Why didn't Rome Conquer Germania?

Candel and Culture
30 followers
11 Video Views·Oct 22, 2022
Ancient history has become almost synonymous with the immense significance and influence
of the marvellous Roman Empire. Extending far across the European continent and lasting for
centuries, the Romans seemed capable of doing just about anything that they put their minds to,
regardless of the challenge. So why did they stop where they did? Was there a reason why
Rome never conquered Germania? The fact that Germania never fell under the Roman crown was
not entirely due to a lack of trying from Rome. While there was a point when the Romans decided
to avoid the region, this wasn't the case at first. Initially, Germania was actually a target
of the Roman Empire after securing Gaul. Under the reign of Caesar Augustus around 20 BC,
the Romans had consolidated their power in Gaul and began to increase military presence
throughout the Rhineland. This led Augustus to start considering the prospect of expanding
further and seizing Germania, although he was quickly forced to rethink his plan.
In 17 BC, three Germanic tribes, the Secambri, Eusebius and Ticteri,
unexpectedly launched an incursion across the river into Roman territory. The tribes ended up
running into the Roman Fifth Legion under Marcus Lullius and emerged victorious, which seemed to
startle Augustus enough that he felt the need to pause any advances into Germania. The goal now
was to increase military presence and power in Gaul even more, first and foremost, although
another scuffle soon after between the Germanic tribes and Lullius and his men finally pushed the
invaders back across the river and forced a ceasefire. Over the next few years, the Romans
now put increased effort into creating a more stable and controlled environment and military
control in Gaul. In 13 BC, Nero Claudius Drusus became the governor of Gaul but was quickly met
with a rebellion. Previously, Augustus had established a new census for tax collection,
which had greatly angered the locals. It was now Drusus' responsibility to deal with the backlash,
while also working to bring a new string of forts along the Rhine in preparation for future
expansion. The first major test of Rome's newly strengthened military in the region
came when a couple of Germanic tribes, the Secambri and the Eusebius, returned to Roman
territory with another offensive. Drusus managed to push the attackers back and decided to follow
them across the river to propel his own invasion. The Romans then plundered the lands of the tribes
before continuing on into the modern-day Netherlands and then routed the Frisians
and attacked the Chalcaeans before heading back to Rome. A year later, Drusus would return to
his conquering ways, and pushing on until the approaching winter and dwindling supplies
brought the campaign to an end, sending the Romans back to their own territory.
As they tried to return home, they were attacked once again by a Germanic tribe
and were nearly defeated without ever reaching Gaul. In 10 BC, Drusus set out on another campaign
and managed to capture the lands of the Chatti and surrounding Germanic tribes,
then return to Rome for a short period before blazing the expansion trail once more the
following year. On the fourth offensive, Drusus conquered new territory and pillaged many cities
of the local tribes. He spread the Roman border as he went, and when it was finally time to travel
back to Rome, he had carried himself an impressive reputation. But on his return ride, Drusus fell
off his horse and died a month later from an infection caused by the severe injury he had
sustained from the fall. After Drusus, Rome still had its sights set on Germania. His successor,
Tiberius, quickly launched his own campaign into Germania and found immense fortune as
According to Roman scholar Cassio Dorus, who wrote about the time period in the 6th century AD,
all Germans who lived between the Elbe and Rhine had surrendered to the Roman invaders.
This means that, for a while, not only did Rome try to conquer Germania, but the empire had
actually been pretty successful in doing it so far and continues to consolidate this newly
expanded territory. Tiberius continued to push through the Rhineland and actually began to form
friendships with some of the German tribes. It appeared that Rome would easily continue to
stretch its border over more and more of Germania with little resistance. Tiberius had more military
bases built and began to show special favor to the Cherusci tribe, of which one member,
Arminius, would later play a major role in what would happen to the Romans in Germania.
For now, Rome saw the German tribes as mostly conquered or allied with,
aside from the Marcomanni. Though a large-scale offensive had been prepared to take down the
Marcomanni and their king, Marobarus, the Romans had to abandon this plan,
to instead address a revolt in Illyricum. As Tiberius was now busy in the Balkans,
the leadership of the Romans in Germania was given to Publius Quintilius Varus, who was left
only three legions to command. Varus was also given Arminius as an advisor and the two quickly
built up trust, completely unbeknownst to Varus though. Arminius was actually working to unite
the Germanic tribes back home and create a shared hatred of Varus and the Romans.
This wasn't all either. As summer was ending, Arminius created a false rumor of a supposed
uprising happening at a large enough scale that Varus' immediate action was required.
The night before Varus left to go subdue the rebellion, Arminius' father-in-law came to warn
the Roman commander. He insisted that Arminius was not to be trusted and that he was actually
responsible for the uprising that was about to happen. Varus quickly blew him off and accused
him of acting on a personal vendetta against Arminius. With that belief, Varus left the next
day with Arminius at his side, commanding him on a detour route that he claimed would give the best
positioning for an ambush. At some point along the way, the men separated as Arminius alleged
to be going out to gain support from local Germanic tribes, but was instead gathering his
own army that he had created prior behind Varus' back. As the Romans marched along through a narrow
gap of forest between a hill and bog, completely out of any type of battle formations and barely
fitting through the 60-foot wide space, German troops suddenly began to arrive on the scene.
The Romans were at a major disadvantage, as the Germans launched their own attack. The terrain
was to no aid of the Roman troops, but furthermore, Arminius knew their every strategy. After being
raised in Rome as a hostage tribute from his father, he knew exactly what they could and would
do, and was one step ahead at all times with his own commands. The Romans were quickly hit with
significant casualties as they spent the next 24 hours trying to gain traction to fight back or
simply escape. Varus would soon fall on his own sword after recognizing that there was no other
way out without becoming another victim of the Germans, and his other commanders did the same
or were struck down as they tried to flee. The Roman troops were left leaderless and swiftly fell
to the Germanic tribes in a vicious one-sided battle. The conflict ended with roughly 15,000
Roman casualties and the complete removal of all things Roman from east of the Rhine.
Though the surviving Roman legions in Germania managed to keep Arminius and his troops from
invading into Gaul, there was nothing more for them to do in Germania. When word reached Emperor
Augustus, it is said that he was so disturbed by the defeat that he stood shouting,
Varus, give me back my legions, while hitting his head against a wall. Although there are many
theories as to why this event ended Rome's conquering ambitions in Germania, one thing is
clear, Augustus would not risk it again. He sent his nephew, Germaticus, to avenge the lost legions,
and there was surely some success at first, but after defeating Arminius and feeling they'd sought
enough revenge, the Romans pulled back and decided to remain on their side of the Rhine.
With the previous devastating defeat still haunting the minds of the Roman leadership,
they decided that the potential gains of seizing all of Germania did not outweigh the risks it
undeniably posed. While there is a multitude of reasons that may have contributed to the new
Roman belief that Germania didn't offer enough to make the risks they'd have to take to conquer it
worth it, there is no question as to when or what caused such a sudden shift in thought.
The routing of the Battle of Teutoburg Forest completely stunned Augustus and Rome as a whole.
The betrayal of Arminius, the gullibility of Varus, and the catastrophic results of
the events leading up to the conflict were enough to severely shake the confidence of an entire
empire. The proud belief that Rome just may be unstoppable or even invincible was utterly
shattered. Germanicus did his part to pick up the pieces as well as could be done,
but that was all the Romans could stomach. Germania was no longer worth conquering and
would instead remain a terrifying reminder of the nightmare its tribes had so effortlessly
yet unexpectedly caused.
