Tomiki Aikido: A Polite Critique

Martial arts originated from Japan
137 followers
I should go without saying that I am a Tomiki Aikido appreciator.
If you've watched my stuff, you've almost certainly seen me use footage from the style
in the background of my videos, I'd even go as far as to say my two favorite Aikido
YouTube channels are of Tomiki stock.
Beyond this, I've brushed shoulders with plenty of Tomiki guys over the years despite
never really formally taking a class outside of, if it can even really be counted, a seminar
here and there.
I'm telling you all this because I genuinely do think that most of the truly innovative
Aikido stuff comes out of this style.
Not all, but most.
I give you this disclaimer because I want to stress that this video comes from a place
of affection, not antagonism.
I have six major criticisms of this style, and at the end I'll speculate a bit about
the state of things, and throughout I'm going to sprinkle in what I'd personally change.
So, without dawdling around anymore, let me hop to it.
Criticism number one, and I'm just going to be blunt about it.
I think the presence of the knife in sparring is dumb.
Mostly because it's not a knife at all, it's just a prop.
One person gets armed with it and they can only do a thrusting stab off the lead hand.
No cuts, no reverse grips, no slashes, no grab and stabs, and no changing hands.
In essence, it is a karate point sparring jab, and that's it.
In my opinion, this is easily the most egregious flaw in the Tomiki competitive format.
It seems to implicitly make the statement that Aikido is for weapons defense, but then
restricts well over 90 or perhaps even 95% of what makes a knife truly dangerous.
Now, personally, I disagree with the notion that Aikido is for weapons defense.
But to steelman Tomiki Aikido a bit here, I can't recall anywhere in the official literature
offhand that presents that idea either.
It's just baked into the sparring system for some reason.
And yes, I'm aware there is a format in which both parties are unarmed, no weapons involved
at all, but it doesn't appear to be the most popular format even though it's just
all around better, from where I sit at least.
I'm going to return to the limitations on the knife at the end of the video,
but I'll leave this point with this.
If you want that to be a feature of sparring, if you want the knife, fine, but then the
knife has to be a knife and function as such.
Otherwise, it really is just a prop and a gimmick meant to aesthetically disguise an
unnatural behavior.
You could pretty much just as easily have one side only be allowed to do a lead jab,
and the format would be virtually unchanged.
That's just not a good look for anyone who has a discerning eye.
Speaking of unnatural behaviors, my second criticism is the range limitations.
For those outside the know, Tamiki Aikido has rules that essentially make the wrist,
elbow, and tricep the primary legal grips.
This is silly in my view, and it's silly in the same way judo banning leg grabs is
silly.
Or another example, silly that in BJJ, the person who is standing is for some reason
obligated to deal with the person who just sits down.
The problem with all these cases is that they prop up an unnatural grappling behavior.
If you grapple with a child who has no martial arts experience, they will almost certainly
eventually try to grab a leg, and there is no martial incentive outside the mandate of
competitive rules to walk directly into somebody's guard.
You would not do that if you had any inkling that the other person is that good on the
ground.
It makes the judo equivalent would be walking right into somebody's preferred grips.
It's just not a good rule.
I'll stand by that.
I know it's not a BJJ video, but I just go back to that argument.
It should be up to the guard puller to entangle the person standing and force them to play
their game.
There is no reason the person who is standing should have to walk directly into where the
person wants them to go.
That's a weird rule.
It's an unnatural, tactically backwards behavior.
You would not see that out in the wild.
And of course, in a similar vein, no grappler is going to snag your elbows and think, yeah,
I'm just gonna hang out here for the next two minutes and try to make something happen.
I'm not suggesting that those kinds of grips never occur.
They definitely do.
But even a day one grappler is going to intuitively understand that those are relatively weak
grips compared to, say, a collar tie, an underhook, an overhook, or like a lat hook.
Usually, a wrist or elbow control is paired with a stronger primary grip that a grappler
is constantly going to be trying to progress towards.
Now, look, I understand that there is no such thing as a perfect rule set, and these kinds
of idiosyncrasies are a bit par for the course when it comes to developing a competitive
format.
That said, I think why the judo leg grab ban and guard pulling are both considered such
cardinal sins by so many people is that they just don't reflect a grappling reality outside
of that very specific combat sport.
Obviously, many BJJ and judo athletes are willing to accept these contrivances in the
rules.
I just happen to not accept them.
I don't like them at all.
I think they're silly.
I'm willing to embrace some basic gaming of rules or general jankiness just for the
sake of, you know, having a consistent rule set.
But not when the rules say, hey, you know that obvious tactic that you want to employ
that you can just intuit would be a good idea?
Yeah, you can't do that.
That's banned.
That doesn't feel good, nor does it reward good decision making, nor does it attract
outsiders to the style.
A point that I'm going to circle back around to later.
I also know that one of Tamiki's big theses, and by the way, I mean Tamiki the guy here,
not Tamiki the style, was that Aikido is a sort of long range judo.
And look, I have a lot of respect for Tamiki Kenji.
I think he was a genuine innovator, and he was correct about a lot of things.
Respectfully, I think he got this one wrong.
I can think of plenty of Aikido techniques that fundamentally demand chest to chest or
hip to hip or chest to shoulder proximity.
Aiki otoshi, koshinage, kubinage, ganseki otoshi, riminage, and a slew of kokyunage
variations just to name a few.
I'm not blaming Kenji for testing this idea out.
That is how we learn.
But this just isn't an idea that really fits from where I'm sitting, especially after all
the years of toying with it that we've had.
All of this is to say, if you want to keep judo techniques banned, fine, I guess.
I still think minor foot sweeps and sutemi waza should be allowed, but fine, I'm willing
to give that up.
Like I said, I can accept certain contrivances.
But there shouldn't be any range limitation on grips.
My opinion is that a complete Aikido must have answers for things like collar ties,
underhooks, and all those common positions that any other grappling discipline is going
to preach.
I don't think we do any favors for the art by superficially ignoring the most common
intuitive grips in all of grappling.
Which leads me smoothly into critique number three.
Y'all wear a gi, y'all should be able to do gi grips.
Again, this is just one of those weird rules that bans what is natural.
A gi is functionally a gripping apparatus.
The lapel and belt are literally ropes either tied around you or sewn into the garment itself.
I've always found it so bizarre that Tamiki Aikido wants to basically be a no-gi art while
also wearing a gi.
Especially in 2025, this sends mixed signals to people who might want to try the style
out because no-gi and gi are so widely understood to be completely separate things in the public
consciousness.
Now I get it, in the 30s and 40s of the 1900s, the no-gi scene wasn't a thing in
Japan, so of course you wore a gi.
But again, this is just one of those things that should be an obvious change.
I'm aware there are some out there that like to argue that Aikido, too, is different from
Judo because it doesn't use gi grips, but I think these people must be training with
blinders on.
While such grips absolutely don't have as massive a presence as, say, Judo, and gripping
certainly is not as sophisticated as it is in that art, gripping the gi in Aikido has
been in the system since the very beginning, especially around the collar.
I'm sure I'll have a clip up on screen now showing you exactly that.
Now, there are several solutions to this.
Of course, you could just go completely no-gi and the issue would get resolved basically
overnight.
I'm not really for that, though, partially because I do prefer gi grips.
But actually, and even more subjectively, I just find no-gi kind of gross.
I know some folks are completely unbothered, but being in a gi just feels so much cleaner
and there's so much less sweat on the mat.
So, my proposition would be to either use Shuaijiao tops, which don't use sleeves but
you could still use the collar and belt, or go back to an older 1910s-1920s gi design
which was essentially like a t-shirt where the sleeves cut off midway down the bicep.
I think there's also room for a bit of aesthetic creativity here as well, which I bring up
only because I think it would be useful for Tomiki Aikido to have a uniform that is easily
identifiable to the untrained eye.
It's very useful for recruitment when a person can look at a uniform and just instantly recognize
the style.
This is something that a lot of styles have.
Of course, no-gi BJJ is very identifiable with its rash guards.
Judo, very identifiable with its heavy gi.
Wrestling has its own uniform.
And even other Aikido styles technically have a sort of differentiation with their hakama.
So, I really do think there probably is some room for people to get a little bit creative
with the uniform here.
But at the very least, if you want to keep the gi, then all gi grips should be allowed.
If you don't, then just change the uniform.
It's that simple.
My fourth criticism has to do with training methods.
So, I actually think limitations on grips that I just railed against would be perfectly
fine as a drill with constraints to really focus on certain concepts or techniques, just
not as the supposedly holistic competitive rule set.
What I'm less convinced on is the Tamiki Aikido tendency to just sort of hold hands
out as a starting position to begin practicing techniques.
Like, I get it.
Truly new people might benefit from that simplicity, and it's not like the other Aikido styles
are much better with their very unnatural chopping attacks.
But even without the changes, I've suggested the most common position in contemporary Tamiki
Aikido sparring is like a double elbow grip.
Pretty much every technique should be trained out of that position, in my view, assuming
that you're not implementing any of the changes I've previously talked about.
It's much like how Judo has collar and sleeve as its golden standard, and indeed, a majority
of Judoka fight out of some riff on that position.
This is just one of those things where you should train how you want to spar so you can
spar how you train.
Not much else to add on to this point.
It's pretty self-explanatory.
Number five will probably grind some gears, and keep in mind this isn't aimed at all at
Tamiki people individually, but I have noticed that a lot of my encounters with Tamiki folks
do bear this out.
There seems to be a bit of a chip on a lot of the Tamiki crowd's shoulders, and it tends
to relate back to the whole, we are the only Aikido style that spars.
I find this sort of goofy, because, well, first and foremost, the bar for sparring in
Aikido was last detected somewhere in the earth's lower mantle.
Most weak-to wrestlers could walk into a mainstream Aikikai dojo and ragdoll them effortlessly.
I wish it weren't that way, much of this channel is devoted to trying to change that phenomenon,
and there are exceptions to the rule out there, but let's just be honest, Aikido is not known
for participants being fantastic athletes with sparring-tested techniques.
So, when Tamiki Aikido folks scoff at other Aikido systems, it feels very much like a
big fish little pond scenario.
And more importantly, people just come off as snobby and unlikable, which no one really
likes.
I also deliberately saved this point for later in the video because, as evidenced by my previous
criticisms, it isn't like Tamiki Aikido sparring is perfect from a grappling standpoint either.
To be completely honest, I'll really only accept an Aikido person huffing their own
farts when they can start putting Judoka on their backs using solely Aikido tech
in an open rules grappling format.
If you can start doing that, then I will be a bit more tolerant about the
whole we spar superiority fetish that some Tamiki folks seem to have.
But feeling that way because you could manhandle the average person in mainstream Aikido
is like patting yourself on the back for being able to defeat a kindergartner.
Like, come on now, that's not that big of an achievement.
Again, too, a big part of this is outside perception as well.
No one likes people who put themselves on a pedestal, even people who arguably deserve
to be on that pedestal.
We all want our arts to grow and do well.
Being charismatic, affable, open, kind, and humble are infinitely more attractive traits
to newcomers and martial peers alike as opposed to posturing as some kind of Aikido master race.
And yes, I know full well the other Aikido styles tend to have this arrogance issue too.
It's just as obnoxious there and even less justified.
The art needs better diplomats and ambassadors.
I can't help but feel like a lot of this probably comes from people not
cross-training enough and talking to people from other arts.
And again, I would say that Tamiki Aikido tends to be a lot more chill than some of
the other more insular styles, but I have seen quite a bit of it where there's this whole,
well we spar so we're light years ahead of the other styles.
And it's like, you are ahead, but you're not as ahead as you think you are.
My final critique is kind of the summation of all of this.
Tamiki Aikido doesn't really reach an outside audience well.
A huge reason I harped on natural behavior in the rules, uniform aesthetics, and practitioner
behavior, even socially, is that whether you like it or not, we have to market to and we
have to reach people that likely know very little about Aikido, grappling, or maybe even
athletics in general.
When I show someone a video of Tamiki sparring, I'm usually hit with just so many questions.
Why does one guy have a weapon and the other doesn't?
Why don't they grab the other's clothes?
Why won't he collar tie that guy?
Will he ever shoot on in his legs?
How do they win this match?
Meanwhile, I show those same people Judo or Sumo and they just intuitively get it.
Sure, they might have a few questions, here and there, but the win conditions are pretty
much self-evident.
I'd even extend this to really any competitive sport.
Anyone can sit down and watch a basketball game and by the end of that game, they will
understand the most important aspects and rules of the game without anyone ever having
to give them an exposition dump.
I've seen it in comment sections and even asked in real life, why isn't Tamiki Aikido
the most popular Aikido style?
They spar, why hasn't it naturally risen to the top?
Obviously, the real answer to that is complex and multifaceted.
We'd have to talk about reach and money and organizations and resources and all this,
but I do think the primary reason is pretty straightforward.
When people who know nothing about the system watch their very first match, it is hard to
tell what is even happening or why.
I understand what the rules are aiming for.
I get it.
I know what they're trying to do.
But I really believe they are far too clunky and unintuitive.
They prop up too much unnatural behavior.
For potential solutions, again, scrub back to my previous points.
To wrap up, I just want to say that I think Tamiki Aikido fell into the same trap so many
Japanese martial arts do.
Founder Paralysis.
It seems to me like the life cycle of a Japanese martial art is that one gets founded and will
have one to three generations of students that is crazy productive and genuinely innovative.
Then the founder dies, and suddenly that role gets filled by a giant bureaucracy more interested
in freezing the style in place than progressing it in an effective way.
Change can still happen, but it often has to be bureaucratically approved, and it tends
to not be all that well received.
Instead, it's motivated by marketing incentives rather than martial development.
Again, see the judo leg grab ban.
Other innovations, even good ones, can still occur, but they almost always have to happen
so quietly and so incrementally that no one can actually perceive the shift in real time.
This is all, of course, a far cry from the early days when the common ethos was,
we are going to openly try to do new ----.
We need to get back to that in Aikido.
I think it would be a shame to have to break away and completely rebrand, but if that's
what it takes to have just one more generation to push it the rest of the way there, maybe
that's what needs to happen.
I hope not, because I like Tamiki Aikido and I think the changes I've kind of put
forth in this video aren't really that big of a deal in the long run.
I know people who are very invested in the art are very deep into it probably are going
to resist me on all of this, but I don't think anything I'm saying is unreasonable.
Of course, I'm biased because they're my ideas.
To me, the current state of Tamiki Aikido feels like a beta test.
A project that has a direction, but is clearly incomplete.
The thrust-only knife setup just feels like it was meant to be built up to a certain degree
before introducing other attacks so people were skilled enough to handle those diverse
attacks.
Just as an example.
The same premise could be applied to the range or grip bands.
The whole system feels like it's only 30% realized.
Like, it's a constrained drill for building up skills rather than a holistic sparring
format.
Now, I don't think there is much documentary evidence to support my take on this.
It's just my speculation, but that is my two cents.
And if I think this, I promise you other people can sense it too.
Even those people who might have some interest in the art but have not yet committed to joining
it.
Again, to put a very positive spin on all of this, I still think Tamiki Aikido is often
the best at the things they are good at.
I think in terms of their Ate series, in the exploration of techniques like Sumi-Otoshi,
they are head and shoulders above other styles in terms of technical sophistication.
The addition of sparring, despite its limitations, was, indeed, the correct move.
There is a lot to be appreciative of in modern Tamiki Aikido.
This video is not to suggest otherwise.
But I do think there is this tendency in Tamiki circles to believe that they are the style
that has it all figured out.
That isn't true.
Not only is there still a lot of work to be done, and were it truly the case that Tamiki
Aikido had cracked the Aikido code, it just wouldn't be nearly as fringe as it currently
is, pure and simple.
I'm hopeful that code can be cracked.
If I had to place bets, I think the Tamiki tradition is the most likely of the three
major Aikido styles to successfully make that leap.
I think they are the most likely ones to do it, even if it means some subgroup might
need to splinter away to make it happen.
I would just warn against resting on one's laurels.
Tamiki Aikido is certainly ahead of its Aikido peers in many ways, but personally, I won't
be all that satisfied with it until it starts to be discussed alongside wrestling, Judo,
and BJJ, which, in my humble opinion, is still probably many, many years off.
Again, I think there's a lot of work to be done.
That's not a bad thing.
It's just an assessment of reality from where I sit.
But I digress.
This is all from me for now.
Feel free to roast me in the comments.
I'm sure I've ruffled some Tamiki feathers.
But regardless, thank you all for watching and listening.
There would be no Tengu Channel without you, and I will catch you all in the next one.
Peace.
