Why historical SHIELDS were LIGHTER than modern replicas?

Eternal Shield
2 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 20, 2026
Many modern replicas of shields are TOO HEAVY, but ironically some are too light. Here we look at why.
Why were many historical shields actually a lot lighter than modern replicas and why were some
of them actually heavier? Hi folks, Matt Eaton here, Scholar Gladiator, so I'm going to try and
keep this concise honestly and simple. So fundamentally a lot of modern replica shields
are made in a different way and from different materials to original shields because they're
made for different purposes. So many shields that you'll encounter in the modern world are either
made for decorative purposes or many of them are made for reenactment. Now reenactment shields
clearly are not used for exactly the same purposes or in exactly the same ways as original historical
shields. They're also often made of different materials and those two things are often related.
So let's just pick up a different type of shield for a second. So let's put that Norman shield down
there and let's pick up the Viking era boss grip shield. So first of all reenactment shields are
expected to last week in, week out, month in, month out, sometimes year in, year out, even decade in,
decade out and they are repeatedly hit by blunt weapons. With the main priority really of most
reenactments or certainly perhaps not these days but certainly in the last 30 years reenactment
shields one of the priorities of them was durability. Now it also has to be said that while
you want your shield to be more durable and that would naturally lead it to be made thicker and
heavier with heavier components, we'll get into the individual components in a second, in addition
there's also an element of ignorance. Now I don't mean that in a mean way but quite simply we know
a lot more about historical shields whether it's Anglo-Saxon and Viking era shields, whether it's
Roman shields, whether it's you know Norman shields, whether it's later medieval and Renaissance
shields, bucklers and all things like this. We'll get into ethnographic stuff a bit here as well not
just European. So let's have a look at this shield. So this is actually a pretty good reconstruction
however it's not perfect. There are a number of things about this that are different to a real
historical Viking shield. Firstly it is made of plywood not planks. So the original shields would
have been planks glued together, not particularly durable. Many of you will know that in the Viking
era during a Viking duel you were allowed three shields and the three shields were expected to
break and fall apart. Different ideas about durability. A reenacted shield is not expected
to fall apart on a regular basis so they're built heavier and chunkier in some cases
but also they're made of a different material. Plywood is very very strong but they didn't use
plywood, they used planks. Planks which split, which fall apart. The glues aren't as strong, they didn't
have modern resins and epoxies and such like. So this is made of a heavier denser material than
the original ones which leads to it being heavier. Moreover even little details like some of the
sort of ironwork and fittings, fixtures and fittings, sometimes even the grips and the handles
tend to be on reenactment shields made more chunky than the originals were and something which often
gets overlooked are the bosses. If you actually look at the thickness or gauge of the iron and
steel used on migration era and later kind of Viking era bosses they tend to be much thinner
than most replica ones because of course if these are repeatedly being hit by blunt swords and axes
you want that to protect your hand number one but you also want it to last and period ones quite
simply if one broke they just throw the thing away and get another one even within a Viking
duel they might go through three shields. So Viking era shield often the components oh and very
important element so not only is the shield board made of planks but it's often tapered so if we
look at the surviving remnants of those found archaeologically often they might be about 1-1.2
thick of the board at the base here but they get thinner towards the edges whereas usually plywood
ones aren't tapered they can be and some people go to the lengths of tapering them. Now historically
of course the main reason why you want a shield to be light is to be quick you want to be able
to hold it out for a long time you want to be able to march for miles or ride for miles carrying it
or wearing it easily but equally in combat you want the thing to be nimble if it gets chopped
up or split or falls apart in combat it's not a disaster so long as it lasts that duel or that
battle you can always get another one these are disposable objects unlike the reenactment versions
so very often not only are reenactment versions made of denser and heavier type of wood plywood
but they've also got heavier fixtures and fittings and they are made to last in a way that many
historical shields simply weren't now obviously there are exceptions if there are certain types
of helmet shield rather from history which are known to be quite heavy by comparison with other
shields of the day so three examples i'm gonna pick on here are number one the greek hoplite
shield okay so the hoplite shield can be made various constructions some of its conjectural
but fairly thick wood in a domed or convex shape with a bronze covering now whenever you're putting
metal on top of wood you're gonna end up with something quite heavy and now this is bearable
for the simple fact that these are strapped shields essentially so unlike boss grip shields
which are held in the hand out often at arm's length and moved around quite a lot any type of
shield which is held close to the body you are able to sustain a heavier weight so there's one
example another example is roman shields now roman scutum are held down by the body and here i have
a reconstruction of a roman scutum and there's no beating around the bush these are quite heavy
shields but because of the way that they're held almost like a suitcase you can march with them for
long distances and even in use they're kept relatively close to the body so they are sustainable
now because of the way that the roman scutum was used and bear in mind there were many different
designs they weren't all exactly of this shape there were slightly more more oval ones and ones
not quite as big as this they because of the way they're used they sort of number one you can bear
their weight but number two their weight can actually be advantageous to the formation so
that's one thing the final example is the pavis i don't actually own a pavis but i've been lucky
enough to handle a couple of dozen original 15th and 16th century pavises in austria and germany
and they are often very heavy and very thick and superficially they look a little bit like a roman
scutum however of course they're often designed to be stood on the ground and they're often designed
for people like crossbowmen to reload their crossbows behind in some cases they're used at
sieges they're not necessarily used in other types of warfare and there are different types of pavis
so if you've got a very large shield it's going to tend to be heavier than a smaller shield obviously
but additionally if it's carried or used or transported or used in certain ways in certain
types of battle or by certain types of troops then you might want it to be particularly thick
and particularly heavy and i would say the three obvious examples famous examples from history
there are others are that roman scutum the greek coplight shield and the uh the pavis however i
will caveat that with when we're coming to the world of replicas okay and modern replications
my observation is that roman scutum tend to be a little bit overweight
unless they're the indian replicas and when they sometimes tend to be underweight so replica
shields can end up being too heavy or too light and too flimsy it can go either direction
with the row with the sorry the greek shields i actually haven't seen a really faithful good
replica of a greek hoplite shield in my own hands however it's my observation that when i've seen
online people making reproductions of them they tend to i think slightly use over heavy
construction in both the wood and the bronze and when we look at the surviving elements of the
archaeological remnants that we have or details with it i think we're probably looking at something
which is a little bit lighter than some of the replicas now ironically with the pavises my
observation is most replica pavises aren't as heavy as the originals because some of the originals are
exceedingly thick wooden section in the middle and because of the way that they are made and
carved out of thick pieces of wood and put together in a planked construction with plank and dowel
they are actually more chunky than a lot of the replicas which superficially look like a 15th
century pavise but don't feel like a 15th century pavise in your hand so we've got several things
at play there we've got the fact that modern reproduction shields are used in a different way
than they would have been historically they're not carried for long marches they're not used
perhaps as lightly and nimbly and seen as disposable as the historical ones were they're
expected to last a long period of time against blunt weapon impacts number two we've got a degree
of different materials using plywood instead of plank and things like this and using modern glues
rather than sort of thicker wood and dowel construction and perhaps doing full leather
or kind of rawhide coverings on some of the shields and finally we've got the fact that
sometimes it's just ignorance it's difficult because of the way that these things archaeologically
survive to get enough information about the originals to make a faithful replica that's all
being said they are getting better and better and there are more and more good quality replica
shields around right finally i'm going to talk about ethnographic a lot of people fixate on
european history medieval renaissance ancient you know classical world but there are a whole
other family of shields both from european history but also from african asian even north american
history where the primary material of the shield isn't necessarily wood this is rhino hide this is
an indian shield but equally we can find shields made of wicker or various types of cow hide raw
hide other types of animal of course sometimes completely different like rattan shields for
example in china so completely different materials essentially basket work shields so shields can
take many different forms than just a big old plank of wood they can be made of many different
materials and in fact these hide shields this is you'll see it's about a centimeter thick rhino
hide in asia and africa we find rhino hippo elephant buffalo loads of different animals
used for their hides to make shields and these shields they might not be as durable as your
however they are more than durable enough for one or several you know mortal fatal encounters
duels battlefield skirmishes whatever and in this case this has still got the original straps and
pad on incidentally if this is lighter and nimbler but still strong enough to stop swords and spears
and arrows and things like that then that's perfect that's what you want you want the shield to be
strong enough to stop the typical weapons being directed at you and they might penetrate but so
long as they don't get to you and it can be chopped up and it can be damaged but so long as it protects
you you want it to be as light and nimble as possible very often and this even goes over into
steel shields as well so very often when we look at reproductions of steel shields be they bucklers
or large rotellas or indeed these indian dal when we look at the replica ones they tend to use
something like 1.5 millimeter steel and very often when we look at the originals they're actually
thinner than that and there's no real chance of something like a sword or even an arrow getting
through one of these and wounding the person behind so so long as they are thick enough let's
say one millimeter to protect the person and function as a quick nimble buckler or shield
that's what you want you don't want them to necessarily last for 20 years against blunt
weapons because they'd have to be too heavy for that purpose so there we go it's all about the
context really isn't it you've really got to look at what is the shield actually made for is it made
for a reenactor is it made for a movie set is it made for display on the wall or is it actually
made for campaigning for dueling for warfare for battles for skirmishes and these are different
priorities and that also will change over period as to over time over history as what materials
available obviously plywood offers all sorts of advantages for durability but it is tends to be
relatively heavy compared to a plank of wood but it's way more durable and far less likely to split
of course so all of these things and little things like the thickness of the boss or indeed if we're
looking at other organic materials like various types of hide and leather or indeed things like
wicker and some of the wicker and rattan shields can actually be extremely light and they might
not be durable enough for typical reenactors but they're certainly durable enough for people who
are going to take them to war and if they get damaged or broken they'll just get another one
so very different priorities also different materials and it's fun learning about these
things and i would really like to see us starting to see shields as important to get right replicating
as swords and bows and all of the other things that we pay a lot of attention to for historical
accuracy i'd love to see people starting to get the shields more correct because i think it will
inform our knowledge and our understanding of how these things were used and remember that shields
historically have been one of the most important types of arms and armor and important pieces of
equipment used by humankind in warfare going way back into prehistory anyway i have been matt
easton i will of course continue to be i'll see you back on the channel soon cheers folks thanks
for watching we've got extra videos on patreon please give our facebook a like
and subscribe if you haven't already cheers folks
