Tyreek Hill Chose $120 Million Over Patrick Mahomes
1 Video View·Oct 6, 2026
He left anyway! In March 2022, Tyreek Hill had the best quarterback in football throwing him the ball.
He wanted to be paid like the best receiver in football. Kansas City said no. Miami said yes.
Tyreek Hill chose $120 million over Patrick Mahomes. In the next two seasons,
Mahomes won two Super Bowls. In Miami, Hill never won a playoff game. And four years after signing
him, the Dolphins ate $28.2 million in dead cap just to let him go. Hold that number. Hold pick
number 29, too. And hold the one question Hill admitted he couldn't shake. It started in 2016,
when Kansas City took a receiver in the fifth round, pick number 165. They called him the
Cheetah. Defenses found out why. In six seasons, he caught 479 passes for 6,630 yards and 56
touchdowns. Six Pro Bowls. Once Mahomes took over, Mahomes to Hill became the deep ball every
defense feared. In Super Bowl 54, played in Miami's own stadium, he caught nine passes for 105 yards
and won a ring. Then came a three-year, $54 million extension. Then, the market moved.
Devontae Adams signed for five years and $141.25 million. $28.25 million a year, a receiver record.
Hill wanted Adams' money. As he put it later, Kansas City valued him like Devontae Adams,
but didn't want to pay him like Devontae Adams. Kansas City made offers, up to a point.
You just can't keep everyone that you'd like to keep. So, that was the case with Tyreek.
By Hill's account, the last offer was close to $58 million guaranteed. His agent, Drew Rosenhaus,
said the Chiefs were millions short. Hill even said $25 or $26 million a year would have been
enough. Everyone agreed it was about money. Nobody agreed on how much. And Hill says the
trade request was bait, a way to get Kansas City to pay. Kansas City called the bluff. The Jets
offered the 10th pick. Kansas City wanted more, and Miami was willing to pay it. Six days after
Adams signed, Hill was a dolphin. At his introduction, he sounded like a man coming home.
Miami sent five picks. A first, a second, two fourths, and a sixth. The first was number 29.
Remember it. Hill got four years and $120 million, with $72.2 million guaranteed.
At $30 million a year, he was the highest paid receiver ever, and the first non-quarterback to
hit that number. Ask him why, and he didn't talk about rings. Notice what he asked for,
not a bigger number, a safer one. A receiver's body is the bet, and Hill wanted it insured.
Kansas City did its own math. A month later, General Manager Brett Veach explained it.
Use some of those resources to add to the defense, and we certainly want to get younger
and deeper there too. So the Hill haul went to defense first. Kansas City packaged pick 29 with
two others, jumped to number 21, and took cornerback Trent McDuffie. The second rounder
became receiver Sky Moore. Mahomes had a new cornerback, a new receiver, and no cheetah.
Three months after the trade, Hill started talking. Hill launched a podcast called It
Needed To Be Said. In episode one, he compared his quarterbacks. I'm going to go with one five
as the strongest arm, but as far as accuracy-wise, I'm going with two all day. He also complained
that Kansas City never gave him the ball enough. Mahomes waited five days. He didn't fire back.
I'm surprised a little, just because I feel like we love Tyreek here. We've always loved him. We
still love him. One sentence, a little hurt. Then the season started, and Kansas City answered on
the field. Kansas City went 14-3. Mahomes won MVP with 5,250 yards and 41 touchdowns, without a
single thousand-yard receiver. Juju Smith-Schuster led the wideouts with 933. The Chiefs beat the
Eagles 38-35 and won the Super Bowl. No Hill? No problem. Hill was having his own year, and on his
scoreboard, he was winning. First season in Miami? 119 catches, 1,710 yards, first team All-Pro.
It ended with a wild-card loss in Buffalo, 34-31. He still loved the move, and he told
Shannon Sharp why. With no state income tax, I'm basically living in my house for free right now.
Year two started even faster. After six games, he had 814 yards, on pace for more than 2,300.
2,000 yards was on his bucket list, and it looked like a formality.
He finished with 119 catches again, a league-leading 1,799 yards and 13 touchdowns.
First team All-Pro again, and second for Offensive Player of the Year. But an ankle
injury cost him a game, and Calvin Johnson's record of 1,964 survived. Meanwhile, Kansas
kept cashing in his trade. Miami's fourth-round pick helped the Chiefs move up to No. 55.
That pick became Rasheed Rice. 79 catches, 938 yards and 7 touchdowns as a rookie.
Then, the two teams met in Frankfurt. McDuffie, the cornerback bought with Hill's pick,
forced a Hill fumble. It went back 59 yards for a touchdown. Kansas City won, 21-14.
They met again in the playoffs. January 2024 at Arrowhead, about four below zero.
Kansas City won, 26-7. Hill scored once. Rice had 8 catches, 130 yards and a touchdown.
A month later, Rice converted a third down on the overtime drive that won Kansas City
another Super Bowl. Hill posted three words,
Our time coming. It never came. Six months later, someone asked him if he was better than Mahomes.
That month, Miami reworked his deal. $90 million over three years,
$65 million guaranteed. On his way to the season opener,
police stopped him near the stadium for alleged speeding. The body cam shows how fast it escalated.
Officers pulled him from his car, put him face down, and handcuffed him. He played that day.
The citations were later dismissed when the officers didn't show up,
and the Dolphins called the officers' conduct overly aggressive and violent.
The season never recovered. Playing with a broken wrist, according to his agent,
Hill fell to 81 catches and 959 yards. Miami went 8-9. Kansas City went 15-2.
In the finale, a 32-20 loss to the Jets, Hill left the game early. Afterward, he said this,
Mike McDaniel called leaving a game,
not acceptable. General Manager Chris Greer said Hill had never asked him for a trade.
Hill called it frustration, and later admitted he could have handled it better.
A month later, Kansas City played in its third straight Super Bowl and lost to the Eagles,
40-22. That week, Hill admitted something he'd been carrying since the trade. We'll get to it.
In September 2025, on Monday Night Football against the Jets, Hill went down in the third
quarter. He was carted off. A dislocated knee. A torn ACL, plus multiple other ligaments.
His season was over after four games. Off the field, his estranged wife's divorce filing that
accused him of domestic violence. Hill's lawyers called the claims false, and the NFL opened a
review. Weeks later, he already sounded like a man looking back. The front office went next.
Greer was out by Halloween. McDaniel was fired after the season. In February 2026,
the new regime released him, before his 2026 money could become guaranteed.
The dead cap came to $28.2 million. That's the number from the start.
Miami gave up five draft picks to bring him in, and ate $28.2 million to let him go.
Three weeks later, Miami cut Tua Tangavailoa too, with a record $99.2 million in dead cap.
The quarterback Hill picked over Mahomes was gone as well. Hill posted,
The Cheetah will be back. Born again.
Now the other number. McDuffie became a first-team All-Pro, then a second-team All-Pro,
and won two rings. Then Kansas City traded him to the Rams, who paid him $124 million.
The return? A first-round pick.
Number 29. The same number Miami sent for Hill. Kansas City turned pick 29 into a star,
then turned the star back into pick 29. Not everything went to plan in Kansas City either.
The season before, the Chiefs went 6-11 and missed the playoffs for the first time since 2014.
Mahomes tore his left ACL in December. Mahomes and the receiver he lost were both rehabbing
torn ACLs. And the $120 million? Miami paid him about $106 million in cash over four seasons.
Never the full amount. Hill was blunt about where he stood.
I have no power in my left leg at all.
Under one of his comeback posts, Mahomes left three words.
Keep going, brother. Run the scorecard.
Hill got the record contract, two first-team All-Pro seasons,
the best receiving year in Dolphins history, and zero playoff wins in Miami.
Kansas City got McDuffie, Rice, a first-round pick back, and two more rings.
And remember that Super Bowl week with Kansas City chasing a three-peat?
This is what Hill admitted.
I mean, I'm human. So at the end of the day,
you're always thinking in the back of your head, like, man, did I make the right decision?
Did Tyreek Hill make the right call? $120 million? Or Patrick Mahomes?
Tell us in the comments.

