What is a Pretendian and how do they harm Indigenous communities? Pretendians are people who falsely claim to have Indigenous heritage. They have become more of a mainstream Indigenous issue with people like Buffy Sainte-Marie and many others being called out for the practice. Impersonating these communities is not just in bad taste, it's dangerous. For the first time in history, there are benefits from having an indigenous identity. And with this shift, people not apart of these communities are moving from cultural appropriation to identity appropriation to take advantage of these benefits. In the process, they are stealing space and opportunities from Indigenous peoples and taking money from Native advancements. They are playing off the generation trauma and systemic racism faced by native groups to benefit themselves. Not every Pretendian is trying to harm Indigenous communities. Sometimes people believe they are apart of these groups because of unchecked family lore, wishful thinking, or the pursuit of trying to reduce their colonizer's guilt. But that doesn’t lessen the impact on the people they are pretending to be. Why do people feel the need to steal Indigenous identity? What is the true harm to Indigenous communities and families? What does it mean to have true Indigenous ancestry? NDN POV takes a sharp and unflinching look at key and sometimes controversial issues through the eyes of Indigenous leaders in Canada. 0:00 Other Words for Pretendians 0:26 What is a Pretendian? 0:56 The Benefits an Indigenous identity 2:06 Psychological relief from Stealing Indigenous Identity 2:36 Intentions Behinds Falsely Claiming Identity 3:03 Reconnecting with Stolen Heritage 3:62 What is True Indigenous Ancestry? 4:20 How do Pretendians Harm Indigenous Communities? 5:57 Indigenous Protocol: Determine Belonging to Indigenous Nations 6:39 Mainstream Indigenous Issues 7:08 One More Act of Colonialism
They've been called wannabes, identity thief, race shister.
They have been called indigenauts.
Oh, playing Indian is another one as well that we use.
Pretendians.
Pretendian is short for pretend Indian,
meaning someone who falsely claims to be indigenous
but can't prove it in any meaningful way.
They first tried to get rid of us, right?
And then they tried to assimilate us.
And when all of those things failed, they said,
well, if we can't get rid of you, we'll just become you.
Pretendian is a controversial term.
Some people have decided that pretend is too gentle of a word,
that they're actually doing something a lot more dangerous
than just playing pretend.
Cultural appropriation has moved on to actual identity appropriation.
There's always been pretendians.
I think a really famous example in indigenous communities
would be Iron Eyes Cody.
I feel like we've seen such a higher frequency in recent years
because now the benefits that people can reap
from claiming an indigenous identity have increased tenfold.
For the first time in Canadian history,
there are advantages to being indigenous.
And in an act of colonial violence,
pretendians are exploiting this moment,
stealing much-needed space, opportunity and benefits
from actual indigenous peoples.
People can get job opportunities.
They can get scholarships and bursaries.
They get roles in television and film.
You know, applying for grants.
Because you apply for a job in a government or a big corporation,
there's a box there that says,
are you indigenous, Métis, Inuit, etc.?
You tick it off and nobody follows up.
That means you have a head start in getting a good job.
Industries where you can capitalize on an indigenous aesthetic
are particularly vulnerable, I think, to pretendian claims.
There may even be psychological relief for those making false claims.
People do not want to feel complicit in colonialism
and the kind of violence that has been done to indigenous peoples.
They want to feel that they're the good guys,
that their ancestors were the good guys.
There's a real incentive to say,
I am part Mi'kmaq, I am part Cree, I am part Cherokee.
And then people don't have to feel like they are literally
living in these lands and benefiting
based on the dispossession and violence
that happened to indigenous people and the theft of indigenous land.
False claims aren't always intentional or malicious,
at least in the beginning.
They're often the result of unchecked family lore and wishful thinking.
You hear from your uncle, your grandparents,
that supposedly great-uncle so-and-so was part native.
And it gets passed down through the generations
so that basically people just believe it
without taking the time to accurately assess its validity.
Pretendians should not be confused with people
who are trying to reconnect with their indigenous heritage
in the aftermath of cultural genocide.
There's a big difference between somebody
whose parent left the reserve or the community
or whose grandparent was forcibly relocated
or went to residential school,
but you still have cousins, aunties, uncles, grandparents,
and somebody who is looking back to 1640.
The number of our ancestors increases exponentially
the further that we look back.
We all come from two parents, four grandparents,
eight great-grandparents, 16 great-great-grandparents, and so on.
If you go back 20 generations,
we're talking thousands of ancestors.
Today there are cases of people scouring historical records
claiming to be indigenous based on ancestors many generations ago
who may or may not have been authentically indigenous.
So what does it really mean to prioritize one ancestor
in a family tree that's otherwise filled with Europeans?
You've got many generations of your family and ancestors
living as white people,
not subject to the laws that indigenous people were subject to,
the oppressive, racist hierarchy laws,
and then you're going to claim one ancestor among all of those.
It's really a way of disowning one's white privilege
and the experience of many generations of one's family.
Pretendianism harms indigenous peoples and communities in numerous ways.
They're taking grants.
They're taking monies designed for Native advancement,
Native arts, Native business,
and using it for their own expenses.
When we think of some of the classic cases
that we've seen in the last few years,
a famous writer, a famous director, a famous attorney,
we see people that are normatively attractive and intelligent
according to settler white standards.
They look and move and talk the way that settlers want people to talk.
They don't want to have to work hard to relate to people
who they are actually really uncomfortable relating to.
And so it allows them to say that they're doing inclusion,
that they're making substantive changes,
when in fact they're just bringing people in and holding people up
and putting people on platforms that are just white people basically,
but they're maybe dressing up as an Indian
or putting on a story of historical trauma,
showing that they have overcome.
The implication being,
why aren't all these other indigenous people overcoming
when in fact these people haven't overcome anything
that indigenous people have had to overcome
because they're white people?
It's extremely frustrating as I,
like I think every indigenous person
who has lived through trauma, generational trauma,
ongoing colonialism,
we don't get to just pick up and put down indigenous identities
when it benefits us.
And it makes me angry that anybody,
any actual indigenous person also has to feel
like that they have to prove themselves in this way now.
Determining somebody's belonging to an indigenous nation
is a matter of indigenous sovereignty.
It's about our ability to choose who our people are
by whatever means we see fit.
Unfortunately, proving that somebody isn't indigenous
is pretty complicated.
But proving that you are indigenous
can be pretty straightforward.
People will say,
oh, you're indigenous, where are you from?
Maybe I know your grandpa or something like that.
And then this exchange happens where,
yes, we're chatting and we're getting to know each other,
but through that also,
I'm telling them who I am,
who I'm accountable to,
where my knowledge comes from.
Those are all, I think, parts of that exchange.
And I think some people would call that protocol.
Indigenous issues are taking up space in the mainstream
more than ever before.
Pretendian exposés are now nationwide scandals,
and they seem to be happening more and more.
There could be hundreds, if not thousands,
of cases yet to be uncovered.
When we're having these conversations,
it's also important to check in
not just with indigenous people writ large,
but displaced people,
people who have those complex histories,
who have been raising alarm bells for a really long time
that we could be hurting some of our own people
when we don't have these conversations with care.
In the common framing of the problem of pretendianism,
people are often talking about identity
and what does indigenous identity mean?
I don't think that's really fundamentally
the question at play here
or the problem that we are confronting.
It's white people, what is their problem?
Why are they intent on appropriating our identities
in the same way that they have appropriated the land?
They have disrupted our governance systems, right?
It's one more act of colonization.
We really need to turn the camera back onto the settler.
Why are they continuing to appropriate every last thing
and take the gaze off of indigenous people?
Because we are not the problem in this issue.