Why The Batman's Sound is Different

Movie sound effects
101 followers
Listen to this.
This otherworldly sound happens to be a Justin Bieber song slowed down 800%
and it's this contorted version of the song that was responsible in part for
inspiring what would eventually become the sound of the Batmobile in the latest Batman film.
This video is sponsored by CuriosityStream. Watch the exclusive companion video on Nebula
when you sign up for the CuriosityStream Nebula bundle today. Watch this clip on mute.
A truck passes in front of the frame. And imagine with me for a moment what
sound you think will accompany that truck. Got it? Okay, here it is.
Instead of a truck, we hear a train. But there's no visual sign of a train in this
shot or any of the shots in close proximity. The film establishes trains as part of the setting,
but when the sound plays, we don't see a train. The sound of the train passing
fades out as the truck passes. It's almost as if the truck was making the sound. I'm guessing if
you've seen the movie, you didn't even notice or think about this. But this small detail reveals
something about sound in film and especially how it's used in the Batman that I think is fascinating.
Gotham City in the new Batman film is soaked in rain. I don't think I've seen a film that uses
rain this relentlessly since David Fincher's 7, which this movie is obviously drawing some
inspiration from. It's impressive the range of effects and moods that the sound team for
the Batman manages to get out of the sound of the rain. This rain hitting the Bat-Signal at
the beginning almost has a sinister, sizzling feel. The rain in this scene feels cold, icy,
and almost sleet-like. The rain in a more intimate setting like this one,
or this one, feels warmer and cozier. And in this scene where Batman's doing some hard-boiled
detective investigating, the rain in the background almost sounds like boiling or simmering water.
If you listen closely, the rain has a unique sound in almost every scene or location in the film,
and the differences in the sounds don't just reflect the fact that rain sounds different
in different environments. They actually design the sound of the rain to reinforce the mood of
each scene. I've talked before about expressionism in cinematography, and similar to how harsh
shadows and lighting and even set design can become an external manifestation of a character's
internal psychological state, sound can express these things as well. But the way something sounds
isn't the only way you can use sound expressively. The mix of the sound, its volume and the relative
volume of different sound elements in the scene can be used in an expressionistic way.
Take this moment. If you were standing in a room and it was raining outside, you could hear the
rain, and as long as it's still raining in the real world, the volume of the rain outside isn't
going to change. But let's turn down the dialogue in this scene, and I want you to listen closely
to what's happening with the sound of the rain in the background. The rain, which is a prominent
part of the ambient soundscape, softens and almost drops away completely for a moment,
to emphasize the tension between Batman and Selina, before coming back in towards the end.
The mix here is modeling the sound of the film around the subjective experience of the characters.
In the real world, when you're focused in on something, you tend not to pay attention to the
ambient sounds around you. They're still there at a constant volume, but you're not actually
hearing them. Right now, in whatever environment you're watching this in, there are probably all
kinds of external sounds that you haven't been listening to while you're listening to me. But
if I draw your attention to them like I'm doing now, you probably suddenly become aware of them.
In our subjective experience of the world, what we hear reflects what we're paying attention to.
So by manipulating the level of certain ambient sounds, the sound team is placing you as the
perspective. This kind of subjectivity isn't just created through levels. Listen to this moment,
and pay close attention to the sound of the camera flashes. He's wearing gloves.
Friday, July 16th. My life has been a cruel riddle I could not solve.
Hear how they become echoey and reverby as Gordon reads the Riddler's words? In this scene,
we're inside Batman's auditory perspective. Here, the sound design isn't replicating a
real-world effect in how we perceive sound, just like we don't actually see in slow motion, but
sometimes cinematographers use that to create a subjective effect. There's a kind of dissociative
quality to this kind of echoey effect that helps us understand the headspace the characters are in.
In a film, sound's relationship to reality can be very loose. Instead of crafting a soundscape
that is realistic, sound designers and engineers have a lot of leeway in a film to design sounds
that create the right impression of reality, or that reflect a character's subjective experience,
rather than what the environment or the objects would actually sound like.
I'm sure we're all familiar with the idea of score using a motif or theme to cue a certain character.
This film obviously has one for Batman that it employs in sometimes strikingly subtle ways,
like in this moment where it literally only plays the first note of the theme
as the words The Batman appear on screen. We often think of a film's soundtrack as coming
from a kind of objective perspective, where the film itself is telling us what the emotions of
the scene are or what's happening, but film score can be used subjectively as well. In this moment
when Selina's theme plays as this boot is revealed, the film's score isn't telling us objectively that
it's Selina, because it turns out not to be. The film is telling us that Bruce thinks it's Selina.
My favorite soundtrack cue in the film is the Riddler's Ave Maria, which is used expertly for
this scene. The association between the Riddler and the song is established earlier in the film,
and here the fact that the choir sings it before the Riddler shows up gives the whole scene a
sense of foreboding and suspense. But by placing the music in the scene diegetically, which just
means that the sound is actually coming from within the world of the film instead of just
part of the omniscient soundtrack, it creates a sense of ambiguity that pervades the scene.
The ambiguity doesn't just come from the song, we also hear this sound,
which sounds like the Riddler's signature gasp scream thing, but then it ends in a cough.
So we're not quite sure if it's supposed to actually be the Riddler or not,
which is the entire tension of the scene. Bruce is paranoid and is seeing the Riddler everywhere,
and the film does a great job of helping us enter into that ambiguity and mystery
through the sound design. One of the interesting auditory tools that this movie uses kind of
exists in the space between sound effect and soundtrack. Listen to this ambient soundscape.
It's kind of an underwater droning and it crops up pretty much anytime the Riddler is on screen
and Batman is looking at or listening to him. It's not a piece of film score,
but it's also not really a sound effect, it's not motivated by any element of the environment.
But this sound, unlike Ave Maria, also isn't a cue for the Riddler,
it's more of a cue for Batman's emotional response to the Riddler.
Here that underwater ambience comes in right after Falcone is shot,
giving us an early indication that the Batman thinks the Riddler is responsible.
And then it shifts to the Ave Maria theme as that suspicion is confirmed.
After the Riddler is unmasked and the Batman has a confrontation with him,
the next time we see a video of the Riddler, that ambient soundbed is absent.
Because the Batman's perspective of the Riddler has changed.
I'm honestly kind of in awe of the extensive work and artistry that goes into the sound
design on a film like this. It takes entire teams of people, an incredible amount of work,
and a lot of thought goes into crafting every part of how a film like this sounds.
And a lot of the techniques used aren't even intuitive. For example, why is this scene so
impactful? The sound of the club just seems so intense and overwhelming.
Well, it turns out to make the scene feel the way it does, the sound team discovered that they
actually needed to make the sound of the punches quieter. Compare the sound of these hits
to these from moments earlier. It's a mild difference, but in the mix, these hits are
actually quieter than these. Here's a modified version of the scene where I've brought up the
levels of some of these punches. It changes the whole feel of the scene. When we're watching a
film, we understand the volume of sounds relative to each other. So if the punches in this scene are
clearly audible, the music feels way quieter. If we were in the room and the music was really
blaring, you wouldn't be able to hear these hits. Another example of this kind of thing is in this
scene where we can clearly hear the rain, but then moments later, once gunfire breaks out,
the rain falls away into silence. Listen to this modified version where the sound of the rain
remains audible. The gunshots actually sound quieter, even though I haven't changed their level.
All I've done is leave the rain at the volume it was at moments before.
The key takeaway here is that almost nothing you hear in a film like this
is a reflection of reality. The sound is almost entirely impressionistic and expressionistic.
The idea is to create a sound that feels right to the audience, not one that would be accurate
if closely examined. Because realism isn't the goal, you often can't achieve what you want simply
by going out into the world and recording real world sounds. The Batmobile is a great example
of this. The sound design combines the engine sounds from multiple sources,
but there's a key ingredient that comes from a curious place.
That's the sound of a bottle rocket going off. Supervising sound editor Will Files liked the
sound and wanted to incorporate it into the sound design of the Batmobile, but it was too short and
felt too quick and small. It was ultimately the same technique that was used to create this strange
ethereal version of this Justin Bieber song that morphed the bottle rocket sound into the sound of
the Batmobile that's in the film. By stretching the same bottle rocket sound out into different
lengths and then layering those together, Files and his team were able to build the unique rising
scream that helps make the Batmobile reveal so impactful. And by modifying a real sound instead
of trying to generate it synthetically, they maintained a physicality and imperfect quality
in the sound that's a better fit for the film and the Batmobile's grungy, dirty aesthetic.
Subjective perspective plays an incredibly important role in the story of the Batman,
and I've been talking about how that subjectivity is created through sound,
but it's also developed in cinematography in a way I think is crucial to the story the movie
is trying to tell. You can see more about how the film develops and uses visual perspective
in the companion video I've made exclusively available on Nebula. Nebula is a streaming
platform created by and for independent content creators like myself. On Nebula,
you can watch every video from me and a ton of other amazing creators early and without any ads
or sponsorships, but you also get access to a bunch of exclusive Nebula content like my video
on perspective in Batman or my video on the sound design in Dune, which goes into some of the cool
uses of surround sound mixing that I don't talk about in this video. And now you can also get an
entire bonus episode of my podcast Cinema of Meaning where Tom and I discuss 1917. It's
available exclusively on our Nebula feed. And here's the best thing. You can get Nebula for
less than $15 for an entire year when you sign up for the CuriosityStream Plus Nebula bundle.
When you sign up for the bundle using my link, not only are you getting all the great Nebula
content I talked about, but you also get access to CuriosityStream, which is a streaming service
with thousands of great educational and documentary titles. You can get all of this
today for 26% off when you sign up by going to curiositystream.com slash Thomas Flight
or by clicking the link on the screen.
