Footage: Rome (2005-2007) Rise of Empires: Ottomans (2019) Gladiator (2001) Pope Joan (2009) Voltaire et l'affaire Calas" (2007) Taboo (2014) Amazing Grace (2006) Medici (2016) Quo Vadis (1951) Barbarians (2020) Cleopatra (2023) Music: Imperator: Rome Soundtrack - We The People Imperator Rome: Soundtrack - Caesarion Europa Universalis IV Soundtrack - Castle of Versailles Europa Universalis IV Soundtrack - A New King Arrives Crusader Kings 2 Soundtrack - The Byzantine Empire
00:00 Intro 00:26 Early Popularity 02:05 Enlightenment Attacks 05:00 The Decline And Fall 10:56 Revival 14:48 Looking Forward
When it comes to popular historical subjects Classical Rome is up there in the top with the
Second World War and the ancient Egyptians. Byzantine history, on the other hand,
barely receives any attention, despite being its direct continuation. In this video we are
going to figure out how this happened, how did the popular image of the Byzantine Empire form
and is this likely to change any time soon. The popularity of Classical Rome isn’t hard
to explain. Ancient Romans were all about looking cool and winning big. Liking Roman
history is a nerd equivalent of being a fan of a dominant football team. So it is more or
less expected that Byzantium, which wasn’t as dominant, garners way less interest. However,
popular ignorance about the Eastern Roman Empire is still vastly disproportionate to
its historical significance, even if we take objective factors into account. That’s because
there are also subjective factors at play. Believe it or not, before the 18th century,
Byzantine history was actually very popular in Europe. Often when people talk about the origins
of the term “Byzantium”, there is this narrative that “The Evil West” always tried to denigrate and
besmirch the Eastern Romans by any means, but that wasn’t really the case. Hieronymus Wolf,
the guy who coined the term, didn’t do it with malicious intent. He actually contributed quite a
lot to the studies of the Eastern Roman Empire. He considered the Byzantine History a subject that is
separate , but not inferior to Classical Rome. His works and the works of his disciples made
Byzantium a very popular topic among European scholars. Different groups were attracted to it
for different reasons. The Catholics studied it to work towards a union with the Orthodox church,
while the Protestants related to its anti-papal narratives. France became the main center of
Eastern Roman studies when Louis XIV sponsored the publication of the first complete edition of
Byzantine historical sources. Things were looking very optimistic for all Byzantium enjoyers.
But everything changed when the Enlightenment nation attacked.
There were two big Enlightenment trends that are important to us:
liking Classical Antiquity and skepticism of religion. I bet you can see how this would be
detrimental to the popularity of Byzantium. Dismissal of the Eastern Romans can already be
found quite early in the works of French Enlightenment thinkers like
Montesquieu and Voltaire. Here’s what Voltaire writes:
“There is another history even more ridiculous: that is Byzantine history.
This unworthy collection contains only declamations and miracles:
it is the disgrace of the human mind, just as the Greek empire was the reproach of the earth.”
French Enlightenment was also, among other things, about dunking on Louis XIV and French
Absolutism. And considering the fact that Louis was a patron of Byzantine Studies,
they quickly fell out of fashion by association. Because of this association,
the Byzantine Empire started being branded as “Oriental Despotism”, even though Montesquie
himself argues that Eastern Romans weren’t paying enough respect to government authority.
Louis was despotic, and he liked Byzantium, that means it was also a despotism.
The Eastern Roman Empire simply didn’t fit into the Enlightenment's narrative of world history.
Classical Rome and Greece were supposed to be the progenitors of “The West”, and the Persian
Empire was the embodiment of “The East”. These two weren’t supposed to be linked at all, so
the Byzantine history with its fusion of western and eastern influences was dismissed and ignored.
To drive the point home, the Eastern Roman Empire was called “a sad epilogue to the glory of Rome”,
“a tissue of rebellions, insurrections and treachery” and “a thousand years of decline”.
Byzantine art and architecture were discarded as derivative, reconquests - as insignificant
and technological achievements - as fictional. Voltaire even denies that Greek fire ever existed,
because how could such a backwards civilization produce such an advanced technology.
Now, mind you, these weren’t yet works of history in an academic sense. For Montesquieu and Voltaire
history is more of a branch of literature and a field to promote their philosophical theories by
cherry picking fitting examples. In every age, there’s no shortage of windbags claiming that
the entire world history proves their political views and they don’t necessarily have an impact on
people who are doing actual historical research. But in 1776 along came a book that ingrained the
idea of Byzantine inferiority in the minds of academics and in, the words of Cristopher Kelly,
“killed the Byzantine studies for nearly a century”. I am talking, of course,
about Edward Gibbon’s “The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire”.
Gibbon was also a man of Enlightenment, and as such, he really wanted to convince people that
the Roman Empire fell because of Christianity. But this thesis can’t work if there is a Christian
Roman Empire in the East that lives on for another thousand years. That’s why he had to employ the
same tactics as the French and denigrate Byzantium as “the triumph of barbarism and religion”.
It’s pretty obvious that Gibbon didn’t actually want to write about the later Empire. For context,
he spends 3 full chapters and a total of about 100 pages on Julian the Apostate who only ruled
for 3 years, but speedruns from the Birth of Islam to the Fourth Crusade in 50 pages.
The worst thing about “The Decline and Fall” is that it is actually a very well-written book. Had
Gibbon been a bad writer his magnum opus would’ve been quickly forgotten since no one has the
patience to read through six volumes of sub-par prose. But, unfortunately for the progress of the
Byzantine studies, Edward Gibbon was an excellent writer. The first volumes up to the reign of
Heraclius are very detailed and present a solid analysis of factors that led to the collapse of
Roman rule in the West. Gibbon’s rigor in working with the primary sources that were available to
him was unprecedented for the time. In terms of historical methodology the book was revolutionary.
For academic history it did what “Wealth of Nations” did for the field of economics.
Sure, there is a very clear bias, but this bias was easily palatable for the 18th century reader.
Gibbon simply projects the intellectual mainstream of his age to the historical work he’s writing.
The influence of Voltaire and Montesquieu are obvious and apparent. Throughout “Decline and
Fall” there are 51 mentions of Montesquieu and 41 - of Voltaire. It was also an especially hot topic
for the British audience. The Whigs of 18th century England, including Gibbon, viewed the
Romans as honorary Englishmen, the Roman senate as a proto-parliament and thought that the British
empire was currently living through a golden age of stability and prosperity akin to the age
of Augustus. The contemporary period in English literature is even called “Augustan humanism”.
It’s pretty ironic to us how Gibbon posited the stability of British rule in a book published mere
weeks before the American revolution, but that was the dominant political view of the British elite
at the time: “Britain is the new Rome, because of the freedoms and political representation”.
The anti-religious vibe may seem detrimental to the book’s mainstream popularity, but that
wasn’t really the case. Gibbon doesn't offer a blanket condemnation of Christianity as a whole,
that wouldn’t have passed censorship in 18th century Britain. Instead,
he criticizes the hierarchical clergy and the involvement of the Church in secular affairs,
which is a pretty standard Protestant take. The “Decline and Fall” turned out to be incredibly
influential. It propelled ancient Rome to new heights of popularity and pioneered a new,
more academic and analytical methodology for the discipline of history.
Unfortunately, it also did great damage to the reputation of the Byzantine Empire
and its popularity as a historical subject. The fact that Gibbon writes with such passion about
the earlier periods and then just loses all interest after Heraclius signaled to
the audience that there’s probably not anything interesting after that. And Gibbon clearly states
that himself. The summary of his Chapter 48 is “Everything past Heraclius is hella
boring and you shouldn’t bother with it. Except maybe the Komnenians, they’re kind of OK.”
Should I persevere in the same course, should I observe the same measure, a prolix and slender
thread would be spun through many a volume, nor would the patient reader find an adequate reward
of instruction or amusement. At every step, as we sink deeper in the decline and fall of the Eastern
empire, the annals of each succeeding reign would impose a more ungrateful and melancholy task.
These annals must continue to repeat a tedious and uniform tale of weakness and misery…
And the readers of the time took this advice to heart. Whenever you look into mentions of
Byzantium in the Western sources of the next 100 years, it’s all about “oriental despotism”,
“superstitious barbarians”, “effeminate weaklings” and “backwards Asiatics”.
Gibbon isn’t actually the worst in this regard, even though he was the main influencer of this
trend. Occasionally he has something nice to say about Byzantium, so for the most egregious
takes we should look to his disciples. This passage from an Irish essayist William Lecky
can just be the apogee of Gibbonism. “Of that Byzantine Empire the universal
verdict of history is that it constitutes, without a single exception, the most thoroughly
base and despicable form civilisation has yet assumed. Though very cruel and very sensual,
there have been times when cruelty assumed more ruthless, and sensuality more extravagant aspects;
but there has been no other enduring civilisation so absolutely destitute of all forms and elements
of greatness…The Byzantine Empire was preeminently the age of treachery. Its vices were the vices of
men who ceased to be brave without learning to be virtuous…slaves were willing to be slaves, in
both their actions and their thoughts, immersed in sensuality and in the most frivolous pleasure…The
history of the empire is a monstrous story of the intrigues of priests, eunuchs, and women,
of poisonings, of conspiracies, of uniform ingratitude, of perpetual fratricides.”
If I sincerely believed this to be true, I wouldn’t want to learn about Byzantium either.
But not everything was that bleak. Despite the many slights from the Classical Rome fans,
true Byzantine enjoyers remained steadfast. In 1856 a Scottish historian George Finlay
published the first volume of his “History of the Byzantine Empire”. It was much more substantive
than Gibbon’s writings and didn’t have such a blatant bias. Everyone now saw how fascinating
the Eastern Roman Empire was and Byzantine history became more popular in Victorian
England than tea and crumpets. Well, not exactly.
But at least now there was an alternative to the doomer narrative of Gibbon. For once, a history
of Byzantium in English was being written by people who actually enjoyed the subject.
The appearance of many new Byzantine scholars in the late 1800s wasn’t a
coincidence. Greece finally got its independence in 1829. The Greek Independence War saw Russian,
French and British soldiers fighting for the Greek cause. George Finlay was one of them.
Over the next few decades the contact between European powers and Greece have strengthened,
more translations of the medieval works have appeared and a greater appreciation
for the Byzantine studies have emerged. The following decades were a long struggle
against Gibbon’s legacy both in academic circles and in popular imagination. The efforts in the
first department were more successful: new Byzantine histories were written in Britain,
Germany and Russia. Indexing the works of Emperor Konstantin Porphirogenetos reinvigorated
researchers’ interest in the empire’s heritage. Irish historian J.B. Bury was the first to argue
against using the word “Byzantium” to restore Eastern Romans to their historical identity.
By the middle of the XX century the academic field had fully recovered from the blow dealt
by Gibbon’s book. George Ostrogorsky’s “History of the Byzantine State” is a perfect summarization of
the work done in those decades to restore the image of the Eastern Roman Empire.
But the mainstream perception lagged quite far behind. With the advent of cinema and Hollywood,
historical epics about classical Rome soon became some of the biggest cinematic attractions.
“Spartacus”, “Quo Vadis”, “Ben Hur” and “The Fall of the Roman Empire” all attracted massive budgets
and big audiences, thus further contributing to Rome’s popularity. The Byzantines, on the other
hand, had no representation on the big screen. The Eastern Roman Empire remained a niche subject for
a few enthusiasts, not a household name that could attract a casual audience.
But things were slowly getting better. People interested in history were getting
more material about Byzantium. Writers like John Julius Norwich and Lars Brownworth based their
popular history books on the works that came long after Gibbon and with that they managed to present
a much more sympathetic image of the Eastern Roman Empire: not a tedious tale of misery,
but a gripping story with many ups and downs filled with ensembles of memorable characters.
Even though the information in those books is considered outdated by the modern academic
standards, for many readers they became an entry point to the many-faceted history of
the underappreciated empire. The stereotypes of backwardness, religious fanaticism and effeminacy
were being slowly but steadily whittled away. Don’t get me wrong, Gibbonist views are still
alive and well. Particularly in the West, if you meet someone who has heard about Byzantium,
chances are his or her first associations would be “backwards Asiatics” and “1000
years of decline”. They may not be aware where they got it from, but you can be sure they’ll
accuse you of trying to “rewrite history” if you dare to challenge those notions.
Despite this, my outlook on the future of public knowledge about Eastern Romans is still positive.
More and more people are discovering Byzantine history for the first time through social media,
Youtube videos and podcasts. The academic Byzantine studies have been a big mess for a
couple of decades, with all the old dogmas being challenged and every topic having 5 competing
claims at the same time, but that’s probably what an active research discipline should look
like. Looking at how the big historical productions from Hollywood and Netflix
have been turning out lately, I am kind of glad they’ve been ignoring Byzantium so far. God knows
we don’t need anymore rage-bait at this moment. Hopefully, one day we will get something good.
I hope you enjoyed this video. Tell me in the comments if you think that Byzantine history is
likely to become more popular in the near future. I’d like to thank my patrons Moulay Cherkaoui,
Conventus Orbis, Pyykkimies and others, who are supporting me on Patreon. And for the rest of you,
thanks a lot for watching and I will see you in the next one.