This video explores the conversion of the Goths and other East Germanic tribes to Arian Christianity. It challenges the image of Goths as mere barbarians, highlighting their adaptability and the role of Arianism as a critical marker of ethnic and political identity that distinguished them from the Catholic Roman population until their eventual assimilation.
Comments are disabled for this video.
The Goths are known to us primarily as savage barbarians,
raiding deep into Roman territory in the 3rd and 4th centuries AD,
culminating in the devastating defeat at Adrianople in 378 AD.
From the aftermath of this battle emerged Alaric,
who would become known to later generations as the first person to sack Rome in 800 years,
further cementing the image of the marauding Goths.
But following the turmoil of the 5th century,
the Goths proved that they were more than Greco-Roman authors made them out to be,
establishing Roman successor states and imperial soil
that continued the legacy of the Roman Empire in the West.
This is especially true in the case of Theoderic the Great,
who has been seen as a Western Roman Emperor in all but name in recent scholarship.
One of the most important factors in the success of the Goths was their adaptability.
As they migrated towards the Black Sea coast and into the Balkans in the 1st centuries AD,
they encountered other populations and intermixed with them,
as a recent genetic study has convincingly shown.
In spite of this, the Goths seem to have retained a distinct Gothic identity,
perhaps most evident in the Gothic language,
which was spoken by Goths in the Gothic kingdoms of the post-Roman West for centuries
after settling among Roman-speaking populations.
But another, potentially even more important, but sometimes overlooked aspect of their identity
was their adherence to a sect of Christianity,
which had been proclaimed heretical by the Catholic Church.
Arianism.
This hasn't always been the case, however.
Up until the Council of Nicaea, and indeed for some time afterwards,
Arianism was extremely popular throughout the Roman Empire and beyond,
and even favoured by some Roman Emperors, such as Valens.
This makes it all the more surprising that the Goths,
those savage barbarians from the North,
were probably the first non-Romans on the northern frontier of the Empire to take up this faith.
Why they did so, how their conversion played out,
and what consequences it had will be the subject of this video.
As previously mentioned, the Goths had established themselves
on the northern Black Sea coast and in the northern Balkans by the 3rd century AD.
From there, they conducted raids deep into Roman territory,
and not just over land, but remarkably also across the Black Sea and into Anatolia,
devastating parts of Cappadocia and Galatia.
As part of their booty, the Goths also took slaves back into their territory.
Some of which were adherents to what at this point
was still a relatively minor religious sect in the Roman Empire, Christianity.
Just like the Romans themselves during this period,
the Goths were most likely predominantly still pagan,
although the details of their exact beliefs are lost.
Due to their Germanic origins, it is likely, however,
that they practised a form of Germanic paganism,
closely related to the belief systems of Central and Northern Europe,
which are most widely known from the famous sagas of medieval Scandinavia.
Caution is advised, however.
Between those early Gothic pagans and the Scandinavian myths and legends
lie almost a thousand years and thousands of kilometres.
Because of this, it is probable that the Gothic mythology
differed substantially from that of the medieval Scandinavians,
although they probably shared a common root
in the proto-Germanic paganism of Central and Northern Europe.
Due to their pagan beliefs, these Roman Christians and their faith
might have appeared strange and alien to the Goths at first.
But in stark contrast to Christianity,
pagan belief systems usually didn't require their adherents to spread their faith.
They were also inclusive in the sense that a pagan could worship gods
from originally different pantheons,
as is attested among many of the inhabitants of the empire
who came to worship local as well as Greco-Roman deities
and the emperor himself, who was seen as divine.
Because of this generally open nature of paganism towards new divinities,
the Christians who were brought to Gothic lands
seemed to have been allowed to continue practising their faith.
Even though they were most likely slaves in the beginning,
some of these Christians, or perhaps their children or grandchildren,
might have been able to work for or to buy their freedom
and become fully-fledged members of Gothic society.
In the genetic study mentioned earlier,
it has been shown that the Goths were a genetically heterogeneous nation,
showcasing admixture from at least three different regions,
Central and Northern Europe, the Steppe and the Balkans.
This shows that the Goths were relatively inclusive
and that ancestry apparently didn't play an overly important role in being Gothic.
So that some of the descendants of Anatolians eventually became fully-fledged Goths
wouldn't be too surprising,
as was probably the case with one of the most famous Goths in history,
the Bishop Ulphulus.
Ulphulus was probably the descendant of one of these early Christians
that the Goths had taken from Anatolia.
His Gothic name, meaning Little Wolf,
indicates, however, that these Christians had taken on parts of Gothic culture
and perhaps even a Gothic identity.
They apparently also spoke Gothic fluently by this time,
which is demonstrated in the Gothic Bible translation undertaken by Ulphulus,
which he is most famous for.
Ulphulus became Bishop of the Goths in 340 AD
and was not only a significant religious figure of his time,
but probably also played an important role
in the settlement of Gothic Christians in Moesia.
He may also have been involved in other negotiations
between the Goths and the Eastern Roman Empire as an intermediary.
Most importantly, he looked after the Christians among the Goths,
who had apparently survived for multiple generations
and assimilated into Gothic culture.
It is also believed that he engaged in missionary activities among the Goths,
trying to spread the Christian faith among the barbarians,
although the scope of these activities was probably limited.
He was, however, successful in converting
one of the most prominent leaders of the 4th century Goths to Aryan Christianity.
This leader, known as Fritigern,
was one of the most influential political figures on the Balkans
during the second half of the 4th century.
He was a leader among the Travindian Goths,
one of the two major branches of Gothic people attested during this period,
and is most famous for leading the Goths to victory
against the Eastern Roman Empire at Adrianople.
The Travindian Goths, just like the Goths in general,
weren't a unified people, however,
and before Fritigern led the Travindian to victory in 378 AD,
he saw himself confronted with another leader among them,
a certain Athanaric.
This Athanaric, probably fearing Roman influence among his people,
ordered a persecution of Christians among his followers
in stark contrast to Fritigern,
who received a Christian baptism
that is likely to have been conducted by Ulphalus himself.
Athanaric, on the other hand,
was defeated by the Huns in 376 AD
and took his followers into the Carpathian Mountains.
Thus, Fritigern remained the sole leader among the Travindian Goths,
most of which apparently decided to follow Fritigern into the Roman Empire.
But why did Fritigern decide to take this path
when Athanaric so violently fought against the Christian influence among the Goths?
Most modern interpretations of this early conversion to Christianity
do not necessarily see an actual change in Fritigern's spirituality
as the main motivation,
but rather a politically motivated alignment
with the elites of the Eastern Roman Empire,
who were themselves mostly Aryan Christians at this time.
Through his conversion to this particular denomination of Christianity,
Fritigern hoped for better diplomatic relations with the Empire
and thus a political and military advantage over his rival, Athanaric.
The conversion to Aryanism was possibly even contractually regulated
as a condition for Vardan's support against Athanaric
and could be seen as an act of missionary activity by the Eastern Roman Empire
if this was actually the case.
Of course, it is possible that personal motives
also played a role in Fritigern's conversion,
but this interpretation is extremely speculative,
as there are no preserved statements from Fritigern himself on this matter.
Therefore, based on the sources available
and the circumstances in which Fritigern found himself,
court political calculation is the most probable motive for Fritigern's conversion.
Even though this act brought Fritigern closer to the Eastern Roman elite
and helped him secure passage into the Empire,
ultimately it was to no avail,
and the abhorrent conditions in which his Goths had to live
after being allowed to settle within the Eastern Roman Empire
eventually forced them to rebel,
leading to their confrontation with the Romans at Adrianople.
Despite this betrayal by the Eastern Romans,
Aryan Christianity continued to spread among the Goths,
but how was this facilitated?
In other cases, such as the famous conversion to Catholicism
by the Frankish king Clovis,
many of the king's closest followers followed him into the new faith.
Although it is not attested if this happened in Fritigern's case as well,
it surely sent a signal to other Goths,
probably leading to many others converting to Aryan Christianity as well.
This would explain why, by the time of Alaric,
just one generation later,
most of the Goths that he led out of the Balkans
seemed to have been Aryan Christians,
and their faith seems to have become an important mark of Gothic identity
in contrast to Roman Catholicism.
This is not only true for Alaric's Visigoths,
but also for Theolaric's Ostrogoths,
as well as for other East Germanic groups
such as the Burgundians and the Vandals.
In the case of the latter,
this even led to the religious persecution of Catholics.
The Aryan faith probably spread to these groups
from those Christian Goths that Ulphelas had looked after during the 4th century.
The speed at which this happened suggests
that some of Ulphelas' followers may have conducted missions to groups
such as the Vandals in the latter part of the century.
It is astonishing that the Vandals that invaded the Roman Empire in 410
and established a kingdom in North Africa a quarter of a century later
seemed to have already been predominantly Christian by the time they left their home.
This means their conversion happened within the space of a single generation.
This begs the question,
Why was Aryan Christianity so popular among the East Germanic people?
Were Ulphelas' missionaries just so effective?
Or did political reasons, like in Fritigern's case, play a bigger role?
Whatever the original causes might have been,
it created a religious boundary that justified
their separate legal and cultural status within the former Roman Empire,
preventing complete assimilation with the Catholic majority Roman population.
Unfortunately for them, this wasn't to last.
By the mid-6th century AD,
Justinian's wars saw the demise of first the Vandal Kingdom of North Africa
and then the Ostrogothic Kingdom of Italy.
Aryanism subsequently saw a sharp decline and the Visigoths,
although unconquered by the Eastern Romans,
were eventually forced to convert to Catholicism.
Thus, this particular sect of Christianity,
which the various East Germanic groups had claimed for themselves
in the turbulent years of the migration period,
largely came to an end and with it the barbarians that had practiced it
themselves disappeared,
further hinting at the importance of Aryan Christianity
as a marker of ethnic identity among the various East Germanic groups of the post-Roman West.
Thank you so much for watching this video on the Christianisation of the Goths.
Unfortunately, detailed information was hard to come by,
so this is a bit of a shorter one.
If you'd like me to cover the conversion of other groups,
let me know in the comments below
and whilst you're down there, please also consider liking and subscribing.
It would help the channel immensely.
I've got enough material to make a video about the Franks,
the Alemanni or the Anglo-Saxons pretty much straight away.
And if you'd like to support my research,
consider becoming a Patreon member to get early access to my videos,
to the scripts and to full-length academic essays written by yours truly.
All support is greatly appreciated.
Thanks again for watching and I'm looking forward to seeing you in the next one.