🇺🇸 What are the Monist and Dualist Theories in International Law? (subtitles 🇧🇷 🇪🇸 🇫🇷)

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
1 Video View·Nov 14, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explains the relationship between international law and domestic law, focusing on the monist and dualist theories. It explores how states incorporate international treaties into their internal legal systems and how conflicts between these two legal spheres are resolved.
Hello everyone, welcome back to RectaRatio,
your international law channel created by me,
Professor Natália França and Professor Flávio Bassos.
Today we're going to tackle one of the
most important issues in public international law
in order to understand the conflict,
apparent or not, between international treaties
and internal rules of states.
We speak therefore of monist and dualist theories and their aspects.
From the moment that international law began
to be understood as such, that is, with the
abandonment of the belief that in international field there
were only customs, good practices
and voluntarism of states,
and that a true international legal system was being created,
theories of how those two worlds,
international and internal, are legally related to each
other began to be discussed.
Reluctant to the advancement of an international legal system,
we have the dualist theory by
Trippel and Anzillotti, for example,
which understands that the objectives of international
law and the domestic law of states are totally different,
since they are legal systems produced
in a different way, and they are mutually exclusive,
as if there was a radical line
dividing between the two of them.
For this theory,
Both systems are equally existent and valid,
but they have different sources.
They have different objects and different goals.
In international law, its source is the treaty,
the accommodation of at least two sovereign
wills, while in domestic law, the source is the will of a single state.
In the same way, the sources
and norms of international law do not influence matters
of domestic law and vice versa.
Only one applies to the outside
and the other only applies to the inside.
Still, the dualist theory believes that the assumption
of an external commitment does not have
any impact or repercussion on the domestic law of the countries,
but only for the relationship
between two or more countries.
In order for the international norm to have a legal value
internally, the state needs to transform it into an internal norm.
Whether by an amendment, an act, a decree,
regulation, in short, some time of incorporation,
since the mere verification, signing of a treaty is not enough.
There has to be a reception by the internal mechanisms.
Finally, in the dualist theory,
the state initially refuses the applicability of international law,
putting an internal filter to comply with its rules.
There is no mention of conflict between
international and internal norms,
because within the country the internal law is applied,
whether it arises from the parliament
or an international norm formally internalized.
Treaties are just commitments outside the state.
They are only valid, therefore, within the country
when formally transformed into domestically.
There is a subdivision of the dualistic theory.
The radical dualistic theory preaches the need
to issue a separate law for the incorporation
of a treaty into the national legal order.
This is what Trippel believes, for example.
And the moderate dualist theory says
that the incorporation of a treaty into domestic order
does not require an act,
although it is done through a complex procedure with the approval
of the parliament and the promulgation of the executive power,
such as the president or prime
minister. We now move on to the monistic theory,
according to which the law is one, and international
Law and domestic law are two branches of a single legal system.
After all, both are produced by the state whether there
are commitments made with other states
or norms for their administered people in the domestic order.
According to this belief,
international law applies directly to the legal order of states,
regardless of any form of transformation or incorporation,
since the manifestation of sovereignty has already been given
when the treaty was ratified.
Both international law and domestic law would be able
to govern the legal relationship of individuals.
Signing and ratifying a treaty means assuming a legal commitment.
If the treaty includes rights
and obligations that can be demanded domestically,
it is not necessary to issue a new normative diploma
to materialize such obligations at the domestic level.
Ratification already generates effects at the national level.
It is a relationship of genus and species.
Domestic law integrates international law,
depriving it of its logical validity.
They are concentric circles,
where the largest represents international law and the smallest
within domestic law.
There are matters that fall under
the exclusive jurisdiction of international law, but the
same is not true for domestic law.
For monism, the foreign commitments assumed by the states
are not bravado, empty promises of diplomats,
but they have immediate application
in the internal order of the country that agrees,
which reflects the system of automatic incorporation.
The problem that arises,
however, is that of hierarchy in case of conflict of norms.
If both are part of the same system,
which one prevails when there is a conflict between an internal norm
and an international norm?
Hence, we have a subdivision of the monist theory.
Firstly, the nationalist monist theory,
or the monist theory with domestic law first,
says that the domestic norm will always prevail.
Full stop.
Secondly, the monist internationalist theory, or
a monist theory with the primacy of international law,
which can be radical like Kelsen's believes
that international law always prevails even with the
nullity of domestic law applicable
or moderate like Verdross for whom there is no nullity and
there is a case in which
the internal norm prevails over international law
when the international norm contradicts
the fundamental law of the nation
usually the constitution that is why this aspect is called moderate
Well, that was it. I hope you enjoyed today's video and,
more importantly, hope that you
understood these two important theories of international law.
See you later in our next video. Bye!
