Most people are wrong about how meetings actually work. The majority of people assumes that you start a meeting with a clear goal and end it with a clear outcome and action steps. But in reality, that’s not how meetings usually work.
Most meetings are chaotic because collaboration between people is chaotic. That’s where a facilitator comes in. As a facilitator, you probably won't be able to eliminate all the messiness of collaboration, but you can bring structure, get the best out of every team member, and “conduct” the chaos so that real progress gets made.
This video is a clip from our highest level in-person facilitation training, Full Stack Facilitator, happening in Summer 2025 in Palo Alto, California, led by AJ&Smart’s CEO, Jonathan Courtney @theunscheduledceo
0:00 Intro 0:25 how people think meetings work 3:42 how meetings actually work 5:11 how facilitators can help
You cannot predict what's going to happen
when you get into a room with a group of people
because someone might just be in a bad mood.
There might be a fight between two employees
you just didn't know about.
There might be something in the news
that just freaked some people out
that now everyone's pissed about, right?
What we would like to believe
is that a meeting starts with,
okay, here's the goal.
We have a goal.
We have a shared goal.
And then, as we all know,
what happens is we go into a meeting
and then 90 minutes later we have a decision
which is like clear next steps
on what all of us should be doing, right?
That's what meetings look like, right?
Always.
Every single one of them.
But the problem and the big insight here
is that actually that's what people think meetings,
how they're supposed to work, basically.
And so this is why they break
because you're going into a room
and this is what people think is supposed to happen.
They're going to all sit down in a room.
Everyone's going to start talking
and then somehow that'll happen.
Some people might have a more granular expectation
which is slightly more realistic
where they're like if they've done design thinking
they might be like,
well, in the beginning we're going to diverge.
We're going to have lots of different ideas.
We're going to have all these different directions.
And then like in the middle
we'll kind of like battle out the different ideas
and this one stays, this one stays, this one stays.
And at the end we converge and then we have a decision.
So that's what even like when you're looking at theory
around collaboration and around meetings
and around decision-making,
this is what's presented as the theory
where you have the divergent zone,
the convergent zone.
And if you have the, if you're looking at the,
which is in your book here,
the Diamond of Participatory Decision-Making by Sam Kainer.
By the way, your booklets in front of you,
the full stack facilitator ones,
go into like a thousand times more depth
to everything I'm talking about.
But I just don't want to give you the stuff you don't need.
So, but this is, even in the theoretical models
of how meetings work,
they kind of still have a much more optimistic view
than what happens when humans are involved.
And when humans are involved,
I mean, how many of you see meetings start off
with a clear goal and end with a clear decision?
It's relatively rare.
Even, and I always think about this,
my guys want to go on,
we rent a cabin outside of Berlin, my friends and I,
and the WhatsApp group,
does anyone know how unbelievably horrible
WhatsApp groups of friends
trying to organize anything looks like?
What we think is going to happen is
all the boys are going to get into the WhatsApp group
with the goal of choosing a date.
All we have is two things to do.
When, where, we can't do it.
It's like six months later and we're still here.
And what happens in meetings is on a smaller scale
is that we start the meeting,
okay, let's say best case scenario,
the meeting name is describing what we want to actually do.
In most cases, it barely does that.
And then it's like, we're talking about this topic.
So let's say we're talking about the company retreat, okay?
We're talking about the company retreat.
Okay, there's five people in the room.
In the beginning, the person who set up the meeting says,
all right, let's start talking about the company retreat.
Great, cool.
We're talking about the company retreat.
That's all right.
Where can we go?
What about this place?
Should we stay in the country?
Then Dave asks, there actually is a Dave in the room.
Dave, you ask, hey, just quick question, guys.
The laptops we were supposed to be given,
we were supposed to get our laptops upgraded.
There was an email about the laptops
because my one is like the laptop thing.
Oh, yeah, yeah, the laptop thing.
So the laptop thing, and then someone's like,
wait, we need to talk about the retreat.
Yeah, okay, whatever.
Look, laptop thing, two people are already on Slack
talking about the laptop thing now.
And the other three are still sitting there,
like one of them is fully checked out,
not paying any attention.
So the laptop thing, we've got the laptop thing going on.
We've got the retreat going on.
We've got two people just chatting separately
to each other on Slack.
No one's paying attention.
All of this keeps happening until,
and the only reason the meeting ends
is because time is up.
So it's like, oh, we've got five minutes.
What should we do?
What usually happens here?
Another meeting.
Another meeting is spawned from the filth
and dirt and goo created in a meeting.
And so what we can do as facilitators
is deny that this is the fact of how collaboration works,
or we can accept it and go with the flow.
Embrace it, exactly.
We can just, acceptance.
And this is what I actually am going to be suggesting
to you guys.
There's going to be scenarios,
and we're going to teach you guys
how to use all of the tools and everything you need
to be a great facilitator.
But the actual real insight here
is that 99% of the world believes
that a meeting should go from here to here,
and then everyone's disappointed when it doesn't.
Somehow disappointed forever.
How is it that we are working at a company
for 20 years, and for 20 years straight,
we're still disappointed that meetings don't work?
Well, they just don't.
It's fine.
That's it.
That's just human messiness.
Within all that human messiness,
we still know how to make planes and stuff.
So stuff does get made.
It's just made with a lot of pain.
Okay, so it's not that nothing ever gets done.
We can make nuclear plants.
That's crazy.
We can make spaceships.
That's so crazy.
Yes, everyone has to burn out on the way
and lose their life and hate every part of it.
But that's fine.
We get stuff at the end.
And our goal as facilitators is to,
and the cool thing and the thing
that's very satisfying as a facilitator,
is to help companies and to help teams
make the things that they want to make
without their lives being absolutely,
completely miserable.
By jumping in on this ---- show,
but being able to,
by being an emergent facilitator,
being able to actually bring them through it
in a way that just removes a lot of that pain for them.
And the cool thing is,
when you are able to do that,
you essentially unlock the actual superpowers of a team
because the individual members of a team
can now do what they're supposed to do
instead of having to learn
how does group dynamics,
how do group dynamics work?
Who talks now?
Like, when is this meeting going to be over?
A facilitator can come into this
chaos and allow it to still be chaotic,
but also allow the people to actually
get the important information out of their heads
and keep them on track
so that they can come to a decision
that doesn't just turn into multiple meetings.
So what I do not want to teach you
and I do not want you to leave this week with
is going back to your companies
or going back to your clients
and telling them they have to now work like this.
If you can do that, that's amazing.
If you have that authority in the company,
then you can make that so good for yourself.
But for example, we at AJ and Smart,
we can't do that
because every company we go to, it's fresh.
There's a new problem to solve
and there's zero chance of them changing
the way they're working
outside of the week we're working together with them.
And so I want you to be able to just be dropped
into a chaotic situation,
accept that it's chaotic.
By the way, be pleasantly surprised if it's not.
If they have systems in place like a Chuck's company,
then you can be like,
whoa, this is the one rare opportunity
I get to work with a team
that actually has its ---- together.
But most of the time,
they won't have their ---- together
and that's totally fine.
And you can actually learn to enjoy
and thrive in those environments
where the more chaotic it is,
the more you know,
the more chaotic and the more tense
and the more fights that are happening
between the employees
and the random dude who comes in halfway
through the meeting and fucks everything up,
the more you know that you can actually make it
a noticeable difference
when you're in the room with them.
That's also good for your career.
It also feels good.
It also feels really cool
when people say,
okay, next time we're doing one of these,
I want to have Jonathan in the room.
That feels good.
It gives me like a kick.
It gives me the feeling of like,
okay, actually,
there's a point of this thing that I'm doing.
It actually feels exciting.
And the other thing is,
we're not like in this room competing.
We don't want to compete
with the type of facilitation
where we wrote,
learn how to do specific workshops
because AI will be able to do that all for us.
We don't want to learn that.
I don't want to teach you things
that will be completely irrelevant a year from now
because these tools are so goddamn good.
And eventually,
they will be able to perfectly decide
what exercise to run.
It'll speak in a human enough voice
that it doesn't really matter that much.
It will keep time, et cetera, et cetera.
But the mess of human collaboration
isn't going to budge
when a robot is telling people
to do something with Post-its.
It's going to need someone in the room
or on the call,
being able to be the composer
and move between all the chaos
and decide what to do.
That's really the role of a facilitator
is helping people get from this goal,
by the way,
which is always a mess,
they even have to figure out the goal
in the first place,
to the decision
in the least painful way possible.
And with the most of the knowledge
of the group unlocked as possible,
meaning also that the person
who doesn't really want to talk
because they're so checked out
because of all the bad meetings
gets to actually contribute again.