What if you put your head in a particle accelerator?

We Science Too
67 followers
14 Video Views·Oct 22, 2022
On the day of the accident, the only thing standing between Anatoly Burgosky's brain
and a beam of protons traveling close to the speed of light were a lock and a light bulb.
Anatoly Petrovich Burgosky was an employee of the Protivinsky Institute of High Energy Physics,
the beating heart of the science town of Protvino, outside of Moscow, Russia. And in 1978,
Anatoly, a 36-year-old particle physicist, was one of the scientists working with the largest
Russian atom smasher, the U-70 Synchrotron, which lurks below Protvino and magnetically
accelerates protons in a 1.5-kilometer-long circular tube completely evacuated of air
to just 1 kilometer per hour below the fastest speed in the universe.
On June 3rd of that year, a series of simple mistakes would answer a question that no one
asked. What would artificially accelerated protons carrying 70 billion electron volts of energy do
when they pass through a human brain? This is the true story of Anatoly Burgosky's personal
Chernobyl. On June 3rd, 1987, Burgosky was a few meters below the earth surrounding Moscow,
looking after the U-70 Synchrotron's detector system with the hopes of eliminating some
temporary failures it had been experiencing. As protocol dictated, he called the control room
and told the beam operators that he'd be in the experiment hall in five minutes. The beam
operators needed to know this because in the experiment hall, the main proton beam is shunted
off from the main ring and directed through the open air at various detectors. What should have
happened next is that the control room should have removed the beam from the chamber Burgosky
was heading towards. The door to that chamber should have been locked, and a sign should have
been illuminated telling Burgosky that the beam was still very much active inside. But he didn't
see any of this. Instead, what he saw was a flash reportedly brighter than a thousand suns.
Particle accelerators are easily the most complicated machines on earth.
They are colossal constructions, the awe-inspiring endpoint of hundreds of the brightest minds,
thousands of superconducting magnets, hundreds of thousands of kilograms of liquid helium,
and more wire than you can even wrap your head around. The Large Hadron Collider, for example,
pictured here, contains approximately 1 billion miles of superconducting wire. That's enough wire
to go around the full orbit of earth, not its circumference, its orbit, twice. The wire in this
machine could line a path from the earth to the sun and back six times. Scientists use the absurdly
impressive engineering of these accelerators to study the fundamentals of the universe,
the structure of matter, space, and time, and the interactions between atoms and their
constituents at their most basic. This is done by accelerating particles through a near-perfect
vacuum with magnets and smashing them together at near-light speed to record what happens
with sophisticated detectors. Burgosky was intimately familiar with the physics here,
and he was about to get closer to it than any human before or since. Murphy's law is the
that anything that can go wrong will go wrong. And the day a high-energy particle beam pierced a
physicist's brain, everything did. Burgosky asked the control room to remove the beam in the
experiment hall in five minutes, but he arrived at the chamber earlier than expected. The automatic
lock that should have prevented Burgosky from entering the room was turned off. The previous
experiment was using a low-intensity beam, and apparently someone thought that locking the door
was overkill. In the last line of defense, a single light bulb that illuminated a sign
indicating the danger beyond burnt out just before Burgosky arrived. An experienced operator,
Burgosky did reportedly have doubts about entering the unlocked door to the chamber so easily,
but he proceeded anyway. Inside of the chamber, packets of protons were still flying silently
and invisibly through the open air, a pulsing beam between where Burgosky was and where he
needed to go. And so when he bent down to check the instruments, as he had done many times before,
Burgosky was instantly blinded when his head intercepted a particle beam,
humming with many trillions of protons moving at nearly 300 million meters per second.
The subatomic particles, each carrying 70 billion electron volts of energy,
effortlessly passed through Burgosky's brain, skin, and skull. According to a later report,
he felt no pain. Incredibly, the physicist wasn't instantly killed, as you may expect,
but after he saw a thousand suns, Burgosky knew he was in serious trouble. Anatoly calmly finished
his work in the chamber, logged the visit in a journal as usual, and then, without saying a word
to anyone about the accident, went home. The next morning, after a night of worrying symptoms,
Burgosky was brought before doctors and dosimetrists. The left side of his head was swollen.
Translating from the official case history, Anatoly's doctors immediately calculated the
dose he had received. Quote, an intense beam of high-energy protons with a transverse size
of two by three millimeters passed along the trajectory. Occipital region of the head,
medial basal regions of the left temporal region, pyramid of the left temporal bone,
bony labyrinth of the middle ear, tympanic cavity, jaw fossa, tissues of the left wing
of the nose. The radiation dose at the entrance is 200,000 roentgens. At the exit, it is more
due to scattering on the material, 300,000 roentgens. In theory, the dose of ionizing
radiation that is 100% lethal is just 1,000 roentgens, 300 times less than what had been
apparently absorbed by Anatoly's brain. The magnitude of these numbers begs the question,
why didn't he die that day? When you hear a value like 70 billion electron volts,
it's a way of quantifying the kinetic energy of particles, the energy of motion. And if
particles with kinetic energy suddenly start encountering a medium other than vacuum,
they will interact and lose some of that energy. In a biological material like your body,
this deposited energy is going into ionizing your atoms, breaking up molecules, creating heat,
and otherwise smashing nanoscale structures. Enough of this damage will eventually end any
living thing through the creation of cancer or the initiation of widespread organ failure.
And so, particles entering a medium bump into matter and lose energy. As kinetic energy is
the energy of motion, these many interactions will, as the particle proceeds, slow the particle down
and eventually stop it. And where a certain particle will stop is not a mystery to nuclear
physicists. It's something that can be calculated. For example, alpha particles pushing through the
air at a defined energy will stop after only a few centimeters. This is due to the stopping power
of air. Stopping power is a measure of the ability of a material to slow down energetic particles
that travel in its interior. Understanding stopping power is very important in nuclear physics,
but this knowledge can be practical too. It has recently given us a new way to fight the cancers
that ionization can sometimes cause. When a high-energy massive particle like a proton moves
through matter, it will lose energy as we said, but more specifically, its energy will diminish
in inverse proportion to its velocity squared. Therefore, a proton will deposit the majority
of its energy in a material right before it stops. This is what nuclear physicists call
the Bragg peak. And if scientists know how much an energy a particle will lose and where it will
be lost, then in theory a particle beam could be directed to enter a material and disrupt or
destroy only a certain volume of that material. Well, this is exactly what so-called particle
therapy does. Heavy particles from a small accelerator are pointed at a person's body
and lose almost all of their energy at a calculated distance inside and no further.
Particle therapy at its best can even pass through a person's skull to damage and destroy
brain tumors non-invasively. Anatoly Burgoski's brain effectively received the most overpowered
particle therapy session in human history. And so again, why didn't he die? The answer is the
Bragg peak of the beam that he crossed and the stopping power of human flesh. For example,
look at how far a beam of protons will travel through water, a similar density to human flesh,
at an energy 300 times less than what Anatoly experienced. It's only around 25 centimeters
or a foot. Your head is likely not even 25 centimeters in depth. Therefore,
the protons in this graph would not dump all of their energy in your head. They'd pass right
through it. And even more powerful beams protons would then be able to travel even further before
stopping. Anatoly's brain matter literally did not have the stopping power to bring the beam's
high-energy protons to a stop and to create a Bragg peak inside of his skull. This is why
Burgoski did not even come close to receiving the full dose that the U-70 synchrotron could
theoretically deposit. And that is why the actual radiation dose was so small, nowhere near hundreds
of thousands of roentgens. That he crossed the beam in the way that he did, of course, was pure
luck, as was the path the beam took through his face, missing critical brain areas and blood
vessels. Still, the fraction of energy he did absorb was enough to change Burgoski's mind and
body forever. When the doctors and scientists in Protvino first heard Burgoski's story,
they didn't believe him. But the symptoms and the severity of the situation,
an unprecedented accident involving the largest accelerator in the country, soon convinced them.
The physicist was whisked away to Moscow, to the 6th hospital inside the Ministry of Medium
Machine Building, which actually specialized in radiation injuries. After the meltdown of
Chernobyl Reactor No. 4 in 1986, the world discovered via intense media coverage that
such a hospital even existed. And according to an article published by the Ecological Truth
Organization in 1998, it had no shortage of patients. The hospital in Moscow treated the
victims of accidents at nuclear reactors, both research and military, nuclear material production
plants, and on nuclear submarines. But no one had seen a patient like Anatoly Burgoski before.
His face had swollen up beyond recognition. Over the next few days, the actual path the
proton beam took was revealed by peeling skin and lost hair. Given this face value,
few staff in the ICU thought Burgoski would live, including Angelina Guskova,
a pioneer of radiation medicine in the USSR and the same woman who headed up the treatment of
every victim of the Chernobyl disaster. But with her overseeing his treatment,
Burgoski did indeed recover. However, what those treatments were, how long each took,
how Burgoski recovered specifically, is unknown. Everything, every document and report,
every statement and testimony related to his treatment, was immediately classified.
A year and a half later, Burgoski returned to Protvino to work on the exact same beam and
instruments that caused the world's first human-slash-particle accelerator accident.
While scientists were publishing papers and dissertations surrounding the Burgoski phenomenon
behind closed doors, Burgoski was working and required to return to the radiation hospital
in Moscow twice a year to continue his treatment and to commune with other nuclear accident victims.
Like former inmates, Burgoski told Wired magazine in 1997, we were always aware of one another.
Quote, there aren't that many of us and we know one another's life stories.
Generally, these are sad tales. Though Anatoly had survived an incredibly dangerous situation,
his personal Chernobyl had only just begun. After a proton beam blasted through his brain,
hearing in his left ear completely disappeared. He started having epileptic seizures.
Any mental effort was accompanied by extreme fatigue. The nerves on the left side of his face
were destroyed, freezing his expression in place there for the last 43 years. And when he
concentrates, only half of his forehead wrinkles. The decades following Burgoski's accident were
not easy. Though the physicist was able to defend his PhD in 1980, which he prepared before the
accident, obtaining the medicine and treatment he needed was a bureaucratic nightmare. In the
Soviet Union, so-called radiation patients were only legally recognized after the Chernobyl
disaster in 1986. This meant, again, according to the Ecological Truth Organization in 1998,
quote, the entire material side of the cost of treatment and other compensation for damage to
the health of victims is somehow legally related to Chernobyl. End quote. Burgoski therefore had
the right to compensation and benefits established by the law of the Russian Federation for, quote,
the social protection of citizens exposed to radiation as a result of the Chernobyl disaster.
But of course, Burgoski's health had nothing to do with the actual Chernobyl disaster.
This confusion made him ineligible for the state insurance he was entitled to
and badly needed. Officials apparently found it too difficult to understand or process this
mini-Chernobyl Burgoski had been through. For a long time, they flat out refused to establish a
new kind of disability group for him. And no group meant even more difficulty getting health benefits.
Thankfully, Anatoly wasn't completely alone in this battle against the red tape of the once-red
state. The Prodovinsky Institute of High Energy Physics and his colleagues at work did what they
could, as did related labs and physicists working at CERN, the current site of the Large Hadron
Collider. The well-known American entrepreneur and philanthropist George Soros even bypassed
bureaucracy to establish a small grant for Burgoski. By 1997, however, the confusion
around what benefits Burgoski was actually entitled to from the state caught up with him.
That year, a ban was placed on releasing more funds for Anatoly's continued treatment,
which included insanely expensive drugs and examinations. The reason? The specific wording
on the documentation for his radiation disease said nothing of his unique encounter with a
particle accelerator or indicated that he was part of a select few with similar injuries.
It simply said that Burgoski had experienced an accident. Eligibility revoked.
He did not speak publicly about his accident for over a decade, but talking with Wired
magazine in 1997, the year his health was put into his own hands, Anatoly Burgoski said that
he would like to make himself available for study by Western scientists and presumably
have his health looked after by them. But he admitted that he didn't have the money to leave
the science town of Provino or leave the particle accelerator underneath that passed through his
brain like it was barely there. I'm being tested, he said. The human capacity for survival is being
tested. Until next time. Thank you so much to the very nerdy staff at the facility for their direct
and substantial support in the creation of this here video. Today especially, I want to recognize
research assistant Comatose and visiting scholar Simon Gould. If you want to join the facility,
if you want to drape on a silky white lab coat, get videos before anyone else, join our discord,
get behind the scenes stuff, get members only live streams with yours, truly, not like that,
you can go to patreon.com slash Kyle Hill and join the facility today. And as you can see,
if you support us just enough, you get your name on ARIA here each and every week. And as you can
see, there's literally hundreds of you, so I have no idea how I'm going to pass the test.
Anatoly Burgoski is really a specimen of what the human can endure as an animal. Not only did he
survive billions of electron volts with a particle beam passing through his brain as a young boy,
he survived an electric shock incident with a broken wire. And when he was just a month and
a half old, he was thrown out of a window by Nazis into the snow and survived in the snow as a baby
for a couple of hours. He's been through a lot. I don't know what he's doing today, but
hopefully if he's watching this, I wish you all the best. And man, you're not very lucky though.
Thanks for watching.
