Nvidia cofounder and CEO Jensen Huang has made himself indispensable to the success of his company--which, as Challenger, Grey and Christmas chief revenue officer Andy Challenger told Forbes senior editor Maggie McGrath for this “Forbes Newsroom” segment, isn’t uncommon for founder-led companies but is a liability when the CEO in question is under fire for inappropriate behavior. andy
NVIDIA has launched an internal investigation after CEO Jensen Huang admitted to a relationship with an executive linked to Chinese intelligence. This situation highlights the risks of founder-led corporate structures, where deep personal ties between the CEO and the board can hinder governance and succession planning.
NVIDIA announced Sunday that it has launched an internal investigation
after CEO Jensen Huang acknowledged
an intimate relationship with a business executive
that U.S. intelligence says has ties to Chinese intelligence.
There are significant ramifications for the U.S. economy here.
NVIDIA stock was down in Monday trading.
It commands a massive market share in the semiconductor market.
So there are significant economic, financial,
and also leadership questions that arise from this story.
Joining us to discuss all of these aspects is Challenger Gray
and Christmas Chief Revenue Officer Andy Challenger.
He is a workplace advocate.
expert and knows a lot about executive coaching
and probably has some advice
for Mr. Huang. Andy, thank you so much for being here.
Thanks for having me.
So Challenger Gray and Christmas has a significant view
on corporate America, typical corporate structures.
So I want to start off by saying this conversation will
be focused on the corporate aspect of this story
and not the U.S. intelligence aspect of this story.
And just to set the stage, Andy,
can we talk about NVIDIA's corporate structure?
There are a lot of reports showing how flat it is and how much power.
Jensen Huang, who is also the co-founder of NVIDIA, has within
this company, which is one of the reasons this is such a huge story.
Yeah, NVIDIA is a relatively flat organization
and long as the founder or co-founder of the
organization.
And when we look at companies
and how they deal with scandals that have to do with their
top leaders in the organization around private relationships,
it's very categorically different
when we're talking about a company
that's founder run versus a company that has a professional
CEO that's been brought in by a board.
And has more of a power dynamic that isn't quite
as strong as a founder would have in an organization.
You have said in statements that you put out this week that this is
something that every board in America should be paying attention to.
So I was looking at NVIDIA's board. It's a lot of deep,
deep professional relationships between NVIDIA's founder
and the executives on this board.
Several are folks who are formerly C-suite members of...
big companies, but are no longer part of those companies.
It's a really interesting board.
Can you talk about the board that we're seeing
and the power it has to perhaps investigate
and remove Jensen Huang in this moment?
Yeah, in a case like Nvidia,
where it has seen enormous growth in a short period of
time, still run by the people who founded the organization,
they've also been the ones
Accumulate and build the relationships
that founded the board to start with.
So when you're in that situation,
the board is going to have less outside control over the situation,
even if they may legally and in all of the board documents have
the right to remove a founder or CEO when they have those human.
Personal relationships,
and they deeply believe in the founder's vision for the organization.
It's much harder for them to take action against the leader
of an organization when they do something that is morally wrong, brand
damaging, and potentially even involved in international espionage.
How dangerous is it for any board,
not just NVIDIA's board, to have so much trust in the
founder and CEO that they end up in a situation
that we are currently seeing, which is there's
no obvious successor?
How dangerous and also how common is it
for the founder CEO to have this much power?
For founder-CEOs, this is more common than you might suspect.
The best boards and the best founders themselves have created
a path within their organization to develop successors,
to give some outside governance actual power to the board so that they
can make the best decisions for the company in the long run.
However, more often than not,
we see founder-led organizations don't have...
Have all those governance structures in place
that are not as clearly enforceable.
And there's always just this issue of really close, deep relationships
that make governance actually difficult to push on to an organization.
Now you released a report yesterday that notes that the NVIDIA probe
is coming in a year that has already seen a quote elevated amount
of CEO departures tied specifically to personal conduct.
So you tracked, is it 17 CEO exits attributed to allegations
of professional misconduct? That seems like a large number, but Andy,
could you contextualize that for us and how common is this really?
Yeah, it is a surprisingly large number, we tracked 17 this year.
Last year, there was only five
and eight recorded in 2024. So this is a big spike.
I don't know if there's any way for us to
correlate that with something specifically,
but it's a good sign that professional
misconduct of leaders is being taken seriously
by boards of most organizations. We saw
This first become a big national conversation around Me Too.
We started to see the number of CEOs that were ousted because of
professional misconduct really start to fall after the peak of Me Too.
But this year we've seen 17.
They're not always big headline stories like a couple
at the Coldplay concert or the Nestle CEO, Laurent Freixe.
When you have that undisclosed relationship,
sometimes they make big news stories, but
a lot of these human issues are happening all
the time across corporate America.
Is there anything we can say about the way the numbers are moving?
Is there a trend or a conclusion about executive behavior,
something that maybe more boards
should be more aware of, a question they should
be asking their CEOs on a regular basis?
Any broader takeaways here?
Yeah, I think it's a good signal, a good reminder to every board across
the country that they should be really explicit with the leaders
of their organization, that personal relationships with subordinates
or even other founders of other firms are going
to be looked at very closely and could be actionable.
You don't want to.
In a lot of ways, let CEOs be a victim of their own behavior.
If you can be really clear about how consequential
those types of relationships could be to you
as a board, it's going to hopefully curb behavior
in a way that sees less of this type of activity.
When you talk about CEOs being a victim of their own behavior,
I think about some of the commentary I've read around NVIDIA
in that part of this story that has taken so many people by surprise
is the fact that Jensen himself has become the potential threat
to the financial security of this company, this massive company.
And to be clear,
they are still generating hundreds of millions of dollars.
But co-founder,
CEO himself is one of the biggest financial liabilities here.
What's your response to everyone's surprise
that it's the man at the center and maybe
not a market reality,
maybe not a political reality that is one of the bigger financial
liabilities here?
Yeah, I think it's it's really difficult,
especially an organization that is run
by a charismatic leader that is pushing an industry forward.
They have a lot of people bought into the organization's plan of action
when they take when they have a
Public, personal failing of this magnitude.
It's something that's going to be noticed, obviously,
across the organization, but across the entire industry.
it
There's such high consequences.
Thank
is
You do wonder how somebody in this position could make
you
a mistake that could cost so much.
and
With the amount of responsibility they have,
take
take these types of actions.
off
But I also would caution that in situations where it's
you
you.
much.
a founder-led organization,
very
there's much less pressure on that individual to leave than there would
be in an organization where a board has a lot of authority.
much.
So I would say that even though this has had
A big impact on short-term value of the company.
The idea that there's really going to be change in the organization,
I would be a bit skeptical.
That's interesting. So I was going to ask you, you know,
in your capacity as workplace expert at Challenger Gray and Christmas,
is there something you would recommend
to NVIDIA's board that they do this week?
A public statement they put out, a question that they ask, something,
a lever that they can pull that would maybe stop the stock slide
or maybe help some public confidence. Is there anything they can do?
Yeah, I think it's always valuable
to be really transparent what they knew, what national
security risks are involved,
and what the future risks are to the organization.
Lay it out on the table
and put together a plan of action on how to prevent this type
of potential damage to your organization going forward.
Be really clear, really communicative.
I think any area where there's opaqueness, that's where speculation
can creep in and it can start to really snowball in panicky markets.
And when we talk about succession planning, again, part of this story
that I think is remarkable is the number of times I've read
this sentence, no clear succession plans, no clear successor.
What is your recommendation either for NVIDIA or for any founder-led
company about building a coherent, clear, and reliable succession plan?
Is there advice you would give?
Yeah, it's not.
A situation where you need to name who the successor is going
to be or make public who that person you think is that would take over
if something unexpected happened to the CEO, but at least put forward
your policies around what would happen in the case
of something happening to the CEO so that there's a clear plan
in place, regardless of who it is that comes in to take over.
And then be really clear from a talent development standpoint
that you are internally grooming
a group of candidates to potentially take that role,
and that you have a good sense
of globally the market of executives
that can come in and take the role if necessary.
It's really important to be structural about that,
especially at an organization that relies
so heavily on a single person like a founder-run organization.
Is there anything else that you can say about
this situation based on the data that you've
accumulated over the last 10 years around CEOs
who've lost their positions specifically
due to quote-unquote inappropriate behavior?
We've covered a lot of ground, but is there
anything else you would want the Forbes audience
to understand about NVIDIA and or any situation where a CEO
or CEO founder is behaving inappropriately
and could lose their position?
Yeah, I think.
There is a positive story about the number
of CEOs that have been held responsible for
personal actions over the last six or seven years.
It is not that this type
of behavior didn't exist before a decade ago, but
This wouldn't possibly have even been a news story a decade ago.
And today, the whole world takes notice.
Thank
The fact that there's international espionage involved maybe makes
this an edge separate case.
But this overall idea of CEOs having real consequences
for their personal actions is something that is new
you,
and very positive change for companies, largely.
guys.
Andy Challenger, Workplace Expert
and Chief Revenue Officer at Challenger Gray and Christmas.
Thank you so much for joining us
and sharing your research and your insight with us.
It is a fascinating story, and I think we'll all be staying tuned.
Thank you. Thanks for having me.