The only way to find out what the Enderby Shield, the only known Iron Age shield made from bark, may actually have looked like is to task a crack team of experimental archaeologists with crazy Iron Age skills, and a nose for detective work, to authentically recreate it.
Curator of European and Roman Conquest period, Sophia Adams and this extraordinary team follow a trail of clues from laboratory findings at the British Museum, to marks and patterns on the remains of the shield itself, as they forensically piece together how this bark shield would have been constructed 2200 years ago.
This shield project was made possible by the inspiration and knowledge of Matthew Beamish and the skills and dedication of a team of field archaeologists, experimental archaeologists, independent specialists, conservators and scientists from The British Museum, University of Leicester Archaeological Services https://le.ac.uk/ulas, SUERC and York Archaeological Trust; including Caroline Cartwright and Barbara Wills (BM); Prof. Melanie Giles, Matthew Beamish, Adam Clapton and Roger Kipling (ULAS); Diederik Pomstra, Paul Windridge and Michael Bamforth. With thanks to Everards of Leicestershire and Mike Winterton and family.
Comments are disabled for this video.
So I'm Sophie and I'm the curator of the European Iron Age and Roman Conquest collection at the
British Museum. We are in Leicestershire and I'm here because nearby was found a shield made of
bark from the Iron Age and this is the only one known from this period in not only the UK but
Europe and potentially the world. So we are in a field working with a group of specialists who
are bringing different bits of knowledge together, so knowledge about bark working, woodworking,
about the Iron Age, about shields, to see if we can recreate and understand the evidence we found.
My job is to make things from prehistory, so anything from tools, boats, houses to
shields. Any reconstruction or replica making is a difficult thing because you don't know,
you weren't there. So how do you recreate something from that time? Of course some things you can
learn by looking at the artifact and the kind of technology that was present in the period,
so in this case in the Iron Age. You talk to people who know about similar objects, yeah then it's
just the material will dictate what you can and cannot do. So there are certain seasons that you
can harvest certain materials or there are certain tools that you need for certain jobs and they will
tell you more or less what to do and what to use. I think we need to help people who haven't seen
a lot of Iron Age shields or haven't spent the hours we've spent looking at it to understand
what we found. If you look at the preserved original bark shield it looks almost like a
piece of leather or a piece of dried meat. It's very brown, it's squashed, it's difficult to
understand it and by comparing that with a finished replica version you can start to show people,
oh this is what it probably looked like when it was new and this is what those little features
I'm beginning to see on this brown object in front of me are. So welcome to my corner or rather our
field. I'm stood next to a willow tree that we took bark for shield making from a little over
three years ago. When looking at trees to make shields out of you're looking for clean bark
with the least fissuring as possible. Fissures are these grooves that develop in the bark. Now the
older the tree the deeper the fissures get. You don't really want deep fissures because they
actually weaken the bark but at the same time the tree's got to be big enough to provide the
bark that you need. We made cross cuts horizontally using saws and then we used axes to cut the lines
down each side and then we got our fingers underneath a leading edge of the bark and kind
of pushed and peeled it off. What happens to the tree after the bark's come off is an important
thing. A rule of thumb was that if you took less than half the diameter of the tree off the tree
would come to no harm unless the tree had got an underlying problem. So we've come back to the tree
to kind of see how is it after three years, has it survived, what's happening to where the bark has
come off and we're interested to know how it's trying to heal. So the tree looks healthy, the
tree's still alive, it's still growing and it looks okay. What we can see is that on the sides of where
the bark has come off is that the tree has put some vigorous growth into putting new wood into
these gaps and then forming a new bark layer over that and I can see that it's also doing that at
the bottom, this regrowth is actually carrying round below the bark that's still on the outside.
So what I think is really cool is its bark, so you wouldn't expect someone going into battle
waving a bark shield, but why not? There may be martial techniques that you could very well do
with a light bark shield that you cannot do with a far heavier wooden and skin covered shield.
What we started out with is a piece of bark like this slab over here and this bark is then shaped,
we don't know exactly what shape the shield has, so this is more round, this is more squarish,
but this is what we're going for at the moment and as you may can see the next thing we did was to
remove part of the cork layer because the cork layer doesn't add a whole lot to the strength of
the shield. This is where it's all about, so this is the the best fibre layer and that's going to
be really hard and strong.
It was the unique preservation conditions that enabled us to gain such an insight into all the
different crafts and materials that have gone into its manufacture. There are many aspects of its
making and its components that we don't quite understand and to be frank until we've made one
of these objects we don't quite understand how it came together and what all the different
components were for. Some of them may be purely decorative, we know that the appearance of Iron
Age weapons was almost as important as their functional qualities, it was part of the
psychological warfare and although this isn't a metal shield it's still functional and it is your
first line of defence, so through working with different craft practitioners and making a
replica we hope to understand more about the fragments that were found in this pit.
I know so much about this shield now that I didn't know even 10 minutes ago, we're learning
all the time. I for one have come to this very much as a novice in terms of what you can achieve
with bark so I'm absolutely astounded to watch what these guys are able to achieve with it.
The bark shield isn't complete, it's almost complete. We have the central woven boss with a
bit broken off the edge of it and we have the face of the shield and we have the inside but we don't
have all the edges and we have laths going into it which are these little battens that seem to be
passed through the bark but we don't have the complete end of each lath so we're trying to work
out how long they were, how the ends were put into or attached to the shield, how thick they were
because we got to take into consideration the fact that the shield has shrunk and squashed
slightly over time as well.
So here we've got a printout from a layered computer model of what we know about the NW
shield. This has been central to the work because it includes the spatial information where in the
bark shield the laths that we found were. So what we're seeing here is the main black dashed line
is a reconstructed edge of shield and then within that we've got the information that we do know
from the various fragments of the shield. Obviously centrally you've got the boss that we know was
made out of a basket tree. The laths are shown by the solid rectangles where they're grey they're
not visible at all but we know they're within the body of the bark and where they're blue
they're visible on the inside of the shield where they are amber there's a suggestion of visibility
on the outside of the shield but this is a little bit of a grey area because then looks like there's
probably been some damage and it may be that exposure on one side or the other is actually
accidental rather than intentional.
So we're using hazel rods for the binding around the edge of the shield so it's a round rod that
we're splitting two along its length and we're simply going to attach this to the side of the
bark. What we're going to do to hold it on is we're going to put little ties through the shield
tying it in place and if we just use the ties and the binding gets hit when it's being used
there's a real great possibility that it gets knocked out of place so what I'm doing is I'm
cleaning up the outside of these thorns because we're going to use these to actually nail it
through the binding and into the shield and that gives it some real rigidity. There's no evidence
to say these were actually used on the shield because there isn't enough of the edge of the
shield left however during that period of time the woodworking techniques used wooden dowels
to pin pieces of wood and bridges and timber and stuff together so it was a known technique.
We're stitching on the rim here and this is not the definite shield that we'll be
making for the museum so this is just a trial. We want to know what the laths are for we think
it's for controlling shape of the shield so having it flat but to well to learn a bit more about that
we have this one without any laths in so we just want to see whether the rim by itself can control
the shape and that's why we're stitching it up every 10 centimeters or four inches we have a
binding and we'll see if this is strong enough to keep the bark from curling up because that's
what the bark wants to do it was around the tree in this direction so it wants to curl like this
and obviously you don't want that because this is the outside of the shield right you'll be holding
it like this so this one is going to be finished pretty soon we just stick the boss on and put the
handle in place and then this one is done and this one just for drying and seeing what happens
and the other one the laths are still in place and then we put on the rim as well put the boss
on put the handle in place and then we'll decorate it but that may have to wait until it's dry so it
will take a while the difficulty of the rim is that we know there was a rim but except one kind
of stitch hole there's no evidence of how it was attached to to the shield itself the rest of the
we have evidence of bus fibers so these strips you get them from the tree in in june and these
are these are raw raw bark strips and we can use it for tying that's why they're soaking in water
to keep them pliable and they'll dry out and become stiff and then the binding is quite firm
the other test that we did in an earlier experiment we put blackthorn thorns through
here so drill a hole through the rim and tap some blackthorn thorns in and that worked really well
but we decided not to do it now and just see where the stitching takes us you have to learn right
well we're learning a lot about timing with this shield so we've learned about the season when they
would have had to take the bark off the tree so looking at between april and july we've learned
about the need to keep the bark in a relatively damp state until you start working it so again
you don't want perhaps too hot dry weather i didn't know the strength you could get from just
putting a very thin batten into the bark and how this can add strength to it and help it stop
distorting and you can see the curved shape of the bark from the tree gradually flattening out
as these laths are put in so we think this cross design helped hold the shape of it
and then there's a binding around the edge which is the next bit that we're working on at the
moment and that binding again helps hold the whole shield together so i'm learning the value
of all these little bits of evidence that we can see on the remaining shield and i can either do
a simple stitch as we did i think in the other ones or i can also go around twice so that this
is also filled up so there's streaming everywhere i'll be inclined to do a double two so drilling
the holes they have to catch the boss here in the in the outer coil like the rim of the boss
and there we stitch to the bark so those stitches we found in the original artifact so we even know
how widely they were spaced and what kind of material was used so this is going to be
well as good as it gets i think a moment like this is one of the things that iron age archaeologists
hope for because we have lots of metal bits and pieces that survive well but it's when you find
those rare organic objects that your mind is blown really that your eyes are opened to that lost world
of organic materials that we so rarely get to glimpse in the past that is what makes this so
special from this process we will understand a lot more about the color the appearance
materiality of the iron age itself we will learn so much
the handle for me was the key piece in the journey of understanding this shield and how
it might have been made because up until my consideration of the handle the shield had been
flat and we'd found it flat all the pieces that had been conserved and gone through the
conservation and analysis process they were flat as well and shield didn't have any particular
shape and when we look at the iron age shields that have been found generally they're flat so
there was a broad assumption that this shield was in fact flat but their handle made me reconsider
that because the handle was chamfered at both ends so they've taken a piece of round wood
and then they've used the knife to cut a flat on one side of round wood and then turn it over
and make a flat against the other side as well now we only found half a handle and i'm making
an assumption that the handle was symmetrical so on the basis of that assumption if the shield is
actually going to meet both ends of the chamfer it's got to curve we think that's where the laths
these pieces here and the rim combine to actually help this process
and this is it the enderby shield recreated as best we can this is the result of another
day of experimental archaeology we've looked back at the original compared it with the
experimental work you've just been watching and come up with a few more features we have
shorter laths than the ones you saw and that's because those long ones they were too thin they
didn't add any benefits to the shield so we look back at the original and we've recreated the exact
lengths of surviving laths they survived to about one to three millimeters thick we think that that
shrunk down and got a bit narrower over time and they're probably maybe close to about five
millimeters thick and they seem to work much better when they're a bit shorter and a bit thicker
the shape is slightly different we think it's this more pointed shape based on where we can
see the remains of stitches on the original we don't think they'd have had continuous stitches
because it would perforate this and middle would pop out so it'd be no use so we looked at the
original and found that there appear to be groups of stitches about four in a group and that's what
we've recreated here and there's something that you may spot is the color when it was first
excavated there was a little bit red pigment surviving in some areas and scored lines and
what we think happens is they scored out a kind of squared pattern and then filled alternate areas
with red pigment this is an estimate of what it would have looked like but i think you'll agree
it looks quite impressive it gives it this nice shining front as well if you want to find out more
about this shield watch my previous curator's corner and get up close with the enderby shield