Everyone wants to get a great deal on a house. But does throwing out a crazy low offer actually help you get one?
In this episode, we’re talking about one of the most common mistakes homebuyers make: assuming you should start low and simply “meet in the middle.” Sometimes a low offer makes sense, but without the right research, leverage, communication, and strategy, a lowball offer can actually make your position worse.
We break down what really makes an offer “lowball,” why asking price and market value are NOT the same thing, how sellers typically react to unreasonable offers, and why the way your agent communicates and negotiates can matter long after the initial offer is accepted.
There are still great opportunities for buyers in the Dallas-Fort Worth real estate market. The key isn’t just offering the lowest number possible. It’s understanding the property, the seller’s situation, the competition, and where you actually have leverage.
If you’re buying or selling a home in DFW and want a smarter strategy, the Todd Tramonte Home Selling Team is here to help.
Call or Text us ANYTIME 214-216-2161 or visit www.dallashomerealty.com
THIS SHOW IS BROUGHT TO YOU BY: The Patrick Glaros Mortgage Team: (469) 399-2411 Republic Title: (972) 423-8777 our insurance guy, Kyle Freire with TWFG Insurance: (954) 594-5347 And the Todd Tramonte Home Selling Team: (214) 216-2161
Is Moving to Dallas - Fort Worth, Texas Right For You? 👉🏘️Take the Texas Fit Finder Quiz: http://texasfitfinder.com/
My name is Todd Tramonte, and I've been a Real Estate Broker and Team Leader of the Todd Tramonte Home Selling Team in Dallas Fort Worth for the past 15+ years. If you need an expert, full-time, fully committed agent, call our team. If you have ANY questions about relocating to Dallas Fort Worth or moving within Dallas Fort Worth, please contact us:
This video warns against making \"low ball\" offers in residential real estate, distinguishing them from reasonable low offers. It explains how insulting prices alienate sellers and destroy the goodwill necessary for a successful transaction, advocating instead for data-driven strategies and professional communication to secure a home without sabotaging the deal.
What is up party people?
It's time to get real.
It's time to have a grownup conversation.
It's time to acknowledge that quite often home buyers and sellers are in fact,
their own worst enemy.
I'm really excited about this conversation today because I think that you can
just, I think people think that you can just offer whatever you want.
Okay. So the cat is out of the bag. Courtney has spilled the beans.
We will today be talking about low ball offers.
Now we're not only talking about the buy side,
we're going to reference the sell side.
We are talking all things residential real estate across the Metroplex across
DFW. This will apply pretty much anywhere in the country though.
So send this to your friends, save this one, listen back twice.
Don't be the problem in your own transaction.
Do not be the giver of terrible advice to your friends,
your family and your neighbors when it is time to buy or sell a property.
So we need a humble heart today. We're going to dig into today. We'll do,
we'll break for some intros here in a second. So standby,
but here's what you need to know. If you are buying a home,
you have a significant amount of responsibility on your own shoulders.
Obviously I, Todd Tremonti,
am a fan of you having a world-class full-time professional and team at your
disposal. But even then,
even when you go find the best real estate agent and team you can find on
planet earth, you are still the decision maker.
You are still responsible for you, your family and your finances.
And I'm not saying it's all on you. I'm saying the final decisions,
your future are your choice.
And a lot of people are coming into these things with really bad strategies,
really lazy approaches, and sometimes somewhat smart,
somewhat sophisticated, poorly timed, poorly placed strategies and approaches.
And they're creating a lot of destruction in their own lives.
And they're often blaming the lender, the title company, the real estate agent,
the inspector, the tech, you know, everyone, but themselves,
I'm not here to say buyers are stupid.
I'm here to tell you a lot of buyers are doing stupid things.
And one of them is making ridiculous low ball offers.
Is that always a terrible thing to do? No, I don't think so.
It's not always a terrible thing to do,
but it is almost always a terrible thing to do.
Well, and you have to like define low ball, right?
Like that's the biggest thing that we need to,
one of the biggest things we need to dig into because there's a low offer and
then there's like a low ball offer. And then there's like really,
really horrific, stupid offer. Low ball. Yeah.
We're going to get into it. As you can tell folks,
you've already heard the soothing tones of full price. Courtney, the triple C,
coming off the top rope and the English wonder himself,
the Yanni Donnie. And he swears. I never say this next part. Ian Daniels.
No, I've said, you say it. Listen, your feelings were hurt.
Feelings were hurt. And now we've cleaned it up.
43 year old man.
I just want to be referred to by my name and not Yanni Donnie. Listen,
some people like to hear their name said, okay,
here's what we've got.
People have been told for, I don't know,
probably thousands of years,
but certainly hundreds of years and absolutely decades in my personal
experience since time began that generally speaking,
you just make a low offer and then the seller does what
they'll negotiate and they will meet in the middle.
They'll meet you in the middle.
I feel like there's a song there. What a boring predictable.
You start walking my way. I'll start walking yours. We'll meet in the middle.
Never heard of it again. Meet that old Georgia.
We gain a lot of ground.
It's a great song. Don't you dare disrespect country music.
It's a great country song. I don't know. Classic metaphor.
They're walking to meet each other at a tree and I'm good,
but they're also going to metaphorically moving towards each other in oneness,
hopefully biblically. We can move on. Okay. Anyway,
should I keep us on track?
The low ball offer meet in the middle strategy almost never works.
And even when you think it worked, it almost never works.
And what we mean by that is it's almost never your best strategy. Okay.
So Ian asked what is in fact a low ball offer?
What I'm not going to do is give you a math equation and tell you that, uh,
within 20% of asking price is a fair offer or a low offer.
And then it's low ball after that. It's all a bit of a, uh, an art,
a science. And the science is maybe more math is we can, we can calculate it.
We can quantify it.
So if I'm asking 500 and it's beautiful and it's marketed really well and it's
a good market, anything under 500 is a stupid offer.
Unless I know something else.
If I happen to know that there's no offers on this house for some weird reason
and that the seller has already moved out and is paying a second mortgage and
living in another city,
then maybe I have some leverage and there's nothing wrong with using that
leverage. But generally speaking, people don't even ask those questions.
They don't get that information.
People will come into a market like the one we are in today,
right now in fall of 2026. And they will just say,
let's just see if they'll take it without asking those questions,
without knowing the situation, without knowing if there's any competition,
without knowing what the home is actually worth.
Oh, that's one of the last things that they would ask.
They would look at the asking price and assume that's a relevant benchmark.
How we feel about that. We do know, but we always have to say it again.
So here we go. Courtney,
the asking price is just the headline of the advertisement.
The seller usually sadly,
because real estate agents are typically on average,
not very good at their jobs, not very professional. I'm not attacking anyone.
I am attacking everyone on average. Real estate agents are pretty bad at this.
So often they're just pricing the home based on what the seller wants,
what the seller says.
And then a buyer trying to be smart is measuring their success based on asking
price. I got it for less than the asking price.
We had to pay over asking price when in fact asking price was an arbitrary made
up number based on the seller's feelings or a neighbor or a father-in-law or the
internet or a Zestimate or AI,
which are all generally bad places to get a property value.
So I think we've set the tone. Yep. A low offer is anything below asking.
A low ball offer is unreasonably below asking.
And by unreasonable, we mean it is not based in reason.
There's no calculation. There's no, this is what this property should sell for.
This is the seller's situation. This is the buyer's timing.
This is the creative financing we're asking for, or this is the cash for those
things can make a very low offer, not low ball.
We're defining low ball as unreasonable.
It would not be unreasonable to make you a 50% of asking price offer.
If I think you're asking price is 80% over true market value.
So is a low ball offer essentially your leverage is I don't care if I get this
or not. Exactly. Yeah. Now, if you do care,
then a low ball offers even more dangerous because let me just ask the obvious
question. If you do know what your house is worth,
let's say your house is worth 400, 500,000 and you've, you've had,
you've done research homes, similar have sold similar. It's marketed.
Well, it's clean. It's presentable. There's no poor conditions or anything.
You know, it's worth 500. It could sell for more.
Might sell for a little less, but it's worth it.
And I come along and offer you three 90. What do you think about me?
What's your initial response?
Insulted. I mean, I'm going to be pissed off. Yeah. You're angry. You're insulted.
You think I'm either a jerk or an idiot. Yeah. There's,
you're certainly not thinking, Oh, that's something we need to consider.
Yeah. It's a,
it's a horrific idea because it just there's not a single positive thing going
on in the seller's mind. If you do that now, let me,
let me, if you come in at four 10 for 24 30 for like,
people need to put themselves in position of the other side is what I think.
Right. But let's go back to Courtney's point.
If you actually don't care about getting the house,
do you care about the other side? I mean, my answer is, you don't.
My answer though,
is going to turn to the actual real estate professional in saying,
why are you guiding your client this way?
Yeah. So couple caveats,
not all offers are presented with and by a professional.
Some people just float offers on their own.
Oftentimes investors and investors do this more often than the typical consumer,
but, but more and more consumers, especially in a difficult to navigate,
difficult to understand markets are doing this.
Investors will do this professionally.
They just want to make hundreds of offers and get two, three,
four accepted.
And they're getting offers accepted at 40, 50, 60% below market value.
That's the business they're in. It's a wholesale game. It's a numbers game.
We're going to make a hundred offers to get one or two accepted,
but that means every offer that gets accepted is that, you know,
40% or more discount.
Well, and oftentimes that's just an automated system.
It's an automated system or they have a new, not so good agent,
just hammering out offers. But that that's where logically it makes sense.
It's still not necessarily respectful or caring of the seller.
You are saying my goal is to kind of take advantage of a seller.
Now I'm not saying that's illegal,
but it's not something that I get excited about doing or helping someone do.
We do get excited about helping someone get the lowest possible
ethical price.
A seller is openly and honestly willing to take.
And so I don't have any problem with somebody trying to purchase a home for the
lowest possible price, right?
The problem is when buyers make the situation worse for themselves
by making a crazy low offer without any reason,
without a message to the seller. Hey, this is why.
I've actually been having a conversation with the property owner for the last
two months about how I am interested in purchasing their property,
but I would only purchase it almost $200,000,
almost, almost half of what they originally asked.
I have not even yet made an offer.
I've had an open conversation and just said, man,
I don't really know where you got that original value.
I want to communicate to you why it's not attractive to me at that price point.
I can't up my investment. I couldn't make a return on this investment.
And they've, they've decided that I'm generally right.
And they've come down to a number that I may be somewhat comfortable with.
I may still not buy it by the way,
but the point is I'm telling them why before I even make the offer.
So I think we've established that.
Now we did talk for a second about how people feel when you do this thing.
I don't want to, I just want to talk about the actual consequence of that.
What's the real risk to a buyer when they do that?
Let's just say you were selling for 500.
Well, let me preface by saying,
I think we need to like tailor this part of the conversation to a homeowner,
to a, to a buyer salary that does want the house,
but puts in a low ball offer as opposed to the one that like they don't.
So we've let's put the investor thing on the shelf. Cause we've addressed that.
That's a numbers game and it's obviously different.
So Courtney selling her house for 500, I'm a buyer.
I really do want it or I'm an agent for a buyer who really wants it. Um,
and we did the whole three 90 thing.
And now you think we're a jerk and an idiot.
Let's say I somehow still talked you down to like four 50.
I did get you to kind of meet me in the middle or below the middle of where we
started, but you still think I'm a jerk. Sure. And go ahead.
Well, I guess I want to know like,
what do you think about that being your agent strategy?
Well, I think it's in your responsible strategy.
I think it's an unsophisticated strategy,
but I'm trying to paint the picture now that let's say that it looks like it
worked. Let's say that you, you're like, well,
I actually think this strategy is great because I got Courtney down to four 50.
I feel like I already know where you're going.
I'm not going to want to give on anything else,
but now I need an extra day to close. Cause my Linda just told me that.
And you're like, yeah, forget you. Right. You know what? You need a day,
50 grand. Right. Give me $50,000. I'm going to sell it to somebody else.
You've made this unfair and just ridiculous.
I need you to pay for the survey because I don't have quite a lot of cash to
closing right now because I'm getting transferred for my job. Right.
I'm kind of floating the salary right now. And you're like, no.
And this came up in inspection about no. Right. No.
And my agent is saying to you, Hey,
we need an amendment to repair a little wood rot on the, no,
I'm moving on. No, but my loan won't get approved if I don't get soil grading.
I'm moving on.
That's exactly how somebody is going to respond to you after you think,
your brain dead strategy of just throw a crazy low number worked,
by the way, it never worked. But in the rare statistical anomaly,
one out of a thousand, two out of a thousand where it works,
that's what you get to deal with later. And it costs you money later,
time later, energy later, opportunities later, home later,
family ease and sleep later.
And it costs you respect and relationship and decency in the community.
I'm not saying you need to be everybody's best friend and give away money to
be nice, but that's not what we're saying.
We're just saying there's a much better way to get a better deal on a house
than just lobbing grenades at people of unfounded,
unreasonable, crazy low prices. Okay.
So I think we've made that point,
but maybe what we haven't fully communicated is I guess degrees of
this or a better way. So we've got plenty of notes,
plenty of directions we could go here. What do you guys want to jump in?
Where I'm going to go while you're thinking is the better way is to have
a reason. Okay. So you might be asking 500 and I might say to you, Hey,
Courtney, or I might be an agent talking to your agent. Hey, look,
this is a beautiful house. You guys have done a great job getting it ready for
market. I don't know if you have any other interest or not.
I can tell you this. My clients absolutely in love with it.
They'd love to live there,
but here's the four reasons they can't or won't pay 500.
Is there any reason your client would be responsive if we were to send an offer
much lower or should I just tell them to move on? Now,
if I asked you that, would you be offended? No, feels very kind. Yeah.
But would you maybe still be disappointed? Sure. Yeah. But of course,
could you live with that? Yeah.
Now what if you had seven other offers all at or above 500 and you're just like,
Hey, thanks, but no, thanks. We've got tons of interest.
That's like, it's not going to happen. I don't, I don't blame you for trying,
but don't waste your time. Drawing that up is never going to happen.
And then I go to my client and I go, Hey, they got four other offers.
She was very sweet. She just said, don't waste our time.
Isn't that they're not even going to look at that.
Yeah. I mean, just like, don't,
you don't want to burn bridges because you never know. Also, well,
as an agent,
you may come across another listing of this sort of agent at some point and
they're going to remember. Okay. Now I'm so glad you said that you want to give
them a little good job here. Okay. Now let me ask an obvious question.
If I'm a client,
why do I care what some other agent thinks about my agent from six months ago
or 12 months ago or three years ago?
And we can answer the question for you.
You may think what your agent did with and for a client a year ago doesn't
matter.
But if Courtney is the agent and I insulted her twice and
told her I didn't care, treated her like I didn't care.
And now she's the agent for the house.
You really want to buy and I call her and she sees my name come up on her
phone and she's like, Oh great. This is that freaking jerk.
You just throw stuff out. Has no reasons. Doesn't answer questions.
What is she?
Even if she is trying to be maximum professional
subconsciously,
what is she going to do when she goes and backs goes back to talk to her seller
about my buyer and our offer this guy. Yeah.
Talk negatively about the age.
Even even if you're trying not to, it's like, well, the offer's okay. Right.
Even if you never said, I know this agent and he's a jerk.
Even if you tried deliberately not to do that, it's like, look,
here's the offer. It's not great. It's low. This is what it's like. You know,
they're, they're asking for a 10 day option period that most people only want
seven. That's a note. Like you're like, no matter how hard you try,
it's going to seep through that. My,
that agent's past behavior is going to paint how you communicate
their new clients offer to your client.
So if you're listening and you didn't follow that,
if your agent has a reputation of lazy strategy,
like just hammering people with low ball offers or not leading and guiding
people through the transaction, just doing whatever the buyer,
the investor,
the client wants and they do willy nilly junk like this without a good reason,
without good communication, without respect to the other side,
without a strategy that has any track record of success,
it's going to end up costing you. So by the way,
I say this as one of the top real estate teams in all of North Texas,
but the most reviews of any agent in DFW,
just because a team is big doesn't mean they're better. Sometimes it does,
but sometimes it just means they've wheeled and dealed and hammered and pounded
their way through the, through the marketplace.
And their reputation might be what we just said.
Their reputation might be a bully just bulldozing people,
treating people terribly. We get a lot of calls from sellers that are like,
I had an agent, they were the worst. We're right. We want to work with you.
And so be careful who you work with. Now,
if you're a buyer and you're thinking about, you know,
I want a $400,000 house. Don't go look at $500,000 houses.
In this market, you might be able to look at $430,000 houses.
You might potentially, depending on where you're looking at,
go find a seven or eight or 9% below market opportunity right now,
but you're not likely to find a 10 or 20 or 30% below market value unless it's a
unique situation. Remember I said at the very beginning,
I'm not saying it's never ever appropriate to offer way lower than asking.
I'm saying it's not appropriate to do that without knowledge,
without research, without relationship, without skillful communication,
without a strategy, the idea of come in way low, meet in the middle.
It just almost never works. And even when you think it works,
it usually ends up being a really bad scenario for everyone involved.
And often those transactions never close and fund.
I can paint a hundred versions of when it could work. Estate situations.
When somebody is motivated more by getting out than getting the most money,
they're motivated more by you taking it as is than them having to clean it up.
Those are rare. But again, that would be a reason,
a situation where that offer way below asking price makes sense.
Remember a couple of key things we said,
asking price does not always mean value. It's just whatever somebody said.
It's just that we call it the headline to the advertisement.
Doesn't mean it's accurate.
Doesn't mean they did any math or any science or there's any art to it.
I do want to circle back. The art piece is how it's delivered,
how it's communicated, how it's timed, what we learned before we make the offer.
There's a ton more we could say,
but I do want to go to you two real quick and just say, you know,
have we beat the point to death or is there anything we're leaving out?
I want to encourage people that there's still great opportunity to get a great
deal on a home.
You just need more strategy than throw out the lowest number you can think of
and hope it works.
Yeah. That's the main takeaway I think for people is you have to stop thinking
about it. How, uh,
you may have thought about it in the past or your parents,
grandparents may have thought about it. I know growing up in England,
that was the way you got a house. I mean, that's just haggled.
It's just what everybody did. Oh, we love a haggle. We love a haggle.
Um, but that was it. Like it was like, well, we're going to list it here.
So we know that they're probably going to come in here and then we'll just settle
for here. And it's like, that was just the way it was for everybody.
And honestly it still is.
I, I,
what I am walking away with is this is a really great question to bring to your
agent when you're interviewing them. How might you handle this scenario?
I'm wanting to really maximize my money. You know, we're,
we come up against this situation and how are you going to handle it?
Yeah. I think a great way to ask that question is, Hey,
what's your offer strategy? Like how do you create offers?
How do you pick a number? How do you communicate that? What are the,
what all do you consider when we make an offer?
It's not just like what payment can you afford? What do you want to pay?
Although that is a factor. There's nothing wrong with that being a factor. Uh,
and then of course on the selling sides, similarly,
like what's your marketing strategy?
What's your approach to getting me higher offers, better offers,
cleaner offers, less requests, less knickknack stuff, things like that. Um,
how do you determine asking price? I mean,
everyone just assumes it's what the house is worth, but that's,
that's actually a bad way. Um, it's a, you need to know what the house is worth,
but you don't just type what it's worth into the computer and spit out.
That's our asking price. That's actually a really bad way to do it.
Most agents would disagree with me because they don't have any other strategy.
They've never considered. There's a lot of different ways to do this.
If we can ever help you, we are the Todd Traumani home selling team.
I am Todd Traumani. You can go to Todd Traumani team.com.
You can find out all sorts of information about us. Of course,
you can look us up online. However you like Google us, whatever.
We have more five-star reviews and more total reviews than any real estate team
in all of DFW.
And we are proud of that because every one of those is somebody telling you what
they think about us, whether they're a past buyer, a past seller,
they might be a vendor partner or a friend that is literally just telling you,
you can trust these people. This is what they do well.
This is how they help me or this is how I would want to use them.
That kind of thing. So check it out. However you want to look us up,
Todd Traumani, Todd Traumani team.com.
We are here to help not make Louisville offers,
but get you phenomenal deals on homes when you're buying. And of course,
when you sell,
we still guarantee to sell that home over the average price and under the
average time.