Thucydides' History of the Peloponnesian War

History TV Epic
4 followers
17 Video Views·Jan 9, 2025
"This video discusses Thucydides' History of the Peloponnesian War as a whole text, though I've done several videos about individual portions of the History. Largely my focus here is on Thucydides' historiography--how he approaches telling history--in comparison both to Herodotus (pretty much the only person who had attempted to do what we would now call history before Thucydides) and to modern historiographic norms.
*If you’d like to reference this information or would like to ask me a direct questions for an assignment you are working on, that’s awesome and I am glad to help."
Hello, so in this video, we're going to talk about Thucydides's history of the Peloponnesian
War.
Now, I've made a few videos about particular parts of the history that are very important,
but this video is going to talk about the history across the board, because Thucydides
is very, very interesting in the history of history.
So basically, I'm focusing primarily on Thucydides's historiography.
That's the way in which history is told, the way that the narrative of history is constructed.
Thucydides is, along with Herodotus, one of the two earliest people whose works survive,
who are doing what we would today call history as such.
This is as opposed to something like mythology, as we get with, for instance, Hesiod's Theogony
or Homer's Iliad and Odyssey.
What Herodotus and Thucydides are attempting to do is to record an accurate description
of events as they actually occurred.
And this is a unique endeavor in the history, at least of Greek literature, and really kind
of in the history of what we would now call the Western tradition, including Middle Eastern
societies, Egyptian society, etc., etc.
But there's some big differences between Thucydides and Herodotus, Herodotus being the
earlier of the two historians.
One of the things is that Thucydides is much more concerned with fact checking.
So what I mean by that is that Herodotus often records what people have told him without
necessarily making any attempt to confirm it through multiple sources or by checking
with outside resources or whatever it is.
Part of that is, and that's actually a huge problem in Herodotus in some cases, because
he's often recording as historical events, things that have been told over generations
to the point where they become almost mythic or legendary in themselves, and Herodotus
records them as fact.
He also will sometimes record things that are of questionable accuracy, whereas Thucydides
tells us that he, as much as possible, double checks the sources that he's found.
So he will attempt to find multiple people who were witness to an event or who were present
at the event or whatever it is, and he will try and assess what is true from their stories.
Now part of that is there's a huge difference in the chronological relativity that Herodotus
and Thucydides are working with.
Herodotus is attempting to essentially write a history of the known world, whereas Thucydides,
because he's focused on the Peloponnesian War, which takes place over the previous 30
some years, and actually a large portion of it was almost certainly written while the
war was going on, Thucydides has access to many more primary witnesses, so people who
were actually in these battles, who actually heard these speeches, who were involved in
these campaigns, and actually Thucydides was involved in some of these campaigns himself.
He was a general during the Peloponnesian War, and he fought for Athens, so some of
these things are also drawing on his first-hand experiences in a way that Herodotus really
can't.
Like, he has no first-hand experiences, he has no first-hand eyewitnesses of, for instance,
what we would now date as, say, 7th century Babylon, for instance, or the Middle Kingdom
in ancient Egypt, the early dynasties of ancient Egypt, or something like this.
Like, there's no one, in some cases, whose great-great-grandparents were alive at the
time.
So, Herodotus has much less access to primary witnesses than Thucydides does.
So, I want to talk a little bit here, or I want to give you a little bit of what Thucydides
himself says about his methodology.
So, this is in the introduction to the history.
So, he says here, he's talking about some incorrect beliefs that certain people, including
Herodotus, hold.
And he says, "...the rest of the Hellenes, too, make many incorrect assumptions, not
only about the dimly remembered past, but also about contemporary history."
So, this is one of the things that Thucydides sort of sets up as his statement of purpose,
is to correct misconceptions that people hold.
He says here, a little bit later, "...however, I do not think that one will be far wrong
in accepting the conclusions I have reached from the evidence which I have put forward.
It is better evidence than that of the poets, who exaggerate the importance of their themes,
or of the prose chroniclers, who are less interested in telling the truth than in catching
the attention of their public, whose authorities cannot be checked, and whose subject matter,
owing to the passage of time, is mostly lost in the unreliable streams of mythology.
We may claim instead to have used only the plainest evidence, and to have reached conclusions
which are reasonably accurate, considering we have been dealing with ancient history.
As for this present war, even though people are apt to think that the war in which they
are fighting is the greatest of all wars, and when it is over, to relapse again into
their admiration of the past, nevertheless, if one looks at the facts themselves, one
will see that this was the greatest war of all."
So, Thucydides, again, is very much concerned with his contemporary history, but he is making
a concerted effort to be accurate about that history in a way that Herodotus is not necessarily
as concerned about, or as able to do, given his subject matter.
Now, the one very, very significant gray area, in terms of Thucydides's accuracy,
is the speeches that he records, and he records a lot of speeches and a lot of dialogue, like
the Melian Dialogue, for instance.
He records speeches like Pericles's funeral oration, or speeches that generals or admirals
gave to their men to inspire them to fight particular battles.
Here, Thucydides is in a sort of weird balancing act, because on the one hand, he's trying
to record as accurately as possible what was said, without any sort of transcripts or anything
like that, so he has no sort of primary sources for what was said.
But then, on the other hand, he explains that he is also concerned with reproducing what
that speaker should have said, what was appropriate in that situation.
So he explains this here.
In this history, I've made use of set speeches, some of which were delivered just before,
and others during the war.
I found it difficult to remember the precise words used in the speeches which I listened
to myself, and my various informants have experienced the same difficulty.
So my method has been, while keeping as close as possible to the general sense of the words
that were actually used, to make the speakers say what, in my opinion, was called for by
each situation.
So this is a weird element of Thucydides' historiography, because he is so much dedicated
to checking and double-checking and getting things right, which is of course an admirable
approach to take for a historian, that it seems really surprising to somebody steeped
in the modern historical tradition, modern approaches to historiography, that he would
just kind of say, yeah, I got the gist of it, but really I was more interested in what
should have been said in this instance.
That's a very, very odd approach from a modern perspective.
Now, it's almost inevitable, realistically, in that Thucydides is primarily interested
in military and political matters, and so speeches are going to be crucial, but it's
inevitable that you get this sort of weird blend of what happened and what should have
happened, because Thucydides does not have access to the kinds of primary documents that
contemporary historians tend to work with.
So modern historians, if you're, say, a historian of World War II or the labor movement in the
1930s, if you're a historian of Tang Dynasty China, if you're a historian of the Mayan
Empire, people tend to look for documents and artifacts, concrete physical things that
exist that tell us about those cultures or civilizations or time periods.
Thucydides is not doing that.
Herodotus is not doing that.
They're not looking for documents or artifacts.
They are getting their information from witnesses, sometimes second-hand or third-hand or
more, especially in the case of Herodotus, but they are relying on what people remember
about the events, and again, Thucydides is sort of cross-checking various accounts whenever
he can to try and make sure that what he's recording in the history is as accurate as
possible.
So, in this way, it's pretty much inevitable that Thucydides ends up recording not the
actual words of the speeches because people would not be memorizing them in real time,
but he ends up recording the gist of them.
So, he's an interesting historian, not just because this is an incredibly important
resource for telling us about the Peloponnesian War, why it was fought, who fought it, what
was actually, what actually occurred in the war, but because Thucydides is the way, as
a historiographer, as a person who is essentially making up how to do history as a discipline,
Thucydides is incredibly important.
