Viking Martial Arts Lesson 2 Shield Cleaving?

Eternal Shield
2 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 27, 2026
Thrand and Eldgrimr continue with their Live action Book review of Antony Cummins new book The illustrated guide to viking martial arts.In this episode they cover the controversial shield cleaving Antony documented from the Sagas.They test a razor sharp Viking long sword against Two different designed round shields and come to an exciting conclusion of the possibilities of these documented Historical accounts.So sit back and lets explore shields and shield cleaving with Thrand and Eldgrimr as they review Antony Cummins new book.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hey, this is Thrash.
Hey, this is Field Brever.
And today we're going to be covering the Illustrated Guide to Viking Martial Arts by Anthony Cummins.
And we're continuing with our four-part review, and we're going to be labeling this as Viking Martial Arts Lesson 1, 2, 3, and 4.
Continuing our five-part review.
We're going to be covering...
Today we're going to cover lesson number two, which is shield cleaving.
It's a highly controversial technique.
I don't know if you'd really call it a martial art technique, but it is definitely something that's been in the sagas.
And it brings up a lot of questions.
Correct.
Can you do it?
We're going to explore whether...
Can it be done?
And if it can be done, how do you do it?
What variables are involved that allow you to do this?
Because I believe it's a quantum-type thing.
It's either yes, it can, and no, it can't.
Is it a good idea?
Yes, it is.
No, it's not.
I mean, it's one of those types of situations.
You would have to really know what was going on, evaluate your shield, and be able to understand that.
Today we're going to go over that and see how it turns out.
Explore this today.
We've got the book here sent by Anthony Cummins.
Oh, yeah.
We'd like to thank Anthony Cummins.
He's an accomplished artist.
And we'd love to thank you for another autographed piece of art that he's done.
To Ellesmere, believe it or not.
Yeah.
It's totally hip, so check out Anthony Cummins' book.
And, of course, look for any of his artwork.
Like I say, he's an accomplished artist.
This is a very beautiful piece.
Thank you very much.
All right.
Get on with our thing today.
Let's get to work.
Y'all.
What we're covering today is something that's controversial that Anthony's actually documented out of the sagas.
It's shield cleaning.
Straight through the shield into the body and killing the guy or wounding him badly.
And what we'd like to cover is three variables of making a great shield.
One, I would say first you'd have to have the knowledge to do so.
If not, you've got too heavy a shield, stops everything, but you can barely use it, hindering you.
Knowledge to build one lightweight, knowing what you're doing, knowing what materials to use, which a lot of times they use linen.
They use lots of layers of it with milk or cheese glue.
Which makes it almost like Kevlar.
Right.
Or rawhide, which rawhide is the same thing, big old thick.
It's like a plastic.
You have the front and the back covered in it.
And that takes time to dry.
A lot of times adhesives were used.
It was stitched.
There was rivets used in the shield.
The whole thing basically took a lot of time to create.
Right.
And that time requires you to have time to even gather materials.
Which is our second variable.
Yeah.
Without the time and the knowledge, you can't gather the materials and create a proper shield.
So a lot of these things right there would mean whether a guy had a great shield or he had a poorly made shield that you could possibly damage and injure him.
Or if he had a shield where he could catch your blade and disarm you, knowing they had one weak spot to do so.
Just weak enough.
Right.
Then there's the Holmganger shield.
If you make a shield on purpose to be torn up.
Correct.
That was another variable there too.
That would be our fourth one, but I don't consider it part of the first three.
Because that one is a ritualistic duel where the shields were purposely made with a light rimming and just slats.
If you look here, these are like slats.
And if you cut into the grain, of course when you go across grain it's hard to cut, but it's easy to cut into grain.
Because a lot of these shields are only about a quarter inch thick.
Other than the stuff that reinforced them.
In Holmganger you took turns throwing blows.
You couldn't move around much.
The only thing you could do was pretty much cut your way through that man's shield.
And they were like dueling pistols.
They were all equally made.
Probably by the same shield crafter.
With the same rimming and edging and everything.
So it was a fair duel.
Because no one would go in there knowing it was unfair if somebody had this bulletproof shield.
Now in the case of this martial art lesson, we're talking about it actually being used in a combat application where somebody gets injured.
The third variable that I think in a regular war shield is damage.
Oh yeah.
If you're heavily damaged, somebody could potentially cut through.
This was made for the SCA guys.
A lot of times I use these shields because they're not trying to stop arrows.
It lasts a long time for fighting with wooden weapons.
With the proper edging.
As you can see here.
But if you're doing something for actual steel reenactment, you want to put several layers of linen or rawhide or something on your shield.
A lot of people will just use plain leather.
But I recommend to make it last longer.
Rawhide would be your best even though it's very expensive.
But what we're going to cover is all these variables today.
We're going to try different shields.
And we're going to try cleaving through them.
Hopefully this chain here protects the elder bear well.
And we're going to see what kind of results we get today.
Alright.
And answer Anthony's question.
The question we said we were going to answer in the first one.
Can you cut through a shield?
I say yes and no.
And no, you can't.
Is it a good idea?
Yes, it is.
And no, it's not.
No, it isn't.
Okay.
What we're doing now, this test, we're doing a linen covered shield with a nice edging.
This is a well-made shield.
I think you should stand up against a real steel sharpsword easily.
We'll see how it works when I go for that leg shot.
I'm going to come right in here and see if I can cut through into the legs.
He's standing in a proper stance.
Oh!
I think I hit his leg through the shield, but no damage to the shield.
That didn't cut at all.
Nope.
Try holding it out just a hair more just to make sure it's not a fluke.
Yeah, let's try holding it at a little angle where I can actually hit the edge.
Alright, alright.
Let's do that.
Because you might be at that type of angle.
Let's do it.
One more time.
Negative.
All I seem to do is it cut into the rimming slightly.
It chipped it, and the shield gave.
So, as long as the shield's held correctly.
Let's even try that one time.
I'm holding it flat like some reenactment would.
I'm going to see if I can even cleave into this.
No, there's nothing there.
We're going to be rebuilding these, so fear not.
But it still won't even cleave through that.
There's no way.
Nope.
Well, let's test out a damaged one and see what happens.
Yeah, let's switch the roles.
Alright.
Good.
Now we're covering a badly damaged shield that's lost rimming.
And this one actually has nothing on it.
So, it would be a lot like a home game shield, but it's also badly damaged.
So, what I'm assuming, it's probably going to cut through.
Especially if I hit the grain properly.
And we're hoping the elderly chain here will stop that.
So, let's see how this one works.
Are you ready?
Ready.
That was a bad blow, Millard.
How's your leg?
Oh, it's going to be bruised, but thankfully we have the chain on.
Yeah, it is a razor sharp.
That was a mighty blow.
If this chain shirt was not here, I have no doubt that would have clipped into his hip.
And probably ended the fight, especially home game or even on the field.
And we've lost some of the shield because of shield damage.
This is a damaged shield, so this would be the result of a damaged shield.
So, I think shield cleaving is something that you would probably likely do.
After you've already done a lot of damage to the shield, the shield wasn't hit properly in the first place.
Right.
If you've got a lot of rimming, it's possible.
Yes, I think you could just clean right all through, possibly.
I really believe that shield cleaving is purely an opportunity thing.
Turn it over.
We're turning these up today.
Turn the grain up.
This way.
Head up.
I was going to show this.
Cutting against the grain is really not as easy though, usually.
It cuts, but it's a lot harder to go through against the grain.
Yep.
It sucks.
That's right.
So, there we go.
That definitely worked and the chain did its job.
Hell yeah.
Now, we'll try one other aspect in a second here.
See what we can do with that.
This is the shield we used to catch blades with in the past.
Alright, let's check it out.
Now, I'm here single sword.
Maybe my shield was already damaged.
I lost it, whatever.
We're going to cover, you know, just to do it.
I'm going to grab this because it is described sometimes the sword was held too handy for extra powerful blow.
And this shield is missing a part of the rimming as you saw in one of the other videos where we did a disarm with it.
This could have been done intentionally in a small section here and in the front or something to disarm.
So, we're going to see if this actually works out well.
I'm going to do this for extra power.
Try to chop into that leg and see what happens.
Well, we saw what happened today.
What did you think?
Well, you know, I think that we're absolutely right.
That the variables we covered are really the variables you're going to look for in a fight if you're out to kill somebody and you're not in a home ganga.
I mean, if you see a damaged shield, you know you've damaged his shield or he's been in a fight that's already damaged it, then you might take the chance.
But, do you want to get stuck in their shield?
That's a game we have to take.
Anytime the sword goes this way, you're pretty much going to lose it.
And, as I talked about right here, the strong and stuff.
A lot of the home ganga fighters used it like a thong.
But, other things they did that were different, they used shields that tore up.
And, that was to have an extra weapon in case your shield did tear up.
They could use it to parry with.
The swords were not even very good metal.
They lost the edge easy.
They were about an L long.
I mean, it was a different fight.
But, in an actual battle, the shield is tearing up instantly.
If he's got a fresh shield, it's not going to happen.
But, in a long drawn out battle, that shield can be damaged over time.
And, in that situation, yes, you could take it to your advantage.
Yeah, I think we can safely say that in our experiments today, it's an opportunity thing to do.
Unless it's a home ganga.
Then, you want to do that.
Right.
But, in a real fight, it's an opportunity.
If you see it, you can take advantage of it.
Do it.
But, it's a complicated quantum physics issue.
Oh, don't let the shield bearer thing confuse people either.
If they look at some of those sagas like Cormac's and stuff, that was home ganga.
There's a shield bearer standing next to him even though he can't move around much on the map.
So, even though there's an extra person there, he's not allowed to strike the other opponent.
I was letting you know that.
So, it was a ritualistic duel.
Look it up, guys, if you want to study about it.
Right on.
The Viking Answer Lady actually has a whole thing, a whole write-up, which is research for home gangas.
And, that's actually a good site.
Very good.
And, Hurstwick?
Hurstwick?
Oh, yeah.
We've got to tell you, man.
Hurstwick's another great...
And, Empty Cover's done a good job with the sagas.
If you look those sagas up, you can read them yourself if you take time to analyze it for yourself.
Right.
And, I think that as you analyze the sagas, you will see that the Vikings did have a martial art.
They just, I don't think, organized it or...
Passed down from generation to generation.
Just they didn't catalog it and keep it.
That's what I mean by organized.
Back then, I'm sure that you went to certain men to train.
If they would train you and you weren't a family member, then it was an honor to train them.
Because of how great of warriors they were.
Because that's documented, too, in a lot of the sagas.
They went to a certain man to learn.
Like Gunnar in the Icelandic sagas.
He was a famous swordsman and duelist.
He trained Hjartar.
Stuff like that.
You'll see that, too, there.
When they go to a special man to train them.
They go get a special sword that's more durable and better.
And, I think that anybody that's going to teach you about cleaving through shields
is not going to teach you that this is necessarily a technique like standing in a back stance
or knowing the difference between lunging and things like that.
It's just a variable.
It's a variable and it's an opportunity.
But, yes, it's useful.
A crappy shoe.
A skidder shoe.
Skilder.
Yeah, I could see it because he had to do it in a hurry.
But, also, anything you can block with.
Even if that shield's damaged, I can block with the shaft on the spear here.
As long as I'm holding it.
I wanted to say that he's not over.
It just takes a little bit more doing to try to parry.
It's true.
And, you know, that's another advantage to having the axe versus the sword.
With your blade, you really can't and don't want to block with just any portion of your blade.
No, that's why the shield is almost always used with something with it that can take a blow and not damage the axe.
The beauty of this is that it can do that.
If I hit this, it might damage it.
But, I'm not going to lose my axe over that.
And we'll cover some more stuff later about the actual shafts and whether they can be cut.
Well, we'd really like to thank you for joining us today.
And be on the lookout for our next three book reviews for Antony Coates.
That's Lessons 3, 4, and 5.
We're glad you were here with us today.
And we're glad we could be with you.
But our senses have kept us away for a while.
