Long before Homo sapiens populated the earth, the Neanderthals lived in Eurasia. Now, paleoanthropologists in England and France are using new archeological methods to shed light on some previously unexplained Neanderthal mysteries.
In an age clouded by the mists of time, the first early humans colonized the Eurasian continent. They settled on land that had only recently been covered by glaciers. This species, called Neanderthals, died out about 30,000 years ago -- but at one time, they formed the largest group in an area that stretched from northern France to the Belgian coast and from the Channel Islands to southern England.
During the last Ice Age, the North Sea was frozen over -- and the English Channel was a small river that could easily be crossed on foot. The Neanderthals lived in close harmony with their perpetually changing environment. They had everything they needed to survive: the meat of prey animals, edible wild plants, water and wood for cooking and heating. How did these early humans develop over almost 300,000 years? What were their lives like before they became extinct?
Our documentary is based on the latest research. We investigate various populations of Neanderthals, and visit archaeological sites in northern France, southern England, and on the island of Jersey.
Renowned researchers such as the British paleoanthropologist Chris Stringer and his French colleague Ludovic Slimak describe how the Neanderthals lived, and discuss their cognitive abilities. Was this species capable of structured thinking? Did they have cultures, languages, and societies? How intelligent were they, and what sort of adaptive strategies kept them alive for 300,000 years? How similar were they to modern-day humans?
Long before Homo sapiens began to populate the Earth,
another human species had established itself
across much of the Eurasian continent — the Neanderthals.
Fossils discovered during the last two centuries in the Atlantic Ocean
and in Siberia have shed some light on these mysterious archaic humans.
They had culture, they had social systems, they had intelligence.
Recent archaeological finds in England and France
have helped researchers find out more about these early inhabitants of Eurasia.
They mastered their environment and understood it perfectly.
Neanderthals managed to survive for some 300,000 years,
and then they disappeared.
How did they overcome existential threats, such as extreme climate change?
And what do Neanderthals and modern humans have in common?
After the first archaeological evidence of Neanderthals was discovered in the 19th century,
many experts described this species as ape-like.
A more realistic picture of the Neanderthals evolved decades later.
Analysis of their remains and various artefacts
provided details about the way they lived, the survival skills that they developed
and the climate in which they lived.
That climate was extremely harsh during the millennia that Neanderthals inhabited the Eurasian continent.
This was the Ice Age, and there were periods of extreme cold,
with temperatures dropping to minus 20 degrees Celsius,
and sea levels were much lower than they are today.
The evidence indicates that the Neanderthals adapted well to these particularly difficult conditions.
Paleoanthropologist Professor Chris Stringer of London's Natural History Museum
specializes in the physical and anatomical development of early humans.
The Neanderthal face is very different to the shape of a modern face,
and many arguments about how that face evolved and why it evolved.
And I think the view now is that certainly that face, it's partly to do with cold adaptation.
So we know Neanderthals evolved in conditions that were largely colder and drier than the present day in Europe.
And it's likely that that face was particularly the nasal area,
because the nose is very large and it's pulled forwards.
It has a very large internal volume.
So partly it seems that it's there as acting like a radiator.
It's warming up and humidifying the air that's coming in.
And this was true for all of these ancient humans.
All of them really have larger nasal apparatus than modern humans do.
But Neanderthals take it to another level.
They really are pumping a huge amount of air through their noses,
and they've got huge lungs, barrel chest.
They need to oxygenate their blood.
They're burning more energy to stay warm as well.
These physical characteristics helped the Neanderthals survive in an inhospitable ecosystem.
They also developed an important skill — making tools out of flint and other materials.
This was groundbreaking technology.
It's known as the Levallois technique,
and involves using a rock or bone to chip off thin, sharp-edged flakes from the core material.
Here, archaeologist Vincent Lascaux demonstrates the technique.
I'm shaping the core, and then I'll remove pieces that could be used as tools.
This is what's called a Levallois point.
It runs along these ridges. Now I'll break off a piece.
It's a long, slow process.
Now he has to sharpen the edges.
Here you can see the distinctive features of this process.
The two ridges that come to a point, and the beveled cutting edge.
This concave ledge could be used to attach the pointed flake to a spear.
The Levallois technique helped Neanderthals create weapons
to hunt large animals that would provide them with meat for food and skins for clothing.
This allowed the Neanderthals to spread across the continent despite the cold weather.
They were also able to adapt to brief interglacial periods
that were marked by significant increases in temperatures.
There are only a few sites where experts have been able to study
thousands of years of Neanderthal history.
One of them is on the island of Jersey in the English Channel.
Excavations over the course of the last century
have revealed new details on the lives of these early humans.
Archaeologist Becky Scott is a researcher at the British Museum.
She and her colleagues have spent several years
studying the Neanderthal site at La Cote de Saint-Brelard.
The sediments preserved within the fissure
begin accumulating at least 240,000 years ago
through to, we have dates now of around about 40,000
and there are later sediments as well.
So actually that captures that entire time span.
But what it also captures is huge changes in climate and environment.
So there are times when it's warm, you know, it's nearly as warm as today
and the sea is quite close.
There are other times when it's cold, we're dipping down into a glacial period
and the sea is locked up a long way north of the site
and a completely different landscape is exposed.
In prehistoric times, Jersey was not an island.
It was part of the European mainland.
One of its most prominent geographical features
is a rock formation that towers 150 meters over a broad plain.
Neanderthals may have used it as a lookout post.
For Neanderthal people, that view gives them control of that.
So you can maybe imagine somebody sat up there perhaps directing other groups,
perhaps spotting maybe other people coming through,
maybe herds of animals coming through.
So by getting up, they're actually able to control and work with their landscape
in a way that you can't when you're just down low and moving through it.
Scientists mapped out the ocean floor around the island
to find out what the area might have looked like in prehistoric times.
A few years ago, my colleague Richard Bates and Martin Bates
actually started to conduct a bathymetric survey of the bay
that surrounds La Cotte and up to five kilometers offshore.
So that was painting in the landscape that we can't see.
So there's little bits of it that are still visible
as skerries and reefs and eroded sea stacks.
The Bates brothers' investigation showed that the seabed was not very deep.
They also found canyons where Neanderthals could trap bison,
wild cattle known as aurochs or mammoths.
Here at the University of Reading,
archaeology professor Stephen Mithen has been researching
how early humans learned to develop survival skills
and adapt to their environment.
I think in many ways the Neanderthals were wild people,
but I mean wild in the best sense of the word.
They were very sensitive, emotional, caring people,
but they were engaged in the wilderness,
the wilderness of ice-age tundras, of interglacial forests, of coasts,
and had a great understanding of nature and were very much part of nature
in a way that we're not today so much.
Rivers and streams were vital to the Neanderthals' survival.
They used these bodies of water to help find their way
through dense interglacial forests.
They also hunted animals who gathered there to drink.
Excavations at Cahors, in northern France,
revealed evidence of big game hunts
that took place there an estimated 123,000 years ago.
Experts from France's National Institute for Archaeological Research, INRAP,
have been working at the site for more than a decade.
The animals were probably killed on the riverbank.
At that time, the river was about 10 meters from here,
not where it is today.
The ground was soft, which made it difficult for the animals to move around.
It would have been too dangerous to hunt them on open, hard ground.
The lives of the Neanderthals were focused on hunting.
They developed skills that eventually made them
the most dangerous predators in the region.
They were expert hunters.
We usually associate Neanderthals with sites
where the remains of medium-sized animals have been found —
various species of deer and reindeer.
But they were also apparently able to kill wild cattle,
which were nearly two meters tall.
The woolly rhinoceros was also huge.
They were very aggressive and dangerous animals,
but they also provided a rich source of food,
including meat and bone marrow.
Excavation director Jean-Luc Locht says
the site has yielded important new information
on how Neanderthals adapted to their environment.
And this has changed our perception of these primitive humans.
Before the Cahors site was discovered in 2002,
experts believed that Neanderthals could not adapt
to interglacial environments.
It was thought that they inhabited only the colder steppe zones
and moved out of our region during interglacial periods.
Evidence from the Cahors site indicates that Neanderthals
spread their activities over several locations.
For example, the current excavation was set up
at a place where these early humans
butchered the animals they'd killed.
This was an intermediate site they used for slaughtering.
They killed the animals somewhere else
and then brought the carcasses here.
Afterward, they probably took the meat to a base camp
that was a little further away.
We've recovered items that indicate that these people
made their weapons very quickly, without a lot of extra work.
The idea was to complete the hunt
in what was, for them, a short period of time.
Scientists have now determined how these sites were used
and how long they were occupied.
The oldest lair is around 124,000 years old.
They went there twice a year.
The newest stratum, which is about 121,000 years old,
was used for ten months at a time.
It's clear that Neanderthals were able to adapt
successfully to their environment
by restricting their activities to specific areas.
They were nomads, but they lived in a rather limited region
where each site fulfilled a specific function,
like extracting raw materials or slaughtering animals.
And they created living spaces in sloped areas
that protected them from high winds.
They knew how to make good use of these narrowly defined areas.
Materials recovered from the Ka'ua site
highlight an important feature of Neanderthal culture,
their nomadic way of life.
This phenomenon has been confirmed by evidence
found at the La Côte site on the island of Jersey.
The first scientists who visited the site
at the turn of the last century
discovered the remains of numerous woolly mammoths.
Most of these items ended up in private collections.
This tooth is the only one that remains in the hands of scientists.
We don't know precisely how Neanderthals
are getting hold of the mammoth that we see brought into La Côte,
but we assume that they're probably hunting
numbers of them in that landscape
or maybe also scavenging them as well,
but they're certainly not bringing them in any great distance.
The Neanderthal hunters trapped their prey
in the rugged Jersey landscape
and then used flint-tipped weapons to kill them
and flint tools to butcher them.
But no items made of flint have been found on Jersey.
So where did these essential tools come from?
We know from the flint that's carried in
that the journeys people are making are from maybe 20,
maybe 30 kilometres away from out around Guernsey,
Alderney, where fresh flint outcrops.
To make those journeys,
you're tracking in maybe over a couple of days.
You're carrying your toolkit with you,
you're working it down as you go
and you're not replacing it with local raw materials.
So it's like these are deliberate moves
to get to places that you know are there.
It sort of gives us an insight
into Neanderthal geographies,
the ways Neanderthals are mapping their world, really, I think.
Materials excavated at Kahua and La Corte
indicate that Neanderthals learned to plan their activities,
such as hunting, in areas where they lived.
This level of sophistication does not correspond
to the stereotype of Neanderthals as crude, low-browed cave dwellers.
I think unquestionably Neanderthals
were undertaking some planning in their activities.
We know that they were hunting big game.
We know they were hunting mammoths, bison, horse.
Now, to do that, you have to do some planning for that
because it's got to be a group, cooperative activity.
You need to anticipate where the herds are going to be,
exactly how you're going to hunt them.
You then also need to plan how you're going to distribute the food and butter it.
So clearly there's got to be planning there.
We can just see that from the basic archaeological evidence that we get.
Planning allowed the Neanderthals to optimize key activities like hunting.
This was an important development
because there were so few of these early humans.
It appears that they lived in small groups, with perhaps 20 or 30 people.
A large clan might have two or three families.
These small groups moved over relatively large areas.
In all, there were only a few tens of thousands of people
in an area the size of Europe.
It's unusual that such a relatively small group of people
scattered over such a large area
kept coming back to places that were far less spectacular
than the cliffs of Jersey.
In southern France, excavation work continues at Grotte Mondrain,
a cave-like structure on the Rhône River that served as a Neanderthal shelter.
Ludovic Slimac is the project leader.
He says that the evidence they've found here
indicates that this was an important stop on many Neanderthal migrations.
Mondrain faces due north towards the Mistral River,
which deposited sediments in the cave over thousands of years.
Humans first arrived here 120,000 years ago.
We've recovered items from the cave that date back 80,000 years.
It's a marvelous archaeological repository
that covers the period from the first settlements
to the extinction of the Neanderthals 42,000 years ago.
It's the only one of its kind in the world.
In these layers of sediment,
Slimac and his team have found a lot of evidence
showing that Neanderthals lived here.
They stayed only briefly, sometimes just a few days.
But they apparently came back, again and again,
throughout the course of their existence.
Archaeologists have discovered gaps of several decades
where no Neanderthals appear to have been present here.
Slimac believes that over 80,000 years,
the Mondrain caves were occupied frequently by nomadic groups.
What makes a Neanderthal a nomad?
Did they follow herds of animals, like horses, bison or reindeer?
I think that they had good reason to migrate.
When we talk about nomads,
we mean populations that are thoroughly familiar with a specific area
that could be relatively large.
Groups of Neanderthals apparently met regularly in specific places.
For example, once a year, they'd gather to exchange information
and members of their group, especially young people.
There's evidence from the Cidrone cave in Spain
that Neanderthals also exchanged women at these meetings.
They lived together in small groups and reproduced amongst themselves.
And that could cause genetic problems.
A healthy gene pool needs constant imports and exports of material.
So, for example, I might exchange my sister for someone else's.
This would help to enhance the group's genetic continuity.
A typical gathering place was La Côte-des-Saints-Brelades.
Various groups met there over tens of thousands of years
for the specific purpose of population exchange.
The survival of the tribe was essential.
That's also why groups of Neanderthals met often
to hunt migrating wild animals.
We found evidence that certain objects were transported from far away,
or in a completely different direction.
For example, flints that came from 300 kilometers farther east,
or 300 kilometers farther west, or 150 kilometers farther north.
It's not possible that one group would cover such a large area
in its annual migrations.
That's thousands of kilometers, and it doesn't fit an annual cycle.
The evidence indicates that there were several groups,
and each had its own territory.
And once or twice a year, they'd meet at one place
to engage in common activity.
These meetings would produce the desired results
only if the various groups could communicate with each other.
This raises the possibility that Neanderthals
had developed rudimentary language skills.
I think to be able to anticipate and plan your social activities,
your hunting activities, your foraging activities,
must imply a pretty sophisticated system of communication.
It doesn't mean it's necessarily compositional language like we have,
in terms of words and grammar and so forth,
but it means a very sophisticated form of communication.
Scientists have been studying what sort of language
the Neanderthals may have spoken.
In any case, these ancient humans do seem to have had
the physical capability to speak.
We can reconstruct the basic shape of the Neanderthal vocal apparatus,
and it seems to be fundamentally similar to ours,
but maybe the voice box was a little bit higher in the throat,
which would suggest the voice was a bit higher pitched.
It doesn't quite go with the Butch Neanderthal image
of them having higher voices, but maybe they did.
But we know that the ear bones of Neanderthals
seem to be functioning like ours do for sound transmission,
the same range of frequencies,
so their hearing certainly would have given them
the same capabilities as we have in terms of hearing language.
So I think all of that suggests Neanderthals had a basic language.
They'd be talking to each other, they had speech capabilities.
So it seems likely that Neanderthals
were able to communicate with each other.
But did they use language in a form that modern humans would recognize?
They did communicate, so they did have language capability.
It was a complex and sophisticated form of language
that allowed groups to exchange information with each other.
And that was crucial to their survival.
The crux is whether they were using words in the way that we use words,
and those words were then combined with complex grammatical rules or syntax
to be able to convey complex ideas, narratives, information.
Now, I suspect not.
Still, Neanderthals were able to communicate among themselves.
But what form did this language actually take?
I think musicality is really important.
Musicality is hugely important for expressing emotion.
It's hugely important for social bonding as well.
If you go off hunting a bison or working as a team,
I've got to be absolutely confident that you're going to throw your spear
just at the right time to hit that bison,
because if you don't, I'll get trampled to death.
So how are we going to build up that trust if we haven't got words?
I think we sing and dance together,
and I think we still see that in the modern world.
Singing and dancing together builds up trust,
builds up that common bond, that sense of a group.
That must be critical to Neanderthal survival.
Scientific analysis of Neanderthal brain cases
and comparisons with those of modern humans
may help scientists to better understand
the speech capability of these prehistoric people.
The brain case of Neanderthals
is very different from that of anatomically modern humans.
For example, a flat forehead and strong brow ridges,
an elongated flat skull.
This is a robust male.
He died at an age of 42 years.
The shape of the brain is very typical
and is unique under the fossils of the world.
The morphological structure of Neanderthal brain cases
is strongly different from that of anatomically modern humans,
but the internal structure isn't well known yet.
We may never be able to create an anatomical profile
of the Neanderthal brain.
But scientists can use their knowledge of modern human brain structure
to study that of these prehistoric people,
especially their cognitive abilities.
Because when you talk about cognition,
you know, my cognition is partly a factor of my brain
and that's partly a factor of what I've biologically inherited
and partly a factor of my development environment,
but then there's also all the other support around me.
You know, I'm not very clever
unless I've got a smartphone in my hand these days
or a ruler or a book and so forth.
So cognition is really a combination of your material culture you have,
your social environment and your biology inside of you.
So we know the Neanderthals had large brains.
They may have become networked differently,
but without that material culture to scaffold their cognitive development
and scaffold and support their thinking,
and without words to do that,
I think they were inherently inhibited.
But despite the limitations cited by Professor Mithun,
were the Neanderthals able to develop a culture
as we understand the term today?
Expert opinion on this topic is divided,
since there's no hard evidence of songs or dances,
if indeed they had any.
Some scientists believe that the archaeological evidence
indicates that Neanderthals were capable of creating works
that may be described as art.
One of those scientists is British prehistorian Matt Pope,
who knows the flint deposits on the south coast of England quite well.
Pope is part of the team that's studying the site at La Côte de Saint-Brelard.
He and colleague Becky Scott will carry out further excavations there.
Within La Côte, perhaps the two most famous stratigraphic levels within it
are the two bone heaps.
On the western wall of the cave,
they were piling large amounts of mammoth
and a small amount of woolly rhinoceros bone.
They could be just the remains of butchered animals,
neatly piled up in just a very ordered behaviour.
They could be stockpiling them for other uses.
These bone heaps go even further in their ordering.
The way the skulls of mammoth are placed around the outside of these bone heaps,
the way that ribs are driven on end into the sediment,
almost to fence in and constrain the bone heaps,
and in one case, a rib even driven through a skull
into the sediment underneath,
goes beyond simple tidiness, goes beyond stockpiling material.
They're creating something.
Even if it's just a kind of routine, habitual behaviour,
even if it has no symbolic meaning,
it's still monumental, what they leave behind.
It would still, if you saw it today, look very, very striking.
Evidence that Neanderthals were capable of planning and building structures is rare.
So the discovery of the Bruniquel Cave in 1990,
in France's Aveyron Valley, caused a sensation.
In a space located more than 300 metres from the entrance,
archaeologists discovered several structures made of broken stalagmites.
There are rings of this material, as well as random piles.
The ring structures were later determined to be approximately 175,000 years old.
Some scientists say that the Neanderthals who built these structures
had developed a complex level of social organisation.
There's a parallel between the bone heaps and the stalagmite circles at Bruniquel Cave.
Both, in a way, are inexplicable in their order.
Both are very, very structured.
Of course, at Bruniquel, it's deep in the cave.
They're not using food refuse.
But it shows that they're capable of working together
to create structure out of chaos without any obvious function.
We've got lots of words for those sort of behaviours in our own language.
We can call it symbolism, we can call it art, we can call it ritualistic behaviour.
I don't think those words are very helpful.
I think it is just something very, very human to try and monumentalise landscape.
Monumentalise landscape with our own traces and our own interventions on it.
A rare indication of Neanderthal abstract expression
was discovered at Gorham's Cave on the Gibraltar Peninsula in 2014.
A series of intersecting lines.
The press dubbed it history's first hashtag.
It's not clear what the symbols mean.
Some experts, like Ludovic Slimac, caution against speculation.
There's evidence that early Homo sapiens made jewellery.
They took the teeth of carnivores that they killed,
drilled holes in them and created necklaces.
We've found none of that among Neanderthals.
No jewellery, necklaces, beads or anything that might require drilling.
And scientists have examined countless artefacts from that period.
Humans wear jewellery and clothing to show off.
These items shape our mental, cultural and social universe,
which we then present to others.
Neanderthals simply didn't do that.
Future archaeological discoveries may prompt sceptics to change their minds.
But this discussion also raises an important question.
How closely did Neanderthals resemble modern people?
The science constantly changes how we envisage Neanderthals.
And at the same time, we want to bring them close to us.
We're seeing them as very modern in terms of their behaviour.
We should never forget the fact that if we were confronted by one,
if we encountered one in the street or in the landscape,
we'd instantly notice differences in their mythology,
in their face, in their bearing, in their gait.
The first humans of the species Homo sapiens
arrived in Western Europe about 50,000 years ago.
This development appeared to seal the fate of the Neanderthals,
who were far less sophisticated.
Studies of the Mondrang cave, the reconstruction of settlements there
and the discovery of flint objects
indicate that Homo sapiens came to Western Europe in two waves.
The first consisted of scouting parties who used advanced flint tools.
That group disappeared after about ten years,
and the Neanderthals gradually returned to the Mondrang site.
Homo sapiens returned to the region a few thousand years later,
around 42,000 years ago.
This cave was home to both the last Neanderthals and the first modern humans.
They probably traveled north from the Mediterranean,
through the Rhône river valley.
They settled there,
and it's likely that they came into contact with Neanderthals.
This was just about the time that the previous residents of this region,
the Neanderthals, started to die out.
There's been a lot of speculation about why and how this happened.
The Neanderthals had been there for dozens, even hundreds of generations.
But suddenly, with the arrival of Homo sapiens, they disappeared.
They never returned to the caves where they had lived.
Studies at sites in France, other parts of Europe and Western Asia
have concluded that the Neanderthal population became extinct
about 42,000 years ago.
Tom Haim is an expert on carbon-14 dating.
He's a professor of archaeological science at Oxford University
and says that recent scientific studies have provided new information
on why the Neanderthals died out.
And actually this is different to what I originally thought
when I first started working in this area.
I thought that modern humans would kind of sweep in
and the Neanderthals would go extinct relatively soon after.
But actually, it seems to be a lot more complicated than that.
And there seems to be a mosaic of populations in different parts of Europe.
We also know, of course, that the DNA is telling us
that these two populations not only met, but they interbred with one another,
which adds an increased layer of interest and complexity at the same time.
I think over the 2,000 to 4,000 years in which we see modern humans
and Neanderthals living or overlapping in Europe,
that there was a slow and gradual disappearance of Neanderthal groups.
As Neanderthals started to interbreed with Homo sapiens,
their numbers grew smaller and smaller,
until they eventually disappeared altogether.
I think the Neanderthals were, to some extent, trapped in their success.
They survived for 200,000 to 300,000 years
through huge amounts of climate change in very challenging environments.
But their culture remained pretty stable.
For 200,000 to 300,000 years, they were making basically the same types of tools.
They were exquisite tools,
but the amount of innovation, the amount of creativity is minimal.
Neanderthals and Homo sapiens co-existed across Eurasia for several thousand years.
These ancient humans managed to survive major changes in climate,
but they failed to adapt to the arrival of a superior species.
The thought that there was a point where there was a group of people
surviving in the same landscape who were superficially so similar to us,
but maybe did things in a different way,
it's almost like playing a hunter-gatherer thought experiment or something.
I just think it's incredible that, at one point,
we weren't the only human species that walked the Earth as we are today.
I think that the way that we look at Neanderthals
says a lot about how we deal with others.
And this raises the question of how we treat other members of our species.
Today, people are always talking about the cultural shock of migration.
I think the situation is exaggerated,
but it still reflects on how we deal with others.
From time to time, archaeologists find new evidence
that helps us to better understand how Neanderthals lived.
But these are just fragments from the long history of this species.
Modern humans inherited part of their genetic code from Neanderthals.
Perhaps that's why many of us are fascinated with the relics of these ancient people
and the similarities that Neanderthals share with modern humans.
If they had managed to survive, the world would likely be a very different place.
Neanderthals developed a distinct social intelligence
and were much more attuned to their environment
than was the species that replaced them.
We can only speculate on what influence the Neanderthals might have had
on the course of human history — for better or for worse.