Why Moscow's Red Lines and Kyiv's Referendum Strategy Keep Peace Elusive

News District
4 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe discussion centers on a reported US proposal to trade the Donbass region for Ukraine's NATO membership. Former diplomat Anil Trigunath analyzes the security demands of both Russia and Ukraine, the geopolitical hurdles involving European nations, and President Zelensky's strategic use of a potential referendum to maintain political legitimacy.
So let's talk about, you know,
the ongoing talks on how to resolve the Ukraine issue.
Zelensky threw a bomb yesterday, a stunning claim,
which though the Americans haven't confirmed,
he said that the Americans for the first time had floated a proposal
that would he be ready to trade the whole of Donbass for...
Membership or a seat at the NATO table now this the Americans
as I said haven't confirmed it. How serious could this be both
for all players for Europeans for Zelensky for the Russians
because remember the Russians premise for entering into Ukraine
was that or making the invasion was the you know membership.
A proposal of NATO for Ukraine.
To talk more about that, I'm joined by Anil Trigunath.
Trigunath, former senior diplomat on the show.
Ambassador Trigunath, thank you very much for being on the show.
So, how serious is this proposal?
Or is it just a trial balloon that the Americans,
if they have, floated?
Well, it looks like that it could be a trial balloon also.
So, but at the same time.
Since all sides are looking for security guarantees, the Russians have
been asking for it since their meeting with Biden in 21.
And the Ukrainians have been asking out ever since
the Budapest memorandum has been violated
or the Minsk agreements have been violated.
So there is a tremendous deficit at the same time, even if it is false.
But there is some kind of a security considerations
that are being sought by both sides.
For the understanding of my viewers,
what is the difference between the security guarantees
or security architecture that the Russians are seeking?
And that what and the one that Ukrainians are demanding.
Well, what Ukrainians are demanding
is that there should be a foolproof.
a guarantee of their security
because they have suffered not having enough security or
having given up their nuclear weapons after the Budapest memorandum.
So obviously they are looking
to become a part of NATO.
That has been the basic thing and that's precisely the reason that you
have seen that there's some quid pro quo
that is being talked about here. As far as Russia
As far as Russia is concerned,
Russia had developed some kind of a NATO Russia Security Council.
And that council meeting in Brussels often discussed
the various issues between the two sides, the Europe and the Americans,
as well as the Russians, and therefore any issues which were there.
But since 2014, Russians and their Russians have been virtually
expelled and they are no longer part of that council meeting.
And so therefore they are saying that there should
be a proper security architecture.
And they are asking now going back to the 1997,
which means that any country that has joined ever since,
they are even asking Finland to get out of NATO,
which it will not, obviously.
But this is a situation in which the Russians are wanting.
But I think for Russians,
the biggest red line has been Ukraine's inclusion into the NATO.
And that's precisely the reason that the Russians started this war,
because they can't actually allow this kind of a security process.
They can't have NATO on their borders. Yes.
Stationing of the forces even here now what they
are asking is that from all the European after
1997 all the European forces must be withdrawn.
So this is a very it's again a very very maximalist position
But at the same time I think that if you remember
that within two months of the war in Istanbul meeting
Which when both sides Russia and Ukraine had agreed in the beginning
and Russians had not made enough advances
into Ukraine
It was very clearly agreed, Russians had even agreed to let the
Ukrainians be a member of the European Union, but not that of the NATO.
And then the head announced that he will not become a member of NATO.
But then, of course, the British and the Americans pushed them into.
Even if assuming he does not become the member of the NATO,
but by seeking Article 5 like security guarantee.
That is why he wants to be in NATO,
that if he is attacked by the Russians,
The Europeans should protect him and they should respond back.
So by seeking what he calls ironclad guarantees,
he's essentially seeking an Article 5 status.
Well, obviously, I mean, nowadays, the Article 5 status,
which have so far we have not seen been invoked so frequently.
And that's precisely the Article 5 that has prevented
the inclusion of Ukraine into the this war,
because everybody has known that in the case there is a fight
or something happens that they will be forced to fight directly Russia.
And that's precisely the reason that so far, not much has happened.
But apparently, the Americans have come up
with this idea that provide some kind of
But if the, sir, what you are saying is,
if Zelensky's claim is correct,
then it is not acceptable
to put Putin at this stage.
Then you were saying that the Americans might want
to put their forces on ground.
So is there a change of stance there?
Because earlier Donald Trump had ruled out putting
the American forces there.
He had ruled out these fellows, the Ukrainians joining NATO.
No, this was earlier done.
But now, you know, the thing is that while you are negotiating,
there are all kinds of proposals keep coming up.
And therefore, when these proposals are floated,
they're, as you said, kite flying.
I mean, it's exactly the same. But there is a big difference
between achieving it and talking about it.
So I think both sides at the moment are having,
you know, we'll know that now President Putin,
President Xi Jinping and President
And Trump will be meeting in China also.
And the one meeting in Abu Dhabi has happened whereby
the largest exchange of prisoners will take place
and the next meeting is also supposed to be held
and apparently Europeans will become part of it.
But let us say the Russians are very much, you know, not wanting all
the countries like France and everybody else to be there.
What they're saying the one country should be represented.
So technically it could be European Union, which means Kaya Kalas.
If she happens to be, so they don't agree to her as well because she's
the one who's been criticizing all along and is a hawk as far
as the security or agreement with the return coming from the Baltics.
So that is something that the...
Basic dynamic that is preventing the whole thing from moving forward.
But both Russians and Ukrainians and the Americans and everybody else
probably is far too tired now to carry on with this war any further.
They may be tired, but looking at it from the European perspective,
would Europe risk?
Getting a member on board with unresolved borders,
I mean, getting Ukraine into NATO,
which clearly has unresolved borders with Russia
and the Russian expansionist ambitions
are very clear to the Europeans.
So would Europe, would even Europe want that?
I doubt very much that the Europe or,
because even if it was there, let's say,
but do they have the capacity to fight
the Russians and that is another thing.
Would they like to fight the Russians?
Take on that, you know, given that they are facing,
already facing such protests
over housing crisis, over economy, etc.
They have a lot of problems at home as well.
So, now would they want additional problems of, you know, third party?
Precisely, that's the reason.
I don't think that they are very much interested,
but since they are more engaged than even the Americans in this war,
and they have been supporting this war also, and now
with the Democrats coming into power, it is very likely that there will
be a much greater support for Ukraine in the U.S. Congress.
So the Americans would also be interested in finishing this war
or having some kind of a ceasefire,
at least, to begin with before that.
I mean, NATO and other questions will come much later.
Let's talk about Zelensky before I let go of you.
Why is he playing the referendum gamble?
He says, I have no right to decide on my own.
My people will decide. I will put it to a referendum.
When he knows very well that people who have made sacrifices,
lost families, lost sons in war,
will they ever agree to give up territory?
My question is, what is he playing at?
What he's playing at is that he can easily say that I was ready,
but that my people have
rejected this idea.
So that so that his acceptability
into the capitals will continue to be there and
his ability and his survival also there
but as you know the Russians have been saying
that he has stayed far too long
and he is not a legitimate leader anymore and all those kind of
things. So he also perhaps feels that he has not been re-elected
so far the war has been going on
therefore for any major issue putting it
to the referendum is perhaps the right choice for him
To legitimize it one way or the other.
Okay. One last thing, sir. Where do you see this going?
I think that the war is not ending so soon.
Okay.
There might be, even if there is a ceasefire,
we will still be in the phase of frozen conflict.
This will continue for some time now.
Ambassador Trigunath, thank you very much for taking our time
and sharing your perspectives with us.
Thank you.
