Riots in France—begun by students but now taken over by migrants—expose the dangers of uncontrolled immigration. Will the unrest flowing from Islamic-majority enclaves give rise to a populist Right movement? Meanwhile, what remains of a functioning society in South Africa is buckling under the strain of extreme governmental dysfunction. Racial violence between black communities and white Afrikaners has intensified as state control recedes, and more race laws now exist than during apartheid. Jeremy Carl, senior fellow at The Claremont Institute and author of The Unprotected Class joins President Ryan P. Williams to discuss what lessons America can draw from woes across the West. Plus: Predictions for the 2026 midterms and 2028 election.
Chapters 00:00 Introductions 01:33 South Africa: Current State, Infrastructure, and Identity Politics 16:40 Civil Unrest and Riots in France 29:43 Midterm Elections Outlook 40:52 Democratic Party Prospects and Future Leadership 45:31 The Left's Anti-Trump Political Weaponization Strategies 57:18 Closing Remarks
------
Recommended: The Unprotected Class: How Anti-White Racism Is Tearing America Apart: https://amzn.to/4issKQp
Jeremy Carl and other speakers analyze the systemic collapse of South Africa's governance and the rise of identity politics. The discussion extends to France's struggles with immigration and the U.S. political landscape, specifically focusing on the weaponization of the legal system (\"lawfare\") and the strategic outlook for the 2026 midterms and 2028 presidential election.
Welcome, everyone, to the American Mind Podcast.
I'm your host, Ryan Williams,
president of the Claremont Institute
and publisher of the Claremont Review books
and the American Mind. We are down a couple men today.
Sabo and Clavin both are out,
but this is a good excuse for me to bring on our friend
and Claremont Institute senior fellow,
Jeremy Carl, known to most of our listeners
and viewers for his book called The Unprotected Class
on the rise of identity politics
and the one excluded class from that phenomenon that is
white and especially white males.
So if you have not read The Unprotected Class, please go
check it out. It's a well-researched
and I hesitate to call it a polemic because it's
very straightforward, sticks just to the facts,
but it documents the rise of identity politics
in modern America, especially over the last 10
or 15 years and why it's an unwelcome development
not good for American self-government.
Jeremy's working on a new book, but we'll leave that
for the coming weeks and months
when we are in a position to talk more about it.
I wanted to talk to Jeremy today about
the headlines in recent days. But first, we wanted
to start with a trip Jeremy took to South Africa.
I was there for 10 days fairly recently. So we
thought we might just get a dispatch from the field from Jeremy,
and then I'll ask some follow
ups and we'll kick off the podcast that way.
But as always, thanks, Jeremy, and welcome.
Yeah, thanks so much for having me on, Ryan.
And you're just touching on racial politics.
And South Africa is, of course,
makes our racial politics in many ways, both the history and the
current iteration look really mild
and straightforward and easy in comparison.
I was invited down by a sort
of a leading Western business group down there, along with a few other
uh, folks from the policy communities, um, and,
uh, investing communities, um, in the United
States. Um, uh, some folks, yeah, some names that would,
uh, would be known, I suspect to some of
our, our viewers here, but, but I'll,
I'll kind of leave those, uh, sort of untold for now, but a
good group of a small, a good, but small group of folks.
And the real reason they brought us out
there was to sort of show the challenges
that are facing Western businesses and Western people
in South Africa today and just the difficulty of the environment.
And that kind of touches on a lot
of things. It touches on kind
of the specific anti-white policies that are ubiquitous right
now in South Africa. In fact,
they now have more racial laws in South Africa than they did during
apartheid in terms of uh kind of discriminatory laws
so that could kind of tell you something
right there that was by the way not true uh
in and of the time mandela took over it was at a
much much lower point they'd sort of been rapidly repealing
a lot of those laws um in sort of
preparation between the time mandela was released in 1990
and the time he took over in 1994 and then
there was a sort of brief interregnum where that remained
and then what's happened is that
accretively the government has just been adding to them ever since.
But I'd say even beyond that,
just some of the problems that they have in terms
of infrastructure that are really profound in
terms of misgovernance and frankly, government collapse there.
And it's a really fascinating
amalgam of a state that still has some parts that are first world.
I mean, there were a lot of
things that we did where I could have
been in a really high-end US environment and it would have
been absolutely identical like a really nice resort
or really uh whatever and then there are
you know their power cuts in the capital on a regular basis
or something they're three different
capital cities but but all of them suffer
from that so there's a schizophrenia and i think the
reason that um we should care about this as americans
is is kind of uh beyond certain strategic
elements that it has and being kind of the gateway
to uh the continent that is is growing far faster
than any other in terms of its population
and its sort of strategic uh location where it kind of
controls some shipping lanes
and um potential access to the arctic but but kind of beyond that
also it does some interesting things
to hold down immigration from africa to the united states
because it acts as a magnet
but i'd say kind of beyond that is that it um it sort of serves as a
certain you know i don't want to say mirror
um because i don't think our situation is as obviously
nearly as dire as south africa is nor does it have prospects
of becoming that dire that was something
that uh when i went on um when i went
on the New York Times podcast with Ross Douthat that we talked
about a little bit but i do think that directionally
um we are facing a lot of the same phenomena and
so it was interesting to see that kind
of highlighted in a more dramatic uh sense and it
was a fascinating place one of those i've probably
been to about 60 countries and certainly one of
the most fascinating uh certainly business related
trips i've ever uh ever taken just in terms of the
lessons that i think we can take
from it i mean what does south africa represent in a way uh i
think some of our more some of the more hyperbolic commenters
on south africa like to say you know
this is the u.s.'s future
and what they mean by that i think is um uh decade more and many more
decades in the united states of uh explicitly identity politics
or race-based um policy making
coupled with um demographic change that continues along
the trends it's been headed for a while of
course one way in which there's just just one way there's really
no comparison is that uh
south africa of course has its unique history
and the uh sort of for lack of a better term the white
black split is uh uh you you almost said mirror
but it is almost a mirror i mean if about 13% of
the u.s population is african-american uh
and the rest is white or other uh south africa is much
more uh bimodally distributed
and it's in the opposite direction right yeah that's right i mean
there's there's actually i mean again there's
there's fascinating uh south africa is a country
i'd read quite a lot about for many years
because as somebody who's interested in race and politics
it's kind of the um it's almost the urtext
that you go to to kind of see a lot of things and
in their pure form so it's it's not just white
and black there's actually a significant
phraseology we don't use in the u.s
but they use in a non-pejorative way they have a colored
population that is actually the um with a kind
of ethnically mixed population of all sorts of
things not just white and black but uh malays
and and um you know people who are from madagascar
and then just a whole mix then they're the majority
in a couple provinces within the black
community you have zulus you have Xhosa you have
a number of different communities that kind of have
their own independent history
so the racial politics there are not at all straightforward
but they are you know black and white is the primary gradient
and i do think and i should
sort of say i mean as much as i saw some things
that were really certainly very disturbing um
you know we don't we don't have a u.s we don't have
a south africa future i don't think in the
It's not going to be that extreme.
The gaps between white and black Americans are not as extreme
as what you see in South America and South Africa.
As you pointed out, the numbers are different.
And nor do I think, quite frankly,
that there is a quote unquote white genocide going on there.
And I think even the kind of South African advocates
are sort of pretty clear on this point.
I mean, there is differential violence being put against South
African whites, including in particular the white farmer
and the Afrikaner farmer population,
and that's gotten a lot of attention from this administration.
It's been the basis for the refugee claims
that we've had where right now these Afrikaner refugees are kind
of the ones that we are letting into the United States.
I think those are entirely based in fact,
but I think it's very different than saying that there's an active kind
of broad scale genocide, at least kind of taking place right now.
And certainly I could show you pictures
from my trip where you're having very nice South African
wine overlooking the mountains in a beautiful location.
Um, and, uh, you know, one might mock that the notion that,
that kind of doing that,
um, that there's sort of some sort of active ongoing genocide,
uh, but there is, um, and
actually also interestingly in a lot
of these elite spaces now, and this obviously would
not have been true three decades ago, um,
in, in some of the most elite places that
I spent time, some of the wealthiest places,
I would say probably maybe half of the people
around me are black South Africans.
So there is, you know, kind of the United Colors of Benetton version
of this story that looks a lot nicer, that shows kind of benefits
of society being distributed in a way that is racially certainly
very different than what we had during the apartheid era.
But if you kind of scratch beneath that,
that kind of attractive surface in a few places and you look sort
of more broadly at what's going on, the story turns a lot more ominous.
From your, obviously you were there speaking about some
of the difficulties of South Africa. What really stood out to you
and what do you think the prospects of changing course on it are?
And I use as my backdrop part of what you discussed, which is, I think,
escapes the headlines, international headlines to a lot of people,
which is endemic corruption in modern South Africa, power outages,
I mean, collapsing infrastructure, a lot of the ubiquitous first world
um, uh, aspects of South Africa are kind
of degrading after the last 20 years or so of,
of, of rule. What, uh, what really stood out and what,
what are the prospects for
kind of turning it around? Yeah.
Well, I mean, it's, you know, it's a classic example.
I thought this when I was there at the time, um,
of, of Burke's comment that there's a great deal
of ruin in a nation.
Um, you know, we have, uh, a situation in South Africa where there's,
there was a lot of capability there uh pre-1994 there's still
a lot of modern infrastructure i
mean i've traveled other places in sub-saharan africa
or other developing countries i mean
there's no comparison there are a lot of um for lack
of a better term first world uh parts of
south africa and things that still do function
um one of the interesting things that's also
happened is as the state has collapsed
um communities of all sorts of different types
have kind of banded together in sort of self-help
and self-organizing ways and so you see communities
banded together for security um you know i visited
a community of 7 000 homes is the largest of its
time it's outside of the capital of pretoria
um and you know very nice houses good hospital nice
infrastructure like you kind of name it it looked like
a very attractive u.s suburb but it's all
controlled by kind of razor wire and electric fence gates
and um and you know kind of access
points where they're scanning your license plate
when you come in one of the gates of the community
and it's also scanning your face to make sure
that the person who's driving the car is actually
that person and they have you know very very
intensive security environment and this was true
in all of these sort of nicer places in south africa
and so by really hermetically sealing
themselves off from a lot of the chaos outside they're able
to have something that almost looks
like pleasantville for any of you
who saw that movie from a couple decades ago i mean it looks
kind of very nice but the cost of doing that is very high
and the people who are doing this are
being double taxed effectively
because they have to pay their taxes for services they're not getting
and then they have to pay to actually get
those services in these private organizations but
it's a fascinating place i mean i'm seriously considering doing
my my next book after i get
done with this current one on south africa's lessons
for the united states because i do think
that while we're not headed for that type
of situation um as demographics change as state
capacity changes in some negative ways in the u.s
and elsewhere i think that the lessons that are
there from south africa are you know they're very very applicable
to what's what's going on with us
and certainly what's going on in Europe and elsewhere right now.
Yeah, I mean, I think it seems like
the most universally applicable lesson
or warning would be, as you say,
in Europe and parts of Central and South America,
which is to say, what are the sort of extra-civil society solutions
to the breakdown of security, among other things,
and the dangers to life and liberty?
um there's actually an answer
though uh yeah sorry i just wanted to jump in because i realized
something that we should talk about just briefly
in the context of claremont's interest there's
actually fascinating issues around constitutionalism uh there
as well um and it was something that we
talked a lot about there was a very uh
distinguished constitutional law scholar
um of the south african constitution
who i spent a bunch of time talking about
with rather when i was there um but he's
also looked at constitutional law in a variety of
context in fact i'm reading a book right now
where he talks about you know sort of comparing
u.s and south african constitutions one of the things
that he he sort of looks at in that context
is how you look at um group and community rights
which tend to not be instantiated in say the u.s
constitution in a clear way or in a lot of others
but in um situations like south africa where you
have a lot of communities with just really really different kind
of states of being um these sorts
of rights become uh really important
and i think in many ways again just really ahead of the curve
in terms of um thinking about some of the things
that we um maybe have not thought about in the u.s
as as certainly white south africans have effectively lost access
to the state uh in any
meaningful way their you know access
to have any influence over it um at all um and so you know
again, just, I think, some really interesting stories for us.
And I think, you know, on the
positive side, because I think the negative side
is unfortunately the most likely, which is you're
going to get to get continued degradation.
But on the positive side, I mean, the kind of crown is
waiting in the gutter for somebody to pick it up,
you know, probably very likely would be a black
African politician from South Africa.
And to kind of get in a much better modus vivendi with the
white population and the Indian population
and the Cape colored population, some of these other
populations in South Africa that still add
a tremendous amount of economic and social capital
to the country, work in a more productive way.
And I think it could really continue to then be
the powerhouse on that continent
and a much more reliable ally than it's been
for the United States in the past.
Social capital and state capacity there has just
been so mismanaged for so long,
you'd think that there's a big opportunity and an incentive
for an ambitious future leader of South Africa
to turn the place around yeah so you know just
again fascinating place i mean uh i think
so many lessons for the U.S. even though uh you know i don't
think there is a South Africa you know we're not going
to turn into South Africa in 50 years or 100
years but um i think they are they are sort
of in certain ways a look at the future um and i think
we can get ahead of certain negative trends
that they've had to experience if we if we just learn
from from what they've uh what they've gone through
um and uh you know uh so in that in that
sense uh a really enlightening and sobering uh trip
and i'll be writing about that for Claremont
in at least one capacity i don't know i'll have something
in the American mind yeah excellent
we'll look forward to it we talked about Europe
so uh it makes sense to move to France uh with
some pretty dramatic scenes coming uh out of some
of the suburbs of France and cities of France over
the last couple of weeks or really
the last week most intensely um what was pitched originally at
least by the uh some of the French kind of center media
and left left-wing media uh and even their
social leading socialist politician as really just
a call by the youth for uh their leaders to look
more seriously at the affordability crisis
and the the jobs the job prospects of the youth
instead at least to those of us watching it
from the outside has seemed to be as much
an instance of recent immigrants to France especially from North Africa
and the Middle East
but although not exclusively from there looting
and rioting and generally causing mayhem there's
the the arresting video from yesterday
or the day before was uh you know thousands of bottles being
thrown at a couple of police vans
and them being basically run out of town you also have seen scenes
of the uh the assembled forces in in France
and they they have a lot of experience doing this
beating back the mob and making there's been hundreds
and hundreds of arrests as well
what I found interesting is that the Macron went
on television I think it was two days ago to say
that the youth must be listened
to that was his takeaway from this whole experience
and then you have some of our right-wing friends be they French
or otherwise European saying that
This is really the evidence of a continually collapsing
or slow-motion collapse of the
Fifth French Republic.
Maybe the caricatures on both sides are overblown.
Well, the last thing I'll say is this looks like,
and maybe you can correct me if I'm
wrong, Jeremy, it looks like this can only help
the electoral prospects of Marine Le Pen
going forward.
and we've seen and we've talked about
with our friend Chris Caldwell in various venues over the
years and even have seen him in print talk about
the popular the rise of populism in response to
the immigration of the last 15 years in Europe Germany Spain
and elsewhere and France has
certainly been at the center of that conversation
and it it may mean that finally right-wing
populism of some flavor may finally get to rule in France yeah
and it's sort of funny and I think
it's not um perhaps i say somewhat sadly
a coincidence that as they get to the brink of
power suddenly Le Pen is kind of i don't want
to say she is moderating her rhetoric she's sort of
like oh well you know these people are are French too
and you know they have a home and and on the
hand you say well that's you know it's good you really you don't want
to be um you're rhetorically
chasing people out of your polity um just in a way
that's um precipitous or kind of irresponsible
at another level it's sort of like i think i
do worry a little bit as somebody who would love to
see the National Rally win that election
um that they're going to get there and then they may shy
away from doing some of the things that they really campaigned
on for decades that would really um
change the problem and i think you know we've seen what Trump has done
on immigration i know it's not
as much as some people have wanted,
but as somebody who's followed that issue closely
for decades, I think grading on a curve,
this administration has done a tremendous amount
in the wake of a lot of opposition.
So we're seeing some of the same things in France. I do
think it helps them, I think, more broadly.
And again, this kind of ties into South Africa, but
my old boss, Secretary of State Shultz,
always said to me that he thought the fundamental
challenge of the 21st century was governing over diversity.
And that is really what you're seeing
in France. And I think in many ways,
for all the problems we have in the US, we are able to
incorporate certain types of diversity
a little more easily into our identity than the French
or Europeans have. Now, French actually are,
I think, a little bit easier than some other
countries in Europe. But I do think it's a challenge for them.
I think that this is not
going to be an easy problem to solve
and i think they're you know they're going to have to um kind
of really decide who's going
to be in their political community who's not going to be in it
and um remove some of the people who are not going to be in it
and for those who are going to be in
it they're going to have to be accepted standards
of public behavior um that uh that are not being
met now but you know again as skeptics
also note it's not uh you don't need to find North Africans
to explain the French in rioting they have hundreds
of years of tradition of kind of doing
that on their own so i think there's there's sort
of broader uh broader things at play here and
again just like any of these political phenomena you don't want
to reduce it down to just it's one
thing or the other but i do think that it's just showing
that these these problems of diversity of
of really different communities of islam etc in europe are severe
and they're not getting less
severe and every day that you have more immigration
from these countries uh the challenges get just
that much bigger yeah certainly our our friend
um peg uh Pascal Emmanuel Gobry a couple days ago
said on twitter you know
but for social media he said i live in paris uh but for social media
i wouldn't have any idea that any of this was going
on in france at all meaning you know he
expressing the the kind of semi-media blackout
at least on normal news channels in in at least in
and around paris about this so there's
this interesting interaction of uh and you've you've
seen also evidence of this in the u.s media too uh covering
this as if some skirmishes between
protesters uh about the cost
of living have broken out between french authorities and and uh and
protesters whereas you know you can watch uh yesterday
the basically the firebombing and the
collapse of of a you know 200 plus year old
um city center uh historic building in one of the
cities so it's it's interesting i think
the um in many ways the media's treatment of this uh and
their unwillingness to talk about it frankly can
only I would think uh fuel the populist fires that
may end up propelling National Rally to some leadership role.
You also have in France the interesting and weird mix of authority.
You have a pretty powerful presidency, although in this one, in Macron,
having lost most of the support of his own party
as its popularity has collapsed,
He's in a powerful institutional position,
but not really in any secure legitimacy posture.
And then you have, you know,
this presidential election coming up, and it's, I don't know,
well, some of our friends who know and love France
and love French history have said to
me, and I'm sure you've had similar conversations,
that if any country can do something about its
immigration problem after decades of neglect and mismanagement,
it's France. And if they can't do
it, then nobody really, at least in continental Europe,
if not the UK as well, can fix this
problem. I mean, what do you make of that sort of sentiment?
And I think underlying that position
is that the French have a less eroded sense of national identity
and some of their defaults are a little more hard-nosed
and even nationalistic and chauvinistic.
So if any country in continental Europe at least
could do something about this, it would be the French.
Yeah, I mean, we've certainly seen a lot of fiery
but mostly peaceful protests to kind of use the U.S. meme
from some time back.
I do think that France, because it does have a strong identity,
has some ability to take this on,
maybe more than some other countries in Europe.
On the other hand, I think the problem there is also more significant.
And I think when you add in, in particular,
Islam to that equation, it becomes really difficult.
So, I mean, obviously, I wish for them for the best.
I think it would be it would be good.
um you know ironically um in fact one of the people
on um this trip with me with South Africa
was from a pied noir i'm i apologize
for butchering that uh pronunciation for french
speakers there but uh essentially
the the french uh citizens who lived in algeria
before they were effectively ethnically cleansed out
of algeria at the time of independence
so uh you know has has experience with um dramatic demographic moves
and people moving out it's hard
for me to imagine something of that scale happening in france
but i do think that you know
certainly significant deportations of people
who are not going to get with the program for lack of
a better term and a closing of the border is perhaps um more realistic
and it would certainly
be welcome if it happened um you know again it's just uh we have
to see what the french people
have uh the stomach for the french right has always actually
been a pretty strong force and
there's there's an interesting um kind of dynamic
and that there's never um been quite as um strict
of a cordon sanitaire between the the sort of what would
be called the french far right uh sometimes
it's called the french new right uh
and the mainstream french right as there is i feel like
in america or certainly most
of continental europe it's one of the reasons why i think
national rally is in a position
to uh take over without people absolutely uh losing their marbles
because the discourse has been maybe always
a little bit more free there than in some other
parts of europe so uh we'll see
but but um you know they've got some real uh challenges to address
for sure yeah i should say that um the other thing you learned
from at least in French
intellectual life uh from friends of ours
who have lived in and have followed France closely for a
long time i mean i mentioned the media kind
of mainstream media blackout but intellectual life
is uh is in many ways quite free and open uh in France still
and so uh you know on the one hand
And you do have the specter of politicians being kind of jailed
or fined for anti-immigrant sentiment expressed
in a way that the state thinks is too harsh.
But the intellectual argument in France and the books
and the articles are, you know, it's not as if this has not all
been debated pretty vigorously and even openly for quite some time.
No, I mean, Renaud Camus, who invented the term the Great Replacement,
which now has a fair bit of currency in the U.S.,
is, of course, French.
And he actually has been prosecuted
by the state for a couple of his remarks.
But on the other hand, he's continued to publish pretty freely
and has a significant profile.
And one might imagine under a national rally government,
him having an even bigger profile.
So we will see.
Yeah, you might say, again, I'm just speaking from what I hear
from Francophiles and friends of France going back many decades,
and people who've lived there have talked about it.
You have more official ways that you can get punished in France
for bringing up naughty topics, but I think the unofficial and social
sanctions are less than you might encounter in the United States.
So in a weird way, you're more free to bring up more risque subjects
while the state reserves a few more powers and rights
on its own compared to the United States to make your life difficult
and even jail and fine you if you step out of line as they deem it.
So it's a fascinating place.
We wanted to talk also about the 2026 midterms.
How could we avoid the midterms?
We're now less than a month out.
uh from election election tuesday here in the united states
and uh i wanted to raise a couple
of uh well first i'll before i get ahead
of myself we want to talk about uh some of the
undercurrents that are are moving around the midterm elections
but i will start by just asking
you Jeremy what do you think
or what's your prediction about the extent of uh of the wave
such as it is in November
and how it's going to shake out yeah i mean i don't have as
strong a lead on this one um as i have
on most other previous elections where i'm sort of like
you know i kind of sense that this is going to go um one way
or another uh i mean in 2024 i was so
confident um that Trump was going to win toward
the end of that election that i i actually um
had several texts back
and forth with Jonathan Swan from the New York Times
who wrote the number one bestselling book,
Regime Change, about the Trump administration
that came out earlier this year.
And I said, look, I am just completely confident that Trump
is going to win this election. We're going to win.
Absolutely. It's just going to happen.
I was that clear of a read.
And that obviously turned out to be correct. I don't have as clear
a read. I don't think it's going to be wonderful for us.
I expect it's going to be even a little
worse than the average um midterm but but i don't know
and i will say as best i can kind of read the
tea leaves and i and i have
been paying fairly close attention i think we may have kind of a
heterogeneous environment
and so it's going to be a little bit tricky to sort of maybe say what's
going on because um uh i think in places like north carolina
and georgia things don't look
great um in places like nevada
or um michigan they they maybe look better than you might expect
and then in places like texas i would say you
know again it's it's early but i think sort of
some of the more apocalyptic things
are um are not going to likely bear out and so i think
my my best guess is going to be there's going
to be a number of races throughout the country
in a larger battlefield that we're used
to that are going to be very very close and that a point
or two in the national environment
in either direction may have a really large effect on
how we kind of ultimately see this whole thing turning out.
The Washington Post reported through the weekend
that Trump is now at an all-time low for his
popularity.
So the macro trends, at least to the extent that you can track,
which you can in midterms
often, party performance
and the president's job rating are trending in the wrong direction.
But we do have a few weeks left.
Although early voting has started in many states,
including where I am in Texas, started today.
So, yeah, I should actually.
It sounded like, Jeremy, you were.
Oh, yeah, please.
No, no, no.
I should say just, you know, kind of beyond my putting
on my analyst hat, I should say from a personal perspective,
because I don't think it's necessarily universal.
You know, I'm a huge fan of what
this administration has done over its first couple of years.
And I could certainly go making a really big list of things
that they haven't done well or things that I'm frustrated by.
But I think grading based on any sort of comparison to the past,
I think they've done a lot of things on immigration,
on anti-white discrimination.
Certainly in the areas that I've really focused on,
my friend Harvey Dillon at Civil Rights, for example,
I mean, they've just done extraordinary work.
I think they've pushed back. They have they've moved
the Overton window in places where it had never been moved before.
Look, I'm frustrated by the gas price,
too, and everything that led up to it.
But that doesn't mean I'm going to let a bunch
of civilization wreckers run the country.
And I, you know, I've written I'd crawl over broken glass
to vote for this administration and vote GOP in the midterms.
And so I just have to hope there are going
to be enough other folks like me who are not being kind
of fully captured in the media narrative, because I definitely think
that there have been a lot of impressive things for all
the frustrations that have come out of this administration.
And I, you know, I have no second thoughts whatsoever about being very supportive
of them coming into the midterm.
It will be interesting to see the extent to which people either
stay home or vote differently, a lot of whom are not that political
but who are just angry about high diesel prices or whatever.
Take your pick of the economic issues causing them anxiety
that have gone in unhelpful directions for the party in power,
if we put it that way, over the last six or eight months,
due in part to a foreign policy decision that many regard,
I think, as either, I'm not speaking for myself,
but many regard as either the wrong choice or just not worth the price.
uh all those things are are very hard to predict how
those things play out in the privacy of a
voting booth especially given the case that i'm
the joke i've been making in recent weeks and
even at our summer fellowships is i mean uh
the one thing the republicans have going for them is
that uh you know the centrist democrats the bill galston's
and the rahm emmanuels of the world
are not running national strategy
and comms strategy for the democratic party so you have
You have a Republican Party facing significant headwinds,
partly because of some of the policies of the Trump administration
and some macro trends, maybe exacerbated by those policies.
But then you also have an opposition party that seems unable
in many ways to get out of its own way and to keep a lid
on some of its more extreme proponents or representatives.
you mentioned a bunch of the states
so i i assumed you were talking about the senate but it also
applies to the house but uh i mean el sayed
in michigan is a great is a great example i mean in
given the the macro headwinds there's no reason
that mike rogers should have a chance in michigan
and yet his opponent uh keeps the door wide open
um yeah no they've they've picked a number of
really bad candidates um this cycle i think you
know more than than we're used to historically
And that's another kind of thing that's out there.
I mean, I think I think Minnesota could be in play
for the same reason where we have Michelle Tafoya,
who I think is not not totally battle tested,
but a pretty experienced communicator.
And they've got somebody
who I think is loony even by Democrat standards.
And some of the polling there has been close.
So we'll have to see. I mean,
I think kind of the the second order implication of what you said,
which I certainly agree with, is that I'm very bullish on 2028, even
though I'm kind of bearish to although uncertainly bearish for 2026,
because a lot of these guys are going to get elected.
I mean, I think the Democrats have pretty much locked
in at least four new DSA representatives to the House,
you know, knocking on incumbents, maybe even five.
And these guys, when they are more visible,
when they're actually in Congress,
they're loons and people are going to see that they're loons.
And I think one of the things that helped Trump most in 2024
was just how crazy the Democrats were in going after him.
And I think one of the things that will help us a lot more
in 2028 is right now the Democrats are out of power.
And so it's really easy to blame everything on the Republicans.
I think if the Democrats take a majority of either the House
or the Senate and launch a bunch of witch hunt investigations
and have all these anti-white candidates and basically near communists
in their party as elected officials, it's going to remind everybody
of what they liked about the Republican Party in the first place.
So I'm actually very bullish in many ways.
The worst things go in 2026.
I think the better it will be for us in terms
of our 2028 politics, although certainly I would love
for us to keep the House and the Senate just
so that we can get things done over these next couple of years.
But I do think that the Democrats have really hurt themselves
by embracing some of their least skilled
and most radical kind of factions.
Yeah, to put it in the terms of our, I don't think he coined the term,
but he uses it a lot. And effectively, our acquaintance, Henry Olson,
the double haters out there, that is to say that in the 2016 cycle,
the haters of both Hillary and Trump,
and then maybe the double haters in 2024 of Trump and Kamala.
um nonetheless many of them ultimately make a decision
and i think uh the one of the parties
clearly having less of a handle on its crazies
and those crazies also seeming to be more more
malevolent and and worse than the extreme
of the other party that those double haters will pull
the lever for uh for the republican party especially after two years
of uh a displayed
uh well two two years of it on display from the floor of the house
and or the senate yeah and
you just hate to make the argument
that we're gonna we're gonna win by losing um well right
and i don't want to do that right like i want to win by winning
but i'm saying that even if we lose
i think it probably puts us in just that much better
a position for 2028 and i you know kind
of further look at it we talk about some
of these unhinged guys um trump you know whatever you think
of him uh positively or negatively
and and i've obviously indicated my my overall enthusiasm for
what he and his administration have accomplished
but he's certainly a polarizing figure rhetorically
and otherwise where he'll just do some things sometimes
that i think even for some of his
supporters are are sort of a challenge
but when you look at our likely 2028 candidates
it's really hard for me to see anybody
not named uh jd vance marco rubio or ron desantis um being
um our nominee uh i'm obviously not trying
to select in advance it just it just seems to me
like if you go on Polymarket, you'd find the same thing.
And all of those guys are very smooth
communicators. I think that they're very good
at sort of being approachable and less threatening.
And I think, you know, the attempts to kind
of paint them as crazed radicals are probably going
to fall pretty flat. And I don't think
the Democrats are gonna be able to help themselves.
And so I think that's one more thing that we're going
to have going for us going into 2028.
And the prospective field
of Democratic presidential candidates is not that impressive.
Yeah, no, not at all.
I mean, the leader, the leader, because of the last couple of cycles,
at least on paper, a name recognition is Kamala Harris,
which, you know, would be, I think,
another yet another gift to the Republican Party.
She ended up being the nominee.
And they have a lot of their more and a lot of their more impressive
kind of 40 something possible candidates are running into the problem,
the problem of the real left edge of the party,
which does not like Jewish Democrats.
So, you know, you think of Ossoff or Shapiro.
So it's a real it's a real pickle that they're in, it seems.
Yeah, I know. I'd agree with you
and particularly with Ossoff and Shapiro,
who might otherwise be pretty attractive candidates for them.
But, you know, I say the kind of it's almost the downside to me.
It makes me worry that the election, it feels the most like
to me in certain respects, was 1992, where the Democratic field
was so weak that what happened is you had Bill Clinton,
who is just a great natural politician, come out of nowhere.
and just win with his political skills.
When I look at all the possible Democratic frontrunners
right now, they feel so weak to me that I think probably
the thing I'm most worried about at this
point is that somebody
who's just not even really on our radar right now comes in and just has
really good political skills
and is able to run the table on the Democratic side because the party
has become so weakened, because it's become so radicalized,
because the left edge is so weird.
um and that's kind of maybe the unknown unknown
that's out there that would be negative for us but
as far as known unknowns um i kind
of feel like whoever they put up is not going to look attractive
compared to any of the likely candidates that the GOP
is going to put up in 2028 yeah yeah who is the
equivalent in 2027 of the man from Hope, Arkansas
who is going to be the dark horse uh middle of
the road candidate for the Democrats yeah no it
is um it still remains a possibility although i
I think, maybe you tell me what you think of this, you know, that was,
that environment in 92 was on the sort of behind-the-scenes side
was the product of some years of real work institutionally
for a kind of more moderate policy basket on the Democratic side.
Again, I talked about Bill Galston earlier.
He was at the center of that kind of centrist wave
of Democratic policymaking that Bill Clinton tapped into and rode
and used to staff his young administration after he won in 92.
and it the the democrats have really spent
the better part they've really been um humiliated
on the national presidential stage on a couple of occasions uh
and they it took them 10 12 years to
learn that lesson i just don't i don't think we're there yet
for the for the democrats they
think trump is such an aberration
and a kind of act of god in a way uh if i can put it that way
that i don't think they're drawing
the same lessons i think they may conclude that if they
just need to get trump out of the way
and then present their their mix of dsa economics and uh
and uh and sort of normal programmatic liberalism
and and they'll they'll win it back without having
to to uh really do soul searching yeah no i think
that's a terrific point ryan um they they haven't
done the institutional work that preceded 1992
and in fact it's quite the opposite to the extent
There is institutional momentum.
It is all on the fringiest side of the Democratic Party. That's
where the energy is in their party right now.
And I think it just, again, that sort of would
suggest that we are less likely to get
that beautiful centrist candidate for them out of
nowhere to really challenge.
I do think that they've, again, just as you said, they think
Trump is an aberration and it's caused them
to not sort of seriously look at the things that they
have done wrong um and uh you know i think again i i would love
to be us rather than them um going
into 2028 almost again regardless of how 2026 uh goes
because a presidential election is always i
mean it's a voters it's like the one time you really
do have a high degree of information
i mean people really develop a view about the person
and it's not just a set of policies and
And Reagan was a classic example of that, of just a guy
who came in with a very sunny, optimistic view of America.
And people just liked him,
whether or not they were signing up for his whole basket of policies.
And again, I just think we are going to look very favorably
as compared to what the Democrats seem to have on offer here.
So it may be a rocky next month, although I hope not.
But I think it's going to be a better time going
into twenty twenty eight.
I think we can close by talking
a little bit about what we might expect from Democratic majorities.
You mentioned that you think they're
not going to be able to restrain themselves.
So we have one data point that I wanted to raise and get your take on.
Alyssa Slotkin, who's a senator, was quoted.
The clip, I should say, was going viral on X,
but Miranda Devine at the New York Post has now written it up.
And Alyssa Slotkin was talking at the University of Chicago.
She's, of course, she's a senator for Michigan, former CIA employee.
And so, like Spanberger in Virginia,
one of these pretty successful in the sort of policy realm
of managerial liberalism over the last 10 years or so.
uh Spanberger of course another CIA uh female Democratic candidate
who's rose to high office
anyway Slotkin
who uh some may recall she participated with I think six others um uh
on this sort of public service announcement uh after Trump
was elected um or after he took
office I should say kind of vaguely suggesting
when Mark Kelly was in this group too that uh
certain military senior military officers had
a first responsibility to the Constitution rather
than unconstitutional orders given
by their commander-in-chief that's Slotkin's background
anyway she's recently at the university
of Chicago last week she said that she wants to this is
Miranda Devine's words unleash a barrage
of political investigations on Trump officials
in order to frighten young people away
from taking jobs in the administration this is the
Slotkin quote the people around Donald Trump have
no immunity the way the president does
she's referencing uh the Supreme Court case
from two terms ago uh that is not this last June but
the June before um giving Trump immunity in some of the prosecutions
so you go after the people who
do his bidding i want to look at these signature cases
and not just focus on the president but on
the people who enabled him i want young people coming out
of school to say should i go work for
the Trump administration, like, that sounds fun.
I might get an opportunity. I want them to be like,
Lord, that might be buying myself a ton
of problems that I don't want. And so let me avoid
participating in that. I want that deterrence message.
This is troubling to Miranda Devine,
as I think it should be to most Americans.
It's what we may have in store if the Democrats retake
the Senate. It's obviously what Slotkin wants to do.
Slotkin, of course, has responded already
and said well look what what's
the big fuss about really all i'm talking about is going after people
who've done illegal things
or have corruptly aided the president in doing illegal things so
those of you making a big deal about
this uh about it re-weaponizing government and continuing our
descent into a bad tit-for-tat
are exaggerating things what what do you what do you make of
Slotkin's plans, or even some of her partners in this sort of view,
which we saw on display
earlier in the Trump administration.
How should we understand this, Jeremy?
Yeah, well, I think she said the quiet part out loud.
This is nothing that we hadn't considered.
Certainly one of the upsides
of Senator Curtis making it impossible for my presidential
nomination as an assistant secretary of state
to go forward was that um you know i don't have to
deal um with this sort of weaponized government
um that that i would have had to take if i were
in the administration in a senior role as many
of my friends are um and that was something i
thought about a lot before i even agreed
to be nominated um was the the whole question of well
You know, what am I willing to put myself or my family through?
Because I fully expect and expected that the Democrats
were going to go after me if I were in the administration.
I expect they will go after my friends, whether or not they,
you know, first of all, I mean, just be clear,
I'm not aware and would be shocked and surprised if any
of my friends were involved in any illegal conduct.
So, I mean, but I think they will be gone after regardless. And,
you know, so I think that deterrent is already there, unfortunately.
And I say that, you know, I have one of my sons who's interested
in potentially going into the administration in a junior capacity.
And I worry about that a little bit with him, you know,
that he could be at risk because the Democrats,
I don't think, are going to play by the rules.
And in fact, one of the biggest criticisms, frankly,
that I would have of the administration is, and this is sort
of the reverse of how it's been portrayed in the media,
is that they have not really exacted retribution against the players
who did this to them and that we've ultimately looked weak.
and again it's not because i want
um broad-based political uh prosecutions of my opponents i mean
far from it i think that's a terrible way to run
the government regardless but there were there
were people who engaged in um totally politicized prosecutions
of president trump when he was out
of office and uh you know he came in back
in and he said well now the hunter hunted has become the
hunter and i would have loved
for that to be the case i mean i would love for the people who
broke the rules of the system to suffer their own consequences.
Or I would love for a guy like
Mayorkas, who I think was actively thwarting immigration law,
I would have loved to see some
very selective, again, I'm not talking about
broad-based things, but I would love to see
prosecutions of the people,
a limited set of the people who were doing real malfeasance
in and around the last administration.
And I just don't think that unfortunately that's happened
to nearly the degree that it should have.
And I think that encourages further bad actors like
what we're seeing with Slotkin,
because they understand there's no real penalty to be paid
for talking in this way. You touched on the fact that she
and some of her colleagues
effectively were inciting insubordination from the military.
And again, these are experienced
people. She's ex-CIA. She knows what she's doing.
She knows what she's saying. She's not just some
clown out there. And so I think we needed a little bit
of mutually assured destruction as a way to
keep the peace, which I very much want
to do because politicized prosecutions of people in
office are really bad. But to have that mutually assured destruction,
you have to show that you
are very serious about going after a few of their worst actors.
And I think I haven't seen as much
of that as I think really needed to be done.
And so I do worry that because we've shown that
there's not really been a big consequence
for the democrats very bad behavior that we are going to
get that bad behavior on steroids if god forbid they wind up
in office in uh 2028 or even in the
running the Senate or House investigations
and in 2026 we'll uh we'll see some of these things
on a more minor key some of our more centrist friends
are uneasy with the tit-for-tat strategy
uh a strategy known in game theory for those familiar
with this sort of thing but uh in it
taps into what you and you've you've participated
on in some public conferences with us on this
topic uh jeremy i think a couple nat cons ago i recall
um you know the the problem the problem
with lawfare is known uh it penalizes people
for engaging in normal political activity and that is
not a good trend uh and yet at the same time we have
to we have to acknowledge that maybe one of
the only ways to stop it or to get both sides
to come to sort of to some sort of modus vivendi or
some is to raise the cost for its for for it happening
and that means you do need a kind of
tit-for-tat strategy and uh to the outside
to outside people it looks like well you're just
re-weaponizing government and i think i think
your point is and i your point is and i agree is that
a few precise strikes against
the most egregious offenders should give the other side pause and
should give the Alyssa Slotkins of the world
a little more hesitation at pursuing this kind
of strategy. But I think we'll have
to suffer through more of it before we can get beyond it.
Yeah, I know. And you look at what's happened certainly
to our colleague John Eastman as one
of the most egregious examples of this,
where he's been relentlessly legally hounded and
subject to millions of dollars of legal bills
for offering offering uh legal advice to the president
um and you know regardless of whether you were i think
that was great legal advice or or otherwise
i mean anybody who's talked to john knows that it was given sincerely
and not cynically in any way
based on his best reading of uh the relevant statutes
in the constitution and the fact that
we are making that criminal uh is scary
or my friend jeff clark in a similar situation
as a legal advisor to the president
and now is involved with raising money for a law firm that
will defend some of our guys if it unfortunately comes
to this even more. And I think that's great
long overdue, but I would love to see more activity
from the administration on this ground.
One fact that I don't know if I've raised it before,
if I have, it's been a while, but one
sort of insider fact that many probably don't know about
is in this administration, as in the
last one, but in this one, it's much more palpable.
A lot of our friends who work in it, especially
the ones who are not political appointees,
who are kind of on the second and third rungs of the
senior management layers at education or anywhere else,
are paying, depending on what policy they
want paying 80, 90, 100, 150,
$200 a month on basically weaponization and litigation insurance
because they know that they may be subject.
And so you'll decide, okay, I want $800,000 worth of
coverage to protect myself in case I get hauled
in front of even just congressional testimony.
I mean, if you're testifying under oath,
you get lawyers to advise you even in front of Congress
because Congress can, as we know from the example of Steve Bannon
and others, Congress can throw you
in jail too if it wants to.
So it's a very real phenomenon and it has some bite. And a lot of our
friends who serve in the administration have taken
precautions against it, but it's not enough. As we
know, our colleague John has spent, you alluded to it,
Jeremy, but the precise number is close
to $2 million on legal representation over the last five years.
And John's one of the bigger
profile examples, but it's a great example
of the process being the punishment. So the only way is
through on the lawfare thing.
And so I think the tide is beginning to turn. You mentioned Jeff
Clark's law firm that he's doing in conjunction
with the Oversight Project, and that's a healthy
development. And I think our side at least
is much more cognizant of the stakes. And I think
if the midterms go very badly for the Republicans,
they'll be reminded of the stakes, at least
starting at the congressional level.
And as you say, the really big stakes are in a subsequent
Democratic administration,
which has a lot more tools to do a lot more damage than just Congress.
Well, I think we'll leave it at that for today.
Thanks, Jeremy. And I'll remind everyone to keep
an eye out for, at the very least,
an American Mind essay on your experience in South Africa,
reporting back to us and some lessons to draw from that.
And as I tease at the beginning,
but I'll re-tease, we'll talk to you soon about
your new book once it's a little closer to
completion, although I know it's quite close,
but publishing takes a while. And I'll thank everyone
for watching the podcast, and thanks, Jeremy, for joining us.
We will talk to you all next week.
As always, for more on Claremont, go to claremont.org.
To support us, claremont.org
slash donate. AmericanMind.org for the latest from the American Mind.
ClaremontReviewBooks.com
for our magazine. A new issue is in the works,
and a brand new issue-ish, now only three or
four weeks old, is in your mailbox and available online.
We're hard at work on the next one.
And then for the latest out of our DC Center, dc.claremont.org.
And please rate and review us,
spread the word. And thanks to Ryan Gannon,
our production and engineering one-man team,
and we will talk to you all next week.