CNN’s Harry Enten breaks down the poll numbers of PA Senator John Fetterman’s popularity and the US support for Israel among Democrats and all US voters. And John Berman asks AJC’s Tia Mitchell and MeidasTouch Network’s Scott MacFarlane if Fetterman switches parties and runs as a Republican in 2028. Also, Manu Raju and the panelists discuss the road to reach 60 Senate seats, and which senators may resign in 2026.
0:00 Harry Enten unpacks Fetterman's polling plunge 3:50 Panel analyzes Fetterman’s Senate standing 5:26 2028 Senate map & Democrats’ path to 60 seats 8:30 Aging senators and 2028 retirement decisions
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Senator John Fetterman has sparked controversy by suggesting he might leave the Democratic Party if Chris Van Hollen becomes Senate Majority Leader. Analysts argue Fetterman is historically unpopular among his own base, particularly regarding his stance on Israel, making his reelection bid and party standing precarious.
All right, Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman making
a little bit of news, albeit it lands
a little differently than it might have two
weeks ago before it looks like the Democrats
would get 56 seats in the U.S. Senate.
Because Senator Fetterman says that if Chris Van Hollen,
who is running for Democratic
majority leader against Chuck Schumer,
Fetterman says if Van Hollen wins, he indicated it might
be possible that he would leave the Democratic Party.
With us now, CNN Chief Data Analyst, Harry.
And so, again, I think this may be landing a little differently
because they don't necessarily need his vote.
But just talk to me about John Fetterman.
Yeah, I would say that Democrats response, the idea
that Fetterman would be leaving the Democratic Party as a little branch.
Oh, I'm really scared. Oh, no.
They would say good riddance, good riddance to this guy.
Sometimes a slide says it all and you literally get the inverse on it.
Look at this, Pennsylvania Dems, John Fetterman's net popularity.
You know, you go back two years ago, it was plus 56 points.
It's literally the inverse now.
It's literally the inverse.
It's minus 56 points.
That is a change of what, Johnny B?
112 points in the negative direction among,
there we go, let's get that all right.
In the negative direction in just two years' time.
Pennsylvania Democrats despise, they hate...
Hate, hate John Fetterman.
So this idea that he would move
and make their majority go from 56 seats to 55 seats,
ooh, real scary.
And again, he's facing a reelection bid in Pennsylvania.
That looks challenging.
It looks challenging.
It looks challenging.
Yeah, I would say it looks challenging.
I think Johnny B. is underselling it,
because I just want you to look at Senators' own party net ratings
about when they lost a primary.
Look at this.
You had Bob Smith, who was at plus 15 points,
goes all the way down to Lisa Murkowski,
who, of course, lost that primary,
then ran as a write-in in the general
election and won at minus 15 points.
John Fetterman is at minus 56 points.
He is literally off the page in terms of his net popularity rating
when it comes to senators who would run
for re-election and then lost the primary.
Simply put, there is no historical analogy
that quite fits the moment right now
of just how unpopular John Fetterman is.
If he runs in a Democratic primary,
unless I don't know, we're literally moved to...
Planet Krypton, he is almost certainly going
to lose that primary based upon what we see
historically speaking. Normally,
if you're running in a primary as a senator, if you're at about,
let's say, zero points, as many approve as disapprove,
you would be in trouble. And he's
down at minus 56 points among Pennsylvania Democrats.
He's really in a deep load of you
know what. It's just hard to calculate it.
It's just completely foreign from anything we've seen.
One of the issues that Fetterman has focused
on more than any other is Israel. He's a fierce
supporter of Israel. He thinks Senator Van Hollen isn't,
which is why he would entertain,
I think, leaving the party if Van Hollen were majority leader there,
But voters are sort of saying something different than Fetterman.
Yeah, I would say that voters are on the side of Chris Van Hollen,
Democratic voters in particular on the side of Chris Van Hollen.
You can see it right here.
Say U.S. is too supportive of Israel.
Well, look among Democrats.
Look nationwide at 74 percent.
Look in Pennsylvania at 71 percent.
Look in Pennsylvania again among all voters.
It's 52 percent.
Look U.S. It's 51 percent.
So, you know, no matter which way you slice this apple.
Voters, and Democratic voters in particular,
are not with the senator from Pennsylvania.
They're with the senator from Maryland.
So you just put it all together in terms of Fetterman's popularity,
which is very much in the basement among Democrats.
You put it with historical context here, which is he's way worse off
than those who have traditionally run
for re-election and then lost re-election,
at least in a primary.
And you put it with the Israel,
and you could just see that at this point,
John Fetterman is very much on the outside looking in when compared.
To the rest of the Democratic electorate and,
frankly, Americans at large at this point.
Harriet, thank you very much.
Thank you, my friend.
With us now, Washington Bureau Chief
for the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Tia Mitchell,
and the Chief Washington Correspondent
for the Midas Touch Network, Scott McFarland.
And, Tia, you know, just let's talk for a second about John Fetterman,
because it was this pretty bold statement
where he said if Van Hollen wins,
indicating he could leave the Democratic Party.
But it just feels different than it might have a couple weeks ago.
Democrats in the Senate are in a vastly different place.
Yeah, so it's kind of, I think, landing with a thud.
There just isn't that much importance
on any one senator's vote the way it would have
been with a more narrow majority. And
I also think Democrats are kind of getting tired
of Fetterman threatening to leave them,
threatening to break with them.
I think there are more and more Democrats, both in the Senate
and in Pennsylvania, who are getting close to saying good riddance.
In Scott McFarland, you know, John Fetterman has
been actually he's given a lot of praise to Chuck Schumer the last week
for helping Democrats increase their majority in the U.S. Senate.
I wonder how much Schumer wants his public support right now.
It's an open question, John, but here's what we know.
We know Fetterman's facing a primary challenge.
It's inevitable.
It's a matter of who or how many people.
Chris Deluzio, House member from Pittsburgh,
Armed Services Committee member, told me he hasn't decided yet, John,
but that whether Fetterman's staying or not,
that's not going to change Democrats' decisions.
They're going to plow right past him in a primary.
They think it's likely
that Fetterman's either
going to lose the primary
or switches over
to preserve his political career,
goes to Republican before 2028.
Do you worry that in 2028,
Dems could get 60 seats?
I do.
Yeah, I worry that that's,
I think there's entirely
that possibility.
And that's the magic number.
60 would mean the filibuster couldn't stop Senate Democrats
from passing their bills
if they stay united.
But is that number actually possible to hit in 2028?
My panel of political insiders is back.
So let's just look at the 2028 map of seats that are up for grab.
There are a lot of Democratic targets.
Now that they could have potentially 56 seats if Alaska goes their way.
And you look at the seats that are up.
Wisconsin, it's a red state.
You have Iowa, another red state where they just picked up.
You have North Carolina and South Carolina.
They just won in South Carolina.
I mentioned Alaska.
They have a very good chance of winning in Alaska, maybe even Florida.
They were surprisingly close in Florida.
Yeah, they got to defend some seats too, like Ohio.
Sherrod Brown will have to run again to keep that seat.
If he decides to run again, you have PA with John Fetterman.
That's something that Democrats will have to defend.
Look, you look at the targets on the map.
There's one, two, three, four, five, six or so
possible pickup opportunities for Democrats.
Is this a...
Look, we'll see.
The environment's going to change 5,000 times.
I mean, now and then,
the presidential race is going to dictate so much of this.
But is this...
Some people say this feels like it could be the 2006-2008
when Democrats won it.
Yeah, I mean, it's not impossible.
The fact that Democrats are starting where they are
with a likely 56-seat majority
Means they only need four more.
And you just pointed out where there are those opportunities.
Of course, as you mentioned,
a presidential year is very different from a midterm election.
But we did see in some places presidential turnout,
presidential level turnouts. If, you know,
Republicans can get a candidate that really excites their base.
I think Republicans will feel
a little bit better than they did this cycle, that their
voters could come out.
But there are a lot of questions,
and Democrats obviously now feeling super bullish on the
South, potentially investing more in Florida,
for example, after seeing just how close Angie
Nixon got.
So there are a lot of pathways,
and it's not out of the question that they could get there.
I'm sure you'll hear more Republicans, as you did,
say they could get there than Democrats
who are kind of always fretting of the now come.
Realistic?
I mean, 2006 led to 2008.
So, I mean, that's sort of been the pattern here.
I would add Todd Young to that list,
only because he's someone Democrats are going to be looking to
maybe as someone they can bring in.
And he could face a potential Trump-backed primary challenger.
We'll see if that happens.
I think what will be interesting to watch, too, among this,
I do think it's possible, and there's
a lot of people working towards it,
but I think that...
Are these Republicans going to make a move towards the Democrats,
work with them on some stuff?
Right now, the Democratic plan is to push some bills out there
that really make it tough for Republicans.
So do they vote for that, or do they dig in?
Right. Yeah. And say, hey, we're going to stay where we are here.
So that'll be great to watch. And also another thing to watch is,
of course, the retirements that will be coming here.
And there are a lot of aging senators, perhaps not surprisingly.
These are senators older than 70 up for reelection in 2028.
You can see a lot of Democrats
and Republicans are a lot of them here on your screen.
And I asked several of these members, including some of the Republicans
who are considering running if they plan to do so in 2028.
Senator, if you're going to run for re-election in 2028?
No, and I don't have to make that decision for a while.
You initially had that two-term pledge.
Obviously, that's out the window these days.
Well, again, I originally said I would never vote my re-election.
Then when I ran the second time,
I said two and done because I only wanted two and done.
But then things change.
Are you running for sure in 2028?
That's why I don't talk to you because that's what I'm working on.
Are you definitely running for re-election?
You'll have to ask me next year.
You haven't made a decision yet?
I've made a decision,
but I've got to talk to a lot of other people if they agree with it.
Chuck Grassley saying that he's made a decision,
but I've got to talk to a lot of other
people if they agree with it if he runs.
He would be 95 on election day 2028 if he decides to run.
I mean, we've seen senators stay till the bitter end.
I mean, Manu, I think when we have this conversation,
it's really, you know, as you alluded to,
going to come down to who's at the top of the ticket
for both Democrats and Republicans.
We've seen when Trump is at the top of the ticket,
obviously he cannot run again,
but a candidate like him can turn out voters
that don't turn out for anybody else.
And so as we look toward the states that will control the...
The control of the Senate,
it's going to depend on who this Republican or Democrat at the top of
the ticket is and whether they're able to mobilize voters.
But I think Mariana makes a really good
point that Democrats are now dreaming of places
of investing that they did not think they could
invest and went in before. So obviously,
it's those states you just listed, but there's other
states too. Carl just mentioned Indiana,
but they are going to think bigger and broader about where
Given the scale of the majorities
that they just won in these midterm elections.
In the meantime,
we're going to be watching these primary challenges play out,
including on the Democratic side,
John Fetterman running for re-election.
We'll see if he runs for re-election.
He hasn't actually said what he will do.
He's already got a primary challenger, a progressive activist,
announced his primary bid against him.
I'm sure there will be others.
There are already others in the House Democratic.
Caucus and the part of the delegation
in Pennsylvania considering running against
Fetterman. He is very vulnerable on the left.
Can he even win a primary is my question.
Yeah, I mean, you're totally right.
He is vulnerable. And you have heard from
House Democrats in the Pennsylvania delegation saying he has more
or less got to go. The person
to watch there, of course, is Chris Deluzio,
who has been signaling he is likely to jump in.
And Fetterman said yesterday that he might caucus
with Republicans if Chris Van Hollen wins that.
race for Senate Majority Leader. We'll see.
He's made that threat before. Will it pan out.