What They ACTUALLY Ate at the First Thanksgiving in 1621

History Of Food
342 followers
#History #Food
This video was produced exclusively for American Food History. We created this content to provide an immersive look into America's culinary past, uncovering the forgotten recipes, survival meals, and daily dining experiences that shaped the nation throughout the decades. We are dedicated to exploring the fascinating and often overlooked chapters of American food history—from the rugged meals of the Wild West and Great Depression survival dishes to the diverse immigrant recipes that built this country's unique culinary DNA.
By https://www.youtube.com/@AmericanFoodHistory
In the autumn of 1621,
about 50 English settlers and roughly 90 Wampanoag men
sat down together for a three-day harvest
feast near Plymouth, Massachusetts.
Most Americans think they know what was on the table.
Turkey, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce,
pumpkin pie, buttered rolls,
maybe a green bean casserole.
There were no potatoes, there was no butter,
Almost none of that was there.
there was no pie of any kind,
there was no cranberry sauce
because nobody had the sugar to make it. The cranberries
were growing in bogs a short walk away,
so sour they would make your face fold in half.
There was no cream, no cheese, no milk,
because there was not a single cow in the colony.
The first cattle would not arrive for three more years.
The centerpiece of the meal was not even provided by the English.
It was five deer, killed by the Wampanoag guests and brought as a gift.
So what did they actually eat? That is what this video is about.
Not the Thanksgiving you grew up with, the one that actually happened.
And to tell that story we have to start with a problem.
We barely know anything about it at all.
You would think that the most famous meal
in American history would be described in
loving detail. It is not.
Everything we know about what was eaten at the 1621 gathering
comes from one short paragraph.
It is in a letter Edward Winslow wrote in December 1621,
which was published in London the next year
in a book now known as Mourt's Relation.
The whole thing is just a few sentences.
Winslow says the harvest was gathered in. The governor
sent four men out fowling
so they could rejoice together after they had gathered the fruit of
their labors. Those four men killed enough fowl
in one day to feed the colony for almost a week.
Many of the native people came,
among them their great leader Massasoit with some 90 men.
The English entertained and feasted them for three days
and the visitors went out and killed
five deer which they brought to the plantation
and gave to the governor, to the captain,
and to others. That is essentially it.
That one paragraph is the entire foundation of the
American Thanksgiving story.
Every turkey, every painting, every school pageant grew out of it.
And it does not mention Turkey by name.
Not once.
Now, there is one more source.
William Bradford, the colony's governor,
wrote about that same autumn in a manuscript
that had a very strange journey.
It went missing for many years,
turned up in London in the 1850s, and was finally published.
Bradford mentions that, besides waterfowl,
there was a great store of wild turkeys, of which they took many.
That line does a lot of heavy lifting.
It tells us turkeys were around
and the colonists were hunting them that season.
But Bradford was describing the autumn in general, not a specific menu.
So what we have is this. Birds. Deer. Corn that did well.
Barley that was indifferent good. Peas that failed.
And a settlement of 50 survivors
who had nearly starved to death the previous winter sitting
down with 90 guests for three days.
Everything else about the food is reconstruction.
Educated guesses built from what we know about the land,
the season, the cooking methods
of the English and the Wampanoag,
and what Winslow and Bradford described growing and
living in the region.
Some of it is very likely.
Some of it is plausible.
And some things that sit at the center
of the modern Thanksgiving table are flatly impossible.
Let us start with what we know for certain.
The centerpiece was deer. Winslow writes that
Massasoit's men went out and killed five deer
and brought them back as gifts.
Five deer is an enormous amount of meat,
hundreds of pounds, enough to feed a crowd for days.
And it came from the Wampanoag guests, not the English hosts.
Think about what that means.
The most celebrated meal in American history,
the image we put on postcards and paper plates,
the meal people imagine
as the English generously feeding the native people,
was in large part supplied by the native guests themselves.
Venison would have been roasted on spits over the fire,
boiled into stews, probably cooked into
pottages with corn. Every part of the deer could be used.
This was a gift of real value from a
leader whose people had lost so much to disease
and who had chosen that year to make an alliance
with these struggling strangers for reasons of his own.
But the first food the English prepared was birds.
Winslow is clear about this. The governor sent
four men out fowling, and in a single day,
they killed enough to feed the colony for almost a week.
Four men. One day. That tells you how rich this land was in game.
So what birds did they bring back?
Autumn is migration season in New England.
Huge flocks of geese pass through and rest on marshes,
ponds, and coastal waters.
A hunter with a musket could bring down several in a short time.
And the English loved goose.
Back home, roast goose was a classic celebration dish,
especially in the fall.
There was an English custom of eating goose around Michaelmas,
a holiday at the end of September.
Which falls right in the window when this feast likely took place.
Goose is fatty, rich, and full of flavor.
As it roasts, it drips fat into the fire or into a pan beneath it.
For people with no butter and no lard to spare,
that dripping fat was gold.
Ducks were everywhere too.
Bradford mentions waterfowl being plentiful that season,
saying it increased as winter approached.
Ducks were smaller than geese,
which made them faster to roast and easier to share.
Many of the birds those four men brought back
were probably ducks.
And turkey? Probably.
Bradford's manuscript says there was a great store of wild turkeys that
season. But the wild turkey of 1621 was not the bird you buy
in a supermarket. It was lean, dark,
strong, a fast runner, and a capable flyer.
There was not much fat, the meat had a gamey edge, and
it was not the star. It was one bird among many,
possibly sharing the spit with ducks, geese,
There may have been birds at this feast that no longer exist.
In 1621, the passenger pigeon was one
of the most common birds in North America. Early accounts
described flocks so enormous they darkened the sky for hours.
Some estimates put their
population in the billions.
If the flocks were passing through that autumn, four men
sent out to bring back as many birds
as possible could hardly have ignored them.
The last known passenger pigeon died at the Cincinnati Zoo in 1914.
You cannot recreate this part of the meal. It no longer exists.
Now, here is how they cooked all of this.
The English of this period roasted meat
on a spit in front of the fire, not in an oven.
Someone, often a child, had to turn that spit for hours.
Birds were also boiled in pots with whatever vegetables
and grains were on hand,
creating a rich broth.
With about 140 people eating for three days,
you can imagine fires burning constantly,
birds turning on spits, pots bubbling,
and the smell of roasting fowl drifting across
the settlement. And the meat did not stop with birds and deer.
Plymouth sits on the water.
The harbor flats were loaded with shellfish.
Clams could be dug out of the mud at low tide
by anyone with a pair of hands and a little patience.
Mussels clung to rocks in dense black clusters.
For the starving settlers of that first year,
shellfish had been a lifeline.
You did not need a gun. You did not need to know how to hunt.
You just needed to know when the tide went out.
The waters around Plymouth were so thick
with lobster that settlers could pull them from the
shallows. Today, lobster is a luxury.
In 1621, it was practically garbage. Later colonial writers
described lobsters so plentiful that people grew tired of them.
The same creature that now costs you $30 a pound
was likely sitting next to corn mush on a plain wooden board.
No drawn butter, remember. No cows.
Just hot lobster meat and whatever salt they had.
Bradford wrote that some of the settlers were employed
in fishing for cod and bass and other fish.
Cape Cod is literally named for the fish.
Cod could be salted and dried.
Bass could be roasted fresh.
A big platter of roasted fish
is not the image anyone puts on a Thanksgiving card,
but Bradford's own words put it right there.
And then there were eels.
If there is one food on this list that would clear out a modern dining
room, it is eels. But eels were one
of the most important foods in the life of Plymouth Colony.
In the spring of 1621,
Squanto walked out to a nearby creek and came back with as many as
he could carry, trotting them out of the mud with his feet.
Winslow described the eels as
Fat and sweet. Eels fattened up in autumn before migrating.
Which means the harvest season was prime eel season.
Smoked eel or roasted eel at the feast is very plausible.
It is one of the most authentic Thanksgiving foods there is,
and you will almost never see it served today.
Without corn, there is no feast. Period.
That first spring, the colony was in ruins.
Half their people had died over the winter.
Their English seeds were unproven in this soil.
Then, a man named Tisquantum, better known as Squanto,
showed them how to grow corn the
way it was grown here, plant it in hills,
put fish in the ground as fertilizer.
The settlers caught herring running up the streams in spring
and buried them in the planting
mounds.
Bradford said that without the fish,
the corn would come to nothing in those worn fields.
And here is the part of Squanto's story that school lessons often skip.
He knew English because years earlier, around 1614,
he had been kidnapped by an English captain
and taken across the ocean to be sold in Spain.
He made his way to England and eventually back home.
When he returned, his village, Patuxet,
was gone, wiped out by an epidemic.
Plymouth was built on the site of his village.
The man who saved the colony's harvest
was teaching strangers to farm on land
where his own people had died.
When Winslow wrote that their corn did prove well,
that harvest carried all of that inside it.
Now, the settlers' wheat was almost gone by
the autumn of 1621. Bradford wrote that every person
was getting about a peck of meal a week.
And he called it Indian corn.
So whatever bread was eaten at the feast was made of corn, not wheat.
But do not imagine sweet, fluffy cornbread from a box mix.
This was flint corn, a hard,
multicolored corn that had to be ground or pounded into
meal.
Without wheat, eggs, butter, or baking powder,
cornbread in 1621 would have been dense,
flat, and coarse.
Mixed with water, and maybe a little salt, shaped by hand,
cooked on a hot stone or in the embers.
Think of it closer to a flat corn cake than a loaf. The
most common corn dish at the feast
was probably something almost nobody has heard of, nasamp.
It is a Wampanoag corn porridge.
Dried corn was pounded into a coarse meal and boiled with water
into a thick hearty mush.
It could be enriched with whatever was available, nuts, dried berries,
bits of meat or fish.
Roger Williams, writing about the native peoples of the region in 1643,
described nasamp as a kind of meal pottage,
and he wrote that the English came to eat it
and grew to like it.
The English were already used to pottage,
a thick stew or porridge that sat at the center
of many ordinary English meals, so nasamp was not that strange to them.
It was a familiar idea
made with an unfamiliar grain.
If you want to taste the most everyday food of that harvest
season, it is not turkey.
It is a bowl of warm corn mush with a handful of crushed walnuts
and dried berries stirred through.
Simple, filling, and entirely native.
The Wampanoag did not plant corn alone.
They planted what are often called the Three Sisters.
Corn, beans, and squash, grown together in the same mounds.
The corn grew tall
and gave the beans something to climb.
The beans returned nitrogen to the soil.
The squash spread its broad leaves across the ground,
shading out weeds and holding in moisture.
It was a farming system refined over centuries,
and it was more productive than anything the English knew.
Native cooks combined corn, beans,
and sometimes squash with meat or fish in a long simmered pot,
creating a rich, thick stew.
The word succotash comes
from a Narragansett word Roger Williams recorded.
It is exactly the kind of food that would make sense
when 90 guests show up for a three-day feast.
Throw in more corn. Throw in more beans.
Add another bird. Keep the pot going.
Winslow's letter also gives us one more grain, barley.
Their barley was, in his words, indifferent good.
Not great, not terrible.
For English people, barley meant two things,
pottage and beer.
Barley broth was a staple English comfort food,
but barley's real value was as malt,
the raw material of beer.
These were people who had been drinking beer
every day of their lives until it ran out.
A barley crop meant the possibility of brewing again.
We do not know if any was brewed before the feast,
but the barley in their fields was a sign of hope
that the familiar life of England might be rebuilt here.
If you enjoy rediscovering the meals America grew up with,
you might enjoy the American Food History Cookbook Collection.
It includes five cookbooks
and hundreds of historical recipes brought back for today's kitchen.
If you'd like to take a look, just open your phone camera,
point it at the QR code on the screen,
and tap the link that appears.
Pumpkins and squash almost certainly existed at the feast.
The Wampanoag grew them, and the English called them pumpions.
But pumpkin pie was impossible. Think about what pie requires.
Wheat flour for the crust, butter or lard,
sugar, eggs, milk or cream, and an oven.
In the autumn of 1621, the colony's wheat was gone.
There was no butter because there were no
cows. Sugar was scarce at best,
and historians do not believe the settlers had built a proper
bake oven yet. So what did they do with pumpkins? They stewed them.
Cut into chunks, boiled down soft,
sometimes seasoned with whatever they had,
maybe a little vinegar, maybe a little spice from the stores.
Later in the century, an English writer
described New England settlers cooking
pumpkin down into a soft,
tart mash and eating it with meat, almost like a side dish.
That is the real ancestor of pumpkin on your table,
not a sweet custard in a crust, a warm,
earthy, slightly sour stew of squash eaten next to roasted meat.
Beans were there too.
The Wampanoag beans, grown alongside the corn and squash,
were dried after harvest and stored.
When cooked, they were simmered with corn, sometimes with meat or fish.
The English had planted their own peas
that first year, and they failed.
Winslow wrote that their peas were not worth the gathering,
scorched by the sun as they bloomed.
So the native bean was the one that came through.
A pot of beans at that table was proof
that native knowledge worked where English knowledge had failed.
Autumn in New England was nut season,
and the woods around Plymouth were full of them.
Walnuts, chestnuts, hickory nuts, and acorns.
Before a blight wiped them out in the 20th century,
the American chestnut was one
of the most important trees in the eastern forest.
In the fall, the ground beneath those trees was carpeted with nuts.
Hickory nuts could be pounded
and boiled to produce a rich, oily, milky liquid
that added fat and flavor to stews.
Nuts are dense with fat and calories.
Exactly what bodies recovering from starvation needed.
If you want one ingredient on your modern table
that would have felt right at home in 1621,
put out a bowl of chestnuts.
Winslow also wrote about wild grapes, white and red,
very sweet and strong. He mentioned strawberries,
gooseberries, raspberries, and three kinds of
plums. Most of those had their season in summer,
but the Wampanoag were masters of drying fruit.
Dried berries were stored through the year
and stirred into corn dishes for sweetness.
Roger Williams described a dish of parched corn
and dried currants that the English
prized as a treat. So when you imagine dessert
at the first Thanksgiving,
do not imagine a pie. Imagine a handful of sweet,
chewy, dried fruit mixed into a warm bowl of corn.
For people who had essentially no sugar, that sweetness was precious.
The English of the 1600s also loved what they called salad herbs.
Fresh greens eaten raw or
lightly dressed. Watercress grew wild
in the cold clear streams around Plymouth.
It has a sharp peppery bite.
For people who had spent a brutal winter eating salted meat
and hard biscuit, fresh green food was not a garnish. It was medicine.
The humble side salad may be one of the most authentic dishes
you could serve on Thanksgiving, and almost nobody does.
And wild onions.
Every English cook in 1621 would have been searching for them.
Onions were the backbone of English cooking.
Wild onions, wild garlic, and wild leeks grew in the woods.
Wild leeks, what Americans now call ramps,
have a deep garlicky punch.
And here is a detail worth knowing.
When English cooks of the period stuffed a bird,
they often did not use bread at all.
They used onions, herbs, and sometimes nuts.
So the stuffing at the first Thanksgiving,
if there was any, would have looked nothing like ours.
Picture a duck or goose packed with wild onions,
a few herbs from the woods, maybe some chestnuts
cracked from the forest floor.
As the bird turned on the spit, the fat would melt through that
filling and the onions would soften into something sweet and savory.
That is a stuffing your
ancestors might have recognized.
This is where the modern Thanksgiving falls apart.
When the pilgrims arrived, they did not bring a single cow, not one.
The first cattle did not
reach Plymouth until 1624, three years after the feast.
That means no milk, no butter, no cheese,
no cream. Think about what that wipes off the modern table.
Mashed potatoes with butter, green
bean casserole with cream of mushroom, buttered rolls,
creamed onions, pumpkin pie with whipped cream,
All of it? Impossible!
Potatoes? Those are gone too.
White potatoes come from South America,
and while they had reached Europe,
they were not part of everyday English cooking yet,
and were not growing in New England.
Potatoes were not established
in the region until about a hundred years later.
Sweet potatoes? Same story.
So the most beloved side dishes in America did
not exist at the meal that supposedly inspired them.
The first Thanksgiving was a feast of meat,
corn, fish, and whatever the forest gave.
Everything soft, creamy, and buttery came later, much later.
Cranberries grew wild in the bogs
just a few miles from Plymouth.
Massachusetts is still one of the biggest cranberry growing
states in the country, but cranberry sauce was impossible.
A raw cranberry is brutally sour.
Turning it into sauce takes a lot of sugar.
And the colony did not have it.
The first written description
of English settlers boiling cranberries with sugar into a sauce
appears roughly 50 years after the feast.
The canned cranberry sauce millions
of Americans slide onto a plate every November was not
sold until the 20th century.
And here is something else you will never see
in a painting of the first Thanksgiving.
Forks. The settlers did not use them.
Forks were still a rarity in England in 1621,
seen as a fussing foreign habit.
People ate with knives, spoons, and their fingers.
Large napkins were essential, because hands got greasy,
and meat was torn apart by hand.
So picture the scene properly.
Not a long polished table with matching chairs and a white tablecloth.
With about 140 people and only a handful of small houses
in the settlement, most people were likely
eating outdoors, standing, sitting on the ground,
on stumps, on whatever was available.
Food passed by hand,
meat cut with a knife and eaten off the blade or in the fingers,
and the guests outnumbered the hosts.
There were about 50 surviving English settlers
and about 90 Wampanoag men.
Of the English, only four adult women
were still alive after the first winter.
Four women, along with servants and children,
helped cook for three days for a crowd of around 140.
And what were they drinking?
17th century English people did not trust water. Back home,
rivers ran through towns full of waste.
Ordinary families drank weak beer with breakfast,
lunch, and supper. When the Mayflower sailed,
its hold was packed with barrels of beer.
By the spring of 1621, the beer was largely gone.
Bradford wrote about the moment the
settlers realized they had to drink plain water,
and he recorded it almost like a confession.
Then came the surprise. Winslow later wrote home describing
the water around Plymouth as some of
the finest he had ever tasted.
The streams were clean, cold, and safe. So, forget the silver
goblets. Most people at that feast
were probably drinking fresh spring water. The most English
people in America were drinking the most
un-English drink imaginable. Nobody at that
That table in 1621 called it Thanksgiving.
To the pilgrims, a day of Thanksgiving
was a religious occasion. Prayer, worship,
sometimes fasting.
Not three days of feasting, food, and firing muskets.
What happened in 1621 was more like
an English harvest home celebration,
a secular tradition where communities gathered after
the crops came in. The phrase First
Thanksgiving was attached to it centuries later,
in a footnote by a Boston historian in 1841.
Then came the lost manuscript.
Bradford's account of Plymouth,
with that line about wild turkeys, had gone missing.
It turned up in London in the 1850s and was finally published.
Right around that time, a writer named Sarah Josepha Hale
was campaigning for a national Thanksgiving holiday.
She spent years writing letters to presidents.
That line about wild turkeys helped seal
the bird's place in the American story.
In 1863, in the middle of the Civil War,
Abraham Lincoln finally declared a national day of
Thanksgiving. The turkey, the pie, the mashed potatoes,
the cranberry sauce, all of that was
built onto the story long after the people who lived it were gone.
The Thanksgiving dinner
Americans eat today is a 19th
and 20th century invention dressed up as a 17th century memory.
And there is one more thing that sits alongside this feast.
Many Wampanoag people and other Native Americans marked
the fourth Thursday of November not as a
celebration, but as a national day of mourning,
which has been held in Plymouth since 1970.
The relationship between the settlers
and the Wampanoag did not stay peaceful. Within a couple
of generations, it collapsed into one
of the deadliest wars in colonial American history.
That history does not cancel the feast, it completes it.
Here is a part of the story
that rarely makes it into the school pageant.
In November 1620, before the settlers had even chosen where to live,
a small group went exploring on Cape Cod.
They found mounds of earth. Inside some of them
were buried stores of corn,
carefully put away by local native people for later use.
The settlers took it. They called the place Corn Hill.
The English later said they intended
to pay the owners back, and months afterward,
they did. But at the time,
They were helping themselves to someone else's winter food.
That stolen corn became seed corn.
Some of what the settlers planted in the spring
of 1621 may trace back to those buried stores.
So, when you see corn on the Thanksgiving table,
remember where the colony's corn story began.
Not with a gift, with people taking food that did not belong to them
because they were desperate.
Here is what the real first Thanksgiving looked like.
No table, no forks, no tablecloth.
About 140 people eating outdoors over three days.
Fires burning constantly.
Constantly.
Burden.
Birds on spits.
Pots of corn mush and stew bubbling.
Deer roasting, lobsters and clams pulled straight from the harbor,
flat corn cakes cooked in the embers,
a bowl of corn porridge with crushed walnuts and dried berries,
wild onions in everything,
fresh water from a cold stream.
50 English settlers who had nearly died,
and 90 Wampanoag men whose leader had his own reasons for being there.
The guests brought more food than the hosts.
The most famous harvest in American history
was fed by the people whose land it was.
The turkey, the pie, the cranberry sauce,
the mashed potatoes, all of it was invented later.
The real meal was simpler, stranger,
and more interesting than anything on the postcards.
So here is my challenge.
This year, add one real 1621 food to your table.
Roast a duck. Stew some squash.
Make a bowl of corn porridge with walnuts and dried berries.
Put out a plate of chestnuts.
Then, tell the story of where it came from.
Drop the one you are going to try in the comments.
I want to know if anyone is brave enough to serve
eels. Because the real first Thanksgiving
was not about the food we eat today.
It was about the people who were actually there.
