Why Does This Man Appear Twice in the Same Painting? | Duccio’s Healing of a Man Born Blind

Medieval Art (c.500–1400)
2 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 27, 2025
Dr Ayla Lepine, The Howard and Roberta Ahmanson Fellow in Art and Religion, explains something we may not have even noticed in this picture - a man who appears twice.
Hi, my name is Ayla Lapine. I'm the Amundsen Fellow in Art and Religion here at the National Gallery
and today I'm going to be exploring the question, why is this man depicted twice
and what can that tell us about miracles? This small painting by Duccio is one of the earliest
in the National Gallery's collection. It's a fascinating image which is part of a much
bigger altarpiece. The National Gallery has three panels from that giant double-sided altarpiece
which is from Siena from the cathedral in the early 14th century. It was constructed between
about 1307, 1308 and 1311. The panel that we're looking at today is most likely from towards the
end of that period. The three panels that the Gallery has are part of the predella which is
the lower section of that altarpiece. We have an image of the Annunciation, we have our image for
today, Christ healing a man who was born blind, and right next to it we have an image which is
called the Transfiguration. All of these are from the Bible's New Testament and our story is from
the Gospel of John from chapter 9. In this image we see something extraordinary which is really
easy to miss because it looks like a pretty unremarkable little figure just here and this
little figure has a stick, has little red boots, has a brown cloak and has a little carrying case
which is attached to him by a rope. He's having an incredible miraculous encounter with Jesus.
So what's happening here is that we have a crowd who are pressing in on Jesus behind and all of
them are fascinated by what's happening here. And here we have an image of Christ in his blue robe
with little bits of gold edging as he does something very very strange. In the story he's
just been on the ground making a paste of soil and his own saliva. Then he takes that paste and he
rubs it onto the man's eyes and here we can see him doing it with just one finger and it looks
very gentle. Christ is giving this man his full attention and this person with his eyes closed
is experiencing this miracle, right that very moment in Duccio's painting. You might miss that
it is the same man who is just over here. So what Duccio has done is he's positioned that figure
facing Jesus here and then turning around 180 degrees in the next part of the story. As you can
see he's dropped his stick, his hand is open perhaps in a gesture of wonder or surprise
and his eyes are focused on something that in this little panel we can't see. You might notice
that down below he's got his other hand in some water which Duccio has painted beautifully with
these little wavy lines. That's something called the pool of Siloam. Duccio depicting this man twice
in this way is relatively rare. However in this period people would have been used to seeing
something like a sequence of narratives in scripture depicted simultaneously in one image
especially in altarpieces and predellas like this one. So the opportunity to be able to read
this image left to right where we see this moment and then this moment in the same panel
is maybe comparable to something like a comic strip for us today. And notice what this man is
looking at. This panel which we have in the National Gallery would have also been the next
panel along in that gigantic altarpiece the Siena Maestà which I explained earlier. And so what
that man is looking at is this miraculous image. This man is depicted twice. Jesus himself
across the threshold of this panel is also depicted twice. Here we can see him as someone
who looks relatively ordinary though he has his gold halo. He has both his feet firmly planted
on the ground and firmly planted in buildings and areas that look surprisingly perhaps like Siena
itself. Duccio is doing something really clever here. He is depicting this moment,
this miracle in a place that looks awfully like Siena, his home city and the city that people
were living in when they were milling around the cathedral and when they were coming into
the cathedral for worship. This is a familiar space with a familiar story even though those
stories are hundreds and hundreds of years apart. So this is an extraordinary image that shows
Jesus with his blue cloak with that gold edging and that image connects deeply with the next
miracle that we see in the panel which is just next to that miraculous image of Jesus healing
the man who had been born blind. This image shows something called the transfiguration.
This is one of the most precious moments in the whole of the Gospels. One of the most powerful
accounts of the transfiguration is in the Gospel of Matthew and what happens there is that Jesus
takes some of his disciples Peter, James and John up to a high mountain. We are no longer in the
familiar surroundings of Siena in its everyday life that Duccio has painted with this extraordinary
biblical narrative. Here Duccio has rooted this biblical narrative in the space of heaven in the
realm of some kind of mysterious threshold and mountains are really important in Hebrew Bible
and New Testament accounts where heaven and earth meet. You can see that by how much gold he's using
and you can see that in what's happened to Jesus' robe. What we saw as blue with gold edging in the
previous panel we now see shot through with the glory and the beauty of gold of heavenly light
shot through with this amazing sense of heavenly radiance and the Gospel writer Matthew he even
struggles to put this into words. It shone whiter than the brightest light. It was this beautiful
thing which no one had ever seen before and there is a voice in this story. It's the voice of God
the Father himself from heaven. This is my son. I love him. Listen to him. So now we have seeing
and we have hearing and we have an everyday insight through this incredible miracle to what
Jesus can do and who Jesus is. Here we have an additional insight into who Jesus really is and
what he can do because this image on the threshold of heaven shows us that this person here is none
other than the Son of God. So in the sequence of the altarpiece what we have is an image of this
man shown twice facing Jesus and then facing away having been healed and cured and then we have
Jesus across the threshold shown twice here and here and here like the blind man. He has somehow
been changed mysteriously. So Jesus in these stories and Duccio in his arrangement of these
stories is showing us that there is something so precious that is happening here not only for this
person but also for his community and also in the whole realm of Christian belief about who Jesus is
as the Son of God fully human and fully divine. I think it's so important to speak for a moment
about what might be meant by blindness here. There is something so important here about the way that
blindness connects metaphorically to the blindness of the community within which Jesus is operating.
He's saying to people you do not see spiritually inwardly because you do not love and embrace this
man just as he is. People come to Jesus and they ask whose fault is it that this man was born blind?
Is it his fault? Is it his parents' fault? And Jesus says it's nobody's fault. This man is beautiful
and perfect and glorious and gorgeous, a beloved child of God just as he is. And yet so that you
can start to understand who I am, I am going to heal him in front of you like we see this miracle
taking place in the altarpiece in front of us. We see something which is beyond the realm of physics
and beyond the realm of expectation and it's so earthy in this story. It's soil and saliva. It's
washing in a pool and Duccio has chosen to show those earthly aspects of this story in a very
clear way. And so what might have been the view about miracles in 14th century Siena?
Miracles were things that just like I've described that might happen that were beyond physics that
somehow showed the abundance of God's love, compassion, and mercy. There would have been
countless people coming to Siena Cathedral praying for a miracle in their own lives inspired by that
story. So for those people at that time and for many Christians around the world today this story
is not some ancient strange idea from another time and another place. It's a story that can
inspire hope today. But let's be clear, especially in terms of disability and inclusion, that Jesus
is not saying that blindness is a problem. He's saying that the inner spiritual blindness of
communities that marginalize and exclude people, that is the problem. And he takes the opportunity
of transforming the life of the man who is born blind shown twice here in order to demonstrate
that deeper truth to absolutely everyone who is a beloved child of God in this tradition.
If you'd like to learn more about art history you can click here or here and you can subscribe to
our YouTube channel. Thank you so much for watching today and we'll see you next time.
