What if the Second French Empire had Succeeded? (Alternative History)

Napoleon III
12 followers
Napoleon Bonaparte is near universally regarded as one of the most influential people in all
of history. His conquests of Europe spread the ideas birthed of the French Revolution
to all of Europe. Liberty, individuality, equality. During his reign France was brought
from a chaotic mess on the verge of complete collapse to an empire whose hold over Europe
was near absolute, from the ports of Portugal to the plains of Poland. But today we will
not be talking about this Napoleon. Not Napoleon I, but Napoleon III.
Charles-Louis-Napoleon Bonaparte, also known as Napoleon III, came to power in strangely
similar circumstances to his uncle Napoleon I. Following a revolution against the restored
Bourbon monarchy in France circa 1830, the French state was eventually reorganized into
a republic once more. After some limited chaos following the revolution, Napoleon III got
himself elected president. But like uncle, like nephew, being the democratic leader of
France was not enough, and in 1851 Napoleon named himself emperor of the second French
empire. A second French empire which he would try so desperately to live up to his predecessor.
But alas, he lacked the genius of his uncle to will this fantasy into reality. After decades
of lackluster attempts at expanding France's position on the global stage, his empire was
unraveled and himself captured in a mere week's long war against an old foe. But what
if the tides of history had gone differently? What if he had been able to live up to his
name, or at least succeed in the ambitions from our own timeline that he held? Today,
I will be looking at a series of best case scenarios for Napoleon III and taking a look
at how these changes would change our modern history if they had all come to fruition.
This scenario will see changes in three major theaters and events, Mexico, Italy, and of course
Prussia and the war that ended the second French empire in our own timeline. We will begin out of
chronological order with Mexico. Following a bloody civil war in Mexico between religiously
fervorous conservatives and republican secular liberals, Mexico found itself in a mountain of
debt to the major European powers. Following the victorious republican government making a quite
clear they had no intentions to pay off this debt, it was decided by Spain, Britain, and France to
intervene militarily in Mexico to seize the payment. This was to be done while the Americans,
who would usually stand against European intervention in the Americas, were distracted
by their own civil war. However, Napoleon III had other ambitions for the invasion of Mexico,
not only to seize debt, but to conquer the entire country and put a puppet monarch on the throne,
namely Archduke Maximilian von Habsburg of Austria. French relations with the Habsburgs
in Austria will actually be a common theme throughout this scenario. As soon as Napoleon's
true ambitions were revealed to the other powers of the intervention, they withdrew their support
and troops. Despite this, France was able to secure control over most of the country in the
name of their newly established imperial Mexican puppet regime under Maximilian. However, before
they could fully establish control, Mexican resistance was able to make a stunning comeback
and push back the invaders, eventually leading to France's retreat from Mexico as a whole.
How were the resistance able to do this? American funding. The conquest of Mexico had dragged on
until the end of the civil war, leading the Americans to be able to intervene with weapons
and funding before the French were able to achieve complete victory. The conquest was a race against
time, and in order for the French to be victorious, they would need to achieve victory
quicker than in our own timeline. France began achieving complete military victory following
their siege of Puebla, also known as the Second Battle of Puebla. But a year before, they had lost
against the Mexicans in the First Battle of Puebla, this victory being the reason behind the Festival
of Cinco de Mayo. In this timeline, General De Lorenzo is able to break the Mexican army during
his second offensive during the battle, which had almost been successful in our own timeline.
This gives the French conquest a whole other year to be completed before the end of the American
Civil War. France and their imperial Mexican puppet are able to be in full control of Mexico
by the end of 1865, just in time. The Americans can do nothing about it. France had established
her foothold on the continent. One of the biggest political shifts in Europe in the 19th century was
the unification of Italy, a decades-long process which took the peninsula from a number of smaller
squabbling states dominated mostly by Austria into a united state and kingdom. Italy was a place of
interest for the Emperor of France, viewing the situation there to be a golden opportunity to
score a new ally. During the unification, it was agreed between France and Italy's eventual unifier
Sardinia-Piedmont that Sardinia-Piedmont would remain under French guidance as they expanded.
However, for a number of reasons, France just didn't have enough influence over Sardinia-Piedmont
to maintain it throughout unification. But this was not the only plan for a unified Italy.
In opposition to the plan for a modern kingdom of Italy headed by the Piedmontese monarchy
was a plan by famous thinker and priest Vincenzo Ghiapparti, who had served as a prime minister
for Sardinia-Piedmont before falling from power and being exiled to Paris. His plan was for Italy
to be a looser confederation of states under papal control, a papacy who just so happened to
be heavily influenced and even militarily occupied by France. I would like to imagine for this
scenario that Napoleon decides it would be easiest to secure a French-influenced Italy
if this was the plan that came to fruition. Now, let's make it happen. First, we'll need a new pope,
as Pope Pius IX was not particularly interested in leading a unified Italy. Enter Luigi Lembrosini,
the main opponent of Pius IX in the papal conclave of 1846. Now, we have no reason to
believe Luigi would have supported a united Italian federation under himself, but at least
he gives us a blankish slate. Let's say he is both elected instead of Pius and is convinced
by Napoleon and his army in Rome to secretly plan for this version of Italian unification.
Now, we need to get there, which will require two things to happen. A French betrayal and
pacification of Sardinia-Piedmont and a compromise with Austria. This can occur during the second war
of Italian independence, which saw Sardinia-Piedmont wage war on Austria to liberate Lombardy and
Venetia from Austrian control. In this timeline, instead of supporting Sardinia-Piedmont, the French
intervene and occupy them, putting themselves on good terms with the Austrians and asserting
control over Sardinia-Piedmont. During the 1859 uprisings against Austrian influence in central
northern Italy, the French and Papal States stage a joint intervention, securing control over all
non-Austrian controlled lands in northern Italy. It is now that a deal is struck with Austria to
allow for unification of Italy under the Pope and a federation, as long as the Austrians keep some
level of influence in the northern region. Then, following a military or diplomatic submission of
the Kingdom to Sicily, Italy is unified under a holy federation, led by the Pope and greatly
influenced by the French. Moving forward just a few years to 1870, we reach the fateful Franco-Prussian
War. In our timeline, this saw Prussia unite the German states behind them in their war effort,
absolutely trouncing the French, and in a matter of weeks completely dissolving the
Second French Empire, at the same time uniting the German Empire under Prussian leadership.
None of the changes we've made up to this point would have a significant enough butterfly effect
in Germany to change the events that lead up to the Franco-Prussian War. Prussia still defeats
Austria in the Brothers War, even if the Austrians don't need to send troops south to face the
Italians. Now, how do we get the French to win this war? Well, I can't just simply hand them victories
in a few battles, as that would be ignoring the bigger picture. The French were completely trounced,
outmatched. Their ability to win hangs instead on two major fields where the Prussians simply
outmatched the French in, logistics slash communications and artillery. Communication
in the French army was horrendous during the war, with slow telegraph lines and too much bureaucracy.
The army was disillusioned and in a state of confusion for nearly the entire war,
not to mention the fact that the Prussians often had better maps of the French territory than the
French themselves. Next, artillery. The Prussians had made significant advancements compared to the
French in artillery, utilizing rear-loading cannons instead of muzzle-loading ones like
the French. During the first crucial battles of the war, namely the Battle of Spitsuren and the
Battle of Worth, the French were better positioned to defend, but the Prussians were able to
overwhelm them with their artillery. So in this alternate timeline, it is the priority of the
French general staff to improve and advance in these two fields in the years before the war.
During the initial Prussian counter-offensive into the French territory, they are able to hold
the Prussians back and inflict heavy casualties onto them, while the French reinforcements arrive.
It's now that the Austrians, who the French have been buttering up to for the last couple decades
in this timeline, seeing this as their last chance to make a comeback in the German sphere in spite
of the Prussians, join the French in their war, even if the Hungarians protest the move. This
leads to the southern German states, who actually had a history of favoring Austria over Prussia
and feared Prussian domination, to defect, framing it not as joining the French side,
but the Austrian side. Facing these overwhelming odds, Prussia is crushed. The North German
Federation is dismantled, with France taking some territories west of the Rhine River and
setting up protectorates in the remainder of Prussia's western territories. Any revolt by
the Hungarians is crushed by a joint French-Austrian effort, securing their alliance. By the time of
Napoleon III's death in 1873 and the ascension of his son to the throne, the French Empire would
once again be the unrivaled European power, with her and her allies controlling almost all of
Western Europe. The Empire was back, and this was only the beginning.
On January 9th, 1873, Napoleon III would pass away from health complications.
During his lifetime, he had once more brought France from a humiliating state to an empire
whose might stands unrivaled in the continent of Europe. The French people were a proud people
once more, and Napoleon III's funeral would be grand, his legacy being one of restoring the glory
his uncle had brought for the French people. But now, that legacy would have to be carried
on by his only son, Napoleon Eugene Louis-Jean Joseph Bonaparte, Napoleon IV. Napoleon IV,
like his predecessors before him, was an ambitious man, though his ambitions lay not in Europe,
but beyond the sea, in Africa. He dreamt of taking the French Empire to territorial heights never
seen before, by conquering all of the vast continent that lay to its south. Almost immediately
following his ascension to the throne, the French began a series of rapid naval expansions to rival
the British at sea, as well as commencing new military campaigns into Algeria and Morocco.
Speaking of Britain, the British government was in a state of paranoia. Their eternal rival,
who they had just pacified a few decades ago, had already bounced back to dominate all of Europe,
and now with their new emperor, they were threatening Britain's naval dominance.
While there had been talks long ago of a potential marriage between Napoleon IV and Queen Victoria's
daughter, Princess Beatrice, any hope of such a thing, or any other cooperation between Britain
and France, had completely vanished into the haze. As France began campaign after campaign into the
heart of Africa, carving out an empire throughout the entire continent, the British began their own
operations to take their peace. The scramble for Africa had begun. Tensions ran high as the
British made connections to all non-French oriented nations in Europe. Clashes in Africa began to
escalate. War was inevitable. Would this finally be the time the flame of the French Empire was
extinguished? Or could the French finally triumph over their age-old enemy? I'll leave that up to
your imagination.
