Has the WNBA lost sight of women's sports? From Caitlin Clark and Sophie Cunningham to the growing controversy over transgender athletes, is the league putting politics ahead of female athletes?
In this episode of The Brief: Insights From The Inside, Shabbos Kestenbaum sits down with National Review journalist Caroline Downey to discuss the controversies surrounding Caitlin Clark, her rivalry with Angel Reese, and the WNBA's response to debates over fairness in women's sports. They examine Sophie Cunningham's outspoken defense of sex-based athletic categories, the confrontation involving two teenage fans wearing XX-XY Athletics shirts, and why these controversies continue to divide the sports world.
The conversation also explores Title IX, including a federal whistleblower investigation into the Biden administration's enforcement of the law, and the broader debate over transgender participation in women's sports. Finally, Caroline examines modern feminism, the challenges facing young men and women in dating, and whether new technology is making it easier for women to balance motherhood and careers. Is modern feminism empowering women—or creating new challenges for the next generation?
Watch more episodes of The Brief with Shabbos Kestenbaum for quick insights from the inside.
The Biden administration bastardized Title IX.
The UN published a report.
It was over 900 medals had been stolen from female athletes.
Why is the WNBA treating her so unfairly?
Caitlin Clark's been accused of making this about race,
but it's really been the media that has created this narrative.
The left has compared that to a Jim Crow-era hate crime.
Let's go back to Sophie Cunningham.
She got into a lot of trouble, ostensibly,
for just defending biological women in women's sports.
It's basic premise.
Is that women and men are different
and they should be competing separately so they both get a fair shake.
Why does this still elicit so much pushback?
So, Caroline, I want to go straight into it.
In 2021, President Biden signs an executive order
that bans discrimination on the basis of what he calls gender identity
and sexual orientation.
And this is across the entire federal government.
20 states immediately sue him,
and they actually win a court injunction
in 2022 that blocks the Department of Education
from enforcing its mandates.
But it seems like based on recent whistleblower testimony and
an in-depth investigation from The New York Post.
That the Department of Investigation essentially ignored
the court injunction anyway.
So what can you tell us about what Title IX
was like under the Biden administration
and what Title IX enforcement
is like now under the Trump administration?
Yeah, well, let's rewind, take a step back here.
So Title IX.
Was obviously the statute that enshrined
the separate spaces for the sexes when it came
to educational institutions that applies to sports competition.
The Biden administration bastardized Title IX to include gender
identity as a protected category when obviously previously it was sex.
So there's female and there's male.
But by including that under the umbrella, gender,
preferred gender, or what you identify as.
That meant that.
Transgender identifying men could be theoretically protected under
that, and from my understanding of the litigation that went on during
that time is that the onus was placed on the educational institutions,
the schools themselves,
to prove why they should not have such a policy on the books,
to prove why men should not be allowed to compete in the same category.
As women, which of course is just warping reality grossly
because any, we didn't have
to explain this previously.
It was, this was just a common understanding among humans for.
The vast majority of our history that men
and women are biologically different down to their
DNA and men have natural physical advantages
that cause them to dominate women in the athletic
arena when they are put together.
And so that was obviously that was known to everyone. But
with the gender ideology craze under Biden, that was really like the.
This modus operandi of the Biden administration,
if there's one legacy that I just will always associate with him,
of course, there were many dangerous and noxious ones,
but it was enshrining gender identity.
As this protected category across the government,
and that included, you know, Title IX.
So I'm going to ask you something that might be a little unfair,
which is responding to critics.
How would you respond to the critics against you, against Riley Gaines,
Isabel Brown, who say, look, when you guys talk about.
Transgender participation in women's sports.
You're talking about like four people.
This is not a major impact on women's sports.
This is not a major issue.
We're talking about a very, very small amount of people.
How would you respond to those arguments?
Yeah, they want to dismiss this issue as being a nothing burger
because this is supposedly
happening to a minority of young women predominantly, right?
I mean, the reverse is also true that there are young,
there are male athletes where there
are transgender identifying women in there.
Category, but obviously it's not the same ballgame we're talking about,
but the UN published a report.
A few years ago that found that I believe it
was over 900 medals had been stolen from
female athletes in their respective sports
by transgender identifying men, you know,
titles, trophies, but also scholarships.
Not a lot of people talk about
the financial opportunities that these young women have
lost out on.
So, yeah, it's a pretty significant number.
And I would argue that, you know,
their reaction to just dismiss the concerns of these women
It's like, it may not have happened in your town,
but we have so many documented cases, and also,
the sports issue is a microcosm of how gender ideology has penetrated
and infiltrated many other institutions.
My beat for a long time in National Review was the prison issue,
which, that's a population that the public doesn't have,
like, immediate compassion for, obviously, by and large,
because they're not innocent, like, they committed crimes, but...
The number of cases I found of transgender identifying male felons,
some of them with horrific rap sheets,
I'm talking like double murderers, killed both their parents,
you know, in the dead of night, they were found
to be sexually abusing female inmates in Seattle, Washington alone.
I mean, I covered that beat for a few years and several,
several cases I was in correspondence with the female inmates,
many of them very battered, very vulnerable.
And they said, yeah, I mean, they're coming in here
and they're terrorizing the place.
And so, you know, we can have this conversation all day long, but it's
but even if they say it's just a small percentage that's affected,
I would argue that one is too many.
So you're essentially arguing that the prioritization
of transgenderism can very often put women's rights.
at risk, which I think is an important distinction to make here.
So let's zoom in for a second on the topic of women's sports.
You recently wrote an article,
Can We Admit Now That Caitlin Clark Isn't Making This Up?
Now, I am pretty confident
when I say that if an American can name a WNBA player,
it's probably Caitlin Clark.
Why is this story so important?
Why has it captivated the minds of so many Americans?
And can you just describe for us, like,
why is the WNBA treating her so unfairly?
I think the WNBA is in a really awkward position of
To acknowledge Caitlin Clark's historic contributions,
they would have to recognize
that they were pretty much irrelevant for most of their history.
The vast majority of Americans
were not watching games. They did not care about the WNBA.
And then this golden goose comes along
and single-handedly elevates it to new heights
because she's a prodigy. And a prodigy, by
By definition has.
Outsized, outrageous talent that means she stands apart among
her peers, among her generation.
But I think that that's an uncomfortable thing because.
They're seeing that most of the WNBA players,
there's obvious jealousy and obvious resentment because they've
been playing all this time without really much recognition,
without the stands being packed to the brim the way they are now,
people flying across the country just to see Caitlin Clark,
ESPN viewership skyrocketing because of Caitlin Clark.
And so they, I think, have to hedge this carefully
because they have a lot of players that they don't want to.
You know, diminish their contributions or,
oh yeah, you're, you know, takes a team, right?
It's not just.
Like, it's not just Caitlin Clark's position
on the court that is the most important.
So it's like, you know, they're democratizing and they're trying
to democratize some of the success that Caitlin Clark has brought.
But I think the way that they have either held her at arm's length
or ignored the outright fouls against her or just sort of dismiss them
is really unacceptable because, again, it's killing the golden goose.
All of the brand deals
and all of the money
that's pouring into the league
would not be happening right now
if not for Caitlin Clark
and this Sophie Cunningham
transgender sports issue
is adding insult to injury.
It's proving that the WNBA,
it's shooting itself in the foot.
No pun intended.
It doesn't know.
It doesn't really know how to handle, I think,
its newfound popularity, and it's kind of
making a fool of itself with it.
Now, I do want to get to Sophie Cunningham,
but just before I do, when you talk about
all the fouls and mistreatment directed against Caitlin Clark,
I would say the propagator
of most of those fouls and mistreatment
is Angel Reese of the Atlanta Dream.
And I would imagine most people know
that name only in relation to the fact that she
is considered the foil of Caitlin Clark.
So maybe I'm overthinking this, so please correct me if I'm wrong.
This rivalry, is this really like
a subtle commentary on race relations?
Is it really just jealousy?
Like, why is there such a big disparity between these two players?
Well, look, let me just say, I mean, we just saw that Barack Obama,
the first black president, went up to Caitlin Clark
and basically congratulated her for her success
and said, don't let all the haters get you down.
So that should have sucked all the oxygen out of the leftist claim
I am that, you know.
Caitlin Clark is interested in sowing a race war,
which has been the insinuation of a lot of the media, really.
The media is just as culpable here.
That USA Today article by a Nancy Armour claiming that Caitlin Clark,
by being the girl who cried foul, she was saying,
oh, Caitlin is making these foul complaints.
Wrongly, that they're they're not actually based. There's no basis
for the fouls that she's claiming have been leveled against her.
She compared that to a Jim Crow era hate crime.
I mean, that that was a an insane accusation to make
and insane comparison and to put them even in the same sentence.
So and so Caitlin Clark has been accused of making that.
That's what's interesting about this.
Caitlin Clark's been accused of making this about race.
But very clearly, she has not ascribed a racial element to any of this.
In fact, she has preemptively issued apologies or,
you know, if not apologies, precautionary
hedge statements to say, look, I don't believe in discrimination.
I want everyone in this league to be treated fairly.
She's issued a lot of those statements as sort of a CYA, I would think.
And you would think that that would appease the left.
It hasn't.
They still think that she is somehow trying to pit her fans against the
The Black players, but it's really
been the media that has created this narrative.
Caitlin Clarke is not at all.
She's just existing.
She's just existing and thriving
and shooting hoops and scoring quite a lot.
And the rest of the media is just running wild with jealousy.
So let's go to a different media incident within the WNBA.
So Celeste Keaton, she's the co-owner of the Seattle Storm.
And again, I will admit ignorance
because I had not heard of this team before the viral video.
But then again, I haven't heard of most NBA teams either.
So I'm really just a nerd.
She went viral because she was yelling,
yelling at these two teen girls for wearing T-shirts reading XXXY,
you know, an implicit message that, you know,
sports should in fact be separated based on biological sex.
Apparently she called these two teen girls effing insane.
You actually wrote an article and I want to quote you.
You said the Women's National Basketball Association may claim
to put women first, but the league
sure has a funny way of showing it.
What do you mean by that?
Well, the Women's National Basketball Association
was founded with the baseline premise predicated
on the idea that men do have natural physical advantages
that will allow them to dominate
women.
If they were put in the same category, it's not that the WNBA
was necessarily this feminist product of early wave feminism.
It it was born out of the WNBA. It was seen as a business opportunity.
But nonetheless, like its basic premise is that women
and men are different and they should be competing separately.
So they both get a fair shake.
Right now, that's that's one side of that.
But the fact that there are now female coaches,
female owners of WNBA teams.
That are wading into this issue and excoriating Sophie Cunningham
and now these two little girls.
The optics of that were so obscene to me
and I thought to myself, did they not?
Ponder, hmm, what does it look like when the elders of a league,
of a sport that already benefited from a paradigm in which Title IX
was sacred, in which sports were separated by sex,
in which they already got their accolades and their trophies,
like the specter of men invading their sport was not a thing.
That was literally unfathomable to that generation,
to the matriarchs of the WNBA.
So now what they're doing to-
To score political brownie points, I guess,
with Hollywood or their peers or whatever
it is, they are pulling the rug out under
from these aspiring female athletes because
they've already cashed in.
They already got to live in a world where we don't have to,
where gender ideology did
not exist.
Right.
Now that they've already had that fun ride,
they can tell the young girls coming up.
So, Caroline, let's go back to Sophie Cunningham,
who you had mentioned.
She's another WNBA star for the Fever,
and she got into a lot of trouble ostensibly for
just defending biological women in women's sports.
And she said, and I quote,
And the reaction, as I said,
has been pretty enormous,
pretty wildly against her.
And so my question to you, Caroline, is,
Whether it's the WNBA or whether it's just the left in general,
how come an issue that is kind
of like 80-20 or maybe even 90-10,
how come an issue like that still creates so much divisiveness
and controversy? Because when you talk
to the average American that, hey, biological men should
not be competing in women's sports,
they'll go along with that. Yeah, of course.
But but within so many of our institutions in the United States,
why does this still elicit so much pushback?
Well, I can give you the kind of undiplomatic answer, which
is that the data shows that it's actually women more than men that
support allowing transgender identifying men into their safe spaces.
So it's classic toxic empathy.
They would. It's a suicidal instinct,
unfortunately, that I think we're seeing.
play out among a lot of, you know, young women who have,
they're basically not pursuing regular
rites of passage, let's put it.
So they are kind of misdirecting their nurturing impulse
into social causes that are actually very destructive
and undermine the very rights
that their sex long fought to preserve,
such as the right to have a separate
space, including in sports, in prisons, locker rooms,
what what have you. And so I think that is
a big reason as for why we still see we've still
seen gender ideology peddled. I think Trump scored
major political victories and obviously all the slew
of executive orders he issued early into this
term, putting to bed effectively the culture war part of that.
But the WNBA is an institution,
You know, run by clearly a lot of.
Like I said, older women
who already benefited from an era in which this wasn't a thing.
And now they're trying to foist their political paranoias onto
the young women that are there.
And it's very unfortunate, but that's what's keeping it alive, I think.
So Caroline, zooming away from women's in sports,
broadly speaking, Brittany Hughes of EV Magazine,
she recently spoke to the New York Times and she essentially argued
that the whole conversation between should women be in the home,
should women be in the workforce is really outdated with the advent
of new technologies, particularly AI, the fact that women, really
anyone can work from anywhere in the world. So why do you say that?
Brittany is right in that characterization
that women actually can have it all in the 21st century.
So, yeah, I'd say ordinarily, if not for this amazing technological age
that we live in, it's usually pretty impractical,
just not in a moral sense, a practicality sense for women
to pursue both the career vocation and the motherhood vocation equally
with the same level of commitment and gusto and time allocation.
together, simultaneously.
But with the dawn of so much technology and, frankly, the remote
revolution, the only positive I see of COVID
is the fact that companies adapted to allow their
workforces to either work from home or work hybrid.
Now there's all these different work
arrangements that are very fluid and flexible and portable even.
And I think women are going
going to be the biggest beneficiaries of that. So I do think
You can have a situation where, yeah,
you're pursuing motherhood and child rearing, and
then you have some gig that is either part-time or it's,
it's just, it doesn't require butts
in chairs the same way that it did before.
And I, I think that serves women greatly,
but at a philosophical level, women can't
have it all because I said, like you,
there's only 24 hours in a day, you know, there's
only so much time and capacity you have mentally.
To do these two very demanding jobs,
one of which is stewarding the next generation of our country,
and one of which you may be equally passionate about.
It's working at a job that you love,
but it's impossible to do both 100%. It's literally impossible.
So I think a good modern compromise is seasons.
You know, there's a season for maybe working
and there's a season for motherhood and maybe.
Because of technology, you can have one season that's like 20-80,
and then when the kids
are older, it's more like the reverse,
you know, maybe a lot less time spent with the
kids when they're, you know, older adolescents,
and then you are, you know, diving into work
again.
So, yeah, I think there's been some benefits
of technology in that respect.
That's very ecclesiastical of you.
There's a season and time for everything.
Let me ask you one last question, Caroline,
because in that interview,
Brittany went on to say that
femininity does not actually mean feminism.
She characterized feminism as actually being
really harmful to women in the modern era.
It's self-hating, it's anti-family, it's anti-male.
I'm just curious, your definition of feminism
and to what degree, if any,
you see it as applicable or empowering
for women in the modern era?
Well, feminism's at least
Public goal originally was equal rights with men in the workplace
and in other venues,
but it's obviously metastasized to mean...
men are destructive.
It's become kind of synonymous with toxic masculinity
and we have to root it out. We have to indict men for this.
And I think that like the warmongering behind what feminism evolved
into is deeply harmful to women because for starters, like
Like, what we're seeing is the aftermath of that movement.
Right now, today, I'm sure you found this,
Shabbos, like, just in your city.
In any dating scene in any city today, you go into a bar.
First of all, men are not approaching women.
And I think a big reason for that is because the Me Too legacy.
Me Too punished.
Essentially, I mean, it supposedly went after conduct
that was sexual impropriety, like deep, serious sexual abuse.
But there were a lot of wrongfully accused guys.
I mean, you go back to the title, the Obama witch hunts
on college campuses and how, you know, basically the alleged victims,
the victims who were accusing men of abuse, they got the longest leash.
There was no due process.
For those who were accused.
So guys had their reputations and lives kind of upended, not destroyed.
And I think that had a chilling effect on courtship
that we're seeing today in all of our cities.
So I think men and women are today very distrustful of one another,
deeply distrustful.
And I know women may say on at face value, young women may say that,
you know, feminism has been such a success.
And I mean, don't don't you want the opportunity
to make your own money and blah, blah, blah.
OK, fine.
But just look at the gender dynamics
that are just evident in our society right now.
Young men and women are worlds apart.
They're worlds apart spiritually.
They're worlds apart politically.
And if that's the legacy of feminism, we don't want it.
Why would you want it?
And women will regret having been such vehemently,
you know, such avid feminists because being alone sucks.
Being alone sucks.
Like you ultimately do want to find someone
and a lot of them come to that realization
maybe a little too late.
Um, but it's just, it's a, it's a, it's a sickness.
It really, it created this sickness
and I see it on my own brothers and, and how many
dating struggles they've had.
And I, I have friends, you know,
female friends who they've kind of like thrown in the towel
and I don't think that was always the way it was,
you know, like courtship was never
this strenuous and like exhausting and.
Um, dehumanizing. And again, you, you have,
you have the dating apps to that equation,
which compounds all of this, right?
It's like, we're incentivizing, you know, gamifying dating.
So we're just like judging people based off very
superficial qualities that you see on this app.
And I mean, there's plenty of, there's plenty of people
who've gotten married from dating apps.
Like there are success stories. Don't get me wrong. But, um, I think.
What feminism really did was destroy gender relations and,
you know, young women.
I don't think they ultimately will say
that that was a good thing.
Like, if you really, really press them on it.
All right, so you guys heard it here first from Caroline.
Go to the bars, ask women out.
As Charlie would say, like, go date, get married,
have kids, build a legacy.
Couldn't agree with you more.
And with that, Caroline Dowdy,
political commentator at National Review
and a senior fellow at the Independent Women's Forum.
Always appreciate you making the time.
Thanks, Travis.
Well, thank you so much for watching this week's episode of The Brief.
Feel free to keep the conversation going by leaving a comment below.
You can also offer an idea for a topic you would like to see covered.
Also ensuring you're liking, subscribing, following,
so you do not miss any new episode of The Brief.
And we'll see you next week.