White House WARNS Dems over Trump probes
Article III Project senior counsel Josh Hammer joins 'Fox & Friends First' to analyze the constitutional conflict over Democrats' potential probes into the Trump administration and the legal consequences they could face for overreach.
#fox #foxnews #media #breakingnews #us #usa
AI Generated·May contain errors
Good morning, Todd and Ashley.
While some Democrats have made comments comparing subpoena pledges
to handing out candy or Mardi
Gras beads, the rhetoric prompting a letter
from the top lawyer in the White House.
White House counsel Will Scharf telling incoming
House Oversight Chair Robert Garcia, we are
monitoring the abusive and capricious threats
that are now proliferating from Democrat legislators
who seek to abuse the legislative process to intimidate
and to interfere with the lawful
functioning of government.
Recent public statements underscore these concerns.
You and your congressional colleagues have asserted
that they will issue subpoenas to harass, threaten,
and deter dedicated members of the administration from further service.
Scharf indicated the executive branch may launch its own
investigations, too, if it finds some of the subpoenas are unlawful.
Garcia is undeterred, saying the White House
is infringing on his committee's role.
I think first, it's shocking that the White House would send
a letter that is clearly a threat to the Congress, a threat to me,
when all we're focused on is investigation and rooting out corruption.
The reality is that we're not going to be intimidated by the president.
We're not going to be intimidated by anyone in our work.
Elon Musk has emerged as a potential target of Democratic oversight,
with some lawmakers looking to probe his time leading DOGE.
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries,
who's in the running to become House Speaker,
tells Fox News Digital,
We're going to follow the facts. We're going to apply the law.
We're going to be guided by the Constitution.
Jeffries says he's letting Garcia and Congressman Jamie Raskin,
who's poised to become the incoming chair
of the House Judiciary Committee, take the lead.
Ashley and Todd.
Maddie, thank you.
Let's bring in Article 3 Project Senior Counsel Josh Amber.
Josh, threats on threats on threats on threats.
This is going all over the place.
Let's go to what Will Scharf said.
White House counsel warning Democrats against using
congressional investigations for political retaliation.
Quote, threats to executive branch officials designed
to deter them from public service
or process designed merely to abuse
or instill fear in the recipient may cross the line.
Here's the key line.
into blatant criminality, the administration will not be extorted
and will not be cowed by unlawful process motivated by animus,
pettiness, hatred, or any other unlawful motive to intimidate,
penalize, or interfere with the lawful functioning.
of government. This falls under this concept of potential deprivation
of rights under color of law. It's a phrase you're going
to hear a lot going forward over the next two years.
So, Josh, what legal consequences could congressional Democrats face
for illegally overreaching,
reaching that criminal threshold that Will Scharf explained right there?
Yeah, so a lot to unpack here. I'll try to be as brief as possible.
So I think the first thing to note is as follows.
The key point of Will's excellent letter to the Congress is this.
Congress is a legislature of enumerated powers.
We know that as a basic feature of constitutional structure.
James Madison writes this in the Federalist No. 45.
You can just open your Constitution and go to Article 1, Section 8.
There are 18 specifically enumerated powers of Congress.
What Will is saying in this letter to Garcia and other Democrats
is that Congress, if you were going to be engaged in investigations,
subpoena power, it has to be in pursuit towards the end
of fulfilling one of your specifically enumerated powers.
To make this even clearer.
There is no retribution clause in Article 1,
Section 8 of the Constitution.
That is not a legitimate function of the government.
If Congress is going to be engaged in trying to exercise
its powers under the Commerce Clause or under other clauses,
then they can engage in legitimate investigations.
But that's essentially what Will is saying.
Now, Hakeem Jeffries, in that clip we just saw,
is saying that we intend to follow the Constitution.
If that's true, then there's no problem.
But if there's going to be a fishing
expedition, there could be some problems.
Now, to your question, there are a couple
of U.S. statutes on the books.
18 U.S. Code Section 241 and 18 U.S. Code Section 242 come immediately
to mind that do criminalize under the Ku Klux Klan Act of 1871
a conspiracy to deprive your fellow Americans under the color of law,
that's Section 242, of their constitutional rights.
You can't do that.
That is actually a criminal conspiracy under U.S. law.
So that's, I think, what Will is getting at in this letter.
But the even higher big picture takeaway is essentially what I said,
which is that Congress is a legislature of enumerated powers
and any investigation or subpoena power.
Simply has to be towards the pursuit of those ends.
So I hear there's a line between legitimate criminal acts
and legitimate oversight, okay?
So when you hear a line, the first thing you think of,
oh, that line has to be decided by a court.
And when you think courts, you think it's ultimately got to go up
to a Supreme Court to decide these things,
especially when it's major national powers fighting.
So strategy question for you
in the time we have remaining, about 30 seconds.
Could Republicans theoretically tie up
these investigations in the courts
in the hopes of time running out on the Dems in two years?
They could. Historically speaking, the courts don't typically
get involved in Article 1 versus Article 2 disputes.
These are typically inherently political disputes
for which courts are not well suited to issue a legal remedy.
So they really should be hands off when it comes to Congress
and the executive branch butting heads.
That's really the essence of what Madison wrote in the Federalist
papers, that ambition should be made to counteract ambition.
So they really should not step in.
But yes, I expect a lot of invocations of executive privilege
by the executive branch when Congress inevitably oversteps.
And again, traditionally the courts don't get involved there because
Because executive privilege is not a clearly defined term.
It's part of the inevitable give and take of our political conflicts.
It's referred to as the accommodations process.
But it's going to be a fascinating battle for the next two years.
It's going to be a lot of executive privilege,
a lot of Democratic overstepping, no doubt.
And I think Will Sharpe has gone off to an excellent start
by reminding Robert Garcia and Democrats to not overstep,
lest they regret what they have done.
And it sort of explains the Jim Jordan selection.
Because as we have learned, Jim Jordan is a fighter.
They selected a fighter.
Josh Hammer.
Professor Josh Hammer.

