Why has Russia never accepted Ukraine’s independence? In this episode of Ukraine This Week, Anna Belokur examines 35 years of Ukrainian independence and the centuries of Russian attempts to control, suppress, and ultimately deny Ukraine’s sovereignty.
From the collapse of the Soviet Union and Ukraine’s 1991 independence referendum to the Orange Revolution, EuroMaidan Revolution, and Russia’s full-scale invasion, the episode explores how Ukrainian resistance has rejected Moscow’s vision of a shared Russian-Ukrainian identity.
Featuring historian Serhii Plokhy and Oleksandr Donii, a participant of Ukraine’s 1991 independence movement, Anna examines why Russia continues to reject Ukraine’s right to exist as a sovereign state — and why Ukrainians continue to fight for it.
AI Generated·May contain errors
On August 24, 1991,
Ukraine declared independence from the Soviet Union.
Three months later, nearly 32 million Ukrainians voted
on the ruling in a national referendum.
Over 90% of voters said yes to independence,
with a majority in every single region,
including Crimea. Countries around
the world recognized Ukraine as a sovereign nation,
including the newly established Russian Federation.
But that superficial acceptance of
Ukraine's independence didn't signify an end
to Russia's centuries-long quest to subjugate its
35 years later, Moscow is waging
the largest war in Europe since World War II,
in an attempt to bring Ukraine back under its control.
I'm Anna Belliker, reporting to you from Kyiv.
This week, as Ukraine marks 35 years of independence,
we'll examine the question
of why Russia has never truly been able to accept it.
The Soviet Union was propped up on increasingly shaky legs
in the latter part of the 20th century,
and cracks in the economic and political spheres
were becoming increasingly visible
from both inside and outside the Iron Curtain.
In the mid-1980s, leader Mikhail Gorbachev tried
to introduce reforms aimed at opening up the
decaying Soviet system, but it was too late.
The newfound openness, called glasnost,
in combination with governmental
restructuring efforts known as perestroika,
contributed to the total collapse of the empire. During this period,
national movements gained traction across the Soviet republics,
from the Baltics to Central Asia.
And as the second most populated Soviet republic,
Ukraine's push for independence from Moscow
was key in the Union's undoing.
In July of 1990, the Ukrainian parliament adopted a Declaration
of State Sovereignty, and later that same year,
hundreds of students went on a hunger strike
in what's now called Independence Square here in Kyiv.
Known as the Revolution on Granite, these protests had several demands,
among them the resignation of Soviet Ukraine's head
of government, Vitaly Masol,
and opposition to a new treaty that would have kept Ukraine inside
a restructured iteration of the Soviet Union.
After two weeks, Masol resigned and the strike concluded,
but the debate around Ukraine's future
as a Soviet state would continue into 1991.
The following year, in August of 1991,
die-hard members of the Communist Party in Moscow
made a last-ditch effort to preserve the old, unreformed Soviet Union
and launched a coup against Gorbachev.
It only lasted a few days and was wholly unsuccessful.
And then on August 24th that year,
Ukraine's parliament adopted the Declaration of Independence.
But let's look a little bit more closely at that referendum
that followed, that I mentioned in the introduction.
Ukraine's Declaration of Independence might have
been voted on by parliament on August 24th,
and that's why we celebrate Ukraine's Independence Day on this date,
but it was the nationwide referendum three months later,
in December 1991, that sealed Ukraine's fate.
More than 84% of eligible Ukrainians turned out for the election,
and of the nearly 32 million
voters, more than 28 million, or over 90%,
voiced support for an independent Ukrainian state.
Now, if you look at Russian propaganda,
you might get the idea that support for
Ukraine's sovereignty was and remains geographically skewed.
And that's why I want to be clear.
In the December 1991 referendum, the majority of voters in every
single region of Ukraine opted in favor of independence.
In eastern Luhansk and Donetsk
oblasts, as well as other Russian-speaking
majority regions like Kharkiv and Odessa,
more than 80 percent voted in favor.
Even in Crimea, it was still a clean win. So the idea
that some parts of Ukraine were liberated
from Moscow's control against the will of their
of their constituents is
Demonstrably false.
We are now joined by Ukrainian politician and activist Oleksandr Dani,
who can share his memories
of what happened in 1991.
I had been working towards August 24th for several years
because I set it as my goal to fight for Ukraine's independence.
Oddly enough, even back in school,
I was preparing myself for prisons and labor camps.
In ninth grade, I sat my mother down in the kitchen
and said that I was going to enter
Shevchenko University, but do get ready.
First, our home will be searched, then I will be expelled
from the university, and then I will be imprisoned.
And when I entered Shevchenko University,
in 1988, I was expelled from the university for the Ukrainian cause.
In 1990 we had a search at home
and in January 1991 I was put in a jail.
So I considered that I had prepared my mother.
That is why for me independence is not just
one day, August 24th, but a path of struggle for independence,
a conscious path chosen back in school
which was not easy but extraordinarily interesting.
The methods of this struggle included creating a student organization
and holding a citywide
all-students' strike, something that had never happened before
and never happened after us
either, meaning the only citywide all-students' strike
in Kyiv took place during the student
revolution on Granit in October 1990.
So, for me, independence was essentially the final element
in this years-long struggle.
Ukrainians managed under stateless condition to create an idea
that became attractive to the majority of the population.
I wouldn't say this is entirely unique,
because there were also the Latvians, the Estonians,
there are a few examples in Europe,
but the fact that it stands out from the general historical context
of the European continent is beyond doubt.
And the fact that we created this under
the conditions of two empires is exceptional.
They decided to create a single nation and it succeeded.
This is undoubtedly an exception.
So to a degree, Ukrainians,
you can't talk about a dissident gene or a freedom gene,
as that's an unscientific approach. But as an idiom, you could say that
here ideas against central power in search
of justice were constantly bubbling up.
That is precisely why I continuously emphasize that for Ukrainians,
a democratic system, for all its flaws, is optimal,
and giving up on democracy is a blow to the gut for Ukrainians.
Thank
Of course, like everyone, I rejoiced.
But I warned that this was a huge challenge,
and the struggle was not over.
And not that we should just sit down,
you
fold our hands, get drunk, and celebrate.
No, it was simply one of the important days.
One of the important days.
very
What is more, for years and decades I have emphasized that personally,
if I were the one making the decision, I would celebrate
much.
Ukraine's Independence Day on December 1st, not August 24th.
Well, because on December 1st, unlike August 24th,
independence was confirmed by the choice
of over 30 million citizens across all regions of Ukraine.
In Sevastopol, in Luhansk and in Simferopol,
the majority of Ukraine's population that came
to the polling stations affirmed that they
were for an independent Ukraine.
Like I said, Russia formally accepted Ukraine's independence in 1991,
along with the rest of the world.
But very soon after, members of the Russian political
establishment began questioning what that independence actually meant.
And as would become a theme in the decades to come,
the narrative around Crimea stood out.
In January 1992, when the ink was still drying
on the former Soviet republic's
declarations of independence,
Russian parliamentarians began challenging the legality
of the 1954 transfer of jurisdiction over Crimea
from Soviet Russia to Soviet Ukraine.
The following year, the Russian parliament tried
to claim that the Crimean port city of Sevastopol
was a federal Russian city.
Ukraine called the motion a violation of its territorial integrity
and raised the alarm with the UN Security Council.
And when Ukraine began negotiating the surrender
of the enormous nuclear arsenal it had inherited from the Soviet Union,
records show that Russia's
attempts to rewrite 1991 borders loomed
large among Ukraine's security concerns.
In 1994, Russia joined the United States
and the United Kingdom in signing the Budapest Memorandum,
reaffirming commitments to respect Ukraine's independence,
sovereignty, and territorial
integrity in relation to Ukraine giving up
its Soviet-inherited nuclear weapons. The memorandum
provided Ukraine security assurances in return
for moving its warheads to Russian territory.
And yet those security assurances did
not save Ukraine from Russia's invasion of Crimea two
decades later, which, as you know,
was shortly followed by the invasion of eastern Ukraine
and ultimately the full scale invasion of 2022.
Whether Russia would have been so
confident waging war against Ukraine had it not given up its nukes is
Debatable, but it certainly set the stage for it,
and as we'll get into shortly, this marked a continuation
of centuries of efforts by Russia to defang Ukraine
and prevent it from asserting itself against creeping Russian control.
The Kyiv Independent is your source
for all things happening on the ground in Ukraine,
the war, the resistance, and everything in between.
And we're primarily funded by our
community, who donate a small amount each month
to help us keep the lights on,
the camera running, and the news coming.
If you'd like to get involved, visit the link
in the description below.
Thank you also to everyone who donates directly via YouTube.
To fully understand why Russia has refused
to accept Ukraine's sovereignty, we have to go back further than 1991,
further even than the formation of the Soviet Union.
Russia's quest to subjugate Ukraine has lasted through centuries
and has seen multiple attempts by Russia
to revise the origin stories of both countries.
Both Ukraine and Russia trace important parts of their historical,
cultural, and religious
heritages to Kievan Rus,
the medieval state governed from Kyiv that reached its height
centuries before Moscow became a political metropolis.
Kievan Rus would ultimately fragment in the 13th century,
and the territories of modern
Ukraine and Russia underwent very different trajectories,
with a lot of what's now Ukrainian
territory alternately falling under Lithuanian
and Polish control amid attempts by Ukrainians
to assert their own statehood.
One example came with the Cossack Hetmanate, a semi-autonomous
Ukrainian political entity established
in the 17th century in rebellion against Polish rule.
In 1654, its leader Bohdan Khmelnytsky signed
an agreement with the Russian Tsardom based in Moscow,
seeking backup in the fight against Poland.
But over the following century, Moscow would
increasingly restrict the Cossacks' autonomy
and bring their institutions under Russian
imperial control.
And then by the late 1700s, Catherine the Great abolished the official
political status of the Cossack state in favor
of absorption as another region of the Russian Empire.
Modern iterations of the Russian state,
from the Russian Empire to Soviet Russia,
would incorporate the history of Kievan Rus
into their national origin story,
with the implication that Ukraine
and Russia have always been two parts of a single empire.
From the 18th century into the imperial era,
the concept of the Russian nation
was commonly depicted as consisting of three branches.
Great Russians, aka Russia,
Little Russians, which referred to Ukrainians,
and white Russians, meaning Belarus.
And then within this framework,
the idea of a distinct Ukrainian nation was counter to Moscow's goals.
If Ukrainians had their own language, divergent history,
and self-governance, then they couldn't be little Russians.
Attempts by Ukrainians to maintain
and promote an independent identity were met with persecution.
At various times, Russia has treated the Ukrainian language,
traditions, literary canon,
and desire for statehood as threats worthy of censorship,
political repression, and military
force. In the late 19th century,
Russian imperial authorities banned the publication and even
reading of books in Ukrainian,
while also suppressing the use of the Ukrainian language
in public life and persecuting people
for speaking their own native tongue.
After the collapse of the Russian Empire in 1917,
the Ukrainian People's Republic emerged
from the revolution, before eventually losing
the struggle for long-term independence as Bolshevik
forces wrested control over much of Ukraine,
turning it into the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist
Republic. And under Soviet rule,
Ukrainian language and culture was again gradually repressed
in favor of Russification, hence why
so many in Ukraine still speak Russian as their first language.
In the 1930s, during Joseph Stalin's Great Purge,
members of Ukraine's intelligentsia,
including poets, writers, artists,
and others who sought to preserve and promote Ukrainian
culture and traditions, were systematically imprisoned,
persecuted, and in many cases,
This is executed.
And within the Soviet system,
there was no real pathway for Ukraine to assert its right
to self-governance until the 1991 collapse
that I outlined in the first segment.
So all of that is to say,
1991 wasn't the moment that the concept of the Ukrainian state
was born into existence,
but it is the point at which the living people of Ukraine permanently
asserted their sovereignty.
And the question of shared history becomes somewhat moot.
One can acknowledge periods of convergence and divergence
without drawing the conclusion
that Russia's rule over Ukraine is inherent or immutable.
We're now joined by renowned historian Serhiy Plokhy,
who can tell us a little bit more about how Ukraine functions
in the Russian imperial narrative.
My first question is incredibly broad.
I know you've written multiple books
about this very subject, but if you could summarize,
what role does Ukraine play
in this kind of Russian imperial narrative?
What is the function of Ukraine in that narrative?
The current narrative that really underwrites
the so-called special military operation,
and now the largest war in the world in the 21st century,
is that Ukraine didn't exist,
Ukraine doesn't exist, Ukraine shouldn't exist.
So the argument there is that Ukrainians are really Russians.
The official line, Russians and Ukrainians are one and the same people,
but that's the key argument.
The history goes back to the, really, 15th century.
That's the time when the predecessor of the Russian modern state
was formed out of the empire that was crumbling and falling apart.
And that empire was the former Mongol Empire
and later Golden Horde or to scholars it's known as
Kipchak Horde as well.
And the founding myth and founding mythology of the Russian state
as it emerged in the second half late 15th century
was that really the state
had nothing to do with the Mongols,
the state nothing had to do with the
Mongol and Golden Horde, but the state,
the roots of the state were really in Kyiv and in Byzantium.
through Kyiv to Byzantium and then eventually to Rome.
But deep down this Ukrainian story
is very much the story of the 20th century and 21st century.
That's the time when the empires
fall and crumble. And most of the states
that you can find today on the map of the world
or flags that you can find
when you go in New York to the headquarters of the United Nations
This is really the result of the crumbling of empires
and emerging of new states.
And the world is going through the process
of really re-educating itself.
Finding out that where there was once Ottoman Empire,
there are all sorts of states from Turkey to Syria,
after World War II, the emergence of Israel.
And to a degree, the same is true for the Russian Empire,
or for the Habsburg Empire,
or for the French and British Empire outside of Europe.
So Ukraine is part of this really process that started 250 years ago.
With the revolt of the North American colonies against Britain,
against the British Empire,
again, it took Americans for a while
to reassert themselves as a separate nation.
36 years after Declaration of Independence,
a special military operation conducted by
British got to Washington and burned White House.
That's just to point that the process of acquiring
and then sustaining and defending independence is a long process,
and so is the process of
really presenting yourself to the world.
And redrawing the mental borders
that exist in the perception of the world
when it comes to the territories of the former empires.
Ukraine is unique in one way.
Ukraine is not particularly unique in another way
and is part of the really much broader processes,
European but also global.
After the breakup of the Soviet Union, Russia maintained
and advanced a huge degree of influence over the Ukrainian economy,
media, and government.
This took the form of trade deals, partnerships,
and support for Russia-sympathetic parties in the Ukrainian government.
But as they've done for centuries,
Ukrainians pushed back against Moscow's creeping advances
in an attempt to assert their own nationhood.
In 2004, Russia openly backed then-Prime Minister Viktor Yanukovych
in Ukraine's presidential election.
And when authorities named him the winner,
international observers pointed out that
the election had really failed to meet democratic standards,
and hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians
protested on the same Independence Square where students gathered
in 1990. Known as the Orange
Revolution, the movement forced a new round of voting,
which Yanukovych lost. And then,
nine years later, in late 2013,
this pattern repeated on a much larger scale.
Yanukovych, who had managed to win the presidency in 2010,
abruptly cancelled preparations for
increased cooperation with the EU,
which would pave the way for deeper ties with the West.
Instead, he announced plans for a deeper bond with Moscow,
and that decision triggered protests
that would grow into the Euromaidan revolution,
again taking place on Independence Square.
After months of demonstrations
and the killing of more than a hundred protesters,
most at the hands of Yanukovych's riot police,
the disgraced pro-Russian leader was ousted
and fled to Russia. So if the Orange Revolution demonstrated
that the modern Ukrainian people
had the tenacity to advocate for themselves,
Euromaidan showed that they were willing to fight
and die for their freedom.
And Russia's brutal response showed
that they understood how strong resistance had grown.
Immediately after Euromaidan,
they launched a military annexation of Crimea and then an
invasion of eastern Ukraine,
where they would wage war for the better part of a decade before
escalating to full-scale invasion of the entire country.
Multiple observers have noted that Russia planned
to defeat Ukraine's military forces within a
matter of weeks in 2022,
before then moving towards a process of occupation and annexation.
And the strategy required swift removal
of Ukraine's leadership, predicated on the
belief that all political
and social resistance would quickly collapse afterwards.
But as you know, that didn't happen.
Ukraine's leadership held its ground, the military mobilized,
and the Ukrainian people have resisted every single day
of the full-scale invasion.
Four years, Vladimir Putin, like others before him,
has claimed that Ukrainian national identity
is artificial, superficial, and easily punctured,
and that Russians and Ukrainians are essentially
one people separated by unfortunate circumstances
and outside influences, namely the influence of
the meddling West. But if that were true,
the Ukrainian people wouldn't be fighting tooth and
nail against the invasion.
They wouldn't be able to clearly articulate what they're fighting for.
They wouldn't have evidence and artifacts of a long, rich history
separate from the revisions and fabrications of Russian propaganda.
Russia's dismissal of Ukrainian independence only works
if Ukrainians dismiss it too,
and that's something that they steadfastly refuse to do.
Ukraine's independence doesn't
depend on Russia accepting the historical legitimacy
of a sovereign Ukrainian nation.
It doesn't require Russia's understanding or permission.
Since 1991 and for centuries before it,
Ukraine has existed because Ukrainians know it to be real
and are willing to fight for its future.
It's been 35 years since the Declaration of Independence,
and those decades have been marked
by unimaginable sacrifice and tragedy.
But for all its efforts,
Russia has never managed to understand
or destroy the Ukrainian identity, and never will.
Happy Independence Day,
and glory to Ukraine.
Hi, my name is Polina Morozyk.
I'm a reporter at Kyiv Independent,
and one of our members asks,
what are Ukrainian people's hopes for life after the war
when Ukraine is occupation-free?
What are they looking forward to doing,
either on a personal level or as a group or society?
Personally, I hope to visit the occupied Ukraine
and go on a road trip in the east and also
Visit Crimea like I did when I was a child.
My name is Yulia Taradyuk.
I am the Crimean independence reporter at the War Desk.
And my personal dream is to visit all the places
which usually appear in my reporting.
And they are not accessible right now at the moment.
So they serve the cities
and villages under Russian occupation and on the front lines.
And also I...
He wants Ukraine to join the European Union.
My name is Linda and I am a junior investigative reporter
at the Kyiv Independent.
And my dream is for Ukrainian society to witness this special
tribunal in The Hague where Russian war
criminals will be held accountable.
My name is Tim Zarozhny.
I'm a reporter at the Kyiv Independent's national desk.
And my dream is to
That's
all
for
this
week.
It's bittersweet to inform you that this will
be my last episode of Ukraine This Week.
But the Kyiv Independent will still be here to give you updates
on the most important topics in Ukraine today
on YouTube, our website, and social media,
which are linked in the description below.
Thank you for watching. It has been my honor to be your host.