Why Copernicus was Unconvincing

It's Just Astronomical!
1 follower
5 Video Views·Oct 24, 2022
16th century scientists had many problems accepting the Copernican theory that the Earth orbits the Sun. These problems would puzzle scientists for centuries. For more information, I highly recommend:
The Case against Copernicus by Dennis Danielson and Christopher Graney
Coming of Age in the Milky Way by Timothy Ferris
How Did Kepler Discover His First Two Laws by Curtis Wilson
Copernicus's theory that the Earth orbits the Sun marks the beginning of the scientific
revolution.
But his theory was widely rejected for many decades, not just by religious leaders, but
by other astronomers who raised troubling questions that Copernicus couldn't answer.
The word planet comes from a Greek word meaning wandering star.
The Greeks didn't know that the Earth was moving and assumed that the planets orbited
the Earth.
But they moved strangely.
They would sometimes change directions.
The planets couldn't simply be circling the Earth because how could they change directions?
Ptolemy realized that he could explain this behavior by adding a second circle called
an epicycle.
Each planet orbits around an epicycle and the epicycle orbits around the Earth.
Copernicus had a different explanation, which had the Earth orbiting the Sun.
It was a more elegant solution, but it had several problems.
Copernicus soon realized that his simple model just didn't work.
It didn't match the observed positions of the planets.
So he added the epicycles back in.
He moved the Sun away from the center of the solar system.
But even with these changes, his model wasn't really any better than Ptolemy's.
Problem number two.
What could be moving the Earth?
The Earth is so big and so heavy.
What could be moving it around so fast?
The fact that planets and stars move wasn't a big problem because Aristotle explained
that they are made of a lighter substance that likes to go around in circles.
Third, parallax.
If we're moving so fast, then why don't we see the stars change positions as we move?
This is called parallax.
You might think that it's just because the stars are really far away.
But then we'd expect the stars to be pinpoints of light.
In telescopes, you see that they have a thickness to them, which means they'd have to be incredibly
far away and gigantic.
Fourth, the problem of projectiles.
If you fire a cannonball towards the south, it will land due south as you'd expect, but
only if the Earth is not moving.
Now, let's put the Earth in motion.
Italy is rotating at 750 miles per hour.
The cannonball was moving at the same speed when it was launched, so we add this speed
to the motion of the ball.
But the equator is rotating faster, so the ball doesn't hit its target because its target
is moving faster.
But this is not what we see.
We don't see the Earth moving when we're on the ground.
We only see the cannonball, which should veer to the right if the Earth were rotating.
These problems with Copernicus would stump scientists for centuries.
Galileo made two key discoveries that supported Copernicus.
He discovered four moons orbiting Jupiter, proving that there were objects that did not
orbit the Earth.
Ptolemy and Copernicus both give similar predictions about where Venus should be.
Remember, they can only measure the angle to Venus, not the distance.
But Ptolemy predicts that Venus is in a crescent phase here, while Copernicus predicts that
it's nearly full, which is exactly what Galileo saw.
So now, did everyone believe Copernicus?
Nope.
Because there was still a good alternative.
Tycho suggested that the planets orbit the Sun, but the Sun orbits the Earth.
This avoids all the problems of a moving Earth.
The man who would fix the Copernican model was a German astronomer named Johannes Kepler.
Initially, Kepler believed that the orbits of the six known planets were closely linked
to the five platonic solids.
Kepler was mistaken.
There was no real connection.
But he sought out the man with the best data.
Tycho Brahe.
Tycho was rich.
His stepfather had rescued King Frederick II from drowning and as a result, died of pneumonia.
The very grateful king supported Tycho's huge research program.
When Kepler finally got his hands on the Mars data, he predicted that he would solve the
problem in eight days.
Eight years later, he was still working on it.
It was hard because he only had one data point to work with.
The angle between Earth, Mars, and the Sun.
He didn't know the distance to Mars or how much of the motion was caused by Mars moving
and how much was caused by the Earth.
But he found a way to isolate the motion of the Earth.
One year on Mars lasts 687 days.
If we use measurements that are spaced 687 days apart, Mars is always in the same location.
Only the Earth is moving.
And now, Kepler estimated the orbit of the Earth.
Then used that orbit to estimate the orbit of Mars.
Then he discovered the mistake that Ptolemy, Galileo, Copernicus, and every other astronomer
had made.
The planets don't orbit in circles, they orbit in ellipses.
Isaac Newton explained how the Earth moves through his laws of motion and gravitation.
We see so little parallax in the stars because they're so far away.
But they're not absurdly large.
The thickness of the stars is an illusion.
George Airy explained how telescopes distort the stars, making them appear larger than
they actually are.
In 1838, Bessel finally showed that the stars do move just a tiny bit.
As the Earth orbits the Sun, the motion of projectiles on a rotating body was not completely
understood until Coriolis derived his equations describing the motion.
However, this effect is only noticeable across very large distances.
When a batter hits a home run, this effect is smaller than the width of the ball.
The Copernican model worked great once Kepler realized that the planets move in ellipses.
Ellipses fit perfectly into Newton's laws of motion.
And the Copernican theory was further confirmed by observing parallax and the Coriolis effect.
For more astronomical videos, please click to subscribe.
