What made the rapid downfall of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang—the star of the AI boom and one of the world’s richest people—all the more stunning was that it revealed he lacked the modern control of his company that other larger-than-life tech founders, through super-voting ownership shares, can exert to prevent such a total loss of power.
That’s because the chipmaker went public in 1999. Five years later two young Stanford computer scientists went to bankers with an unusual request about the public listing of their red-hot startup. Google cofounders Larry Page and Sergey Brin wanted their extraordinary control over the then startup to continue when it became a public company.
The wunderkinds got what they asked for: dual-class shares that gave them 10 votes for every one share when the search giant went public in 2004. Even now, seven years after they retired from their day-to-day roles at Google, Brin and Page still control 53% of the company’s voting power. No matter what happens, these controlling shares allow Page and Brin to call the shots on any board seat, charter changes or succession plans. And when Brin wanted to return to Google to work on its AI models in 2023 as he became emboldened by the race to superintelligence, he likely didn’t have to ask anyone for permission.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Today on Forbes,
why Jensen Huang's firing couldn't happen to Mark Zuckerberg or many
other tech titans.
NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang has been the star of the AI boom
and one of the world's richest
people.
What made his rapid downfall all the more stunning
was that it revealed he lacked the
modern control of his company that other larger-than-life
tech founders, through super-voting ownership
shares, can exert to prevent such a total loss of power.
That's because the chipmaker went public in 1999.
Five years later, two young Stanford computer scientists
went to bankers with an unusual request
about the public listing of their red-hot startup.
Google co-founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin
wanted their extraordinary control over the then-startup
to continue when it became a public company.
The wunderkinds got what they asked for.
dual-class shares that gave them 10 votes for every one share
when the search giant went public
in 2004. Even now,
seven years after they retired from their day-to-day roles at Google,
Page and Brin still control 53% of the company's voting power.
No matter what happens,
these controlling shares allow Page
and Brin to call the shots on any board seat,
charter changes, or succession plans.
And when Brin wanted to return to Google
to work on its AI models in 2023,
as he became emboldened by the race to superintelligence,
he likely didn't have to ask anyone for permission.
After Google, tech companies including Meta,
Alphabet, Snap, and SpaceX followed suit.
In Meta's case, it instituted a dual-class system in November 2009,
before its 2012 IPO.
This came apparently at the suggestion of Napster co-founder
and former Facebook president,
Sean Parker
Zuckerberg currently owns 99% of Meta's super voting class B shares
and has 61% of the overall
voting power, making him almost unfireable and unaccountable.
His friend and Facebook co-founder
Dustin Moskowitz, in a 2023 interview with Forbes,
asked rhetorically, quote,
can you gather all the other common shareholders to vote against Mark?
No, you can't. And Zuckerberg himself said at the time, quote,
There are plenty of companies in the world
that have a lot of capital, that don't have
the leadership or board structure
that enables them to take big bets on the future.
We're a founder-controlled company.
Most recently, Anthropix S1 detailed
an even more insulated structure in which its seven
co-founders will own a single voting share through
an LLC with 50.1% of the company's
voting power when it goes public.
Unlike Meta and Alphabet,
where co-founders maintain control as long as they keep enough
super-voting stock, the Anthropic co-founder's
50.1% ownership doesn't shrink as they sell or
give away shares. Each co-founder has pledged
to donate 80% of his or her equity.
In fact, nearly half of all tech companies
that went public in the U.S. last year
had a dual-class structure, up from just 5% in 2004,
according to data compiled by University
of Florida finance professor Jay Ritter.
Unfortunately for Huang, he took NVIDIA public too early,
when a one-share, one-vote structure
was the standard for Silicon Valley IPOs.
Similarly, Jeff Bezos has no super-voting shares in Amazon,
which went public in 1997.
Nor does Bill Gates, who took Microsoft public in 1986.
Huang's resignation from NVIDIA's board
and the CEO job leaves him with his 3.6% stake
in the company's equity, worth about $145 billion.
That's down from a peak of over $200 billion in early October,
before the scandal.
He also has only 3.6% of the company's voting power,
making him a large shareholder, but
nothing more.
In fact, institutional investors BlackRock
and Vanguard each control roughly twice as
many votes as Huang.
Any involvement Huang has at Nvidia now,
formal or informal, won't entirely be up to him.
Forbes estimates that if Nvidia had used
a standard 10-vote dual-class structure, Huang's
voting power would have been around 26%,
which would have given him far greater leverage
during board deliberations,
though still not a supermajority that would have made him virtually
Of course, for years, Huang did not really need super-voting shares.
His operational dominance and Nvidia's massive growth kept the board
and shareholders aligned.
UBS Managing Director Jason Katz says,
If you have a superstar, you don't want to poke the bear.
Indeed, most investors did not bat an eye
at the company's unusual management structure.
That included Huang having 60 direct reports
and the company having no succession plans.
Most investors had long ago become infatuated with the charismatic,
leather-jacketed leader
who turned a small video game graphic chips maker
into the world's most valuable company.
And neither did the company's board,
which has long been known to be extremely loyal to its leader
over his more than three decades in control.
For instance, board members had discussed
setting up a succession plan over the years,
but Huang opposed the idea,
so no plan was ever set in place. That according to the New York Times.
For full coverage,
check out Alicia Park and Ian Martin's piece on Forbes.com.
This is Kieran Meadows from Forbes. Thanks for tuning in.