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact could come into force. We explain what it is, whether the Democrats will actually enact it, and how the potential death of the Electoral College could reshape American politics.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the potential end of the U.S. Electoral College through the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC). It explains how the current system works, why it is criticized for being undemocratic, and how recent Democratic midterm victories have brought the U.S. closer to a system where the presidential winner is decided by the national popular vote.
Even the proudest American would probably admit
that the US political system is far
from perfect, from the vast amounts
of money sloshing around to its gerontocratic political
class.
But one of the oddities that gets
the most heat is the Electoral College,
A system that means the winner
of the popular vote doesn't necessarily become the president,
as happened in 2016.
But this system could soon be on its way out,
with the end of the Electoral College a genuine
possibility in the next few years.
That's because the Democratic Party's
sweeping midterm victories up and down the
ballot have left them in control of enough states
to put the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact into force
So in this video, we're going to explain what this is,
whether the Democrats will actually
enact it, and how the potential death
of the Electoral College could
reshape American politics.
Never miss an episode and always feel
in the loop by subscribing and ringing the bell.
So how do presidential elections in the US actually work?
And what exactly is the role
of the Electoral College?
Technically, American citizens do not directly vote for the president.
They vote for electors who then make up the Electoral College.
It's the Electoral College that then officially elects
the president and vice president.
The Electoral College is a 538-member body.
Its 538 electoral votes are distributed across the
50 states and Washington, D.C., broadly in line with population.
So, California has 54 electoral
votes and the least populous states have
the minimum of three. Every state,
except Maine and Nebraska, has a winner-takes-all system.
Which means that the presidential candidate
that wins the popular vote in a specific state,
regardless of their margin of victory,
will be awarded all of that state's electoral votes.
To be elected president,
a candidate needs at least 270 electoral votes.
Having survived nearly 250 years
as a central part of the political system,
the Electoral College has increasingly come under fire.
The first and most obvious problem
is that it can lead to undemocratic results,
where the candidate that wins
the popular vote can still lose the Electoral College.
This has happened five times in US history,
most recently in 2000 and 2016, when Hillary
Clinton lost despite receiving nearly 3
million more votes than Donald Trump.
Secondly, the Electoral College,
while intended to ensure that smaller states' voices are
heard, has resulted in a system where presidential
candidates focus outsized attention on just
a handful of swing states.
Meanwhile, the majority of voters live in typically safe states,
sometimes dubbed spectator
And can often end up feeling ignored
and like their vote doesn't matter, which depresses turnout.
Furthermore, because of how electoral votes are distributed,
the least populated states actually have outsized influence.
Wyoming, for instance,
has one elector for roughly every 194,000 residents,
while in each of California, Texas and Florida,
one electoral vote accounts for more than 700,000 residents.
There have been long-running calls for the system to be reformed.
And the 2000 and 2016 elections particularly galvanised this sentiment.
Pew polling from 2024 suggested nearly two-thirds
of Americans supported changing the system
so that the candidate with the most nationwide votes wins.
A popular vote system would fundamentally
change how presidential elections are run,
forcing candidates and campaigns to recalibrate their approaches.
Attention would be less concentrated on swing states.
But admittedly, this may just result in campaigns funnelling resources
into highly populated areas to run up their vote tallies,
therefore overlooking the less populated areas in between.
This would make campaigning more costly,
as populated urban media markets are more expensive.
But despite the pitfalls,
it would fully uphold the principle of one person, one vote,
and would equalise the voices of, say, a Democrat in deep red Idaho
and a Republican in deep blue Massachusetts.
That's where the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact comes in.
Launched in 2006, the non-partisan multi-state
pact requires participating states to pledge
all of their electoral college votes to the winner of the popular vote,
Rather than scrapping the elements,
Electoral College, which would require constitutional amendment,
it's an effort to bypass it.
The compact would only go into effect once enacted
by states whose combined electoral
votes total at least 270.
Since it launched, 18 mostly democratic governed states and DC
have signed up, totalling 222 electoral votes,
so still shy of the magic number.
However, at this month's midterm elections,
Democrats expanded their control of state-level
governments. Crucially, they gained trifecta control,
meaning control of both chambers
of a state's legislature and the governorship,
in Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania,
and Wisconsin. These five states have a combined 61 electoral votes,
Enough to surpass 270 if they sign up to the compact.
Josh Shapiro, the Democratic governor of Pennsylvania,
which has a newly Democratic-controlled legislature,
says he thinks that the national popular vote makes sense,
and that he'll work with lawmakers
to figure out how to move forward on it.
David Crowley, the new Democratic governor of Wisconsin,
which also now has a Democratic-controlled
legislature, wants to quote
do away with the Electoral College too.
Pennsylvania and Wisconsin would add
another 29 electoral votes to the Compact.
So to reach 270, Michigan and one of either Arizona
or Nevada would also need to sign up.
For the Popular Vote Compact to be in place
for the 2028 presidential election,
it would need to be enacted in said states
by July the 20th, 2028.
So the timeline for this electoral cycle
is relatively short.
Furthermore, the Democratic governors of Michigan,
Arizona, and Nevada have either declined to
comment on the issue or signaled that it's not a priority for them.
But for the sake of this video,
let's imagine that enough states do adopt it soon.
At that point, it is all but guaranteed
to face significant legal challenges, particularly
from conservative groups.
As even though the Compact is a non-partisan project,
it's clearly one that the Democratic Party
is far more supportive of than the Republican Party.
Unsurprisingly, given that it's the Democrats
who've been stung by the Electoral College twice in recent decades.
Opponents say the Compact would be unconstitutional,
As the constitution says that states cannot enter
into compacts with each other without
congressional approval.
But proponents say that this is irrelevant.
As per the constitution, elections are run by states,
so the compact wouldn't affect
the balance of power with the federal government.
Ultimately, it might be up to the Supreme Court to decide.
Even if we assume it is upheld,
that's not the end of the potential difficulties, nor
does it mean the popular vote would necessarily be here to stay.
For starters, given that the distribution
of electoral votes is recalibrated each decade
following the census, it's possible that,
after 2030, the Compact's total electoral
votes fall below 270, rendering it inactive again.
Similarly, it could be made inactive
if Republicans retake control of enough state governments
and leave the Compact.
Also, while Republicans are typically
the beneficiary of the Electoral College right
now, the winds could change and give Democrats the edge.
Would Democratic-led states retain their enthusiasm
for the popular vote compact if it meant having
to hand victory to a Republican candidate?
Ultimately, the point we're making is that there
is no guarantee the compact will come
into force soon, or that it would survive more
than one electoral cycle, but its supporters
are justifiably optimistic,
as the midterm results have created the most favourable conditions
for success so far.
If you're looking to keep up with this story,
the first place you'll start is online.
But most of what we do online runs through companies we never choose,
and they see more of our lives than we'd want.
Recently, the European Commission proposed
a package of laws aimed at this problem.
Europe relies on non-EU companies for more than 80%
of its digital products and services,
and Brussels now treats that as a strategic risk,
much like its old dependence on Russian gas.
The same issue applies to us, and that's why we use ProtonVPN.
Proton is a Swiss company,
where they can't be legally forced to log an IP address,
so there's nothing to hand over even if requested.
And its no-logs policy has been
independently audited for the last five years.
You don't have to take our word for it, as its
code is open source, so anyone can check what it actually does,
even yourself. No blind trust
required. And if that hasn't convinced you,
Proton VPN also holds the Which? Recommended
So you absolutely know you're in good hands.
And we're partnering with them to offer
our audience a 75% early Black Friday discount
on VPN plans.
So just go to protonvpn.com/tldr,
or click the link in the description.
With Proton's 30-day money-back guarantee,
there's zero risks, just an easy way to
take back control of your online experience.
