Why Portugal's Public Healthcare Is Losing Its Best Doctors
1 Video View·Jan 28, 2025
So today we're going to be exploring DSNS which is Sistema Nacional de Saúde,
so the national public health system. One of our viewers posted a question regarding
can you talk about of what's going on on the national health care, the public one,
why do people wait for so long to have procedures? So today we're gonna deep dive on that,
why does this happen in Portugal, what are the reasons behind it, so stay tuned and let's go
for it. So let's start by introducing the players on why is the national health care,
public health care system in Portugal is sometimes in such a peril. When you look at the news you see
so many people waiting for procedures, you see hospitals and smaller cities closing,
clinics closing, so let's see who are the main people involved here. So there's two main
elements here that play together, sometimes not as well as we hope. One of it you have the
government and the government in Portugal is elected every four years, so they sometimes change
and on the other side you have an institution that has been here for a really long time and
it's much more stable which is called Ordem dos Médicos. So the Ordem dos Médicos is basically
the association that once you graduate from med school certifies you as a practitioner, as a
doctor. This institution is the one that controls how many openings exist in med school across the
country, so how many universities have spots for students to go into med school. So they are the
institution that is looking at all of this, that each specialization is doing what they're supposed
to be doing, that they're following the right approach, so they have a lot of power as you
probably are already noticing. So they need to play together with the government in order for the
public health care system to work, you need doctors and you need doctors to graduate, integrate the
public system and stay there. So the biggest issue right now is that a lot of doctors are leaving
the public system, either they go full private in Portugal or either they simply leave the country.
And on the other end you have here the Ordem dos Médicos, this association that for the longest
time has been, I don't know if capping is the right name, but it has been keeping the openings for
studying to be a doctor at a very not as big number because their statement is that in Portugal
there is enough doctors. And their statement isn't wrong, there is in theory enough doctors,
but the public system is not captivating them enough for them to stay, so as any person they
want to have a decent pay, a decent hour, so some of them move on. So those are some of the things.
Another big element in consideration is that on the other side you have the government pointing
the finger at the Ordem dos Médicos saying you're the one that caused the problem because you don't
let people in to be doctors. So in Portugal for you to enter university and to be a doctor you
need to have really high grades, so in a scale of 0 to 20 many times they're asking you to have a 19
to be a doctor, so you can't imagine how competitive it is to become a doctor in Portugal,
so much that it has driven a lot of students that want to be doctors to study on our neighbor
country Spain because there is much more accessible to go and be a doctor. You can go in with a 14,
15, you probably can make it. So you have some dynamics here and they are not trivial and there's
a lot of finger pointing. The government points into the Ordem dos Médicos, the Ordem dos Médicos
points at them and says you are not providing good enough conditions to retain this talent
and we need to think as well that for you to have a doctor, a specialized doctor, let's say let's
pick a psychiatrist or obstetrician, they need around 15 years to be specialized and integrate
fully the SNS. So there is a big time window, so there's two lines of thoughts here. There's
people that clearly point the finger towards the government, this is your fault, you didn't manage
this well, you're not attracting people to stay and other people will point the finger at the
Ordem dos Médicos, this association, and point the finger at saying to them that you've been
very elitist, you kept the the openings very low, letting only a small percentage of people
study to be doctors. So of course and on top of that 15 years, so 15 years ago you should have
been thinking about letting more people in. So there's many lines of thought depending on who you
ask. Some people believe it's the government because often they change, so recently they were
on the socialist side, it changed more to socialist but more towards the center and the government
changes, all the ministers change, they need to go into the ministry of health, figure out how they're
going to manage this crisis, so it's not trivial. And then there's real life stories that I want to
walk you through, so you get a glimpse of why do people actually leave the public. So let's jump
into that. So this is the best article I've read regarding what is the reason why do doctors leave
and it's a really harsh reality and actually made me really appreciate even more the doctors that
decide to stay in the public system because what is described by some of these folks is
actually quite atrocious. So let's go and jump a little bit into this news. So the first story
they tell is about this gentleman that is studying to be a doctor and a psychiatrist
and he basically gave up to do this specialization in Portugal because it was so many hours
and so little pay that it was simply unbearable, so he decided to go and do his specialization
in Germany and he believes that coming back to Portugal will be a big step backwards, which is
really really sad, right? We are educating these doctors and we are unable to retain this talent,
so it's painful. But when you look at the reality just here, like in Portugal a doctor that is
studying to be a specialist is making euros and this is probably brut, so you still need to
probably put taxes on it. It's not a lot of money if you think about someone that's putting so many
hours, that has such a stressful job, they're not working and they're studying, plus they have
other people's lives in their responsibility, it's a huge demand from that person and when
you look at neighboring countries like Germany and you can make this amount, I mean it's a
no-brainer, you immediately start waiting, do you want to stay or do you want to leave? I mean you're
just human, even if you want to give your best and help people, you have bills to pay, you have family
and you want to spend time with them, so that's one of them. And then they also interview another
senior doctor that is probably in his 50s, that he's thinking about actually giving his resignation
letter, because he's in the public system and he is really frustrated. So here what they say is
Manuel, he has his letter to resign signed but in the drawer, because he still thinks a lot about
the patients that he is helping and he just describes a situation that for me is just
absolutely insane. So here in this paragraph he says basically, just this is so insane, it's like
literally, so he's a doctor that's doing biopsies and apparently is on the neck, so he needed
needles a little bit bigger and he requested the administration and he had to put up a big case
explaining why it was bigger, so people wouldn't suffer and it took around one year to grant them
those needles. And those needles cost 70 euros, I mean it feels like almost he'd be like,
excuse me patient, could you please bring this type of needle to the procedure, just because to
make things going a little bit faster, this type of bureaucracy is soul-crushing and I admire this
petition to still be able to be there just for the patients, that's amazing. So these are some
of the painful situations they go through. This is also a great article that describes why the
government is unable to retain the doctors in the public system, because the public is
so poorly managed that the private becomes really really attractive. I mean if you're in a system
that you need to wait for so long to get a needle to help someone, it's absolutely insane, why would
you want to stay there? So that's what's happening. Then to pile on what for me is already soul-crushing
to be a doctor in the public system, to have to work so many hours, not enough pay, plus you don't
have the resources or the material. On top of that, the government found a way to solve the
shortage, which is basically bring people from outside, what they call terefeiros, and paying
them an obscene amount compared to their peers that are there studying, doing the work. These
they have no fault, they are there to be hired, they are hired and they come in and they make
double of what the doctor that isn't there studying to become a specialist is making.
So that's absolutely infuriating and you can see here in this news, I think they were able to
get an email of someone making an offer and you basically see here it says,
Dear, I hope you find yourself well, we are looking for an obstetrician here in the hospital
of Caldas da Rainha, well Silver Coast in this case, and we are looking for these spots,
would you be willing to do it for 95 euros an hour? I mean, how do you think the doctors that
are there feel when this stuff is happening? Because I also have their prices, how much they
earn, because this is all public, right? They are public servants, so you can see how much they
make per hour and let's look at the lower scale, so let's look at someone that is still doing the
specialization, so they finished the five years, seven years to be a doctor, but now they are
studying to be an obstetrician or a psychiatrist and they are kind of on the bottom of the scale,
so this is like 15 euros, well, this is a little old, let me look, let me see if I can find,
okay, I think this is a more accurate one, but still, let's look at the very bottom here,
someone that just finished the base core training and now they're doing the specialization
and they're doing basically 19 euros an hour, 19 euros an hour, and then their peer comes in
doing basically the same work in obstetrician and is making 95. I mean, you feel for the doctors,
right? I mean, how would you handle the situation? You'd probably be really, really upset.
So the last news I wanted to walk through you is regarding the comments from the president of the
Ordem dos Médicos, so basically the one that certifies and kind of looks after all the doctors
across Portugal, they keep saying one thing, which is more vacancies in medicine is not gonna solve
the public system situation, and there I kind of agree, but I also disagree. Okay, it's not gonna
solve the core issue, which is if the environment is not good, if the doctors don't have the
material, the equipment, and the support to work, it's always gonna be very challenging.
Like if I think about going to a doctor in US, before you see a doctor, you see like at least
three people, the administration person, you see the nurse, you see a nurse practitioner,
and then you see the doctor, so you can imagine that the doctor, his time is really appreciated,
and he only goes at the right time. Here in Portugal, if you go to the doctor,
you immediately get the doctor on the immediate session, and he's doing administrative work,
many times he's doing nurse stuff. I mean, there's also a huge management problem. I feel like
the SNS is not properly managed. Am I saying it's easy? Definitely not, but they are able to
make it work on the private system, so maybe putting someone there in charge that's well-paid,
so it's motivated to be there and to do a good job, might solve it. Now on the other end,
I also don't agree with this thing of more openings for people to study medicine,
it's not gonna solve the problem. I do believe it's gonna help to solve the problem, because
anyways, it takes 15 years, 15 years to graduate as a specialist, so why not increase the pipeline,
so you get more people down the pipeline, and in parallel, you're also making the SSN a better
environment, so doctors want to stay. So you can do both, I don't think, I don't like this finger
pointing, they do a lot between the government and the order of the medics, just work together
and make it happen. So to kind of wrap here, the conclusion is, okay, this is in Portugal,
is Portugal the worst? What's going on around Europe? So I searched and I was able to find a
report about waiting times across Europe, and Portugal is not the only one, this is happening
across other European countries. Okay, yeah, Portugal is leaning towards the top, but you also
have Norway, you would think Norway, Nordic country would have their problems sorted, well,
you still need to wait for like a cathartic surgery, you still need to wait for a hip
replacement, you have it here again, so Portugal is not the worst offender. Other European countries
have the same type of challenges of not having enough resources to handle their patients. So I
hope you enjoyed this video, as I've explained in the very beginning, this is not a trivial issue,
because there's two parties, government and ordem dos medicos, that don't fully work together towards
a common objective, in my humble opinion. Again, this is all my opinion, it's based on what I've read
and feedback from friends that are studied in Portugal to be doctors, and are actually doctors,
some that stayed, some that left, and they've called out some of these situations, so there is
a lot of opportunity to be better. I have huge appreciation for the doctors that are in the
public system, because I know with the conditions they're working, and they're trying to do their
absolute best. I was, I had a small procedure done, surgical procedure done in the public system,
and I'm extremely thankful, it's unbelievable, I was super well treated, they even did a little
essential oils and a little massage, because I was gonna get a big injection and some points.
There is a lot of amazing people in the system, but if the system is polluted, it pushes them too
far, it does and does not pay enough, this is bound to happen. But it does not mean that the
public system is bad, it's actually pretty good.

