Was Moses Actually Akhenaten? The Real Exodus Story | What Nobody Ever Told You About Moses

Moses
70 followers
28 Video Views·Dec 21, 2022
Moses, circa 1400 BCE, is considered one of the most important religious leaders in
world history.
He is claimed by the religions of Judaism, Christianity, Islam, and Baha'i as an important
prophet of God and the founder of monotheistic belief.
The story of Moses is told in the biblical books of Exodus, Leviticus, Deuteronomy, and
Numbers, but he continues to be referenced throughout the Bible and is the prophet most
often cited in the New Testament.
In the Quran, he also plays an important role and, again, is the most often cited religious
figure who is mentioned 115 times as opposed to Muhammad who is referred to by name only
four times in the text.
As in the Bible, in the Quran, Moses is a figure who alternately stands for divine or
human understanding.
Moses is best known from the story in the biblical book of Exodus and Quran as the lawgiver
who met God face to face on Mount Sinai to receive the Ten Commandments after leading
his people, the Hebrews, out of bondage in Egypt and to the promised land of Canaan.
The story of the Hebrew Exodus from Egypt is only found in the Pentateuch, the first
five books of the Bible, and in the Quran which was written later.
No other ancient sources corroborate the story and no archaeological evidence supports it.
This has led many scholars to conclude that Moses was a legendary figure and the Exodus
story a cultural myth.
The Egyptian historian Mantheo, 3rd century BCE, tells the story of an Egyptian priest
named Osarsif who led a group of lepers in rebellion against the wishes of the king who
wanted them banished.
Osarsif, Mantheo claims, rejected the polytheism of Egyptian religion in favor of a monotheistic
understanding and changed his name to Moses, meaning child of, and usually used in conjunction
with a god's name, so Ramesses would be Ra Moses, son of Ra for example.
Osarsif would have attached no god's name to his own, it would seem, since he believed
himself a son of a living god who had no name human beings could or should utter.
Mantheo's story of Osarsif slash Moses is relayed by the historian Flavius Josephus,
circa 37 to 100 CE, who cited Mantheo's story at length in his own work.
The Roman historian Tacitus, circa 56 to 117 CE, tells a similar story of a man named Moses
who becomes the leader of a colony of Egyptian lepers.
This has led a number of writers and scholars, Sigmund Freud and Joseph Campbell among them,
to assert that the Moses of the Bible was not a Hebrew who was raised in an Egyptian
palace but an Egyptian priest who led a religious revolution to establish monotheism.
This theory links Moses closely with the pharaoh Akhenaten, 1353 to 1336 BCE, who established
his own monotheistic belief in the god Aten unlike any other god and more powerful than
all in the fifth year of his reign.
Akhenaten's monotheism may have been born of a genuine religious impulse or could have
been a reaction against the priests of a god Amun who had grown almost as wealthy and powerful
as the throne.
In establishing monotheism and banning all of the old gods of Egypt, Akhenaten effectively
eliminated any threat to the crown from the priesthood.
The theory advanced by Campbell and others following Sigmund Freud's Moses and monotheism
in this is that Moses was a priest of Akhenaten who led like-minded followers out of Egypt
after Akhenaten's death when his son Tutankhamen, circa 1336 to 1327 BCE, restored the old
gods and practices.
Still other scholars equate Moses with Akhenaten himself and see the Exodus story as a mythological
rendering of Akhenaten's honest attempt at religious reform.
Moses is mentioned by a number of classical writers all drawing on the stories known in
the Bible or by earlier writers.
He could have been a mythological character who took on a life of his own as his story
was told over and over again.
Or he could have been a real person to whom magical or supernatural events were ascribed
or could have been precisely as he is depicted in the early books of the Bible and in the
Quran.
Dating Moses' life and the precise date of the Exodus is difficult and it's always based
on interpretations of the book of Exodus in conjunction with other books of the Bible
and it's always so speculative.
It's entirely possible that the Exodus story was written by a Hebrew scribe living in Canaan
who wished to make a clear distinction between his people and the older settlements of the
Amorites in the region.
The story of God's chosen people led by his servant Moses to a land their God had promised
them would have served this purpose well.
Moses in the Bible
The book of Exodus, written circa 600 BCE, picks up from the narrative in the book of
Genesis chapters 37-50 of Joseph, son of Jacob, who was sold into slavery by his jealous half-brothers
and rose to prominence in Egypt.
Joseph was adept at understanding dreams and interpreted the king's dream accurately, predicting
a coming famine.
He was placed in charge of preparing Egypt for the famine, succeeded brilliantly, and
brought his family to Egypt.
The book of Exodus opens with the Hebrew descendants of Joseph becoming more numerous in the land
of Egypt so that the Pharaoh, fearing they might seize power, enslaves them.
Moses enters the story in the second chapter of the book after the unnamed Pharaoh, still
worried about the growing population of Israelites, decrees that every male child must be killed.
Moses' mother hides him for three months, but then, afraid he would be discovered and
killed, sets him adrift in a papyrus basket on the Nile, where he floats down to where
the Pharaoh's daughters and her attendants are bathing.
The child is taken from the river by the princess, who calls him Moses, claiming she chose the
name because she drew him out of the water, which is making the assertion that Moses means
to draw out.
This etymology of the name has been contested since, as noted, Moses in Egyptian meant child
of.
Moses grows up in the Egyptian palace until one day he sees an Egyptian beating a Hebrew
slave and kills him, burying his body in the sand.
The next day, when he is out again among the people, he sees two Hebrews fighting and pulls
them apart asking what the problem is.
One of them answers by asking if he plans to kill them as he did the Egyptian.
Moses then realizes his crime has become known and flees Egypt for Midian.
In the land of Midian, he rescues the daughters of a high priest, named Reuel in Exodus 2
and Jethro afterwards, who gives him his daughter Zipporah as a wife.
Moses lives in Midian as a shepherd until one day he encounters a bushfire, which burns
with the fire but is not consumed.
The fire is the angel of God who brings Moses a message that he should return to Egypt to
free his people.
Moses is not interested and bluntly tells God, please send someone else.
See Exodus 4.13.
God is in no mood to be questioned on his choices and makes it clear that Moses will
be returning to Egypt.
He assures him that all will be well and that he will have his brother Aaron to help him
speak, as well as supernatural powers which would enable him to convince the Pharaoh that
he does indeed speak for God.
He also tells Moses, in a passage which has long troubled interpreters of the book, that
he will, quote, harden Pharaoh's heart against receiving the message and letting the people
go at the same time that he wants Pharaoh to accept the message and release his people.
Either way, Moses returns to Egypt and, as God had promised, Pharaoh's heart is hardened
against him.
At the same time, Moses and Aaron compete with the Egyptian priests in an effort to
show whose God is greater, but Pharaoh is unimpressed.
After a series of ten plagues destroys the land, finally killing the first born of the
Egyptians, the Hebrews are allowed to leave and, as God directed, they take a vast amount
of treasure out of Egypt with them.
Pharaoh changes his mind after they have gone, however, and sends his army of chariots in
pursuit.
In one of the best-known passages from the Bible, Moses parts the Red Sea so his people
can cross and then closes the waters over the pursuing Egyptian army drowning them.
He leads his people on, following two signs that God provides, a pillar of cloud by day
and a pillar of fire by night.
At Mount Sinai, Moses leaves his people below to ascend and meet God face to face.
Here he receives the Ten Commandments, God's laws for his people.
On the mountain, Moses receives the Law as well as instructions for the Ark of the Covenant
and the Tabernacle which will house God's presence among the people.
Down below, his followers have begun to fear him dead and, feeling hopeless, ask Aaron
to make them an idol that they can worship and ask for help.
Aaron melts the treasures they took from Egypt into a fire and creates a golden calf.
On the mountain, God sees what the Hebrews are doing and tells Moses to return and deal
with his people.
When he comes back down the mountain and sees his people worshiping the idol, he becomes
enraged and destroys the tablets of the Ten Commandments.
He calls all who remained faithful to God to his side, including his brother Aaron,
and commands they kill their neighbors, their friends, and their brothers, all who forced
Aaron to make the idol for them.
Exodus chapter 32, verses 27-28 describes the scene and claims about 3,000 people were
killed by Moses' Levites.
Afterward, God tells Moses he will not accompany the people anymore because they are stiff-necked
people and, should he travel further with them, he would wind up killing them out of
frustration.
Moses and the elders then enter into a covenant with God by which he will be their only God
and they will be his chosen people.
He will travel with them personally as a divine presence to direct and comfort them.
God writes the Ten Commandments on new tablets which Moses cuts for him and these are placed
in the Ark of the Covenant and the Ark is housed in the Tabernacle which is an elaborate
tent.
God next commands that a lampstand of pure gold and a table of acacia wood are be made
and placed before his presence in the Tabernacle for receiving offerings.
He further specifies a courtyard to be created for the Tabernacle and outlines acceptable
offerings and various sins that one must avoid and atone for.
No longer will the people have to question his existence or wonder what he wants because
the Ten Commandments and the other instructions, everything is quite clear and further, they
know he is among them in the Tabernacle.
Even with God in their midst, however, the people still doubt and still fear and still
question and so it is decreed that this generation will wander in the desert until they die.
The next generation will be the one to see the Promised Land.
Moses then leads his people through the desert for forty years until this is accomplished
and the younger generation reaches the Promised Land of Canaan.
Moses himself is not allowed to enter, only to look upon it from across the river Jordan.
He dies and is buried in an unmarked grave on Mount Nebo and leadership is assumed by
his second in command, Joshua, son of Nun.
Moses' trials and challenges mediating between his people and God as well as his laws are
given in the books of Numbers, Leviticus, and Deuteronomy which, taken with Genesis
and Exodus, make up the first five books of the Bible which traditionally are ascribed
to Moses himself as the author.
The Hero's Story
Biblical scholarship, however, discounts Moses' authorship and maintains that the first five
books were written by different scribes at different time periods.
The story of Moses as related in Exodus is the Hero's Story as elaborated by Joseph
Campbell in works such as The Hero with a Thousand Faces or Transformations of Myth
Through Time.
Although Moses is born a Hebrew, he is separated from his people shortly after birth and denied
his cultural heritage.
Upon discovering who he is, he must leave the life of comfort that he's grown used
to and embarks on a journey which leads to his recognition of his purpose in life.
He is afraid to accept what he knows he must do, but does it anyway and succeeds.
The Exodus story resonates as it does because it touches on universal themes and symbols
regarding personal identity, purpose in life, and the involvement of the divine in human
affairs.
Moses' entry to the story purposefully employs the motif of the infant born of humble parents
who becomes or is unknowingly a prince.
But by the time Exodus was written, the backstory of Moses had been known in both the Middle
East and the Near East for almost 2,000 years through the legend of Sargon of Akkad.
Sargon, 2334-2279 BCE, was the founder of the Akkadian Empire, the first multinational
empire in the world.
His famous legend, which he made great use of in his lifetime to achieve his aims, relates
how his mother was a priestess who, quote, set me in a basket of rushes and sealed my
lid with bitumen.
She cast me into the river which rose over me.
The river bore me up and carried me to Aki, the drawer of water.
Aki, the drawer of water, took me as his son and reared me.
Aki, the drawer of water, appointed me as his gardener.
Sargon grows up to overthrow the king and then unite the region of Mesopotamia under
his rule.
Scholar Paul Krawasik, writing on Sargon's story, mentions the International Babylonian
Festival of 1990 CE, at which Saddam Hussein celebrated his birthday.
Krawasik writes,
The festivities came to a climax when a wooden cabin was wheeled out and large crowds dressed
in ancient Sumerian, Akkadian, Babylonian, and Assyrian costume prostrated themselves
in front of it.
The doors opened to reveal a palm tree from which fifty-three white doves flew up into
the sky.
Beneath them a baby Saddam, reposing in a basket, came floating down a marsh-bordered
stream.
Time magazine's reporter was particularly struck by the baby-in-the-basket theme, describing
it as Moses' redo, but why on earth would Saddam Hussein wish to compare himself to
a leader of the Jews?
The journalist was missing the point.
The motif was a Mesopotamian invention long before the Hebrews took it up and applied
it to Moses.
The Iraqi dictator was alluding to a much more ancient, and to him, far more glorious
precedent.
He was associating himself with Sargon.
The writer of Exodus also wanted his hero associated with Sargon.
A true hero would
rise from inauspicious beginnings to achieve greatness.
Those who believe the Exodus story is a cultural myth point to Moses' beginnings along with
many other facets of the story to prove their claim.
Other scholars, such as Rosalie David or Susan Wise Bauer, accept the Exodus story as authentic
history and ascribe to the characters in the story a knowledge of Sargon's legend, which
the author of Exodus faithfully sets down.
Bauer writes,
Sargon's birth story served as a seal of chosenness, a proof of his divinity.
Surely the mother of the Hebrew baby knew it and made use of it in a desperate and successful
attempt to place her own baby in the line of the divinely chosen.
To these scholars, the fact that there are no records of the Exodus and no archaeological
evidence to support it can be explained by the embarrassment which the departure of the
Israelites would have caused the Pharaoh of Egypt.
Bauer writes,
The Exodus of the Hebrews was a nose-thumbing directed not just at the power of the Pharaoh
and his court, but at the power of the Egyptian gods themselves.
The plagues were designed to ram home the impotence of the Egyptian pantheon.
The Nile, the bloodstream of Osiris and the lifeblood of Egypt, was turned to blood and
became foul and poisonous.
Frogs, sacred to Osiris, appeared in numbers so great that they were transformed into a
pestilence.
The sun disk was blotted out by darkness.
Ra and Aten both made helpless.
These are not the kind of events that appear in the celebratory inscriptions of any Pharaoh.
Exodus as History Theory
A simpler explanation, however, is that the events described in the Book of Exodus did
not take place, or at least not as described, and so no inscriptions were made relating
to them.
The Egyptians are famous for their record keeping, and yet no records have been found
which make the slightest reference to the departure of a segment of the population of
the land which, according to the Book of Exodus, numbered 600,000 men on foot besides
women and children, or, as given in Exodus 38, verse 26, everyone who had crossed over
to those counted 20 years or older more, a total of 603,550 men, again not counting women
or children.
Even if the Egyptians decided the embarrassment of their gods and king was too great a shame
to set down, some record would exist of such a huge movement of so vast a population, even
if that record were simply a dramatic change in the physical evidence of the region.
There are seasonal camps from the Paleolithic Age in Scotland and other areas dating back
were not in use anywhere near the amount of time of the 40 years of campsites that the
Hebrews would have made use of in their trip to the Promised Land.
Arguments that evidence of the Exodus does exist, such as those of Egyptologist David
Rolle, are not widely accepted by scholars, historians, or other Egyptologists.
Rolle's claim is that one can find no physical or literary evidence of the Exodus only because
one is looking in the wrong era.
The Exodus has been traditionally placed in the reign of Rameses II, circa 1279-1213 B.C.E.
But Rolle claims the events actually took place much earlier in the reign of the king
Deutomos I, circa 1650 B.C.E.
If one examines the evidence from that time, Rolle claims, the Bible narrative matches
up with Egyptian history.
The problems with Rolle's theory are that the evidence from the period of the Middle
Kingdom, that is, 2040-1782 B.C.E., and the second intermediate period, circa 1782-570
B.C.E., does not actually substantiate the Exodus story.
The Ipwer Papyrus, which Rolle claims is an Egyptian account of the Ten Plagues, is dated
to the Middle Kingdom, long before Deutomos I's reign, and further, is quite clearly
Egyptian literature of a known genre, not history.
The Semites Rolle asserts lived in great numbers at Avaris, cannot be identified with the Israelites.
In every instance where Rolle makes his claims linking the Book of Exodus with Egyptian history,
he either ignores the details which prove him wrong, or twists evidence to fit his theory.
In spite of Rolle's claims, and those of others who have seized on them, there is no
archaeological or literary evidence of Moses leading the Israelites from slavery in Egypt.
The only source for the story is the biblical narrative.
The Egyptian Priest Theory Still, there is an Egyptian record of an
event which, some claim, inspired the Exodus story in Manteo's account of the Egyptian
priest Osarsif and his leadership of the community of lepers.
Manteo's account has been lost, but is quoted at length by Josephus, and later by Roman
historian Tacitus.
According to Josephus, the king Ammonophis of Egypt, who is equated with Amenhotep III,
circa 1386-1353 BCE, wished to, quote, see the gods, but was told by an oracle that he
could not unless he cleansed Egypt of lepers.
He therefore banished the lepers to the city of Avaris, where they were united under the
leadership of a monotheistic priest named Osarsif.
Osarsif rebelled against the rule of Ammonophis, instituted monotheism, and invited the Hyksos
back into Egypt.
In Tacitus's version, the Egyptian king is named Bochorus, the Greek name for the
king Bacchanronif circa 725-720 BCE, and he exiles a segment of his population afflicted
with leprosy to the desert.
The exiles remain in the desert in a stupor of grief, until one of them, Moses, rallies
and leads them to another land.
Tacitus goes on to say how Moses then taught the people a new belief in one supreme god,
and, quote, gave them a novel form of worship opposed to all that is practiced by other
men.
As with the Exodus story, there are no records which corroborate this version of events,
and the reign of Amenhotep III was not marked by any rebellions by lepers or anyone else.
Tacitus's account of Moses coming to power during the reign of Bacchanronif is equally
unsupported.
Further, Mantheo's account explicitly states that Osarsif, quote, invited the Hyksos back
into Egypt, where they ruled for thirteen years, but the Hyksos were expelled from Egypt
in circa 1570 BCE by Amos I of Thebes, and no records indicate that they ever returned.
Historian Mark van de Meereup comments on this, writing,
"...the scholars have different opinions about exactly what historical events Josephus's
account recalls, but many see a lingering memory of Akhenaten and his unpopular rule
in the tale."
Akhenaten famously introduced monotheism to Egypt through the worship of one god, Aten,
and prescribed the worship of all other gods.
According to the theory most famously expounded by Freud, the Osarsif story is actually an
account of Akhenaten's reign and one of his priests, Moses, who carried on his reform.
Freud is openly bewildered by the fact that no one seems to have noticed that this allegedly
Hebrew leader of the Exodus from Egypt might have had an Egyptian name, writing,
"...it might have been expected that one of the many authors who recognized Moses to
be an Egyptian name would have drawn this conclusion, or at least considered the possibility
that the bearer of an Egyptian name was himself an Egyptian."
Freud further states,
"...I venture now to draw the following conclusion.
If Moses was an Egyptian, and if he transmitted to the Jews his own religion, then it was
that of Ikhnaten, or Akhenaten, the Aten religion."
According to Freud, Moses was murdered by his people, and the memory of this act created
a communal guilt which infused the religion of Judaism and characterizes that belief system
as well as those other monotheistic faiths that came after it.
As interesting as the theory may be, like many of Freud's theories, it's based on
an assumption which Freud never proves, but continues to build an argument on anyway.
Susan Wise Bauer writes,
"...for at least a century, the theory that Akhenaten trained Moses in monotheism and
then set him loose in the desert has floated around.
It still pops up occasionally on History Channel specials and PBS fundraisers.
This has absolutely no historical basis, and in fact is incredibly difficult to square
with any of the more respectable dates of the Exodus."
It seems to have originated with Freud, who was certainly not an unbiased scholar in his
desire to explain the origins of monotheism while denying Judaism as much uniqueness as
possible.
Although his name certainly suggests an Egyptian origin, the first text which introduces the
character of Moses clearly indicates he was the son of Hebrew parents.
Whether one accepts the Book of Exodus as a reliable account or a cultural myth, one
cannot change the text to fit one's personal theories, which is basically what Freud does.
At the same time, one cannot claim a respectable date for the Exodus when there is no historical
record of the event outside the manuscript of the Book of Exodus.
The events of the Exodus are traditionally assigned to the reign of Ramses II based on
the passage of Exodus 1.11, where it states that the Hebrew slaves worked on the cities
of Pithom and Ramesses, two cities that Ramses II was known to have commissioned.
Bower, however, writes that a respectable date for the Exodus is 1446 BCE, and that's
based on a straightforward reading of 1 Kings 6.1, which claims that 480 years passed between
the Exodus and the building of Solomon's Temple.
Further complicating the dating of this event is that Exodus 7.7 states that Moses was 80
years old when he first met with Pharaoh, but Moses' birth date is given by rabbinical
Judaism as 1391 BCE, making the 1446 BCE date impossible, and there are plenty of other
suggestions for possible birth years as well, which also make the 1446 BCE date for the
Exodus untenable.
The problem with all of these speculations stems from the attempt at reading the Bible
as straight history instead of what it is, literature, and specifically, scripture.
Ancient writers were not as concerned with facts as modern audiences are, but they were
certainly interested in truth.
This is exemplified by the ancient genre known as Mesopotamian-Naru literature, in which
a figure, usually someone famous, plays an important role in a story which they did not
actually participate in.
The best examples of Naru literature concern Sargon of Akkad and his grandson Naram-Sin
2262-2224 BCE.
In the famous story The Curse of Akkad, Naram-Sin is portrayed as destroying the temple of the
god Enlil when he receives no answers to his prayers.
There is no record of Naram-Sin doing any such thing, while there is a great deal of
evidence that he was a pious king who honored Enlil and the other gods.
In this case, Naram-Sin would have been chosen as main character because of his famous name
and used to convey a truth about humanity's relationship with the gods and, especially,
a king's proper attitude toward the divine.
In the same way, the Book of Exodus and the other narratives concerning Moses tell a story
of physical and spiritual liberation using the central character of Moses, a figure previously
unknown in literature who represents man's relationship with God.
The writers of the biblical narratives go to great lengths to ground their stories in
history to show God working through actual events.
In the same way, the authors of Mesopotamian Naru literature chose historical figures to
convey their message.
Literature, scripture, does not need to be historically accurate to express a truth.
Insistence on stories such as the Book of Exodus as historical denies a reader a wide
experience of the text.
To claim that the book must be historically true to be meaningful denies the power of
the story to relay its message.
Moses is a symbolic figure in the story while at the same time remaining a completely autonomous
individual with a distinct personality.
Throughout the narrative, Moses mediates between God and the people but is neither completely
holy nor secular.
He accepts his mandate from God reluctantly, constantly asks God why he was chosen and
what he is supposed to be doing and, yet consistently, tries to do God's will until he strikes the
stone to produce water instead of speaking to it as God has instructed.
That was Numbers chapter 20 verses 1-12.
God had previously told Moses to strike a rock to get water, Exodus 17 verse 6, but
this time told him to speak to the rock.
Moses' actions here, ignoring God's instruction, prevent him from entering the promised land
of Canaan.
He is allowed to see the land from Mount Nebo but cannot lead his people once he has compromised
his relationship with God.
As with the rest of the narrative concerning Moses, this episode with the rock would have
been conveyed and still conveys an important message about a believer's relationship
with God.
That one must trust in the divine in spite of one's own perceived knowledge or reliance
on precedent and experience.
It does not finally matter whether a historical individual named Moses struck or spoke to
a rock which then gave him water.
What matters is the truth of the individual's relationship with God that story conveys and
how one can better understand one's own place in a divine plan.
Moses in the Quran This is also seen in the Quran where Moses
is known as Musa.
Musa is mentioned a number of times throughout the Quran as a righteous man, a prophet and
a sage.
In the story of Exodus in the Quran, Musa is always seen as a devout servant of Allah,
trusting in divine wisdom.
In Surah 18, 60-82, however, a story is related which shows how even a great and righteous
man still has much to learn from God.
One day after Musa had delivered a particularly brilliant sermon, a member of the audience
asks him if there is another on earth as learned in God's ways as he is, and Musa answers,
no, God, Allah, informs him that there will always be those who know more than one does
in anything, especially regarding the divine.
Musa asks Allah where he might guide such a man, and Allah gives him instructions on
how to proceed.
Following Allah's guidance, Musa finds Al-Qadir, a representative of the divine, and asks if
he might follow him and learn the knowledge he has of God.
Al-Qadir answers that Musa would not understand anything he said or did and would have no
patience.
He then dismisses him.
Musa pleads with him and Al-Qadir says, if you would follow me, ask me not about anything
until I mention it myself, and Musa agrees.
As they travel together, Al-Qadir comes across a boat by the shore and kicks a hole in the
bottom of it.
Musa objects, crying out that the owners of the boat will not be able to earn their
living now.
Al-Qadir reminds him how he told him he could not be patient and dismisses him, but Musa
asks for forgiveness and promises he will not judge or speak on anything else.
Shortly after the boat incident, however, they meet a young man on the road, and Al-Qadir
kills him.
Musa strongly objects, asking why such a handsome young man should be killed, and Al-Qadir reminds
him again of what he said before and tells him to leave and now immediately.
Musa again apologizes and is forgiven and the two travel on together.
They reach a town where they ask for alms but are refused.
On their way out of the town, they pass a stone wall which is falling down and Al-Qadir
stops and repairs it.
Musa is again confused and complains to his companion that at least he could have asked
for wages in repairing the wall so they could get something to eat.
At this, Al-Qadir tells Musa that he has breached their contract for the last time and now they
must part ways.
First though, he explains, he scuttled the boat because there was a king at sea seizing
every boat which put out by force and enslaving the crew.
If the good people who owned the boat had gone out, they would have met with a bad end.
He killed the young man because he was evil and was going to bring great pain against
his parents and community.
Allah had already provided for another son to be born to the parents who would bring
them and the others joy instead of pain.
He rebuilt the wall because there was a treasure hidden beneath it which two orphans were supposed
to inherit and if the wall had crumbled anymore, it would have been revealed to those who would
take it.
Al-Qadir ended by saying that is the interpretation of those things over which you showed no patience
and Musa understands the lesson.
As with the Biblical Moses, the Musa of the Quran is a completely developed character
with all of the strengths and weaknesses of any person.
In the Bible, Moses' humility is emphasized, but he still has enough pride to trust in
his own judgment in striking the rock rather than listening to God.
In the Quran, his faith in himself and his own perceptions and judgments is questioned
through his inability to trust in God's messenger.
The story from Surah 18 teaches that God has a purpose which human beings, even one as
devout and learned as Musa, cannot understand.
Conclusion
Throughout the Christian New Testament, Moses is cited more than any other Old Testament
prophet or figure.
Moses is seen as the lawgiver in the Christian writings who exemplifies a man of God.
To cite only one example, Moses features prominently in the famous story Jesus tells concerning
Lazarus and the rich man in the book of Luke chapter 16 verses 19-31.
In this story, a poor but pious man named Lazarus and a rich man, unnamed, live in the
same town.
Lazarus suffers daily while the rich man has everything he could desire.
They both die on the same day and the rich man wakes up in the underworld and sees Lazarus
with Father Abraham in paradise.
He begs Father Abraham to help him, but is reminded that on earth he lived a life of
ease while Lazarus suffered and now it is only just that the roles are reversed.
The rich man then asks Father Abraham to send someone to warn his family, as he still has
five brothers living, and tell them how they should better live to avoid this fate.
Abraham responds,
They have Moses and the prophets.
Let them listen to them.
The rich man protests, saying that if someone should rise from the dead to warn his family,
then they would surely listen.
But Abraham says,
If they will not listen to Moses and the prophets, neither would they listen to someone should
they rise from the dead.
In this story, Moses is presented as the paradigm of God's truth.
If people would heed Moses' example and words, then they could avoid separation from
God in the afterlife.
The story emphasizes how Moses' teachings provide everything anyone needs to know about
how to live a good and decent life and enjoy an afterlife with God, and how if one is going
to ignore Moses and the prophets and justify one's life choices, one would just as easily
dismiss someone returning from the dead.
The two are equally self-evident of God's desires for human piety and behavior.
Moses is also featured in Jesus' transfiguration in the book of Matthew chapter 17 verses 1-3,
the book of Mark chapter 9 verses 2-4, and the book of Luke chapter 9 verses 28-30, along
with Elijah, when God announces that Jesus is his Son with whom he is well pleased.
In these passages and others in the New Testament, Moses is held up as an exemplar and representative
of God's will.
Whether there was a religious leader in history named Moses who led his people and initiated
a monotheistic understanding of the divine is unknown.
Individual beliefs will dictate whether one accepts the historicity of Moses or regards
him as a mythical figure more than any historical evidence, or the lack thereof, ever will.
Either way, the figure of Moses has cast a long shadow across the history of the world.
The monotheism he is credited with introducing was further developed by the teachers of the
Jewish faith, which influenced the atmosphere in which Christianity was able to thrive,
which then led to the rise of Islam.
All three major monotheistic religions in the world today as their own, and he continues
to serve as a model of humanity's relationship with the divine for people of many faiths
around the world.
