What the Jonathan Brooks INJURY means for the Panthers + could Austin Eckler be the answer?
5 Video Views·Sep 24, 2026
I'm really hoping for his sake.
This is just a minor setback.
Jonathan Brooks has become one of the most talked about players in recent Carolina Panther
memory for all the wrong reasons.
Now let me clarify this up front.
Not for reasons beyond his own control, but yet again, Jonathan Brooks is hurt.
Jonathan Brooks is going down for surgery.
That's going to put him out a minimum six weeks.
Now, in my opinion, my guess is that we probably don't see much of Jonathan Brooks for the
rest of the season.
And even if we do, it's not going to be in full detail as you would expect for someone
of his level of talent.
I mentioned this on the last Mint Street Monday that even before this injury was made known,
or we started seeing any kind of remnants of the potential for surgery or anything that
was lingering, it just looked, he looked different, right?
When you saw him run, it just, it looks like he lacked explosion, you know, like he normally
did.
There were a few moments where you kind of saw, okay, well, things are kind of moving
right along for him.
Maybe he just kind of getting reacclimated, the knee being torn again, but now it's the
growing, right?
And this was something that was lingering from the preseason.
There were a lot of people, myself included, who were concerned with the usage in training
camp a lot.
I mean, he looked great in training camp, right?
And so you knew that if he's not in the best of football shape, it was going to take him
a while to get there.
So we thought just the general soreness could be from the fact that, hey, you're just getting
reacclimated to getting hit and playing and, you know, all that looked good.
But here we are nonetheless.
And I got to tell you, I have never felt more worse for a guy.
And the reason is because there's a duality here.
On one hand, you feel really bad for the player because this guy worked his tail off to get
back to this point, right?
He worked very, very hard, and that cannot come into question.
But on the other side of this, you also look at it as a what if.
And it does kind of make you think like, man, if this would just be amazing if we just had
the healthy version of him in a very short sample size that we had in Tampa of the explosive
Jonathan Brooks, of the catching out of the backfield Jonathan Brooks, and we even saw
that this year, right, against the Bears.
But it just wasn't consistent.
And it wasn't as explosive.
And now here we are again, where he's only played a handful of games in a number of years,
right?
I don't think that this is over for Jonathan Brooks, because I think that there's a lot
left in the tank for him.
We've seen this historically before, not so much with running backs, right?
I know a lot of people make the Thomas Davis comparison.
A lot of people make the comparison to JC Horn.
Both do play explosive positions.
Linebackers in explosive position.
But it just feels different when it's a running back because of the amount of explosion that
you have when you come out of breaks, plant your foot in the ground, things like that.
And it doesn't seem like to me anyway, I'm no football expert.
But it doesn't seem like that same amount of explosion is necessarily needed for those
other positions that I just mentioned.
But either way, I hope that Jonathan Brooks is able to come back.
Apparently, this surgery is going to like I said, it's going to keep him out about six
weeks. So we'll see what happens now.
What does that mean for the Carolina Panthers moving forward as far as their running back
room is concerned?
Well, we got reports today that Austin Echler has worked out with the Panthers, had a
visit, may not have worked out yet, but definitely had a visit with the Panthers.
But even he coming off of a ACL tear from last year with the Washington
Commanders, that he's cleared to go.
But it is kind of a fear because this is a high level player.
Don't get me wrong. I know Austin Echler is 31 years old, older player, but he is high
level, efficient, can catch out of the backfield.
All the stuff that you love about the modern NFL running back, this guy has in his
arsenal and would only help to add to the room with the Chuba Hubbard, with a Trevor
Ichien that's coming off of injury himself, that will eventually be back and be
available for us as well.
But I would expect that Dan Morgan and company would probably
look in another direction, although Dave Canales did mention that they were kind of
just only looking at him for the time being.
So regardless, we don't know how that's going to go.
I just hope that they find something because this passing game, look, Bryce Young
and company have been getting all kind of praise throughout the week, and I love it.
No doubt. I love 30 plus points a game.
But when you start to get a little further down the season, guys like Jalen
Coker fielding, you know, punts, which it looks great, no doubt, but I do not like
it, especially because of how efficient and high level he is as a receiver and
someone he you could directly correlate and tie the fact that this passing offense
is so explosive because of his availability for the first time at the top of the
season since he's been with the team.
Right. And so that's important.
It's important to keep him in a position where he doesn't get overused just because
he happens to be good at something.
They answer that by signing a guy like Amir Smith-Marset, who's been here before.
Glad to see him back.
Obviously, there'll be other options back there.
Xavier Liget can be an option as well.
So they've got other plans and other options of people that they can put back for
both kick and punt return.
You just don't want to see Coker being used that much.
But the point I'm making in all of this is this, regardless of how explosive this
offense is, the thing that you can do to kind of slow down other high power offensive
teams like we saw with the Bears is have a stout running game.
Right. And it also helps out your quarterback to continue to, you know, in his
development, helps your receivers to be able to, you know, kind of take some wind off
and not have to work so hard.
So you do want to see a good running game be established here.
I'm excited about A.J.
Dillon. I seen A.J.
Dillon on punt return the other day or the kicking team, I should say, and had a big
tackle. So I thought that was really cool.
But I am excited to see him get his opportunity because he will definitely get snaps
going into this game against Cleveland because you're just going to have to have him
right. And he's been a look.
He's a bruiser, quadzilla for a reason.
So it's exciting to see him get in and get his opportunities as well with Chuba Hubbard.
And so, you know, maybe that's the answer.
Maybe him, you know, short yardage situation, being able to move the chains, that'll be
a great answer. Play action.
That'll be a great answer as well with him being able to being really good in blitz
pickup. So those are all important things as well.
But I'm excited about the Ekler situation.
I can't even lie about that, because like I said, when he's at his best, he's a high
level player, right?
With the charges for years, Washington commanders, you know that this is a guy that
he can get it done right.
But you just want to make sure you're getting the most healthy version of him.
But to the Brooks thing yet again, man, Jonathan Brooks, man, you know, we're praying
for you. Pray that you get healthy.
Pray that you can keep your same confidence, man, more than anything else, because I
can't imagine how this is for him mentally.
Just knowing, like I said, you put in so much work to get yourself back to a level
where you know that you can perform at the highest level.
And yet again, here we are with another injury.
I don't think it's the book on this guy for his career, but it wouldn't surprise me if
in the future Carolina decides to go in a different direction.
And for, you know, like I said, all intents and purposes, I hope that Brooks gets
healthy. Let me know what you think below.
Make sure to like, run that hype, and I'll see you on the next upload.
Till next time, y'all keep pounding.

