What Actually Happened During Amelia Earhart's Journey?
The Babe of the Sky was the nickname given by many to the beloved Amelia Earhart.
Born July 24, 1897 in Atchison, Kansas, Amelia would go on to become one of the most famous
aviation pilots in America, if not the world. She would become the first female to fly across
the Atlantic Ocean, both as a passenger and later solo pilot as only two of her many
accomplishments and records set throughout her legendary life. But with a legendary life
often comes a legendary fall. In July of 1937, in the midst of her second attempt to become the
first female pilot to circumnavigate the globe, Amelia Earhart disappeared from the face of the
Earth. Let's rewind a few months to March 17, 1937. Amelia Earhart made her first attempt to
fly around the world, in this instance accompanied by navigators Fred Noonan and Harry Manning,
who also happened to be a highly skilled radio operator. The trip was short-lived and seemed
plagued by troubles from the get-go. The trio managed to fly from Oakland, California to Honolulu,
Hawaii, but upon attempted takeoff from the latter, bystanders claimed that either pilot
error or a blown tire brought the journey to an abrupt halt. The entire kerfuffle was apparently
so bad that when Earhart and Noonan wanted to try again two months later, Manning declined to join,
specifically citing the fact that too much had gone wrong in the first attempt.
Nevertheless, Earhart was not so eager to give up. On May 21, 1937, Amelia Earhart and Fred Noonan
boarded their twin-engine Lockheed 10 Electra packed with 1,000 pounds of fuel and readied
for takeoff. Leaving Oakland, California just as before, this time the duo was headed in the
direction of Miami, Florida. The first few weeks of the journey went quite smoothly as they sailed
over and stopped to refuel in South America, Africa, the Indian subcontinent, and even Southeast
Asia. One of these stops would take Earhart and Noonan to Lae, New Guinea, 42 days into the
record-setting trip. With 22,000 miles already traversed and a mere 7,000 to go, they could
nearly taste victory by now as they refueled the Electra. All was well on the morning of July 2,
as Earhart and Noonan retook their seats in the plane and began their departure. The plan,
as the aircraft rejoins the clouds, was to head another 8 hours, or 2,556 miles,
towards Howland Island, where another refueling stop would be made.
The next leg of the trip was supposed to be fairly simple and safe. Back in New Guinea,
a man by the name of Harry Belfer was put in charge of radio operations and maintaining hourly
transmissions with Earhart and Noonan. Shortly after takeoff, Harry began with three transmissions,
attempting to warn Earhart that the current headwinds were much stronger than anyone had
anticipated, and thus she should keep in mind its effects on fuel consumption and flight speed.
Earhart failed to respond to these transmissions, and it's unknown if she ever even got them.
But finally, around 2.18pm, transmissions from Amelia that had previously been blocked
came through to Belfer. The first brought no sign for concern. The pilot stated that she was
going at a speed of 140 knots, flying at an altitude of 7,000 feet and had otherwise no
relevant updates. An hour later, however, another transmission came through, where Earhart stated
that she was now at the uneconomical altitude of 10,000 feet. It's unclear exactly why this climb
was made, and the transmission itself was likely delayed as the previous one had been, but it is
known that Earhart had remarked on that day on how thick the cloud coverage was. It's very possible
that this 3,000-foot increase in altitude was simply an attempt to avoid such dense cloud cover,
and by now, two things are assumed. One, that Earhart and Noonan had realized the problem of
the stronger headwinds and thus accommodated, and two, that the Electra was growing near to
Howland Island with around 100 gallons of fuel left in its tank. As the hours ticked by, transmissions
from Earhart began to make their way through to the Coast Guard's Itasca, which was awaiting the
Electra's arrival just off of Howland Island. The crew believes the aircraft must have been getting
increasingly closer as the transmissions were becoming stronger over time, and at one point,
the radio operator was so convinced that Earhart was near that he actually went outside to look
for the plane. This, though, is when everything began to fall apart. One glaring issue that arose
at this time was the fact that Amelia nor Noonan was able to hear any communications from the
Itasca. They subsequently requested for the crew to use Morse code, but this also failed, and both
aviators were struggling to pin down Howland Island's exact location. At one point, the Itasca
received a jarring transmission from Earhart. Itasca, we must be on you but cannot see you.
Gas is running low, been unable to reach you by radio. We are flying at 1,000 feet. The smooth
and exciting journey had now taken a startling turn, and Earhart and Noonan both seemed starkly
aware of the fact that they were running out of time to make a landing. The Coast Guard was fumbling
to find the Electra, and its pilots were no better off. At 8.43 a.m., Amelia Earhart sent her final,
frantic transmission. We are on line 157337. We will repeat message. We will repeat this
on 6,210 kilocycles. Wait. The message was never repeated. Earhart's attempts to set a world record
had now become a desperate search and rescue mission. The Itasca jumped into action,
searching the deep waters of the Pacific Ocean around the northwest of Howland Island.
Five days later, they were joined by the U.S. battleship Colorado as it searched the southeast.
The USS Lexington soon made its way from San Diego to scour the waves as well,
staying on the search until July 18th. The U.S. Navy went as far as to fly over the nearby Gardner
Island shortly after the disappearance, where they spotted signs of recent inhabitants,
but nothing to point to the Electra making a crash landing in the area. In fact, the plane,
nor Noonan or Earhart, were ever found. So what happened? How did Earhart's final flight end?
The most straightforward answer, and one believed by many, is that the aircraft simply ran out of
fuel. As depressing of an ending as this may be, it's a highly plausible one. Earhart told
the Itasca in one of her final communications that gas was low. So, in spite of debate from
skeptics who say that the plane should have had 24 hours of flight time left in the gas tank,
not 20 as it seemed to have lasted for, Earhart's transmission seems to prove otherwise.
Additionally, the Jet Propulsion Center, or JPS at Caltech, asserts that due to the existing
headwinds plus the altitude climb made by Amelia, the Electra would have run out of gas at the time
of its disappearance. Thus, it remains easy to believe that the lost and discombobulated Earhart
and Noonan flew their plane until its fuel tank hit empty and plummeted into the Pacific Ocean,
killing them and sending the remains of the craft sinking into the 18,000 feet deep sea.
But here's the problem with that theory. Earhart and Noonan knew they were low on fuel,
so why wouldn't they find a place to land before it was too late? Well, some believe that they did.
What the U.S. Navy crew didn't know when they flew over Gardner Island, now called Nicomororo,
and positioned only 315 nautical miles south of Howland, also along the 157337,
was that the island hadn't been inhabited for decades, but they spotted signs of recent
inhabitants. The next theory is then that as the Electra's fuel tanks were draining, Earhart made
the decision to fly away from Howland Island and instead make an emergency landing on Gardner
Island. Supporters of this theory claim that she and or Noonan could have spotted the island
at low tide and thus made the decision. The problem is that to this day, we have no definitive
evidence of a plane crash on Nicomororo, but that's not the end of the theory. There is a
lagoon on Nicomororo that is now believed to potentially have been the Electra's crash landing
site, and that was even acknowledged as a possibility at the time of the initial search.
It's true then that Earhart and Noonan could have smacked down into the waters of Gardner Island,
made their way onshore, and thus lived as castaways for an unknown period of time.
This would explain why the Navy saw signs of human life on an uninhabited island, but it doesn't
explain why they wouldn't see the aircraft. However, for the following week, thousands of
people claimed to have heard radio transmissions from Earhart pleading for help and speaking at
times with a disoriented male voice in the background. All of these communications seemed
to have come at what was low tide at Nicomororo, which would have made sense given the fact that
the aircraft's radio wouldn't have been fully usable if fully submerged in water. While the
Coast Guard dismissed these reports as false, triangulation of these transmissions traces back
to Gardner Island, and as if that wasn't coincidental enough, the castaway theory was taken
to a whole new level when in 1939 or 1940, British colonial officer Gerald Gallagher found the
remains of a campsite and a partial human skeleton on Nicomororo. The skeleton, seemingly a smoking
gun in proving Gardner Island as Earhart's final resting place, was quickly debunked. Physician
D.W. Hoodless examines the bones and determined them to belong to a short, stocky, European descent
male. Asserting that the skeleton belonged to neither Earhart nor Noonan, Hoodless horrifyingly
discarded the bones. In the face of such bizarre investigative practices, somehow, all was not lost
for the skeleton evidence. Years later, the International Group for Historical Aircraft
Recovery, also known as TIGER, decided to analyze Hoodless' findings. With more modern knowledge
and updated databases, they used his work to come to a starkly different conclusion. Maybe the skeleton
belonged to a short male, or maybe it belonged to a tall woman, and Earhart was a tall woman.
TIGER's director, Rick Gillespie, thus theorized that the bones could surely belong to Amelia
Earhart, and that the lack of a full skeleton could be due to the existence of coconut crabs
on Nicomororo. Having the potential to grow up to around 3 feet long and having the strength
to crack coconuts, Gillespie subsequently posits that these crabs could have likely either moved
some of the bones upon finding them or, more gruesomely, eaten the rest of Amelia Earhart
and maybe all of Fred Noonan. But on that note, it's important to remember that there are more
than two theories as to what happened to the Babe of the Sky and her navigator, and we have no
definitive proof to back any of them. All we know is that Amelia Earhart was less than 7,000 miles
away from being the first woman to circumnavigate the globe, and those few thousand miles will
forever be an unsurpassable roadblock for America's aviation queen.

