Do past arguments keep resurfacing in your relationship with a fearful avoidant? Discover the hidden reasons behind this pattern and learn how to resolve conflicts effectively for deeper connection and lasting harmony.
In today’s video, Thais Gibson uncovers the three secret reasons why fearful avoidants revisit past arguments and how these patterns stem from covert contracts, unmet needs, and unresolved feelings. Learn practical strategies for breaking these cycles through direct communication, emotional validation, and vulnerability. Watch now to transform your relationships and create healthier dynamics built on trust and understanding.
00:00:00 – Introduction: Why Fearful Avoidants Bring Up Past Arguments 00:00:59 – The First Secret: Covert Contracts 00:02:15 – How Covert Contracts Lead to Misunderstandings 00:04:10 – The Fearful Avoidant’s Strength in Reading Needs 00:05:54 – Over-Giving and Under-Receiving Dynamics 00:07:37 – The Build-Up of Resentment in Relationships 00:10:20 – Why Negative Framing Fails to Solve Problems 00:12:35 – Tracking Unmet Needs Over Time 00:15:15 – The Importance of Direct Communication 00:17:10 – Resolving Arguments for Long-Term Growth 00:18:59 – Final Thoughts: Breaking the Cycle of Unresolved Issues
So maybe you're in the middle of an argument or disagreement that
could be quite small, but all of a sudden you see that you have
this deep urge to bring up unresolved issues from the past.
And perhaps from your partner or loved one's perspective on the
other side, they're going, wait, why are you bringing up the past?
This isn't something we've talked about before.
I thought we set this to rest.
Well, there's a reason that the fearful avoidant attachment
style continuously tends to visit old arguments.
And there's actually three major ones in total.
And without understanding these underlying reasons as to why
this takes place so frequently, you may easily find yourself
repeating old argument patterns over and over again, often to
the detriment of your relationship with somebody you love and care
about, and you may find that even though you bring these things
back up, you're not actually feeling like they ever get resolved.
So in today's video, we're going to go through the three major
reasons as to why fearful avoidant attachment styles bring up past
arguments over and over again.
And most importantly, we're going to talk about what you can do
differently in a short period of time in a fast and simple way to
totally revolutionize this pattern.
A, so that you feel resolved in arguments way easier.
B, so that you don't actually bring up old things over and over
again, to the point where it can cause some damage or harm to the
relationship, but most importantly, so that you're not carrying and
fostering resentment all the time because of things going left.
Unsaid or unresolved to begin with.
So if you're new to this channel alone, welcome.
My name is Thais.
I'm really happy that you stopped by.
I create daily content here on YouTube, all about the subconscious
mind healing, dating, and attachment styles after working in this
field for more than a decade.
So if you have any questions about this video today, please let me
know in the comments below.
And I'm hoping that if you enjoy this video today, you will also
subscribe to the channel or perhaps share this video with somebody
you think might benefit.
So here's the first thing.
Okay.
The first of three major reasons.
And I think that this can't quite be said enough.
And it's the fact that fearful avoidant attachment styles are almost
always operating by something known as covert contracts.
Okay.
What is covert contracts?
Well, covert contracts are a very common feature of codependency and
basically how a covert contract works is it's based on this idea that
somebody feels too afraid to communicate their needs upfront in a direct
and vulnerable way with their partner.
And oftentimes they may even just believe at a deeply subconscious
level that even if they did communicate their needs wouldn't be met anyways.
And that's not necessarily a reflection of their partner that
they're in the relationship with, but maybe more of a reflection of
the fact that growing up, they didn't really have access to their
needs being met or seen or heard or understood.
And so you got conditioned to just believe that, well, my needs
aren't going to be met anyway.
So it's almost like an unknown that you could even
communicate them to somebody.
And so as a result of this, you tend to operate in relationships
through hyper vigilantly recognizing what other people's needs are,
which is something that fearful avoidance are the best at more than
any other attachment style is reading between the lines and noticing
micro expressions and body language and tone of voice changes and sort
of taking and extracting that information to guess what somebody's
feeling or what they're needing or what they're thinking.
And a lot of times you're probably quite right about what your guesses
are, but a lot of other attachment styles are not necessarily as
adept as the fearful avoidant attachment style at discovering
what people's needs are.
So all of this to say on this point, number one, that if you don't
know how to communicate your needs, and yet you are really good at
guessing and recognizing other people's needs, in fact, often more so
than other attachment styles are, there is an extremely high chance that
you end up operating by covert contracts and relationships that feel
unfulfilled and basically a covert contract is, okay, I'm going to read
between the lines and guess what your needs are, then I'm going to
really go over and above and beyond to meet your needs, hoping that
what I'm really doing at the same time is buying my ability back for
you to want to meet my needs.
Okay.
So it's this idea that if I invest in you enough, you'll then feel
obligated or have to invest in me back.
Or maybe you'll see that I'm worthy of investing back.
And on one hand, this is quite a common theme or pattern for many
people.
And honestly, hearing about this, you might even be like, wait,
what's wrong with that?
What's, what's the problem here?
Well, the problem is the fact that what this filters out almost
immediately is the opportunity for healthy communication, securely
attached people in secure relationships.
The one thing they do very well is they communicate their needs
directly and they don't rely on mind reading, which is obviously we
don't actually think people are mind reading, but it's a psychological
concept that means you expect the other person to get it, to figure
it out if they care.
In fact, I've often had countless conversations with fearful
avoidance who have said, well, if this person really loved me, they
would have figured out what my needs are, but that's not how
healthy relationships are built.
They're not built upon figuring out each other's needs and guessing.
They're built upon open communication and the normalization of
communication.
It's so clear.
The communication and asking about needs feels as easy as asking
somebody for a glass of water.
Now I can tell you before I get to these two other points that as
somebody who was fearful avoidant myself, and this was the attachment
style that I had to work through and in order to become securely
attached, I absolutely operated by covert contracts and that the
roots of this, it was because I felt unworthy.
And so I thought, okay, I have to give more than I receive all the
time.
And then, you know, if I give way more than somebody will finally
see that it's okay to meet one of my needs and they'll, they'll
feel like, okay, it's, you know, I'll feel safe to even ask or to
bring something up, but I never would ask for a need unless they
felt like I had kind of earned it from somebody, which is highly
dysfunctional by the way.
But again, if you would ask me this, like 15 years ago, I thought
that was normal and I couldn't even imagine something outside of
that.
And so what ends up taking place?
And I'll tell you in a few moments, how this relates back to why
fearful avoidance bring up past arguments, but you'll see it really
comes full circle.
But how this ends up showing up in your relationships is that you
will constantly overgive and under receive.
You will constantly, as a result of that feel unseen and unheard,
like, okay, I have to do so much just to get a little bit.
And arguably worst of all, the moment somebody says no to one of
your needs, which by the way, people are not always going to be
able to meet all of your needs, right?
Maybe you ask somebody for a need that in the background for 30
days, you've been like, oh, I'm going to probably ask for some
help with something next month.
So let me for the next few weeks, just really pour into this
relationship.
So I've earned my right to ask for this need.
And then let's say for whatever reason, that person, you ask them
to, you know, go to an event with you that where they have to
travel and they're just not available.
And you're like, you know, the amount of.
Of hurt that causes isn't just about that moment in time, right?
It's not just about, oh, the person's not available for this
event and I just asked them about it.
No, it's the fact that like for 30 days, you've been building up
to trying to feel comfortable enough to even ask for this need
to be met or ask for this person to do something that you were
hoping they would do.
And so of course it's not always like a 30 day cycle for people,
but a lot of times when we're operating by covert contract, we
are literally in a position where we are pouring into something,
hoping that then it's okay for us to ask for something back later.
And what this does is it just creates these tremendous breeding
grounds for you to feel resentful for you to feel not cared about
because you're expecting somebody to read your mind.
And unfortunately, if you are, if you're full avoided, you're going
to be the best person at quote unquote mind reading, which of
course you're not actually reading minds, but like at reading
between the lines and trying to guess what somebody's feeling
and needing, and you're going to be so much better than that,
better than other attachment styles at that, that it's always
going to feel like you're, if you're operating by covert
contracts, but you're giving so much more than you're ever
getting in terms of what you're actually needing back.
And I want to explore one other thing here about this concept, right?
Oftentimes the reason fearful of winds are so much better at this.
And I still have to tell you the two other points, how this
relates to why you bring up past arguments, but oftentimes the
reason that you're better at mind reading is if you look at the
different attachment strategies that the different attachment
styles have are anxiously attached style or the anxious attachment
style, they, their attachment strategy is to maintain proximity.
It's like to get closer to people.
Yes, they can be a little hyper vigilant around abandonment and
read between the lines there, but oftentimes it's less like
they're really hyper attuned to micro expressions in body
language and more like they're recognizing if somebody pulls
back and then they're giving that meaning like, oh my gosh, the
person's going to abandon me.
Dismissive avoidance.
So their main strategy is to maintain their freedom and
independence and autonomy is what makes them feel safe.
Okay.
If I can maintain my freedom, then maybe it's safe enough to
attach a little bit to somebody fearful of avoiding attachment
styles, because you usually grow up in chaos of some kind route,
whether it's a parent who's an alcoholic or has a personality
disorder or who is struggling in, maybe you've got a, an
environment where there's just a tremendous amount of fighting
or a bad divorce, like all these things for fearful avoidance.
What that actually creates is a child who, in order to survive
that environment, you become extremely hyper vigilant about
what's going to happen.
So you may find, for example, that if you're fearful of
avoiding, let's just pretend like as an analogy that your
environment you grew up in was you had a parent who was an
alcoholic.
Well, you're always looking for like, okay, is this person
sober?
Are they going to be in a good mood when they're sober?
Are they going to be in a bad mood?
Cause they're going through detox or withdrawals.
Are they in a, they're drinking?
Okay.
Are they in a good mood when they're drinking or bad mood?
Should I be scared?
Should I be, and you're always reading between the lines to
recognize what could be going on.
And it makes you extremely hyper vigilant.
And so your attachment strategy is like, you want closeness,
but you're scared of it at the same time.
And so you just read between the lines to try to predict
everything that you can.
And that really is the attachment pattern of a fearful
avoidance.
So now you have this dynamic where from a covert contract
point of view, you are going to be overgiving under receiving.
And that's really what brings me to point number two here,
overgiving and under receiving, leaving you feeling unfulfilled
in the relationship.
And then what a lot of fearful avoidance do here.
And again, you're going to see in a moment how this all pairs
into like why you bring up past arguments, but what this is
going to leave you feeling a lot of times it's like people are
not showing up for you in the way that you're showing up for
that.
And you may feel like you have a series of one way
relationships in your life, but here's the craziest part.
You may make that mean that other people don't care about
you the way you care about that.
And oftentimes that that's not even the case whatsoever.
Oftentimes somebody on the receiving end thinks they're
loving you and caring for you in a great way and in the way
that you would need.
And they're not often recognizing that things are going
unsaid or unnoticed in regards to you feeling fulfilled or
like you're getting your needs met in the relationship.
And when you don't communicate about your needs, you hold it
in, you hold it in and you start tracking, okay, a lot of
fearful avoidance when you're, when you are not getting your
needs met, you start tracking all the times you weren't
getting your needs met and you start to build a narrative or
a story like, okay, they didn't do this for me last Friday.
And then two months before that, you know, this other thing
didn't happen.
And I did this for them at this point and they didn't even do
this.
Now, some people right from the outside would, you know, say,
oh, this is petty.
Like you're, you're, you shouldn't be tracking.
Well, what people don't realize is that when you're in this for
you, it's kind of like a survival strategy for how you relate
to people.
It's like, okay, I have to make sure I'm tracking everything
and all of our interactions so that I can keep giving more
than I received so that I can feel worthy of love and
connection so that I can feel safe to even ask for any of my
little needs that I have at all without being a burden or
without that sacrificing the relationship and me seeming like
this person who needs too much and is too greedy for their
needs in a relationship and is taking up too much space.
And so you're tracking because it's, it's your way of trying
to stay and keep the relationship surviving.
Okay.
So it's this strategy.
Now, now, again, you're going to see in point number three,
how this all comes together.
But what I want to really, you know, harp on in point number
two is if you're always over giving and under receiving, not
only does that mean that you're constantly having to track your
interactions, but on top of that, it also means that you're
not only tracking your interactions, but sometimes if
your needs go unmet for long enough, you'll find yourself.
Full steam ahead, down the rabbit hole of going, Oh, this
person doesn't care about me.
And I'm actually going to wait until I reach this critical
threshold of seeing that I'm hurt enough by their lack of
care and lack of investing in me the way that I'm investing in
them, but I'm suddenly going to leave.
And it's actually a big part of the reason fearful avoidance
sometimes leave relationships seemingly out of the blue from
the other person's end.
Somebody might be like, everything was great.
And the fearful avoidance left all of a sudden, well,
sometimes it's because there's a backstory of covert contracts
and interaction tracking where this person feels like, okay,
I'm over giving under receiving.
But at its core, one of the things that's so solvable about
this is if you just learned to communicate your needs, you
wouldn't feel like this.
You wouldn't feel alone.
You wouldn't feel as resentful.
You wouldn't feel like people don't care about you and aren't
able to meet your needs.
It's the fact that you're operating from these programs
and patterns that helped you survive in childhood, but are
not necessarily conducive at all.
To adult relationships, especially adult romantic
relationships.
So we have these two themes.
Okay.
And I'm going to tell you about the most important thing and
how this all comes together and why fearful avoidance bring
up past arguments, but you've got these covert contracts that
lead to you interaction tracking and, and cause you to over
given under receipt.
And these are all features of codependency.
And by the way, if you want to go deeper into codependency,
you can actually check out a fully free course about
reconditioning your patterns of codependency and enmeshment.
And this will help you see some profound results in the
first seven days.
So I'll put a link down below, but it will really help
you challenge these codependent ideas and patterns and fears
that you have, and also learn what your needs are and how
to communicate them in a way that will get you seen and
heard without ever being a burden to anybody.
But I'll put a link to that for free down below for
a limited time.
Now, the last major piece and how you're going to see this
tie together is that if you do this for long enough, because
you're interaction tracking, because you're operating by covert
contracts, under giving and under receiving, this leaves
you point number three, feeling very unseen and unheard.
And when you reach this critical tipping point, either
you'll leave a relationship all of a sudden, or the vast
majority of the time you will start communicating through
negative framing.
So watch this.
Let's pretend that one thing that I really need in the
relationship, and let's pretend it's with Bob is for Bob
to do more chores around the house.
And let's say if I'm fearful avoidance still that I start
doing extra chores around the house and lots of Bob's chores
and do all these nice things for Bob, because I'm working
my way up to being like, Hey, Bob, I need you to do some
chores too, or I'm hoping Bob will see how much I'm doing
and then also want to contribute.
But this just leads to me over giving and under receiving.
So now I start paying attention.
Like, okay, I've been chores the last five or six times and
Bob hasn't done them at all.
And now I'm waiting and waiting for Bob to figure it out
and pay attention and start taking his turn.
But eventually I just get frustrated.
And then by the eighth or ninth time that I'm doing the
chores, I go to Bob and then I start communicating from
frustration, frustrated communication will almost always lead
to something known as negative framing, which means I'm going
to say, Bob, I've been doing all the last chores for the
last nine times.
What's going on from your end?
Why haven't you been able to do this?
Why aren't you making an effort?
Do you not care?
Do you not this?
Do you not that?
And this isn't the answer to this, by the way.
And number three is not going to be what you think.
Okay.
So then I communicate from negative framing.
As soon as I communicate through negative framing and especially
from an emotionally charged place, somebody doesn't see
and hear me.
They just see in here that I'm criticizing them.
So they don't even hear what my need is.
Right.
And there's an old saying behind every criticism is a wish.
And if I'm just communicating through criticism, Bob doesn't
see my need or my wish, Bob just sees that I'm angry and now
he's defensive.
So then that whole argument that we had about the chores,
I'm left feeling like Bob's just defending himself or in an
argument.
Maybe we give each other the silent treatment for a day or
two, and then we're back to the same old pattern.
The moment we leave an argument or disagreement without,
especially if you're listening to this, as if you're a full
avoidant without feeling seen and heard without having your
feelings validated, because remember there's been this backstory
of the covert contracts and feeling like you're overgiving
and under receiving and feeling alone in that the moment.
But after all this time, you didn't get your point seen
and heard.
Bob didn't come to you because Bob was defensive.
He was like, whoa, you're so angry at me and he's defensive.
The moment you didn't get Bob saying, Hey, I'm so sorry.
I haven't been doing the chores.
I see that you've actually been doing the chores so much over
the past little while.
And that must feel like I'm not showing up for you.
And what do we need going forward?
Okay, how can we take turns doing the chores?
Unless you feel like you get two things in an argument, your
feelings and perspective validated.
And number two, unless you actually feel like there's a
strategy to stop this pattern from continuing where you feel
like you're over giving and under receiving and nothing's
getting resolved, you will always store that argument or
disagreement as being unresolved.
So let's say that some time passes and it's time to do the
chores. And here you are.
And you're back at time for the chores.
Well, because the last argument or disagreement you had was
just you both bickering about chores and getting defensive.
And then it was kind of swept under the rug.
And then nothing really got resolved.
You never felt resolved in the first place.
And the number one reason people, especially fearful avoidance
will bring up arguments from the past again is because you
will bring up things that do not feel resolved.
And unless you actually feel resolved, which again comes
through two major ingredients, feeling like your feelings and
perspective are seen and heard and actually validated and
feeling like there's a strategy to solve for the problem at
hand. Unless those things are covered, you'll always store
that argument as we never actually got to resolution.
So you're bringing up things from the past because they still
exist for you in the present.
They've never been solved for.
They're still alive and well in your subconscious mind and
in your perception and experience of the relationship.
And until you learn to actually communicate your needs and see
them through, listen, sometimes people won't actually meet
your needs. But when you communicate healthily in real time,
the vast majority of the time they will.
And if they don't ever, despite you communicating healthily
and creating strategies and doing it from a vulnerable
perspective, somebody doesn't meet your needs and yet you're
communicating them, then you don't belong in a relationship
with somebody who's never going to put in an effort, right?
Like that's just a non that's not even an issue, right?
If somebody is never caring to grow the relationship or make
an effort, you're in the wrong relationship across the board.
So if you do not get those two ingredients, you know, feeling
like there's a strategy, feeling like your perspective is seen
and heard and validated, then you always store the argument
as never being resolved.
So it exists in the present, despite it being in the past,
the challenge, the problem, the issue, it's not resolved.
It's still here.
So no wonder it's getting brought back up.
So all of this to say, unless you learn to communicate your
needs, share your feelings and perspective in a vulnerable
space and ensure that your partner can actually see and hear
you and listen, you will keep bringing those arguments back
up in the past because they're still alive.
If you want to do a deeper dive on rewiring those codependent
patterns and learning your needs in more detail, again, you can
check out that free course down below.
I hope this video made sense to you and sort of just shed a
little bit of light on this issue at hand.
And if you have more questions, let me know in the comments
below.
And if you are somebody who feels like this could benefit
somebody in your life and want to share it or subscribe to
the channel, that's always amazing too.
We'd love to have you here and thank you for watching.